What Sat Nav with live traffic updates?
What Sat Nav with live traffic updates?
Author
Discussion

Sir Bagalot

Original Poster:

7,040 posts

209 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
Currently have a Tom Tom One.... yes, it really is that oldyes

My requirements are Europe maps (as it's occasionally used there, but only once/twice a year). It must have traffic updates. Anything else I'm not bothered about and I'd like to keep the price down.

Also I assume that after a while I'll have to pay to keep the traffic updates.... Cost?

So, recommendations please. Ta

Edited by Sir Bagalot on Friday 9th August 16:05

BIRMA

4,267 posts

222 months

Friday 9th August 2013
quotequote all
I think Halfords are still doing the 1005 HD with free lifetime maps and 3 years free casmeras when you work it out its nearly free.
There have been a few problems getting it set up if you have a certain anti virus software but I have had no problems and rate it very very highly and is a significant upgrade on previous models (mine was a 540 live)

BIG DUNC

1,924 posts

251 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Is there a general view on here about which is better, TMC or the Tom Tom HD live? Are there any other traffic systems on the market? Do Garmin do one?

Sir Bagalot

Original Poster:

7,040 posts

209 months

Tuesday 13th August 2013
quotequote all
Borrowed a friends Garmin the other day.

  • Didn't like the main voice... sound a bit camplaugh
  • Liked the way it announced I would be on this road for 23miles
  • Liked the way it announced the name of the road I would be turning onto
  • It had traffic although this wasn't live live updates
So what's the real life difference between traffic updates and live live traffic updates?

BIRMA

4,267 posts

222 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Sir Bagalot said:
Borrowed a friends Garmin the other day.

  • Didn't like the main voice... sound a bit camplaugh
  • Liked the way it announced I would be on this road for 23miles
  • Liked the way it announced the name of the road I would be turning onto
  • It had traffic although this wasn't live live updates
So what's the real life difference between traffic updates and live live traffic updates?
As far as I know the Tom Tom system works on information from mobile phones, what I do know is that if from Portsmouth I travel to Donington Park put the postcode in and generally arrive within a minute of what it predicts. If along the way there is a major incident it diverts you perfectly and gives you time to call the client to say you will be arriving at whatever time it says, it's that good as far as my experience goes. The new lane indicator system means that Lemmings like me can't get it wrong, I rate the unit very highly and use it a lot. The speed camera is as good as my Road Angel too. I don't work for Tom Tom either!

BIG DUNC

1,924 posts

251 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Thats useful info, thanks.

Getting increasingly hacked off with my TMC system which does not always pick up a signal.

I just have to decide which Tom Tom now.

BIRMA

4,267 posts

222 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
BIG DUNC said:
Thats useful info, thanks.

Getting increasingly hacked off with my TMC system which does not always pick up a signal.

I just have to decide which Tom Tom now.
The 1005 is quite expensive but at the moment Halfords and others are offering a good deal with free lifetime maps and three years live services which added up makes the unit dead cheap. Just a bit of advice about setting it up on your computer if you check out the other thread 'All singing dancing sat nav' dasherdiablo had a right pain with his.

markmullen

15,877 posts

262 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
BIRMA said:
BIG DUNC said:
Thats useful info, thanks.

Getting increasingly hacked off with my TMC system which does not always pick up a signal.

I just have to decide which Tom Tom now.
The 1005 is quite expensive but at the moment Halfords and others are offering a good deal with free lifetime maps and three years live services which added up makes the unit dead cheap. Just a bit of advice about setting it up on your computer if you check out the other thread 'All singing dancing sat nav' dasherdiablo had a right pain with his.
TT would be my recommendation.

I travel a lot (usually 1000 miles a week average) and swear by TT Live traffic, I had a 20 minute dalliance with a top of the range Garmin before I took it back and swapped it.

Tomtom, crap company, great product.

BIRMA

4,267 posts

222 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Couldn't agree more, good products but when there was a problem years ago with a software update Tom Tom were useless to say the least.

anonymous-user

82 months

Wednesday 14th August 2013
quotequote all
Waze on your smartphone does this for free

waremark

3,296 posts

241 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
"Tomtom, crap company, great product."

Agreed. HD Traffic is excellent, journey times are accurate, ability to produce accurate journey times must mean route planning is good - which it is.

When I have tried TMC traffic I have found it useless.

Garmin do an equivalent of HD Traffic which is available via Android phones - and using your data allowance on your phone contract. This seems far less satisfactory than the HD Traffic internal sim card system; I have not tried it nor had any first hand reports on it. Anyone here had relevant experience?

Be aware a new range from TT is coming out very soon (Go 5000/6000, I think).

JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

170 months

Thursday 15th August 2013
quotequote all
waremark said:
Garmin do an equivalent of HD Traffic which is available via Android phones - and using your data allowance on your phone contract. This seems far less satisfactory than the HD Traffic internal sim card system; I have not tried it nor had any first hand reports on it. Anyone here had relevant experience?

Be aware a new range from TT is coming out very soon (Go 5000/6000, I think).
There was two different new TomTom ranges the GO 500/600 = which uses your phone for traffic (needs bluetooth tethering, which for Android is 4 onwards) and the GO 5000/6000 which have sims.

From other threads it seems the data used is quite low and the wait for traffic using bluetooth tethering is almost 0 (as opposed to a couple of minutes on sim versions). So I wouldn't rule it out.

I am not sure the Garmin traffic is comparable to TomTom HD Live

vrsmxtb

2,003 posts

184 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Is it worth holding out a bit until the new Tom Tom range is out? Bigger discounts on the old range?


JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

170 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
vrsmxtb said:
Is it worth holding out a bit until the new Tom Tom range is out? Bigger discounts on the old range?
Both the new 500/600 & 5000/6000 ranges are out/available

RedAlfa

480 posts

212 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
I have been using a Tom Tom with a Traffic Receiver for a year or so. A few months ago it didn't warn me about a 15 mile traffic jam on a very busy route ... frown

JimmyTheHand

1,001 posts

170 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
RedAlfa said:
I have been using a Tom Tom with a Traffic Receiver for a year or so. A few months ago it didn't warn me about a 15 mile traffic jam on a very busy route ... frown
Was it a TMC receiver or HD live traffic?

Sir Bagalot

Original Poster:

7,040 posts

209 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Well I bought a TT1005 with 3 years live traffic.

Really is an excellent device and it's only flaw (that I can see) is that in average speed roadworks it gives your average speed and not your actual speed.

markmullen

15,877 posts

262 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Sir Bagalot said:
Well I bought a TT1005 with 3 years live traffic.

Really is an excellent device and it's only flaw (that I can see) is that in average speed roadworks it gives your average speed and not your actual speed.
Which, unless they ad in static cameras, is the only speed you need, if you need the current speed you can always use the speedo.

BIRMA

4,267 posts

222 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Sir Bagalot said:
Well I bought a TT1005 with 3 years live traffic.

Really is an excellent device and it's only flaw (that I can see) is that in average speed roadworks it gives your average speed and not your actual speed.
Glad you like it I think very highly of mine still, I found the average speed read-out a bit weird but travelling daily through the M27 road works I'm quite at home with it now. I also find the junction guidance display idiot proof to date.

Sir Bagalot

Original Poster:

7,040 posts

209 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
markmullen said:
Sir Bagalot said:
Well I bought a TT1005 with 3 years live traffic.

Really is an excellent device and it's only flaw (that I can see) is that in average speed roadworks it gives your average speed and not your actual speed.
Which, unless they ad in static cameras, is the only speed you need, if you need the current speed you can always use the speedo.
That's not my understanding of how they work. If you have roadworks with 6 cameras in then effectively you have three lots of two. With six I don't know which ones are linked so an average speed isn't much use to you. Current speed is always out on speedo due to overreading.