My battery's lasted just 18 months :(
My battery's lasted just 18 months :(
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

83 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Car is a 96 Crossflow, so not complicated at all.
Had it out for New Year's Day when, after an overnight charge it leapt in to life, apparently pleased at being dragged out in to daylight.
Since then, the bloody thing simply refuses to start. Even after several days on charge, it just whirs away pathetically for about fifteen seconds before the start relay simply chatters away to itself while the rest of the car sits there like a won't even jump off another car.
It appears the battery just won't hold a charge, which I find pretty poor bearing in mind it's a brand name item less than two years old.
Part of me, deep down, suspects the car has an earth fault so no matter how much I charge the damned thing it's losing it just as fast.
Gotta love Lucas electrics.

Roadru77er

473 posts

224 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Tried Blat Chat?biggrin

DCL

1,228 posts

208 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Once the battery has failed there's not a lot to do but replace it. Sulphating of the electrodes is a process that starts from new and accelerates towards the end of its life as the capacity is lost.

The life depends on many things, but a small battery has a hard time in a car and a Caterham is about as bad as it gets. Two years to five years is typical life but 18 months is not that bad considering. But is worth checking the alternator (slip rings, if you can, as they may be worn or burnt) and the charging voltage when you fit a new battery. As you say, poor earth continuity to the engine could also result in a shorter battery life.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

83 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Alternator is only a couple of years old too. Summer 2011 I got to spend a lovely long weekend with friends in Scotland, whiling away the hours chasing the cause of poor starting and a flattening battery.
New battery, alternator and starter motor later and I finally got to go home......
AA Homestart now inbound. Sod it. At least he'll have the kit to give the battery a health check.

snapper seven

713 posts

243 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Is it a Banner battery (53034)?

These are notorious if they have been fully discharged, they really don't recover after that.
On the plus side they do have a 4 year warranty so if you have the receipt then take it back and hopefully they will give you a new one.

TheLastPost

1,150 posts

170 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Crossflow Kid said:
Part of me, deep down, suspects the car has an earth fault so no matter how much I charge the damned thing it's losing it just as fast.
Gotta love Lucas electrics.
Are you sure it's not just a bad earth causing the reluctance to start?

If it is the battery that's definitely dead, and you've lost the receipt for a replacement, then Halfrauds gives a 5 year warranty on Bosch calcium batteries.

Fit a 'Discarnect' or competition battery isolator and isolate your battery when the car is not in use - the battery will hold charge much longer.

Depending on the spec. of your Crossflow (if highly tuned; high compression and dizzy with non-vaccuum advance) they can be bds to turn over even with a fit battery and good earths, mind you, particularly if you're still using an old-fashioned inertia starter motor instead of a modern pre-engaged one (which it sounds like you are if you've got a separate starter solenoid?). Consider a geared starter motor if this is the case - they're not cheap, but they work wonders!

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

83 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
AA man sorted it. Well we did. Bit of fault diagnosis with me cranking while he prodded.....and he spotted the starter motor was shaking as it cranked. Turned out the casing bolts had loosened so it was all rattling apart, so it just wasn't performing.
Took it off, bolted it all back together again, refitted it, along with a new battery lead, and all is good in Crossflow world once more.

Agent Orange

2,194 posts

275 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Good to hear it's sorted but is it worth considering a charger and leaving the car plugged in permanently?

I have mine plugged into one of these whilst not in use
http://www.ctek.com/int/en/chargers/MXS%203.6

Seems to work very well.

Smollet

16,375 posts

219 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
My Banner has lasted for five years. I've got a battery cut off which I remove every time I don't use it. No need for a charger.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

83 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
Agent Orange said:
Good to hear it's sorted but is it worth considering a charger and leaving the car plugged in permanently?
Got one. Mixed results to be honest :-/

Guy Lowe

94 posts

197 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
In 10 years of Caterham ownership I have never charged the battery

EFA

1,670 posts

292 months

Friday 15th February 2013
quotequote all
In my 16 years experience of Banner powered Caterhams, the battery will deplete power over winter if the car is unused even if fully isolated.

Either start and recharge your car every 2 weeks, or use a conditioner. A CTEK XS 0.8 conditioner is a good piece of kit for under £35 on eBay.

Toaster

2,940 posts

222 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
EFA said:
In my 16 years experience of Banner powered Caterhams, the battery will deplete power over winter if the car is unused even if fully isolated.

Either start and recharge your car every 2 weeks, or use a conditioner. A CTEK XS 0.8 conditioner is a good piece of kit for under £35 on eBay.
I didn't realise your old car it was an electrically powered, thought it was a VX ........then again I could be wrong fancy that a Battery powered Caterham 7

Guy Lowe

94 posts

197 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
10 years ago when I got my Caterham, the first thing I did was throw away the Banner and fit a gel battery.

kenny.R400

1,212 posts

269 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
I don't trust just flicking the cut of switch any more, as the Caterham fitted item simply does not chop the power to everything (whether the later ones do I don't know)......as I found out last year and reported on BC.

The Optimate/Accumate/Ctek certainly seem to keep banners in good nick if left on all the time..........and my cars stand still for most of the year in the garage.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

83 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
Guy Lowe said:
In 10 years of Caterham ownership I have never charged the battery
Yes, but having a man to do it for you doesn't count.

Smollet

16,375 posts

219 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
kenny.R400 said:
I don't trust just flicking the cut of switch any more, as the Caterham fitted item simply does not chop the power to everything (whether the later ones do I don't know)......as I found out last year and reported on BC.

The Optimate/Accumate/Ctek certainly seem to keep banners in good nick if left on all the time..........and my cars stand still for most of the year in the garage.
I've experienced no problems so far but my 7 is only five years old. I do have an Airflow conditioner but that spends more time on my WRX as that drains its battery in ten days in really cold weather if not used.

TheLastPost

1,150 posts

170 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
kenny.R400 said:
I don't trust just flicking the cut of switch any more, as the Caterham fitted item simply does not chop the power to everything.
You need an FIA spec double pole master switch.

kenny.R400

1,212 posts

269 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
Cheers for that. Although the one I have was also classed as FIA.......I assume they put the one you mention on as standard for the race cars?

I only realised last summer when the fuel pump was running with switch off and key pulled out. Relay had stuckrolleyes

Tango7

693 posts

255 months

Saturday 16th February 2013
quotequote all
Kenny,

It obviously depends on how its wired. At scruitineering for the sprint meetings, they can check that the red key does shut the engine down by doing just that! I assume there have been times when the key has been turned and the engine continued to run.