Top Gear arctic challenge disproves MMGW
Top Gear arctic challenge disproves MMGW
Author
Discussion

Stigmundfreud

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
Just watching the repeat of the Artic Challenge on Dave. At some point on their trip Jeremy and James hit upon the remains of a 1940s C47 aeroplane that had crash landed.

In the series the image of the plane (reg 316062) is clearly burried in thick ice and snow



That photo, taken in 1965, is pretty much similar to the scene faced by Topgear back in 2006/7.

However just a few years earlier this is what the scene looked like



That shot was taken in 1958 just 7 years before the previous picture and clearly shows that the area has gotten colder not warmer

Edited by Stigmundfreud on Sunday 9th November 14:59

Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
Pics not working.

BTW. Was Diana the pilot?

Stigmundfreud

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
try now fixed the picture

Petoz

116 posts

216 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
Surely the time of year was differs in each picture, and on the Polar Challenge Top Gear?

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
Stigmundfreud said:
Just watching the repeat of the Artic Challenge on Dave. At some point on their trip Jeremy and James hit upon the remains of a 1940s C47 aeroplane that had crash landed.
I missed that...how the hell did they drive artics through all that snow? hehe

CosmicMatt

634 posts

228 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
Its an intersting theory. Maybe you should send it into TG. Get PH a mention on the show and you can bask as a legend forever. wink

Surely the difference in time of year may have something to do with the lack of snow here or there?

XJSJohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
i think what Stigmund is trying to do is to demonstrate global freezing by using Top Gear

thumbup

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Stigmundfreud said:
Just watching the repeat of the Artic Challenge on Dave. At some point on their trip Jeremy and James hit upon the remains of a 1940s C47 aeroplane that had crash landed.
I missed that...how the hell did they drive artics through all that snow? hehe
This is one they tried earlier.


Olf

11,978 posts

249 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Stigmundfreud said:
Just watching the repeat of the Artic Challenge on Dave. At some point on their trip Jeremy and James hit upon the remains of a 1940s C47 aeroplane that had crash landed.
I missed that...how the hell did they drive artics through all that snow? hehe
I didn't want to be so pedantic but now you've done it I actually think it's was done tastefully and is funny. Congrats.

carmonk

7,910 posts

218 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
Dare I suggest one was taken in summer and the other in winter?

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
Olf said:
mybrainhurts said:
Stigmundfreud said:
Just watching the repeat of the Artic Challenge on Dave. At some point on their trip Jeremy and James hit upon the remains of a 1940s C47 aeroplane that had crash landed.
I missed that...how the hell did they drive artics through all that snow? hehe
I didn't want to be so pedantic but now you've done it I actually think it's was done tastefully and is funny. Congrats.
Pedantic is for serious criticism, not whimsies, but thanks for your support...smile

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
carmonk said:
Dare I suggest one was taken in summer and the other in winter?
REPOST OF REPOST...rofl

Edited by mybrainhurts on Sunday 9th November 15:16

mike_1985

357 posts

222 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
It shouldnt really matter what time of the year the pictures were taken , If the town they set off was 400 miles away from pole then it should be snow all year round . The programe made me to belive they found it half way through the journey .

You must be really ignorant if you think man made pollution is not affecting world weather

carmonk

7,910 posts

218 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
mike_1985 said:
It shouldnt really matter what time of the year the pictures were taken , If the town they set off was 400 miles away from pole then it should be snow all year round . The programe made me to belive they found it half way through the journey .

You must be really ignorant if you think man made pollution is not affecting world weather
Who thinks that?

groucho

12,134 posts

277 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
mike_1985 said:
It shouldnt really matter what time of the year the pictures were taken , If the town they set off was 400 miles away from pole then it should be snow all year round . The programe made me to belive they found it half way through the journey .

You must be really ignorant if you think man made pollution is not affecting world weather
What pollution do you talk of?

m3jappa

6,950 posts

249 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
mike_1985 said:
It shouldnt really matter what time of the year the pictures were taken , If the town they set off was 400 miles away from pole then it should be snow all year round . The programe made me to belive they found it half way through the journey .

You must be really ignorant if you think man made pollution is not affecting world weather
Brace yourself.

Sciroccology

29,908 posts

261 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
mike_1985 said:
You must be really ignorant if you think man made pollution is not affecting world weather
Then I must be really ignorant.

Stigmundfreud

Original Poster:

22,454 posts

241 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
mike_1985 said:
It shouldnt really matter what time of the year the pictures were taken , If the town they set off was 400 miles away from pole then it should be snow all year round . The programe made me to belive they found it half way through the journey .

You must be really ignorant if you think man made pollution is not affecting world weather
you are part of the brainwashed/dead generation

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all

Sciroccology

29,908 posts

261 months

Sunday 9th November 2008
quotequote all
johnfelstead said:
So, what you're alluding to is the fact that the ice melted in the summer.

Crikey, who'd have thought it?