NIP - Speed Camera Fine
NIP - Speed Camera Fine
Author
Discussion

ssavill

Original Poster:

287 posts

257 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
Howzit all - hope you are having a good one...

so a question for you - received a NIP for a speeding offense, from a speeding camera problem is a simple one - but i do not have a clue where i stand legally..

was doing 58 in a 50, got flashed, NIP turned up...

For the life of us neither myself or my wife have a clue who was driving... and its turned into a big barney around who should take the ticket...

The forms that they send say its a legal offense if you lie on the form.... anyone know the legal landscape on this or have been thru it themselves?

Thks,

Stuart.

Mr_annie_vxr

9,270 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
ssavill said:
Howzit all - hope you are having a good one...

so a question for you - received a NIP for a speeding offense, from a speeding camera problem is a simple one - but i do not have a clue where i stand legally..

was doing 58 in a 50, got flashed, NIP turned up...

For the life of us neither myself or my wife have a clue who was driving... and its turned into a big barney around who should take the ticket...

The forms that they send say its a legal offense if you lie on the form.... anyone know the legal landscape on this or have been thru it themselves?

Thks,

Stuart.
Return with a letter explaining you cannot remember who was driving and opt for court. As long as you show that there i no way of knowing who was driving with reasonable steps etc then you would not commit the offence.

Ask if they have a forward facing picture as well.

Issues will be, day /time of offence (who had access at that time- work etc), where it was, i.e a road you both drive etc

If you really do not know and they cannot provide a photo then you will be cleared at court, if you do know and as a result a little digging by someone would clearly show who was driving you could face a perverting charge.

www.pepipoo.com I think covers most of it allegedly

58 is right on the prosecution boundary as well.

711

806 posts

256 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
Could the OP phone the scamera office and ask if there is a photo? May be possible to resolve without having to go to court and risk thoughts of PCJ?

Perhaps even a rear facing photo could sort of the OP is bald and his wife has big hair hehe

BertBert

21,355 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
My experience is one of genuinely not knowing. As RK, I wrote back with as much info as I could get. This was on a car with 5 poss drivers incl me as RK. I named the possible drivers, put in as much info as I could (inc the fact that it couldn't have been me with work diary as backing data). I ruled another two out by asking them and that left two of which either could have been driving (but neither knew for certain which it was). It was not possible to sign the 172 as it was designed to only allow signature for naming the driver. [As far as I am concerned that in itself is PCJ as it does not cater for all of the legal conditions, but that's by the by].

The other two drivers then got S172s and they answered with what they knew (as they are not obliged to make enquiries, not being the RK). The responses all tied up as they were the truth.

Then got the usual begrudging "we'll let you off this time sonny" letter, together with wording that strongly implied that there was a legal obligation for me as RK to keep a log (wrong).

Bert




BertBert

21,355 posts

242 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
[redacted]

plushq

78 posts

224 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
BertBert said:
My experience is one of genuinely not knowing. As RK, I wrote back with as much info as I could get. This was on a car with 5 poss drivers incl me as RK. I named the possible drivers, put in as much info as I could (inc the fact that it couldn't have been me with work diary as backing data). I ruled another two out by asking them and that left two of which either could have been driving (but neither knew for certain which it was). It was not possible to sign the 172 as it was designed to only allow signature for naming the driver. [As far as I am concerned that in itself is PCJ as it does not cater for all of the legal conditions, but that's by the by].

The other two drivers then got S172s and they answered with what they knew (as they are not obliged to make enquiries, not being the RK). The responses all tied up as they were the truth.

Then got the usual begrudging "we'll let you off this time sonny" letter, together with wording that strongly implied that there was a legal obligation for me as RK to keep a log (wrong).

Bert
Oh yes there is:

172 Duty to give information as to identity of driver etc in certain circumstances (1) This section applies—
(a) to any offence under the preceding provisions of this Act except—
(i) an offence under Part V, or
(ii) an offence under section 13, 16, 51(2), 61(4), 67(9), 68(4), 96 or 120,
and to an offence under section 178 of this Act,
(b) to any offence under sections 25, 26 or 27 of the [1988 c. 53.] Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988,
(c) to any offence against any other enactment relating to the use of vehicles on roads, except an offence under paragraph 8 of Schedule 1 to the [1989 c. 22.] Road Traffic (Driver Licensing and Information Systems) Act 1989, and
(d) to manslaughter, or in Scotland culpable homicide, by the driver of a motor vehicle.
(2) Where the driver of a vehicle is alleged to be guilty of an offence to which this section applies—
(a) the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and
(b) any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.
(3) Subject to the following provisions, a person who fails to comply with a requirement under subsection (2) above shall be guilty of an offence.
(4) A person shall not be guilty of an offence by virtue of paragraph (a) of subsection (2) above if he shows that he did not know and could not with reasonable diligence have ascertained who the driver of the vehicle was.
(5) Where a body corporate is guilty of an offence under this section and the offence is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance of, or to be attributable to neglect on the part of, a director, manager, secretary or other similar officer of the body corporate, or a person who was purporting to act in any such capacity, he, as well as the body corporate, is guilty of that offence and liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly.
(6) Where the alleged offender is a body corporate, or in Scotland a partnership or an unincorporated association, or the proceedings are brought against him by virtue of subsection (5) above or subsection (11) below, subsection (4) above shall not apply unless, in addition to the matters there mentioned, the alleged offender shows that no record was kept of the persons who drove the vehicle and that the failure to keep a record was reasonable.
(7) A requirement under subsection (2) may be made by written notice served by post; and where it is so made—
(a) it shall have effect as a requirement to give the information within the period of 28 days beginning with the day on which the notice is served, and
(b) the person on whom the notice is served shall not be guilty of an offence under this section if he shows either that he gave the information as soon as reasonably practicable after the end of that period or that it has not been reasonably practicable for him to give it.
(8) Where the person on whom a notice under subsection (7) above is to be served is a body corporate, the notice is duly served if it is served on the secretary or clerk of that body.
(9) For the purposes of section 7 of the [1978 c. 30.] Interpretation Act 1978 as it applies for the purposes of this section the proper address of any person in relation to the service on him of a notice under subsection (7) above is—
(a) in the case of the secretary or clerk of a body corporate, that of the registered or principal office of that body or (if the body corporate is the registered keeper of the vehicle concerned) the registered address, and
(b) in any other case, his last known address at the time of service.
(10) In this section—
“registered address”, in relation to the registered keeper of a vehicle, means the address recorded in the record kept under the [1971 c. 10.] Vehicles (Excise) Act 1971 with respect to that vehicle as being that person’s address, and
“registered keeper”, in relation to a vehicle, means the person in whose name the vehicle is registered under that Act;
and references to the driver of a vehicle include references to the rider of a cycle.
(11) Where, in Scotland, an offence under this section is committed by a partnership or by an unincorporated association other than a partnership and is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance or in consequence of the negligence of a partner in the partnership or, as the case may be, a person concerned in the management or control of the association, he (as well as the partnership or association) shall be guilty of the offence.”

Was it reasonable for you NOT to keep a log?
As you have found it impossible to determine the driver of a company car then it may and most likely will be deemed NOT reasonable.
Have you excercised "reasonable dilligence" if you knowingly allow 5 drivers to regularly use the vehicle yet do not know when or where they do so? How you have excersised reasonable Dilligence must be proved by you, knowingly not keeping a log when you know multiple drivers use a vehicle shold immediately mean you can never bring that proof because it is reasonable to keep such a log.
S172 2(a) clearly puts the RK on the spot.
I wonder if the 5 of you would come up with the same conclusion if the vehicle was involved in a hit and run where a person had been killed; I expect the investigation would have pin-pointed the driver straight away.

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
plushq said:
BertBert said:
My experience is one of genuinely not knowing. As RK, I wrote back with as much info as I could get. This was on a car with 5 poss drivers incl me as RK. I named the possible drivers, put in as much info as I could (inc the fact that it couldn't have been me with work diary as backing data). I ruled another two out by asking them and that left two of which either could have been driving (but neither knew for certain which it was). It was not possible to sign the 172 as it was designed to only allow signature for naming the driver. [As far as I am concerned that in itself is PCJ as it does not cater for all of the legal conditions, but that's by the by].

The other two drivers then got S172s and they answered with what they knew (as they are not obliged to make enquiries, not being the RK). The responses all tied up as they were the truth.

Then got the usual begrudging "we'll let you off this time sonny" letter, together with wording that strongly implied that there was a legal obligation for me as RK to keep a log (wrong).

Bert
Oh yes there is:

172 Duty to give information as to identity of driver etc in certain circumstances (1) This section applies—
(a) to any offence under the preceding provisions of this Act except—
(i) an offence under Part V, or
(ii) an offence under section 13, 16, 51(2), 61(4), 67(9), 68(4), 96 or 120,
and to an offence under section 178 of this Act,
(b) to any offence under sections 25, 26 or 27 of the [1988 c. 53.] Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988,
(c) to any offence against any other enactment relating to the use of vehicles on roads, except an offence under paragraph 8 of Schedule 1 to the [1989 c. 22.] Road Traffic (Driver Licensing and Information Systems) Act 1989, and
(d) to manslaughter, or in Scotland culpable homicide, by the driver of a motor vehicle.
(2) Where the driver of a vehicle is alleged to be guilty of an offence to which this section applies—
(a) the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and
(b) any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.
(3) Subject to the following provisions, a person who fails to comply with a requirement under subsection (2) above shall be guilty of an offence.
(4) A person shall not be guilty of an offence by virtue of paragraph (a) of subsection (2) above if he shows that he did not know and could not with reasonable diligence have ascertained who the driver of the vehicle was.
(5) Where a body corporate is guilty of an offence under this section and the offence is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance of, or to be attributable to neglect on the part of, a director, manager, secretary or other similar officer of the body corporate, or a person who was purporting to act in any such capacity, he, as well as the body corporate, is guilty of that offence and liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly.
(6) Where the alleged offender is a body corporate, or in Scotland a partnership or an unincorporated association, or the proceedings are brought against him by virtue of subsection (5) above or subsection (11) below, subsection (4) above shall not apply unless, in addition to the matters there mentioned, the alleged offender shows that no record was kept of the persons who drove the vehicle and that the failure to keep a record was reasonable.
(7) A requirement under subsection (2) may be made by written notice served by post; and where it is so made—
(a) it shall have effect as a requirement to give the information within the period of 28 days beginning with the day on which the notice is served, and
(b) the person on whom the notice is served shall not be guilty of an offence under this section if he shows either that he gave the information as soon as reasonably practicable after the end of that period or that it has not been reasonably practicable for him to give it.
(8) Where the person on whom a notice under subsection (7) above is to be served is a body corporate, the notice is duly served if it is served on the secretary or clerk of that body.
(9) For the purposes of section 7 of the [1978 c. 30.] Interpretation Act 1978 as it applies for the purposes of this section the proper address of any person in relation to the service on him of a notice under subsection (7) above is—
(a) in the case of the secretary or clerk of a body corporate, that of the registered or principal office of that body or (if the body corporate is the registered keeper of the vehicle concerned) the registered address, and
(b) in any other case, his last known address at the time of service.
(10) In this section—
“registered address”, in relation to the registered keeper of a vehicle, means the address recorded in the record kept under the [1971 c. 10.] Vehicles (Excise) Act 1971 with respect to that vehicle as being that person’s address, and
“registered keeper”, in relation to a vehicle, means the person in whose name the vehicle is registered under that Act;
and references to the driver of a vehicle include references to the rider of a cycle.
(11) Where, in Scotland, an offence under this section is committed by a partnership or by an unincorporated association other than a partnership and is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance or in consequence of the negligence of a partner in the partnership or, as the case may be, a person concerned in the management or control of the association, he (as well as the partnership or association) shall be guilty of the offence.”

Was it reasonable for you NOT to keep a log?
As you have found it impossible to determine the driver of a company car then it may and most likely will be deemed NOT reasonable.
Have you excercised "reasonable dilligence" if you knowingly allow 5 drivers to regularly use the vehicle yet do not know when or where they do so? How you have excersised reasonable Dilligence must be proved by you, knowingly not keeping a log when you know multiple drivers use a vehicle shold immediately mean you can never bring that proof because it is reasonable to keep such a log.
S172 2(a) clearly puts the RK on the spot.
I wonder if the 5 of you would come up with the same conclusion if the vehicle was involved in a hit and run where a person had been killed; I expect the investigation would have pin-pointed the driver straight away.
But he kept a record of possible drivers. The regulation does not state that a log must be kept. It it meant that it would have stated something like 'a log containing driver details and dates and times of usage'.

SS2.

14,712 posts

269 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
plushq said:
BertBert said:
..together with wording that strongly implied that there was a legal obligation for me as RK to keep a log (wrong).
Oh yes there is.
Statute creates an implied requirement for companies to keep a record of who was driving at a particular time - or at least the company must, if summoned for an alleged s.172 offence, demonstrate that a failure to keep such a record was a reasonable one.

There is absolutely no legal requirement whatsoever for a private individual to keep a record of whomsoever may have been driving a particular vehicle at a particular time.

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
plushq said:
BertBert said:
My experience is one of genuinely not knowing. As RK, I wrote back with as much info as I could get. This was on a car with 5 poss drivers incl me as RK. I named the possible drivers, put in as much info as I could (inc the fact that it couldn't have been me with work diary as backing data). I ruled another two out by asking them and that left two of which either could have been driving (but neither knew for certain which it was). It was not possible to sign the 172 as it was designed to only allow signature for naming the driver. [As far as I am concerned that in itself is PCJ as it does not cater for all of the legal conditions, but that's by the by].

The other two drivers then got S172s and they answered with what they knew (as they are not obliged to make enquiries, not being the RK). The responses all tied up as they were the truth.

Then got the usual begrudging "we'll let you off this time sonny" letter, together with wording that strongly implied that there was a legal obligation for me as RK to keep a log (wrong).

Bert
Oh yes there is:

172 Duty to give information as to identity of driver etc in certain circumstances (1) This section applies—
(a) to any offence under the preceding provisions of this Act except—
(i) an offence under Part V, or
(ii) an offence under section 13, 16, 51(2), 61(4), 67(9), 68(4), 96 or 120,
and to an offence under section 178 of this Act,
(b) to any offence under sections 25, 26 or 27 of the [1988 c. 53.] Road Traffic Offenders Act 1988,
(c) to any offence against any other enactment relating to the use of vehicles on roads, except an offence under paragraph 8 of Schedule 1 to the [1989 c. 22.] Road Traffic (Driver Licensing and Information Systems) Act 1989, and
(d) to manslaughter, or in Scotland culpable homicide, by the driver of a motor vehicle.
(2) Where the driver of a vehicle is alleged to be guilty of an offence to which this section applies—
(a) the person keeping the vehicle shall give such information as to the identity of the driver as he may be required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and
(b) any other person shall if required as stated above give any information which it is in his power to give and may lead to identification of the driver.
(3) Subject to the following provisions, a person who fails to comply with a requirement under subsection (2) above shall be guilty of an offence.
(4) A person shall not be guilty of an offence by virtue of paragraph (a) of subsection (2) above if he shows that he did not know and could not with reasonable diligence have ascertained who the driver of the vehicle was.
(5) Where a body corporate is guilty of an offence under this section and the offence is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance of, or to be attributable to neglect on the part of, a director, manager, secretary or other similar officer of the body corporate, or a person who was purporting to act in any such capacity, he, as well as the body corporate, is guilty of that offence and liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly.
(6) Where the alleged offender is a body corporate, or in Scotland a partnership or an unincorporated association, or the proceedings are brought against him by virtue of subsection (5) above or subsection (11) below, subsection (4) above shall not apply unless, in addition to the matters there mentioned, the alleged offender shows that no record was kept of the persons who drove the vehicle and that the failure to keep a record was reasonable.
(7) A requirement under subsection (2) may be made by written notice served by post; and where it is so made—
(a) it shall have effect as a requirement to give the information within the period of 28 days beginning with the day on which the notice is served, and
(b) the person on whom the notice is served shall not be guilty of an offence under this section if he shows either that he gave the information as soon as reasonably practicable after the end of that period or that it has not been reasonably practicable for him to give it.
(8) Where the person on whom a notice under subsection (7) above is to be served is a body corporate, the notice is duly served if it is served on the secretary or clerk of that body.
(9) For the purposes of section 7 of the [1978 c. 30.] Interpretation Act 1978 as it applies for the purposes of this section the proper address of any person in relation to the service on him of a notice under subsection (7) above is—
(a) in the case of the secretary or clerk of a body corporate, that of the registered or principal office of that body or (if the body corporate is the registered keeper of the vehicle concerned) the registered address, and
(b) in any other case, his last known address at the time of service.
(10) In this section—
“registered address”, in relation to the registered keeper of a vehicle, means the address recorded in the record kept under the [1971 c. 10.] Vehicles (Excise) Act 1971 with respect to that vehicle as being that person’s address, and
“registered keeper”, in relation to a vehicle, means the person in whose name the vehicle is registered under that Act;
and references to the driver of a vehicle include references to the rider of a cycle.
(11) Where, in Scotland, an offence under this section is committed by a partnership or by an unincorporated association other than a partnership and is proved to have been committed with the consent or connivance or in consequence of the negligence of a partner in the partnership or, as the case may be, a person concerned in the management or control of the association, he (as well as the partnership or association) shall be guilty of the offence.”

Was it reasonable for you NOT to keep a log?
As you have found it impossible to determine the driver of a company car then it may and most likely will be deemed NOT reasonable.
Have you excercised "reasonable dilligence" if you knowingly allow 5 drivers to regularly use the vehicle yet do not know when or where they do so? How you have excersised reasonable Dilligence must be proved by you, knowingly not keeping a log when you know multiple drivers use a vehicle shold immediately mean you can never bring that proof because it is reasonable to keep such a log.
S172 2(a) clearly puts the RK on the spot.
I wonder if the 5 of you would come up with the same conclusion if the vehicle was involved in a hit and run where a person had been killed; I expect the investigation would have pin-pointed the driver straight away.
You are finally showing your true colours here are you not plushq rolleyes
What’s your real motivation then ? Might you have your snout in the lucrative scamera trough then ?

OK the answer is No ! you are wrong
A OP is a private individual not a body corporate so only S 172 (1)-(4) applies, not 5 onwards
B Sorry to disappoint you but there is absolutely no requirement in the real world for a private RK to keep a log. Your reasoning is pure wishful thinking not shared by many others, not even von
C Despite the spiteful authoritarian intent of S172 to force self incrimination for the convenience of automated enforcement, the RK is not ‘put on the spot’ as you’d like to put it. As BertBert said he provided such information as to the identity of the driver as he was required to give by or on behalf of a chief officer of police, and two of the 5 drivers of his car gave that information which was in their power to give and it seems sadly failed to lead to identification of the driver. End of story. Tough.

I too have been through this scenario and have had the petulant letter from the partnership drones.

Finally

D Had the vehicle been involved in a serious incident where a person had been killed and those involved kept schtumm,as has happened many times before the case would have probably been dropped though lack of evidence to charge and convict;

MillWheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
You are finally showing your true colours here are you not plushq rolleyes
What’s your real motivation then ? Might you have your snout in the lucrative scamera trough then ?
Not any more!! Well not directly!! smile

Rdited to correct the p*ss poor quotes on this forum! smile

Edited by MillWheel on Monday 9th June 00:35

MillWheel

6,149 posts

227 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
You are finally showing your true colours here are you not plushq rolleyes
What’s your real motivation then ? Might you have your snout in the lucrative scamera trough then ?
Not any more!! Well not directly!! smile

edited to correct the p*ss poor quotes on this forum! smile

Edited by MillWheel on Monday 9th June 00:36

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Monday 9th June 2008
quotequote all
MillWheel said:
Richard C said:
You are finally showing your true colours here are you not plushq rolleyes
What’s your real motivation then ? Might you have your snout in the lucrative scamera trough then ?
Not any more!! Well not directly!! smile

edited to correct the p*ss poor quotes on this forum! smile

Edited by MillWheel on Monday 9th June 00:36
I think we both suspect it be Steviebabes here. laugh

But husband/wife sharing the drive on family journey are not going to be filling in a log each time they swap seats. They not see the need to until pinged on borderline blip-over.

rolleyes

I would write as suggested to get a photo .. but to be sure not to give much aways as to who might have been driving at this early stage. Just say it could have been any of the drivers insured to drive this vehicle .. but you need to be sure who it was before you can complete any form...wink (but word it more cleverlywink than thiswink )