How many interviews are normal nowadays?
How many interviews are normal nowadays?
Author
Discussion

ooid

Original Poster:

6,926 posts

131 months

We had a colleague farewell last Friday, he was associate level. During drinks, he said that he had 5 interviews in total with his new job and the total process took nearly 3 months? This is someone who has at least 5+ years experience, great schools in his CV and etc...

I mean is it norm nowadays? How do even employers afford such long process for fairly below director posts?

Sector: Finance, Private Equity.

OMITN

3,083 posts

123 months

Previous job: 6 or 7.
Current job: 4
New job: 2

All senior roles in a variety of sectors.

When interviewing I try not to do more than 3 for candidates, ideally 2.

CMTMB

2,246 posts

26 months

I would be getting quite annoyed after 3 or 4 but I guess that's maybe the point. See how much st you'll put up with.

Edited by CMTMB on Monday 16th November 15:28

louiebaby

11,023 posts

222 months



Wait, you guys are getting interviews?

---

I can't seem to make it through the application process to the point where you actually speak to someone.

(I'm only casually looking so it's not the end of the world.)

Venisonpie

4,947 posts

113 months

If it's any more than 2 then I'd question working for a new employer. When recruiting I always have two stages regardless of seniority.

1) Sense check and intro, ensure both parties aligned, informal opportunity to chat and ask general stuff - amazing what candidates reveal about themselves in a non formal process.

2) Formal interview structured as required possibly including response to a pre-issued scenario.

zbc

1,071 posts

182 months

Possibly as many as 6 here but that would be one initial and then 4/5 over a couple of days. Whole process should only be a week or so. It's the 3 months that bothers me more than the number of interviews.

TheHeadhunter

11,623 posts

151 months

Depends massively on the role and the business.

I only really recruit SME/sub-£80m Main Board and Marzipan layer. The average would be 3 interviews (Initial, 2nd with presentation/similar & Third/appointment interview), plus 1 or 2 with me before those. Sometimes an extra penultimate meeting with a cross section of peers, often more informal.

But with larger true C-Suite roles I have known up to 7 when investors, NEDs and/or Chair get involved. We also had a Series-B tech/gamification start-up COO role this year, that was 6 interviews but largely driven by the ultimate appointee. Conversely, we've just done a Group Legal Director for a Boutique commercial lending business that was only 2 interviews.

ooid

Original Poster:

6,926 posts

131 months

TheHeadhunter said:
Depends massively on the role and the business.

.
Do you get feedback from employers what is the reasoning behind such long interviews and process? I think this 4-5 interviews and 2+ months seem becoming the norm. I personally can't understand how they can afford these? Surely there is probation period, if you think someone is not up to the job, say goodbye.

OMITN

3,083 posts

123 months

louiebaby said:


Wait, you guys are getting interviews?

---

I can't seem to make it through the application process to the point where you actually speak to someone.

(I'm only casually looking so it's not the end of the world.)
It does seem st out there for everyone applying.

My new role came to me through a headhunter. In fact, I’m about to go and resign. Wish me luck and have your fingers crossed this isn’t a complete disaster..!

TheHeadhunter

11,623 posts

151 months

ooid said:
TheHeadhunter said:
Depends massively on the role and the business.

.
Do you get feedback from employers what is the reasoning behind such long interviews and process? I think this 4-5 interviews and 2+ months seem becoming the norm. I personally can't understand how they can afford these? Surely there is probation period, if you think someone is not up to the job, say goodbye.
2+ months is definitely too long. But there is no reasoning to say 4 or 5 interviews is too long, sometimes it needs more, sometimes 2 is too many.

And I would never let a client use the probation period in that way. Be certain before you offer. That's what the process is so important. However costly an extra 1 or 2 interviews might be, it's not as costly about taking a gamble on a hire and bulleting them after 3 months.

FWIW, I'm so confident in my process, I guarantee placement for 12 months and have never had to enact it.

cliffords

4,709 posts

54 months

This thread has reminded me how utterly fantastic retirement is .

That said . Wife and I looked into rehoming a dog a couple of years ago . We have had two dogs now . On this occasion we had three meetings, that were absolutely interviews. I failed and we didn't get the dog

sjg

7,690 posts

296 months

Current job was a quick phone chat with the (internal) recruiter, then one in-person interview and offer.

Multiple rounds of interviews strongly suggests a culture where managers aren't trusted to make recruitment decisions. If it needs more than one person to decide AND you can't get them all to the interview at the same time then the problem is very much the org. Don't waste an applicant's time on more than one interview.

Jasandjules

72,691 posts

260 months

Last one I was "recruited" for was a contact email, quick chat and that was that.

Frimley111R

19,429 posts

265 months

Usually 1 or 2. If they don't know by then they're just incompetent.

Most I had was 4 with a request to come into E.London for one more. I canned it and they seemed genuinely shocked/surprised. Big companies are often so out of touch that I am sure they miss a lot of good people.

Hoofy

80,187 posts

313 months

cliffords said:
This thread has reminded me how utterly fantastic retirement is .

That said . Wife and I looked into rehoming a dog a couple of years ago . We have had two dogs now . On this occasion we had three meetings, that were absolutely interviews. I failed and we didn't get the dog
Let me guess, you failed because on the third meeting-that-really-wasn't-an-interview-and-if-you-asked-the-interviewer-she'd-deny-it, you shouted, "FOR F!!!'S SAKE. IT'S A DOG NOT A BOARD DIRECTOR POSITION!!!" biggrin (Because I would have!)

TheHeadhunter

11,623 posts

151 months

sjg said:
Current job was a quick phone chat with the (internal) recruiter, then one in-person interview and offer.

Multiple rounds of interviews strongly suggests a culture where managers aren't trusted to make recruitment decisions. If it needs more than one person to decide AND you can't get them all to the interview at the same time then the problem is very much the org. Don't waste an applicant's time on more than one interview.
True if it is manager-level hiring manager recruiting sub-management. If it's a main board/C-level hire, it’s a very different story, on both sides.

ATG

23,877 posts

303 months

Horses for courses. I've been hired after a single interview and hired after five interviews. The latter was a flat organisation where they wanted the team as a whole to hire people and, from my side, it meant I could talk to a lot of people about the role and get a feel for the organisation and how it was viewed by existing staff. So long as you know the process from the outset, what's the problem?

ooid

Original Poster:

6,926 posts

131 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
TheHeadhunter said:
2+ months is definitely too long. But there is no reasoning to say 4 or 5 interviews is too long, sometimes it needs more, sometimes 2 is too many.
Thanks, my initial thinking when I heard the number of interviews and 3 months, I assumed maybe he was not their first choice, so they were just debating. (which is very common) but it looks like, this is becoming a common process now.

I understand for first roles, (or graduate schemes) there are multiple rounds, shows and bla bla, but I would assume once you are in one of the top companies, and spent a good time there with seriously good academic background, the next shop(position) should not spend a forensic analysis to hire you?

Do any of your clients spend a similar time/process when they hire someone (associate 5+) from a well known firm (Goldman Sachs, JP Morgan, Morgan Stanley and etc..) and still run multiple round of interviews? I'm genuinely suprised they can afford this, or they are deeply suspicious biggrin

cliffords

4,709 posts

54 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
When I was recruiting long time spans normally meant we were trying to employ the first choice and keeping the second choice warm . Often a candidate would fail the deeper screening and we moved to the warm second or even third

I don't feel good about it now .

chip*

1,891 posts

259 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
cliffords said:
This thread has reminded me how utterly fantastic retirement is .
biglaugh so true.

Ime, unless for a new position, internal move are even worse for delays as the department losing the staff tend to drag out the transfer while they search for a replacement on the market.