Tyre repair or replace
Author
Discussion

davidll

Original Poster:

62 posts

214 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Hi all,
Have a slow puncture on my tyre and found this… can it be repaired or does the tyre need replacing?
Many thanks

Magic919

14,590 posts

232 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Looks too close to the edge for a standard repair.

davidll

Original Poster:

62 posts

214 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Thanks. Was afraid that would be the case

Silverbullet767

11,381 posts

237 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Replace all day long.

davidll

Original Poster:

62 posts

214 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Thanks. It’s a Lexus rx450. There’s about 3-4 mm on each of the front tyres. Is it usual practice to replace both tyres on the axle or only the affected tyre?

dontlookdown

2,568 posts

124 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Too close to the edge for a standard mushroom plug repair.

There are posters on here who claim there are specialists out there who can fix that kind of damage. All I will say is that, while there may well be such next level tyre whisperers about, I have never managed to find one when I needed them!

You can get those DIY tyre plug kits online, my old dad always told me they were dodgy but the yanks have been using them for years - how bad can they be? If it's just a runabout I'd be tempted to give the DIY approach ago, but not on a car that does many motorway miles.

stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
It's a tiny screw, I'd plug that myself and never worry about it.

I've used this loads of times, great quality kit.

https://www.arb4x4.co.uk/arb-speedy-seal-series-re...

There are cheaper variants.


Derry Rhumba

377 posts

22 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Another vote for repair and forget.

A tyre place wont do it as it's too far from the centre, you will need to do it yourself.

My mate has been running about with a DIY repair in a similar area for over a year now. With 3-4 mm of tread, you likely wont be keeping that tyre for ages anyway?

Quantum State

9,109 posts

311 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
I would replace a DIY repair is great until its not….

Pica-Pica

16,727 posts

115 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
davidll said:
Thanks. It s a Lexus rx450. There s about 3-4 mm on each of the front tyres. Is it usual practice to replace both tyres on the axle or only the affected tyre?
There are strong recommendations to replace tyres at 3mm remaking tread depth. You are close to that, just replace. I never imagined Lexus owners as tight-wads.

FlyVintage

531 posts

22 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Pica-Pica said:
davidll said:
Thanks. It s a Lexus rx450. There s about 3-4 mm on each of the front tyres. Is it usual practice to replace both tyres on the axle or only the affected tyre?
There are strong recommendations to replace tyres at 3mm remaking tread depth. You are close to that, just replace. I never imagined Lexus owners as tight-wads.
I have to agree (but not about routine replacement at 3mm). However, at 3-4mm a tyre is 75% worn, so repair seems somewhat illogical unless lack of funds is a driver (no pun intended).

Edited to add my basis for 75% worn; 8mm tread at new, 1.6mm at life expired.

Edited by FlyVintage on Friday 9th October 09:42

Furbo

4,199 posts

63 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
It's a tiny screw, I'd plug that myself and never worry about it.

I've used this loads of times, great quality kit.

https://www.arb4x4.co.uk/arb-speedy-seal-series-re...

There are cheaper variants.
I would do the same. It's a long time since I have had a tyre repaired or replaced for something like that.

E-bmw

13,656 posts

183 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
A "tyre place" can't legally repair that as it is too close to the sidewall, but a "sticky string" repair will still work as a DIY fix.

RacingStripes

1,372 posts

61 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
stevieturbo said:
It's a tiny screw, I'd plug that myself and never worry about it.

I've used this loads of times, great quality kit.

https://www.arb4x4.co.uk/arb-speedy-seal-series-re...

There are cheaper variants.
I would too, as a temp repair.
Its just that by the time i get it replaced it may have worn down to less than 2mm.

davidll

Original Poster:

62 posts

214 months

Friday 9th October
quotequote all
Thanks all… measured tread depth and it’s actually 5mm. Don’t mind replacing if felt necessary. Suspect conventional wisdom is that given the location of the puncture then a repair is not recommended.

I’ve actually got 2 spare tyres taking advantage of the recent Costco Michelin offer of £100 off 4 tyres. The first two were only changed 2 weeks ago. I will be booking an appt and seeing whether they recommend changing just the affected tyre or both…

stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Monday 12th October
quotequote all
Quantum State said:
I would replace a DIY repair is great until its not .
A screw like that could be in the tyre for months before some notice. Difference is the repair won't leak.


Rich1973

1,287 posts

208 months

Monday 12th October
quotequote all
A place that does tractor tyres etc will do a vulcanised repair on that no problem.
I had very similar on a nearly new tyre and had no issues through its life.