Sense checking a cash in lieu offer
Sense checking a cash in lieu offer
Author
Discussion

kiethton

Original Poster:

14,669 posts

211 months

Tuesday 20th October
quotequote all
Hi all, quick ballpark estimate if possible to sense check any insurance offer when it comes.

A neighbour managed to scrape down the side of our 2015 M135i yesterday evening. Thankfully they worked out who owned the car and came to our door to apologise and exchange details. Their insurance company contacted me today and are talking to a cash settlement rather than a repair so it's not written off (high miles but high spec, think worth £8-9k) although I can't see this repair getting anywhere close?

Damage looks to be scuffing to the rear bumper, rear quarter and alloy with no warning lights and no real metal movement so these parts being repaired/replaced plus an alignment should see me good again.

Only headache is we're in S London so have the London tax to contend with. Some photos which hopefully show the full extent of the damage below.






SteBrown91

3,168 posts

160 months

Tuesday 20th October
quotequote all
Its going to need at least 2 wheels refurbed so it matches (unlikely anywhere will get a perfect colour match). But that bumper and quarter should be easily repairable.

I'd say a grand for a decent job? Could likely get it less than that but leaves a bit of fudge factor for any unexpected costs etc.

kiethton

Original Poster:

14,669 posts

211 months

Tuesday 20th October
quotequote all
Thanks, had been a good few years since I had to look at something like this - my gut was saying about £1500 based on being quoted £1k for similar damage (annoyingly matching but in the other side!) following a similar incident in 2019 that we never actually bothered getting repaired. Just didn't know how far costs had inflated, especially in the SE, since then.

DaveF-SkinnysAutos

230 posts

15 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
It depends on your expectations, an insurance paid for job should be the whole rear bumper, the rear quarter which (I cant see from your photo) usually involves going over the top and down to the bottom of the A pillar, being a metallic and the damage to the arch being close to the rear door it needs a blend into the door to colour match, then it also needs the alloy repairing.

If you go to an insurance approved bodyshop with VAT etc its going to be £2K with your London geography.

If you want the cash in lieu and its your choice, you can probably live with a Smart repair on the bumper corner, there may be a swage line on the rear quarter that can be used rather than going over the A pillar? And the alloy can also be smart repaired. The blend into the door is little bit harder, being so little damage and a dark grey it could be possible not to have a edge to edge colour mismatch but that would come down to the skill of the painter.

kiethton

Original Poster:

14,669 posts

211 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
Thanks - let's see what they come back with

Sheepshanks

41,379 posts

150 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
Some years ago I took a cash settlement from a bus company's accident management company for a scuff on front bumper, and a very slight press in of the trim around the wheel arch. It was £750+VAT.

What threw me a bit was they would only give me the ex-VAT amount unless I got it repaired and sent them the invoice.

It polished out enough, and the trim being pressed in wasn't noticeable, that I never got it repaired. Insurance added £50 (about 15%) when I told them at renewal.

v8notbrave

942 posts

44 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
Why do u suggest London tax? There's so much supply if you shop around prices will be competitive

I now live remote/rural and that's different where's there's limited supply and everyone is busy the prices are strong

Basic economics in my experience

I'm sure you can get that done for well under a bag of sand

kiethton

Original Poster:

14,669 posts

211 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
Thanks all, managed to contact a body shop we've been unfortunate enough to use before.... after sending some photos they've quoted £2.7k by the time the VAT is added, eish. At least it gives me a number!

SteBrown91

3,168 posts

160 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
£2700 is outrageous.

The bumper is highly likely repairable and just needs a sand plus paint, and that quarter needs some minor straightening on the arch and a skim of filler.

Then paint plus wheel refurb. All 4 wheels refurbed is £3-400 quid tops!

v8notbrave

942 posts

44 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
Omg, get more quotes from smart repair, back street garages etc, what's the quote for, must be a new bumper and painting the whole side to blend the metallic etc or is there more damage we can't see?

I would've thought a smart repair and live with the slight panel gap pinch at the bottom, £500 i'd aim for, then £75 for the wheel

Good luck

DaveF-SkinnysAutos

230 posts

15 months

Wednesday 21st October
quotequote all
I run a bodyshop, 2.7K is not outrageous, thats an insurance quote price. I don't do insurance work, I do classic resto's, but I do day to day non insurance paintwork alongside to pay the bills.

The insurance market has created its own loop, only insurance approved bodyshops can work with them, but to be approved you have to work to standards that are bonkers, however, taking the insurance side out, thats still a massive repair, you say just put some filler on it, its only a small area etc, but you have to clear coat an entire panel and you have to blend the repair. The rear arch damage is too close to the rear door for a metallic paint blend, all day long the door has to be blended to match, also the rear quarter goes up and over the top of both the doors and down the A pillar, so all of that has to be clear coated and prepped and masked.

There are short cuts and if the customer wants to accept those shortcuts then the price is less, but if you go to a bodyshop and ask for a quote its going to be to approved standards.

I don't think you understand the cost of materials, gas, electricity, rent, business rates, insurance, waste disposal etc etc.

Personally I get to know the customer and offer different choices and explain the pros and cons of each option, is it a car to run the kids to school or is it your pride and joy etc, etc.

Happy to get the feedback, but 2.7k is dear, but reasonable for an insurance approved repair to that damage. But, having said that, I wouldn't pay it and my prices wouldn't be anywhere as high, but I don't have the overheads they do, but I do understand how and why they get to that price.

ExpertCarCheck

7 posts

2 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
Before they make an offer, I'd get the numbers on your side sorted, as that's what you'll be negotiating against.

Get the £2.7k quote itemised: bumper (repair or new), quarter, blending the door, wheel, alignment, VAT. That tells you whether they're quoting a new bumper and painting the whole side, which is what DaveF's describing, or a repair. Then get one or two more quotes, including a smart repairer for the bumper corner and the wheel. That gives you a range, not one number.

A few things I'd check before agreeing anything:

- If it has rear parking sensors, make sure they all still work. A cracked sensor holder or bracket behind a scuffed corner is easy to miss in photos and adds to the bill later.
- Look under the edge of the bumper and the arch liner for anything bent, and get the alignment checked if the wheel took a knock.
- As Sheepshanks found, ask whether the cash figure includes VAT or whether VAT is only paid against a repair invoice. It makes a big difference on a quote this size.

You don't have to take the first figure. If it comes in well under your quotes, send them the itemised quote and ask them to explain the gap. If you take the cash and don't fix it, keep the paperwork, because the next buyer or a future claim may ask about the old damage.

Belle427

12,044 posts

264 months

Friday 23rd October
quotequote all
We have just had a rear bumper repaired with some deeper damage than that, cost was £500.
Im not sure if they removed the rear bumper to paint it all, have not had a break in the weather to inspect it thoroughly yet.
Be interested in a painters view if that was just bumper damage would you need to blend in to the panel above to get a match on a grey metallic?

DaveF-SkinnysAutos

230 posts

15 months

Saturday 24th October
quotequote all
Belle427 said:
We have just had a rear bumper repaired with some deeper damage than that, cost was £500.
Im not sure if they removed the rear bumper to paint it all, have not had a break in the weather to inspect it thoroughly yet.
Be interested in a painters view if that was just bumper damage would you need to blend in to the panel above to get a match on a grey metallic?
You will roll your eyes, but there isn't a straight answer! Your eyes notice colour changes when they are sudden, so what we call edge to edge, when you blend, actually your paint really only needs to be 80% plus match to the original colour, obviously you want it better than that, but the human eye wont pick up a blended colour change. With metallics it's harder because it's not just the colour it's what we call the flop of the metallics, so the way the flakes settle determine how the light reflects on those flakes. If in the factory its been painted say vertically, left to right, and if I repair it horizontally going right to left there will be a difference, you can see it on poorly painted silver cars where its like a striped look. There are techniques to prevent this, drop coats, pressure changes to how we atomise the paint etc, but thats the principle.

On a bumper, its lower down so you are looking down and only get the light reflecting from that angle, plus the shape of a bumper means there are lots of changes to light reflecting as the shape changes, so overall you get away with more, thats why smart repairs work so well on bumpers, plus painted plastic against painted metal means usually there is a slight colour difference where a bumper meets a body panel, as light absorbs on plastic different to how it absorbs on metal, so all good points for painting a bumper.

If its a long flat body panel you don't have that margin so in the example above the chip to the rear wheel arch is so close to the door that when repairing it, the new paint will go to the edge, if you don't blend the door you may see it, if the chip was further in and say directly above the top of the wheel I could repair it without any new paint going near the edge, so no blend needed. If it was a flat colour again, a lot more room for error than trying to lay down a metallic paint to match.

Does that make sense? Ultimately its the customers choice, I could repair the quarter and not blend into the door, on a good day I would get away with it, on a bad day in the right light you would notice a difference. If its an insurance job its getting blended every time, if its a trader selling a car they would tell me not to blend as they don't care about anything but costs.

Hope that helps!

Belle427

12,044 posts

264 months

Saturday 24th October
quotequote all
Yep great info thanks.

kiethton

Original Poster:

14,669 posts

211 months

Wednesday 28th October
quotequote all
And to close this off the third parties' insurer called and settled at the quote I'd sent on. VAT not included for obvious reasons but they did say that if the work was done I can sent the actual invoice in for a VAT top-up.

Have to shout out the insurer (Tusker salary sacrifice policy) for settling it up within 9 days of the scrape happening.

With other parts of the car battle-scarred from 8 years of on-street London parking, the demands of a newborn baby and the ongoing recovery from a big medical incident of my own last month I'm tempted to just leave the scrape as it will have no impact on an MOT and it could well happen again as is still on-road, but accept a reduced price if we ever do sell it in the future.

daytonavrs

1,133 posts

115 months

Saturday 31st October
quotequote all
If the cars nothing posh to you I'd layman repair and pocket the cash if they offer anything like £2k!
My wife had bumper damage AND bodywork and a Wellingborough handy guy sprayed it all in for about £350 - arguable worse damage. It was 99% good, I didn't want to go perfection well....have you had experience of other halves and damage (hint: not the first rodeo biggrin )

I've just gone out and put a bit of paint on my own black car incidentally - where I erroneously touched a dividing wall to the neighbour because one of my other cars was on the road and close....admittedly it needs more work than that and is not "nice" but will do for now. I'd already touched it up lightly and was trying to glue pull some light dent/creases it made on scratching the paint.

The worst issue actually is more these dents the brick made than paint so I just threw another layer of paint to get it more close to smooth in case of further pulling, though I fear as it cannot be reached behind it may be better to get those weld on stick pulling things in longer term which I'm interested to try out.

Your car - Ok there is alloy damage there but I think easily repairable. Northampton alloy guy would do those about £50 a wheel if not diamond cut too.


daytonavrs

1,133 posts

115 months

Saturday 31st October
quotequote all
Also now you have recorded your "evidence"...

You'd be surprised how much of it would look better with just for now a good polish.
(Rear qtr damage is least, looks like nothing to me likely to just polish out)

It may be that some of the material depositing from contact with the other car perhaps....it won't make it any worse.