Ni-Mh battery failure
Ni-Mh battery failure
Author
Discussion

scrwright

Original Poster:

3,085 posts

214 months

Tuesday 5th March 2013
quotequote all
Just had an old ish nimh battery lose all charge very rapidly resulting in a badly parked Twinstar frown

Thought they should drop off slowly rather than fall off a cliff. Usually get 10 mins from a charge on this one, but at around 8 minutes it shut the motors down (after about 10 sec of noise change from the props) then 20 secs later all power to servos lost. It was in the final turn for a deadstick, all looking fine then it nosed in from 30ft. Wing requires a dose of exopy & tape now, it will fly again.

Thinking about this could I have a dodgy ESC? Best see what voltage the battery is now giving

theshrew

6,008 posts

208 months

Wednesday 6th March 2013
quotequote all
How old is the battery ?
How many cells are in the pack ?
Do you discharge them etc ? What is your proceedure ?
How old are the motors ?

Im a car man not a plane so forgive me if im wrong but Your ESC wont effect the servo's - well on a car that only powers the motor


theshrew

6,008 posts

208 months

Wednesday 6th March 2013
quotequote all
How old is the battery ?
How many cells are in the pack ?
Do you discharge them etc ? What is your proceedure ?
How old are the motors ?

Im a car man not a plane so forgive me if im wrong but Your ESC wont effect the servo's - well on a car that only powers the motor


hman

7,497 posts

218 months

Wednesday 6th March 2013
quotequote all
Batteries are batteries and are affeccted by number of times used, charge rate applied, temperature (this can have a BIG effect on battery capacity), and a number of other variables.

I bin all my batteries every year and dont take any chances that way. Batteries are cheap and have a profound effect on the outcome of any flight.

I fly glow engines and have had an rx pack give up the ghost on a 1/2 fuelled plane resulting in a fly away over a very long distance, model hit the roof of a house which knocked out 6 or so tiles... could have been a lot worse.

I include a name and address sticker inside the model so that if this ever happens I can be contacted, because I'm a memeber of a club I have full insurance for this - I assume you do to?

scrwright

Original Poster:

3,085 posts

214 months

Wednesday 6th March 2013
quotequote all
ESC is a bec one so no separate reciever battery. I am a BMFA member so insured. Was a 9.6v 8 cell batery about 18 months old. No matter, I am binning the ECS, batteries & reciever (switching to 2.4ghz) My glow planes are on 2.4 with fail safe so shouldn't have to walk too far for them as they are bound with a throttle cut. Only my twinstar was on 35mhz

theshrew

6,008 posts

208 months

Wednesday 6th March 2013
quotequote all
The battery will be fecked after that long mate.

When i raced a lot with these cells i only used them for a few meetings then they went to be my practice cells. Obv they get a lot more hammer in a car but they dont last long especially if you dont look after them

hman

7,497 posts

218 months

Wednesday 6th March 2013
quotequote all
Am amazed that the power pack wasn't lipo in the twinstar!

My point about binning rx and tax batts after a year still applies, even if you run a failsafe- it's not going to land itself gracefully lol!

Amused2death

2,520 posts

220 months

Thursday 7th March 2013
quotequote all
Search for "Black wire corrosion"

Don't ask me how I know about this.....

getmecoat

hman

7,497 posts

218 months

Friday 8th March 2013
quotequote all
This doesn't bear the hall marks of black wire corrosion.

MartG

22,406 posts

228 months

Wednesday 13th March 2013
quotequote all
NiMH batteries usually only have a lifespan of a couple of years at best, no matter how they are treated