ND2 Super 200 / 220 / Supercharged / Turbo experiences
ND2 Super 200 / 220 / Supercharged / Turbo experiences
Author
Discussion

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

Friday 13th November
quotequote all
Currently have a 2.0 ND2 2.0 and love it, only issue is the sound really. I've stuck a Goodwin Single Tip SuperStreet exhaust on and that sounds a lot better with the roof down but not really much better roof up generally. The engine note itself is OK but nothing special.

So I've been thinking of some tuning. All of these options are on the table.

Just wondering if the catted BBR Super 200 or 220 sounds much better than standard, and whether it makes the car that much better - is it worth the money.

I've also thought about a supercharger, the extra grunt might be nice, but I'd more like the whine like I got from my R53 Mini, but I'm not sure it does.

Also thought about the turbo, but seems a bit against the ethos of the car, but I'm open to it if it is a good upgrade.

I'm after owners experiences of any of the above. TIA.

Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

Saturday 14th November
quotequote all
Not much help sorry but the NC on throttle bodies ticked the sound box, understand its not done on the ND.
Maybe consider a cold style intake first which BBR fit anyway, I fitted a K&N intake to my S2000 and the difference it made when gunning it was tremendous.
Not sure you will get that supercharger whine we all love with the chargers used so worth asking that.
The 220 package certainly appeals but i wonder will you just get used to it and crave more in the future.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

Saturday 14th November
quotequote all
Belle427 said:
Not much help sorry but the NC on throttle bodies ticked the sound box, understand its not done on the ND.
Maybe consider a cold style intake first which BBR fit anyway, I fitted a K&N intake to my S2000 and the difference it made when gunning it was tremendous.
Not sure you will get that supercharger whine we all love with the chargers used so worth asking that.
The 220 package certainly appeals but i wonder will you just get used to it and crave more in the future.
Yes if the ITB option was available, then they could take my money now!

Aye I understand you might not get that whine with the supercharger which may rule it out for me.

I also wondered whether the 220 package is something I'd get used to and whether the gains were worth the substantial expense. A cheaper option is to get Paul Roddison to do a manifold and map package which also raises the red line apparently, might get 90% of the fun for half or less the price.

Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

Saturday 14th November
quotequote all
Yes its a very difficult decision, I fancied supercharging my S2000 but with it costing around £5k I just cant justify doing it really.
Maybe if money were no object I probably would do it.
A lot would say just enjoy it for what it is.

Nickp82

3,997 posts

124 months

Saturday 14th November
quotequote all
I assume the SC they use is similar to the NC , in which case there’s no whine . Most of the time it sounds like a big fan although it if you’re really on it , it does make a cool noise someone told me they think sounds like an X-Wing (I haven’t seen Star Wars so can’t confirm).

My BBR SC MX-5 is a track car, if it was to be a road car I’m not sure I’d go for the supercharger as I think the NA upgrades just suit the car so much and obviously cost less.

I have an Elise SC as a road car which delivers the whine and feels more special but obviously not great as an all year round car.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

Saturday 14th November
quotequote all
I've just watched this video, and it's making me think that the best bang for my buck for what I want is to do a manifold upgrade, stick the induction kit he recommends on it (doesn't lose power!) and get it mapped and be happy with it. That should give me the near 8000 rpm and better sound I'm looking for without emptying my savings too much! smile

Will probably give Mr Roddison a call next spring...


Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

Sounds sensible, the ITB route would be very expensive probably. Seems to be good gains though, he mentioned 260 hp toward the end but wonder what other mods were in place to acheive that.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

I'd imagine that car would have had the full works to get to that point certainly. As for cost, I think the super 225 kit for the NC was somewhere north of 5k so not cheap.

Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

Thats where forced induction becomes attractive really, I wanted to Turbocharge an NA I once owned and wished id done it really as I do miss that car probably more than any other I have since.
Strange how they grab you.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

It is kind of against the ethos of the mx5 to lob a turbo on it but then part of me still wonders what it would be like to have masses of power and torque on a car that small hehe that said I think it would fundamentally change the character and part of what I like about it is having to wring its neck.

Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

Seems as though manifold, map and an intake would not be an arm and a leg money wise but you have to question is it worth it.
For me personally I love putting things on a car I know make slight improvements, on previous cars I have always looked for the best stainless exhausts etc.

Ascari_1

99 posts

164 months

I recently got a turbocharged ND1 after having had both a supercharged NA and stage 2 turbo NC in my past.

It's not quite as quick as the NC as it's 50bhp less, but it is still about as quick as you'd ever need. It's currently on Yoko AD08RS tyres, so it's very firm due to those sidewalls and does snap a bit in the cold or wet. Once I've worn them out with a few track days I'll be on to Pilot Sport 5s, which I suspect will make it feel a little more compliant on the road, if not a bit less capable on track.

I do love a charged 5, but probably because I'm getting older and appreciate torque as much as having to thrash something to get it going. Does it make it better? Subjective. I've had five 5's in total with two staying naturally aspirated (both mk1's), but there is something about that power overspeed of the rear wheels in something so light, paired with brakes that stop it so well because it's light. Is it as pure as the designers intended? Maybe not, but it's small, fast and puts a very big grin on my face, which feels like the main point to me.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

Ascari_1 said:
I recently got a turbocharged ND1 after having had both a supercharged NA and stage 2 turbo NC in my past.

It's not quite as quick as the NC as it's 50bhp less, but it is still about as quick as you'd ever need. It's currently on Yoko AD08RS tyres, so it's very firm due to those sidewalls and does snap a bit in the cold or wet. Once I've worn them out with a few track days I'll be on to Pilot Sport 5s, which I suspect will make it feel a little more compliant on the road, if not a bit less capable on track.

I do love a charged 5, but probably because I'm getting older and appreciate torque as much as having to thrash something to get it going. Does it make it better? Subjective. I've had five 5's in total with two staying naturally aspirated (both mk1's), but there is something about that power overspeed of the rear wheels in something so light, paired with brakes that stop it so well because it's light. Is it as pure as the designers intended? Maybe not, but it's small, fast and puts a very big grin on my face, which feels like the main point to me.
Thanks for your impressions, I sort of know what you mean about the torque thing, my last car was an F56 JCW which was probably pushing best part of 250 bhp / 250 lb ft and the initial response from the car was, unsurprisingly, much more urgent than my MX5 which obviously makes you work for it.

I also get the purity argument, but then I guess I've already started modifying it - albeit OEM+ at the moment.

Only thing is I feel like I shouldn't have bothered spending as much on an ND2 if I was going that route, I could have spent half on an ND1 and boosted that instead.

Also for the outlay I'd have to be absolutely sure I wanted to keep the car, as I'd not see much back if I sold the car later. I guess you are also then in the realm of some other more serious metal - it wouldn't be a huge jump to move to something like an Evora or a GR Yaris (strangely I've always fancied one of those!). I'm basically being realistic about the prospects of me actually keeping a car for more than 2 or 3 years hehe

Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

Im not really a fan of the thrash it to enjoy it camp either really but I can see why people say it, my NA was a standard 1.6 import and i did love throwing it round knowing it wasnt worth a lot if i did bin it.
Cars do come up for sale now and again so it may make more sense to find one of those as i think they are not an easy sell modified either especially privately.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

Aye the re-sale thing is probably the one thing that would hold me back from doing anything too expensive to this car. Even my JCW which wasn't exactly heavily modified (just wheels and coilovers really) took a bloomin age to sell and I got a lot less for it than I'd hoped for.

Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

The MX5 owners club forums may help you more, its a bit dead in here. I think that chap that posted the video you linked to hangs around there somewhere.

Turbofun

1,402 posts

239 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
I have owned and driven the following cars on a few track days, fast touring around Spain an Portugal.
2011 NC BBR Turbo Stage 2 (upgraded coilovers n brakes) - very good all round car 9/10... the best off the shelf car smile
2015 ND BBR Turbo (upgraded coilovers n brakes) - good car however a little asmatic compared to above car 7/10
2010 NC BBR SC stage 2 (upgraded coilovers n brakes) good car, got to wring its neck to get the pace, nice exhaust note 8/10
Current hack
2010 NC PL K24 Turbo (full upgrade) work in progress 11/10 ..... more to come wink

In my conclusion NC/ND with a turbo with improved chassis n brakes are a great option

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

Tuesday
quotequote all
I really need to watch Jayemms mx5 videos again...

I'm sure he did one on a turbo. I can certainly imagine one with north of 250 bhp being fairly nippy to say the least hehe

My concern with a turbo on the nd is breaking the gearbox. Obviously you can fix it but it adds extra cost and inconvenience to what is already an expensive endeavour smile

I'm also pondering whether I should be doing this or spending money on driving and road trips instead.

Belle427

12,045 posts

264 months

Yesterday (06:58)
quotequote all
Would you consider going back to an NC and modifying it?
Depending on the value of yours it may make more financial sense.
Is the ND that much better to drive, I personally think the NC is the best of the bunch and would like a modified one myself.

TameRacingDriver

Original Poster:

20,662 posts

303 months

Yesterday (09:00)
quotequote all
Nah, I've been there, had an NC1 Launch Edition with the BBR Super 200, and still prefer my ND2 over it despite the lack of mods, plus its more modern and much better looking, and I don't think I could stomach the depreciation hit I'd end up taking with it. I've also got it booked in for dinitrol treatment next week so it's staying for now smile

Saying all that though when I was thinking of going back to an MX5 earlier this year, it was between mine and a white NC 3.75 PRHT which I was going to modify.

I had intended on keeping mine mostly standard to be honest, and I still might do that, if I can overcome the disease that afflicts many PHers - upgraditis hehe