Car/cyclist interface failure - likely outcome?
Car/cyclist interface failure - likely outcome?
Author
Discussion

puffpuff

Original Poster:

23,222 posts

257 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
Scenario earlier this morning: Student driving to college turns right across path of approaching cyclist. Car/cyclist collide, cyclist hits windscreen, flies over car and lands on road. Car has dented front wing, cracked windscreen, bicycle has snapped front forks (not metal), buckled wheel. Cyclist? Unknown - no obvious wounds and is able to walk (assisted)to ambulance. He hit car with shoulder and landed on his back on road - sounds very lucky to me.

Young girl student driver is very upset. Other students's (not in car) say she was going slowly across the junction, other witness says she was hurrying through a short gap in the traffic.

Is she likely to be charged? If so, would it be driving without due care and attention?

The Black Duke

1,642 posts

224 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
puffpuff said:
Scenario earlier this morning: Student driving to college turns right across path of approaching cyclist. Car/cyclist collide, cyclist hits windscreen, flies over car and lands on road. Car has dented front wing, cracked windscreen, bicycle has snapped front forks (not metal), buckled wheel. Cyclist? Unknown - no obvious wounds and is able to walk (assisted)to ambulance. He hit car with shoulder and landed on his back on road - sounds very lucky to me.

Young girl student driver is very upset. Other students's (not in car) say she was going slowly across the junction, other witness says she was hurrying through a short gap in the traffic.

Is she likely to be charged? If so, would it be driving without due care and attention?
Maybe Driving Without Due Care and Attention.

Mandat

4,658 posts

269 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
More information required:

Was she turning through a line of stationary traffic, that had left a gap for her to pass through or was it a clear road?

Assuming that there was stationary traffic, was the cyclist riding on the inside or outside of the traffic?


deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
Mandat said:
More information required:

Was she turning through a line of stationary traffic, that had left a gap for her to pass through or was it a clear road?

Assuming that there was stationary traffic, was the cyclist riding on the inside or outside of the traffic?
Possibly mitigating factors but essentially irrelevant. The Highway Code specifically mentions this situation and it's reasonably clear that it is the responsibility of the turning vehicle to make sure the turn is safe.

http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/TravelAndTransport/Hig...

HC said:
When turning right across a line of slow-moving or stationary traffic, look out for cyclists or motorcyclists on the inside of the traffic you are crossing.

Mandat

4,658 posts

269 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
deckster said:
Mandat said:
More information required:

Was she turning through a line of stationary traffic, that had left a gap for her to pass through or was it a clear road?

Assuming that there was stationary traffic, was the cyclist riding on the inside or outside of the traffic?
Possibly mitigating factors but essentially irrelevant. The Highway Code specifically mentions this situation and it's reasonably clear that it is the responsibility of the turning vehicle to make sure the turn is safe.

http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/TravelAndTransport/Hig...

HC said:
When turning right across a line of slow-moving or stationary traffic, look out for cyclists or motorcyclists on the inside of the traffic you are crossing.
I disagree. It's totally relevant.

Depending on the situation on the road at that particular time, the turning driver can be as cautious, careful, safe, observant, etc as is possible but if the cyclist is riding such that he cannot stop in the distance that he can see to be clear, (particularly approaching a side junction where a gap in the traffic is visible, indicating the potential risk of a turning vehicle), then I say that the cyclist could be held partially culpable in the collision.

I am not saying that the cyclist is 100% to blame or the driver 100% innocent but there may be an element of shared responsibility depending on the circumstances of the collision. Hence the questions.

puffpuff

Original Poster:

23,222 posts

257 months

Tuesday 10th June 2008
quotequote all
Only just able to check, no on-coming traffic other than the cyclist. The witness I'm able to talk to was intending to turn left out of the side road but stopped to wait for the cyclist to pass.