Can't lift fingerprints from lead
Can't lift fingerprints from lead
Author
Discussion

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 7th June 2008
quotequote all
So three men allegedly nicking lead from a church roof, who were spotted by villagers and questioned by police, were not arrested.

The police said that they were youths. larking about on scaffolding.

The villagers said they were not youths.

The police said that the "youths" larking about on scaffolding.

The villagers reported them on the roof of the church - previously untouched by thieves but now accessible because of the scaffolding.

The police said that the lead found rolled up nearby, was not evidence as they could not lift fingerprints from lead.

The villagers said the police didn't summon SOCOs.

The police said there was no other evidence to link the "youths" to the lead that had been removed from the roof.

The villagers said that there was no-one else around and the lead was newly removed.

As usual, six of one and half-a-dozen of the other.

Any BiB care to comment on the lifting of prints from lead (old lead that is, presumably well-patinated. New lead might well prove something of a challenge)?

Streaky

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Saturday 7th June 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
So three men allegedly nicking lead from a church roof, who were spotted by villagers and questioned by police, were not arrested.

The police said that they were youths. larking about on scaffolding.

The villagers said they were not youths.

The police said that the "youths" larking about on scaffolding.

The villagers reported them on the roof of the church - previously untouched by thieves but now accessible because of the scaffolding.

The police said that the lead found rolled up nearby, was not evidence as they could not lift fingerprints from lead.

The villagers said the police didn't summon SOCOs.

The police said there was no other evidence to link the "youths" to the lead that had been removed from the roof.

The villagers said that there was no-one else around and the lead was newly removed.

As usual, six of one and half-a-dozen of the other.

Any BiB care to comment on the lifting of prints from lead (old lead that is, presumably well-patinated. New lead might well prove something of a challenge)?

Streaky
Prints no. DNA we had some success with. Depends also whobkids were etc. May well have been larding about and others may have dumped the lead. Most lead thieves wear gloves. You also have to have outlet so average kids would have nowher to go where as a certain type of kid would have an outlet. Just as locals think someone did it does not mean they did. The police may have then been accused of being heavy handed and criminalising youngsters.

darren9

986 posts

226 months

Saturday 7th June 2008
quotequote all
If fingerprints were found on the lead nearby does that prove that who ever's fingerprints are on that lead are the ones that stole it? If the lead was rolled up in a public place then those people whos prints walk past it may have just been interested as to why there was rolled up lead there and had a look (with their hands and eyes despite their mothers advice of "look with your eyes not with yur hands"). - Or at least thats what any decent solicitor will tell them to say

So if it only proves that people were in the area of the lead is it worth fingerprinting it (if the lead could be fingerprinted, I don't know if it could be?)

As for what the villagers say, well villagers like to gossip it may well have been youths larking about, my entire village was convinced I was a drug dealer because both me and my friend had leather jackets and went out after dark when we were 15.

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
streaky said:
So three men allegedly nicking lead from a church roof, who were spotted by villagers and questioned by police, were not arrested.

[Rest of story]
Prints no. DNA we had some success with. Depends also whobkids were etc. May well have been larding about and others may have dumped the lead. Most lead thieves wear gloves. You also have to have outlet so average kids would have nowher to go where as a certain type of kid would have an outlet. Just as locals think someone did it does not mean they did. The police may have then been accused of being heavy handed and criminalising youngsters.
Thanks. Apparently, the suspects were wearing gloves and balaclavas ... as youths do when "larking about" on scaffolding.




darren9 said:
If fingerprints were found on the lead nearby does that prove that who ever's fingerprints are on that lead are the ones that stole it? If the lead was rolled up in a public place then those people whos prints walk past it may have just been interested as to why there was rolled up lead there and had a look (with their hands and eyes despite their mothers advice of "look with your eyes not with yur hands"). - Or at least thats what any decent solicitor will tell them to say

So if it only proves that people were in the area of the lead is it worth fingerprinting it (if the lead could be fingerprinted, I don't know if it could be?) ...
If I've understood you correctly, I'll try to answer your questions.

Certainly, anyone who handles the lead might leave fingerprints on it (but see what Mr_annie_vxr has to say about lifting prints. But it's highly unlikely that a casual passer-by would unroll the lead, so any fingerprints inside it would most probably be those of the person who rolled it up ... i.e. the "thief".

[The defence that "I was in the area" is not uncommon, but that of "my prints walked past" is interesting, although unlikely to sway a Magistrate ... but could possibly persuade a jury of your peers.]

Streaky

Number 7

4,113 posts

293 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
This sounds like the story reported in the Telegraph yesterday. 3 youths wearing gloves and balaclavas on a church roof (Rotherham) with rolls of lead nearby, but according to the C.I., the police had no power to arrest them, as they might have been up there looking at the view.

Church targeted 10 times previously for lead.

7


Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
streaky said:
So three men allegedly nicking lead from a church roof, who were spotted by villagers and questioned by police, were not arrested.

[Rest of story]
Prints no. DNA we had some success with. Depends also whobkids were etc. May well have been larding about and others may have dumped the lead. Most lead thieves wear gloves. You also have to have outlet so average kids would have nowher to go where as a certain type of kid would have an outlet. Just as locals think someone did it does not mean they did. The police may have then been accused of being heavy handed and criminalising youngsters.
Thanks. Apparently, the suspects were wearing gloves and balaclavas ... as youths do when "larking about" on scaffolding.




darren9 said:
If fingerprints were found on the lead nearby does that prove that who ever's fingerprints are on that lead are the ones that stole it? If the lead was rolled up in a public place then those people whos prints walk past it may have just been interested as to why there was rolled up lead there and had a look (with their hands and eyes despite their mothers advice of "look with your eyes not with yur hands"). - Or at least thats what any decent solicitor will tell them to say

So if it only proves that people were in the area of the lead is it worth fingerprinting it (if the lead could be fingerprinted, I don't know if it could be?) ...
If I've understood you correctly, I'll try to answer your questions.

Certainly, anyone who handles the lead might leave fingerprints on it (but see what Mr_annie_vxr has to say about lifting prints. But it's highly unlikely that a casual passer-by would unroll the lead, so any fingerprints inside it would most probably be those of the person who rolled it up ... i.e. the "thief".

[The defence that "I was in the area" is not uncommon, but that of "my prints walked past" is interesting, although unlikely to sway a Magistrate ... but could possibly persuade a jury of your peers.]

Streaky
Streaky. Its not so much sway a jury as sway the CPS. On the extra information you provided I am very puzzled why they were not arrested. I would have done so either for the theft or going equipped. The issue may be the lack of a witness to the actions of the youths which coupled with the belief that with gloves there is no forensics the officers , knowing how the CPS work, decided it was pointless to arrest. Going equipped is very hard to prove without a confession.

We had some success recently though with dna and lifting glove impressions.

It sounds like officers on the ground may have been there and done it with the CPS before and decided hours of paperwork for a refused charge was pointless. I still would have though just for the fk you factor to the thieves and to show the villagers we'd tried.

g_attrill

9,179 posts

277 months

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
The police may have then been accused of being heavy handed and criminalising youngsters.
good point, im with you on this, let em all go do what they want, wouldnt want to get in a bit of trouble for catching a scrote now would we.

eldar

25,367 posts

227 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
If they were, as stated, cautioned, does that not mean they admitted the offence for which they were cautioned? Which isn't mentioned in the article...

Greendubber

15,394 posts

234 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
eldar said:
If they were, as stated, cautioned, does that not mean they admitted the offence for which they were cautioned? Which isn't mentioned in the article...
Indeed

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
The police may have then been accused of being heavy handed and criminalising youngsters.
good point, im with you on this, let em all go do what they want, wouldnt want to get in a bit of trouble for catching a scrote now would we.
It helps Gary not to quote out of context - still don't let that stop you from taking every opportunity to knock me or anyone else here. Its getting rather boring now though.

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
The police may have then been accused of being heavy handed ...
I don't think anyone suggested that the police were nicking the leadwink - Streaky

DucatiGary

7,765 posts

256 months

Wednesday 11th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Its getting rather boring now though.
only been 4 years, or are you saying its boring becuase im pointing out valid points you dont really like?

thought so.

as you where.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Wednesday 11th June 2008
quotequote all
DucatiGary said:
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Its getting rather boring now though.
only been 4 years, or are you saying its boring becuase im pointing out valid points you dont really like?

thought so.

as you where.
No because you really are so utterly full of crap. You also don't see that your not funny or making valid points. People like Justin, Tom, Streaky even fluff (sometimeswink ) make valid points. You just don't.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Wednesday 11th June 2008
quotequote all
Mr_annie_vxr said:
Depends also whobkids were etc. May well have been larding about and others may have dumped the lead. Most lead thieves wear gloves. You also have to have outlet so average kids would have nowher to go where as a certain type of kid would have an outlet. Just as locals think someone did it does not mean they did. The police may have then been accused of being heavy handed and criminalising youngsters.
Jebus, you're as bad as the police the OP is referring to biggrin
Now, repeat after me:
streaky said:
The villagers said they were not youths
Edited by Dracoro on Wednesday 11th June 08:41