Rounded flare nut on hard line
Rounded flare nut on hard line
Author
Discussion

Lord E38

Original Poster:

155 posts

64 months

Thursday 22nd October
quotequote all


Trying to replace the hose on my E46 and in my wisdom I have rounded off the nut at the top. I used a proper 11mm flare nut wrench and let it soak overnight with penetrating oil. No joy with mole grips either. Haven't tried heat yet but I have a blowtorch in the post.

Forgive the stupid question (I've only had to do pads before) but what else can I try, and what should I do if I truly can't get it off? Thanks.

Ritchie335is

2,162 posts

233 months

Thursday 22nd October
quotequote all
Those flare nut wrenches are a waste of time, they just splay out.
Personally I d try decent vice grips again, but make sure that the teeth are decent and you get them on tight enough, if you don t burst a blood vessel in your eye when squeezing them on, they re not tight enough.
A gentle heat will also help.
It will come out you just need to approach it the right way.

steveo3002

11,244 posts

205 months

Thursday 22nd October
quotequote all
vice grips as tight as you can , or its looking a bit scabby replace the pipe or a section of it

i used to round them off all the time , then invested in some snap on flare nut spanners and theyre way better at not wrecking stuff

rOB.bOb

780 posts

281 months

Thursday 22nd October
quotequote all
Since you're replacing the hose, apply heat and then the flare nut spanner will work. The brake fluid does boil locally so make sure to disconnect the other end of the hose first, or cut the hose.
Worst case, cut the copper pipe just above the nut, put a new nut on and flare.

lufbramatt

5,696 posts

165 months

Thursday 22nd October
quotequote all
Looks like the original steel pipe? Which is a bit harder to flare properly.

On my e39 I ended up replacing all the hard lines with cunifer… the steel stuff was all on its last legs and started to split once you put any strain on it with mole grips etc.

ROTELLA

65 posts

12 months

Thursday 22nd October
quotequote all
I bought one of these Russian wrenches a few years ago & it's never failed:

Removing the clamping bolt means you can slip it over the pipe then replace & tighten.
No fear of rounding off the nut.

Was a few £ on Ebay but can't see any now.
Russian name is -
Ключ разрезной для тормозных трубок с винтом для зажима 7 x 11 мм


Ritchie335is

2,162 posts

233 months

Thursday 22nd October
quotequote all
That looks like a good tool!

DaveF-SkinnysAutos

230 posts

15 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Heat, heat and then some heat.

E-bmw

13,656 posts

183 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Personally, due to the state of the hard line, perhaps you should just cut it off & replace the hard line anyway.

steveo3002

11,244 posts

205 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
if youre likley to ever work on a used car again , get a roll of kunifer pipe and the flaring tool then you can laugh at this sort thing and knock up a new pipe in minutes , doesn't cost a massive amount either

and a snap on brand spanner is by the best at getting these undone

Edited by steveo3002 on Friday 23 October 11:21

GreenV8S

31,027 posts

315 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
ROTELLA said:
I bought one of these Russian wrenches a few years ago & it's never failed:
I haven't seen those before - they look like a great idea.

TwinKam

3,573 posts

126 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
It's all about the tools...
A crows foot wrench with a breaker bar is way superior to a flare nut spanner, but I do like the look of that Russian spanner!

Equally, the correct type of water-pump plier is superior to a Mole wrench, as it self tightens with the undoing pressure. Knipex Aligators are fantastic, they don't twist sideways because the hinge is supported on both sides, and have directional teeth, the harder you push, the more they bite.



Edited by TwinKam on Friday 23 October 13:07

stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Vise Grips make a tool that is solid for nuts if you have room. Available in different sizes

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/5a5ZsFJraLo

Although regular vise grips should do well too.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/183347022355

Gland pliers like the Knipex above are also very good as they tighten as you pull harder. I'd go for the Cobra with the locking pivot though

https://www.knipex.com/en-uk/products/pipe-wrenche...

Again available in different sizes.




redbulletv8

18 posts

12 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Parrot nose jaw grips work well too. Agree that the pipe requies replacing though.

E-bmw

13,656 posts

183 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Swedish pipe wrench for me whenever I need to go nuclear.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/MAXPOWER-Plumbers-Stilson...

The amount of torque you can put on is astounding, never ever slipped or failed me.

Although mine are the Bahco equivalent.

Belle427

12,044 posts

264 months

Saturday 24th October
quotequote all
Good mole grips should do it, bit of heat helps too. Recently had had to do this on my S2000.

steveo3002

11,244 posts

205 months

Saturday 24th October
quotequote all
even if you get it undone , are you wanting to re assemble with a rounded nut?

E-bmw

13,656 posts

183 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
steveo3002 said:
even if you get it undone , are you wanting to re assemble with a rounded nut?
Another reason why I said the above.

stevieturbo

18,106 posts

278 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
steveo3002 said:
even if you get it undone , are you wanting to re assemble with a rounded nut?
If it coms undone, pipe etc is all good and you do not have the means or pipe length to re-make the end.....sometimes it's the better option.

The same tools that undo it, will tighten it plenty too.

Lord E38

Original Poster:

155 posts

64 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
Ritchie335is said:
if you don t burst a blood vessel in your eye when squeezing them on, they re not tight enough
I guess this is what I needed to hear, I did the above and finally cracked it loose. I was able to turn it with the line wrench after so it can't be as badly rounded as I first thought.

It'll have to go back together the way it is because the car is in the way of our garage but I may come back and replace the line and fitting at a later date.