"You've got to find your niche..."
Discussion
Was reading through the PH Mat Armstrong thread where he's restoring a knackered twin V12 engined yacht and Rodders commented on the boat mechanics and made the following post...
I'm very much in a niche, really a niche of a niche, in financial services. It was booming when I got into it almost by luck in 2005, but suffered heavily in 2009 onwards with the results of the Global Financial Crisis, which probably saw the industry shrink by 60%+ and my job went with it, so I had to side step into quite a different job, which didn't suit me.
A couple years later, my original industry started to pick up and I managed to get back into it in 2014 - albeit on a part time basis for the first year and then growing to full time and thriving again by 2020 (with a hiccough of 6 months or so after the Brexit vote), just as Covid hit and shut it down again, leading to 6 months of job insecurity and me moving to another firm.
The pros of being in that niche is that it's comparatively well paid, the people I work with are more similar to me than other roles I've tried, it provides great travel opportunities and now I have expertise that not many other people have, I can dictate a lot more of my working conditions.
The downsides are undoubtedly the job insecurity - 3 times in my career I've been forced to consider abandoning the expertise I've built up and going into a more generalised role, competing with people who have more generalised experience.
So, I wondered what other people's experiences are? And would you recommend specialising, or remaining a generalist?
_Rodders_ said:
As I get older I look at these more niche jobs and wish I could impart that info on to a younger me.
What does a regular car mechanic earn? £30-40k on salary.
Working on those engines seems like a piece of piss in comparison to anything with a VW badge for example and I bet a marine diesel mechanic earns a healthy amount more.
You've got to find your niche.
...and I wondered what the wider community's view is?What does a regular car mechanic earn? £30-40k on salary.
Working on those engines seems like a piece of piss in comparison to anything with a VW badge for example and I bet a marine diesel mechanic earns a healthy amount more.
You've got to find your niche.
I'm very much in a niche, really a niche of a niche, in financial services. It was booming when I got into it almost by luck in 2005, but suffered heavily in 2009 onwards with the results of the Global Financial Crisis, which probably saw the industry shrink by 60%+ and my job went with it, so I had to side step into quite a different job, which didn't suit me.
A couple years later, my original industry started to pick up and I managed to get back into it in 2014 - albeit on a part time basis for the first year and then growing to full time and thriving again by 2020 (with a hiccough of 6 months or so after the Brexit vote), just as Covid hit and shut it down again, leading to 6 months of job insecurity and me moving to another firm.
The pros of being in that niche is that it's comparatively well paid, the people I work with are more similar to me than other roles I've tried, it provides great travel opportunities and now I have expertise that not many other people have, I can dictate a lot more of my working conditions.
The downsides are undoubtedly the job insecurity - 3 times in my career I've been forced to consider abandoning the expertise I've built up and going into a more generalised role, competing with people who have more generalised experience.
So, I wondered what other people's experiences are? And would you recommend specialising, or remaining a generalist?
Edited by RearEnginedMidLife on Tuesday 3rd November 12:29
I'm a big fan of the niche approach. It has served me very well but comes with caveats, obligations and risk.
If you are going specialise, you need to become an expert in that specialisation; attended the trade shows and conferences, read the trade press, network and generally sink your self fully into your chosen sector or field.
To capitalise on your specialisation you need to promote it; write articles for the trade press, speak at the conferences join and participate in any trade association that exists. Become known amongst your peers.
The risks....
You cannot afford to drop the ball. If you screw something up badly, you're done because there's nowhere to hide.
You are also reliant upon your chosen sector to be resilient to economic fluctuation. If your industry is hit, so will you.
And you have to be fully enthused about your chosen field.
If you are going specialise, you need to become an expert in that specialisation; attended the trade shows and conferences, read the trade press, network and generally sink your self fully into your chosen sector or field.
To capitalise on your specialisation you need to promote it; write articles for the trade press, speak at the conferences join and participate in any trade association that exists. Become known amongst your peers.
The risks....
You cannot afford to drop the ball. If you screw something up badly, you're done because there's nowhere to hide.
You are also reliant upon your chosen sector to be resilient to economic fluctuation. If your industry is hit, so will you.
And you have to be fully enthused about your chosen field.
My own experiences, as someone in financial services IT with both fairly general and some niche dev/consultancy skills is in agreement with what Terminator X says above.
In the good old days (2000s) you would get random approaches from recruiters on LinkedIn or by phone or email even for generic Microsoft tech stack dev jobs.
These days I only ever get approached by recruiters on LinkedIn for niche skills within specific sub-areas within financial services. I'm fortunate to have been able to find work ok for most of my career. During one period between contracts the niche I was in at the time went from buoyant demand to little new hiring, so there were only roles available if someone jumped ship. A bit like musical chairs. It was only for about 3 months, but I had a mortgage to pay so went into something else that came up and ended up picking up different niche skills there. Well over a decade later I still get approached for that first niche skillset even though I've done nothing in it since. And noticed a similar pattern emerging with the more recently aquired niche skills.
So, in summary it makes you stand out and it means less competition, but it can be a feast or famine dynamic. Yes you might be able to demand a higher salary or day rate for whatever niche you are in, but you may have longer fallow periods between engagements and have to be flexible on location unless you live near a big city where such roles exist or land a remote-only gig. 2 or 3 big projects by more than one large company at the same time can sometimes have quite an impact on marginal demand for those with the required skills.
In the good old days (2000s) you would get random approaches from recruiters on LinkedIn or by phone or email even for generic Microsoft tech stack dev jobs.
These days I only ever get approached by recruiters on LinkedIn for niche skills within specific sub-areas within financial services. I'm fortunate to have been able to find work ok for most of my career. During one period between contracts the niche I was in at the time went from buoyant demand to little new hiring, so there were only roles available if someone jumped ship. A bit like musical chairs. It was only for about 3 months, but I had a mortgage to pay so went into something else that came up and ended up picking up different niche skills there. Well over a decade later I still get approached for that first niche skillset even though I've done nothing in it since. And noticed a similar pattern emerging with the more recently aquired niche skills.
So, in summary it makes you stand out and it means less competition, but it can be a feast or famine dynamic. Yes you might be able to demand a higher salary or day rate for whatever niche you are in, but you may have longer fallow periods between engagements and have to be flexible on location unless you live near a big city where such roles exist or land a remote-only gig. 2 or 3 big projects by more than one large company at the same time can sometimes have quite an impact on marginal demand for those with the required skills.
lord dubington said:
The key thing is the ratio of supply to demand. There's little value being super specialist if there is more supply than demand for the skill.
And that's the crux of it, at least in my experience: niches are small by definition and no-one can predict what changes there will be to that industry over 10-20 years.Similarly to being an entrepreneur I guess - it is risky, but can be rewarding.
When I’m coaching in this space, I often quote: ‘In a free economy, there are two conditions for achieving profit over the long-term. The first is that one must provide something that is scarce, and the second is that one must provide something that is useful to others.’
https://www.gurufocus.com/news/134220/scarcity-use...
I focus on scarcity first. One has to find a ‘niche’ that others in your field aren’t currently providing or are not providing well.
One CEO of a utility company I was coaching went on to decide that he would focus on something his competitors didn’t traditionally do, and that was provide a platinum customer service standard. That was scarce in his industry at that time. He made that the company’s North Star and did go on to reap the rewards as a result of the success of that approach.
https://www.gurufocus.com/news/134220/scarcity-use...
I focus on scarcity first. One has to find a ‘niche’ that others in your field aren’t currently providing or are not providing well.
One CEO of a utility company I was coaching went on to decide that he would focus on something his competitors didn’t traditionally do, and that was provide a platinum customer service standard. That was scarce in his industry at that time. He made that the company’s North Star and did go on to reap the rewards as a result of the success of that approach.
rog007 said:
When I m coaching in this space, I often quote: In a free economy, there are two conditions for achieving profit over the long-term. The first is that one must provide something that is scarce, and the second is that one must provide something that is useful to others.
https://www.gurufocus.com/news/134220/scarcity-use...
I focus on scarcity first. One has to find a niche that others in your field aren t currently providing or are not providing well.
One CEO of a utility company I was coaching went on to decide that he would focus on something his competitors didn t traditionally do, and that was provide a platinum customer service standard. That was scarce in his industry at that time. He made that the company s North Star and did go on to reap the rewards as a result of the success of that approach.
Yes - many companies don't really understand their own operating model. https://www.gurufocus.com/news/134220/scarcity-use...
I focus on scarcity first. One has to find a niche that others in your field aren t currently providing or are not providing well.
One CEO of a utility company I was coaching went on to decide that he would focus on something his competitors didn t traditionally do, and that was provide a platinum customer service standard. That was scarce in his industry at that time. He made that the company s North Star and did go on to reap the rewards as a result of the success of that approach.
Are they - Value based - Innovation based or customer centric ? There are pro's and cons to each - they main thing is to know which one you are are act consistently like that.
On Niche's generally - its a double edged sword, perfect to build up reputation, expertise and carve out a position and ideally a strong personal reward. On the other hand if you do want later to move, then the specialist often loses out to more generalist people.
rog0 said:
One CEO of a utility company I was coaching went on to decide that he would focus on something his competitors didn t traditionally do, and that was provide a platinum customer service standard. That was scarce in his industry at that time. He made that the company s North Star and did go on to reap the rewards as a result of the success of that approach.
Interesting topic, what you are talking about above surely is the development of a company structural with a focus on working out what unique assets your company can offer other cannot. This though needs horizon scanning as we all know a company that doesn't innovate or are too proud to admit the world is changing is doomed to fail.On a personal level I love trying to learn/do everything and anything. I was told a long time ago it's impossible to do a job on shop floor, whilst teaching, lead on research and try your hand in leadership/management......I didn't listen to that advice and still to a degree try everything I can some 20 years on. It means every working day is totally different and often unpredictable, I know lots of people love routine, I however love the challenge of uncertainty and unpredictability. i don't think I've had the same consistent job responsibilities for more than 18 months ever since I started working!!
As an employee if you really love something it's clearly a great path, but there is a very real risk of not being able to adapt if sometimes changes in the work landscape and you don't see it coming. As a employer I think you have to take the opposite approach, even if you have an organisation strategy that puts focus on one area you cannot lose sight of the bigger picture. One the favourite parts of my job is horizon scanning and stakeholder engagement, but that's also because of my personal style.
Reality I think is even if you can choose to focus on a niche, but you also have to constantly keep looking for the next niche.
Edited by gangzoom on Saturday 7th November 06:02
Gassing Station | Jobs & Employment Matters | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


