Pants On Fire
Author
Discussion

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,218 posts

163 months

Found myself exasperated by a colleague lying through their teeth over a serious work related matter.
I took the usual "maybe you want to look over the facts of the matter. be aware of what has been stated by yourself in emails and reconsider your position" .
They doubled down on the untruth.
I then called them out going into full "liar liar pants on fire" mode.
HR are now involved
Am assuming that as the untruth is very easily proved and that as I started the exchange making every effort to de-escalate and give my colleague every opportunity to step back from their position I'm covered.

butchstewie

68,520 posts

241 months

I think we’d need a bit more detail on what "full pants on fire mode" actually means.

Being right about the lie and being OK in how you called it out are likely to be two separate things as far as HR is concerned.

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,218 posts

163 months

butchstewie said:
I think we d need a bit more detail on what "full pants on fire mode" actually means.

Being right about the lie and being OK in how you called it out are likely to be two separate things as far as HR is concerned.
Background is employer had rebranded and changed all our email addresses.
They have, at the same time, dropped all our outsourced IT support, dropped outsourced software that worked perfectly and replaced it with in-house systems. They have also massively upped our cyber security and fragmented all our data files.
The result is a clusterfk.
All my reporting is stuck on spreadsheets on my own laptop and no-one in the company can get any access.
Biggest three problems are we now record on authenticated apps where we sign in with our email addresses (except we can't coz they've changed).
We were then told to generate new accounts which we can't (an existing account exists) and..... we were given randomly generated passwords lots of #@/_-!!!.
The bespoke software has a dropdown box with a keypad that only allows the inputting of numbers and letters.
Loads of staff are suffering issues. All the managers have had their laptops, tablets, phones and sim-cards replaced in an attempt to allow hardware to interface with software.
A director chasing my reports called out my excuses claiming "no-one else is having any problems".
When I said "EVERYONE !!!! else is having these problems"
He gave me that "think very carefully about what you say next look"and asked "are you calling me a lier?"
Unlike the director my response was honest.

Edited by Tannedbaldhead on Monday 16th November 18:10

butchstewie

68,520 posts

241 months

What did you actually say when he asked “are you calling me a liar?”

Your exact words and who else was there?

I'm not an HR bod but that’s the bit HR will focus on - not the IT mess.

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,218 posts

163 months

butchstewie said:
What did you actually say when he asked are you calling me a liar?
"Yes"

spikeyhead

20,653 posts

228 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
OP, I belive you may have commited a CLM

Being right, and stating that in too blunt a way can be a Career Limiting Move

Before you talk with HR, be prepared to have many people express in writing that they too have been having issues.

Be prepared to appologise to being right, but unnecessarily blunt

Mr Penguin

5,210 posts

70 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
I can already tell what the next thread will be asking.

BlackTails

4,040 posts

86 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
IAAL but not an employment one. Every time I have encountered employment law I have found it to be the most counterintuitive and topsy turvy field imaginable.

I have no idea how this will play out for the OP, but experience tells me not to rule out either of “well” or “badly”.

ATG

23,877 posts

303 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
OP appears to have run into a bloke who doesn't know what's going on and who has a fragile ego that means he values "winning" a discussion over actually being correct.

The alternative to agreeing with him that he was a liar would have been to say "No, I don't think you're lying. I think you're bluffing because you don't know what's going on and you don't want to lose face. That's because you're incompetent and infantile, not an inveterate liar."

That would have gone much better.

Good luck, OP. Stick to the facts as you understand them and back your position up with concise evidence without coming across as a lunatic.

Richard-390a0

3,585 posts

122 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
Mr Penguin said:
I can already tell what the next thread will be asking.
"Would I be suited to a new career in diplomacy?"

silentbrown

11,027 posts

147 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
Tannedbaldhead said:
... asked "are you calling me a liar?"
One way or another, when one party resorts to saying something as clearly provocative as that, it's never going to end well.

Best answer would possibly have been https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terminological_inexa...

Muzzer79

13,263 posts

218 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
spikeyhead said:
OP, I belive you may have commited a CLM

Being right, and stating that in too blunt a way can be a Career Limiting Move

Before you talk with HR, be prepared to have many people express in writing that they too have been having issues.

Be prepared to appologise to being right, but unnecessarily blunt
100% this

CypSIdders

1,296 posts

185 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
I've been in a very similar situation to the OP.
A manager lied to me and others.
I challenged him and told him, to his face, that he and his clique were liars.
This culminated in a stand up shouting match between us.
He was bang to rights and he knew it!
Funnily enough nothing was ever said, there was no record of any interaction and I remained in place.
No doubt, anything that could possibly disrupt ascending the greasy pole, never happened.


LennyM1984

1,143 posts

99 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
silentbrown said:
Tannedbaldhead said:
... asked "are you calling me a liar?"
One way or another, when one party resorts to saying something as clearly provocative as that, it's never going to end well.
The moment somebody says, "are you calling me a liar?" Is the moment you know that person is a retard. It's a question only asked by halfwits and children under the age of 10. OP you have my sympathy!

Macneil

1,104 posts

111 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
How long have you worked there? Did you insult an actual Director or a manager with director as his job title?