Is my wheel correct?
Author
Discussion

Master Bean

Original Poster:

5,016 posts

145 months

Wednesday 8th April
quotequote all
It's hard to tell in a picture but I think my wheel is not in the middle. It looks like it's to the left of centre. The bike shop fitted a 135mm wheel but it's a 141 so they've put a spacer but I think this has pushed the wheel over. I've ridden about 1000 miles since.




Super Sonic

12,952 posts

79 months

Wednesday 8th April
quotequote all
Does the chain go in all the sprockets ok? It is possible it has undished itself slightly.


Edited by Super Sonic on Wednesday 8th April 18:47

addey

1,290 posts

192 months

Wednesday 8th April
quotequote all
Surely the disc wouldn't sit straight in the brake caliper if the wheel was wrong?

jamm13dodger

269 posts

61 months

Wednesday 8th April
quotequote all
addey said:
Surely the disc wouldn't sit straight in the brake caliper if the wheel was wrong?
I would imagine this is rim brake looking at the wheel?

Super Sonic

12,952 posts

79 months

Wednesday 8th April
quotequote all
jamm13dodger said:
I would imagine this is rim brake looking at the wheel?
Look closely.

Norgles

180 posts

271 months

Wednesday 8th April
quotequote all
Check the wheel’s properly sat in the dropouts as this is a common cause (well is for me anyway). Loosen the qr skewer, push the wheel into place and hold it there while you tighten the QR so it sits right.

gazza285

10,944 posts

233 months

Wednesday 8th April
quotequote all


That gap between the dropout and the small sprocket is massive.

You are saying the shop have made a 135mm wheel fit a 141mm bike by putting a spacer in one side only?
Sounds like a bodge to me. You might get away with a spacer both sides, but then the disc might not line up with the calliper.

Otherwise the rim needs to be pulled into the centre, again a bit of a bodge.

Why didn't they just fit a 141mm wheel?

James_0541

60 posts

7 months

Thursday 9th April
quotequote all
Have the shop dished the wheel symmetrically, when it should have been an asymmetrical dish?

jrb43

895 posts

280 months

Friday 10th April
quotequote all
TIL there's a 141mm hub spacing. Good grief, how many standards do we need?! So it's the QR equivalent of 148mm boost spacing?

It does seem a little odd that they've put all 6mm on the same side of the axle but if it was working I guess that's fine. I'd second the idea that it's jumped out of the drop outs. I'm increasingly uneasy about QR and disc brakes - the wheel is leveraging itself out of the dropouts under braking. My man maths has funded a new frame and wheels as an insurance against dental treatment.

If the dishing is out, it won't be "perfectly" out and so measurements rim-chainstay will vary around the circumference of the wheel. A piece of string from the ends of the QR to the centre of the bridge will tell you if the frame has twisted or something.

Or just start a "what thru-axle bike?" thread biggrin

Master Bean

Original Poster:

5,016 posts

145 months

Friday 10th April
quotequote all
Initially they fitted the wheel without spacers and just bent the rear triangle in because they didn't know it had 141 spacing. So a complete bodge. Then when I told them they fitted the spacers which works according to some websites. The amount of boost qr, 6 bolt, 27. 5 wheels on sale is about 2.

The shifting is spot on and the wheel sits in the dropouts. I think I'll just keep riding as is.

gazza285

10,944 posts

233 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
They could have centred the rim though, not a difficult job for an experienced bike mechanic.

Master Bean

Original Poster:

5,016 posts

145 months

Monday 13th April
quotequote all
Managed 101 miles today so all seems to be good.

ian996

1,218 posts

136 months

Tuesday 14th April
quotequote all
As per above remarks, a bit strange that a bike shop fitted this, but as there is no rim brake to take into account (the main issue with offset wheels), I should think the only issue would be that the bike will (theoretically at least) handle subtly differently when turning left and right.

In practice, we subconsciously adapt to minor handling issues really easily (unless practising Tom Pidcock type descending skills), so I'd probably ignore it.

I used to ride a bike like this when I first started out (not only were the wheels out of line, but the frame was twisted so there was a definite positive camber between the front and rear wheel). Strangely, it was when I got my first "straight" bike that things felt wierd for a while.


jamm13dodger

269 posts

61 months

Tuesday 14th April
quotequote all
Super Sonic said:
Look closely.
sorry, you are right. Didnt spot that.