Christmas Cake Recipes
Author
Discussion

The Gauge

Original Poster:

7,725 posts

44 months

Thursday 1st October
quotequote all
I suppose it'll soon be approaching the time of year when folk start making their Christmas cakes.
Anyone got a good recipe they can share please?



nikaiyo2

5,980 posts

226 months

Huntsman

9,476 posts

281 months

Friday 2nd October
quotequote all
nikaiyo2 said:
Always.

normalbloke

9,007 posts

250 months

Friday 2nd October
quotequote all
Delia’s creole Crimbo cake is the one we’ve used forever. We ramp it up a bit, and feed the cake with even more alcohol for ages before icing it. It’s epic.

The Gauge

Original Poster:

7,725 posts

44 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
What s your method for feeding? Syringe, spooning over? Rum, brandy?

Also, how far in advance do you all make your cakes? I understand they keep for ages?

Edited by The Gauge on Saturday 3rd October 09:14

Huntsman

9,476 posts

281 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
The Gauge said:
What s your method for feeding? Syringe, spooning over? Rum, brandy?

Also, how far in advance do you all make your cakes? I understand they keep for ages?

Edited by The Gauge on Saturday 3rd October 09:14
Skewer holes in it, spoon brandy on.

Now a good time.

normalbloke

9,007 posts

250 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
The Gauge said:
What s your method for feeding? Syringe, spooning over? Rum, brandy?

Also, how far in advance do you all make your cakes? I understand they keep for ages?

Edited by The Gauge on Saturday 3rd October 09:14
I think we make the mix and let it steep for a couple of weeks, then, when baked, it probably gets fed for 3-4 weeks. Usually rum, usually with a spoon from the bottle, which occasionally slips..

The Gauge

Original Poster:

7,725 posts

44 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
Thanks, so do you leave your cake mixture for a while before baking, is that covered on the kitchen side or fridge?

normalbloke

9,007 posts

250 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
The Gauge said:
Thanks, so do you leave your cake mixture for a while before baking, is that covered on the kitchen side or fridge?
For the Creole cake, the mix sits in the fridge for a couple of weeks.

knotweed

2,006 posts

207 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
I made mine a couple of weeks ago. It's the Bero recipe out of the little book they do, but I add a bit of treacle in place of some of the sugar and I don't put currants in it. The fruit was soaked in Madeira for a week and the cake will be fed with brandy every 2-3 weeks.



adsk

109 posts

190 months

Saturday 3rd October
quotequote all
Another Delia recipe fan here...have been using it for 30+ years. What's great about the recipe, is that instructions are provided for different sized cakes/tins/shapes of tins here. https://www.deliaonline.com/information-centre/sca...

Baldy881

1,559 posts

208 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
nikaiyo2 said:
Question. Me and the missus made a start on this one over the weekend, having never made a christmas cake between us before.

Recipe says to bake at 4hrs at 140, which we did. We unwrapped it (cooled) this morning and the missus is convinced it's overcooked and burnt. I'm more hopeful that time and some feeding over the next few weeks will give it some softness and moisture.

So, for those that use this recipe, should we have dialled back the temp for a fan assisted oven? If it has come out seeming a little dry, is there any way to resurrect it or are we flogging a dead horse and need to go again?

Thanks!



Huntsman

9,476 posts

281 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Baldy881 said:
Question. Me and the missus made a start on this one over the weekend, having never made a christmas cake between us before.

Recipe says to bake at 4hrs at 140, which we did. We unwrapped it (cooled) this morning and the missus is convinced it's overcooked and burnt. I'm more hopeful that time and some feeding over the next few weeks will give it some softness and moisture.

So, for those that use this recipe, should we have dialled back the temp for a fan assisted oven? If it has come out seeming a little dry, is there any way to resurrect it or are we flogging a dead horse and need to go again?

Thanks!
I'm inclined to say keep feeding it, it'll be fine.

sherman

15,345 posts

246 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Huntsman said:
Baldy881 said:
Question. Me and the missus made a start on this one over the weekend, having never made a christmas cake between us before.

Recipe says to bake at 4hrs at 140, which we did. We unwrapped it (cooled) this morning and the missus is convinced it's overcooked and burnt. I'm more hopeful that time and some feeding over the next few weeks will give it some softness and moisture.

So, for those that use this recipe, should we have dialled back the temp for a fan assisted oven? If it has come out seeming a little dry, is there any way to resurrect it or are we flogging a dead horse and need to go again?

Thanks!
I'm inclined to say keep feeding it, it'll be fine.
I would feed it.
You can always trim the worst burnt bits off before you marizipzn it.

My wife covers her cake with a cardbord lid after 2-3 hours once the cake has a crust and it comes out looking ok.

Icing can hide many sins

Baldy881

1,559 posts

208 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Thanks both, I'm hopeful! So, if I feed it say tonight (do you feed both sides - top & bottom?) and then every week, and just keep it wrapped and sealed? We've already stuck a cocktail stick through in numerous places on both sides...


sherman

15,345 posts

246 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
Baldy881 said:
Thanks both, I'm hopeful! So, if I feed it say tonight (do you feed both sides - top & bottom?) and then every week, and just keep it wrapped and sealed? We've already stuck a cocktail stick through in numerous places on both sides...
Feed top this week.
Wrap it up a leave for 2 week
Unwrap
Flip the cake
Pierce the bottom of the cake
Feed the bottom only
Wrap back up leave for 2 weeks
Unwrap
Flip the cake
Pierce the top only and feed
Leave for 2 weeks
etc

Repeat until week before christmas and then unwrap and marzipan.

Then a few days later cover in royal icing so its dry for christmas day.

geeks

11,899 posts

170 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
My personal recipe that I spent years perfecting and now use every year.

150ml of Brandy
1kg of fruit (I use currents, raisins, dried chopped apricots, dried (not glacier) cherries and sultanas, you can just buy a bag of mixed fruit if you like)
2 tablespoon of treacle
1 tablespoon of golden syrup
250g of unsalted butter
250g of dark brown muscovado sugar
1tsp of cinnamon
1/2 tsp of ground ginger
1 1/2tsp of mixed spice
1tsp of lemon extract
1tsp of orange extract
1tsp of vanilla extract
pinch of salt
4 eggs
275g of flour

Add brandy, butter, sugar, treacle, extracts and spices into a large saucepan and put over a very low heat and stir, we're talking super low, just enough heat to combine the ingredients and melt the butter, if you are worried, take it on and off the heat regularly. Once the butter has melted and the ingredients are mixed add the fruit and stir thoroughly turn the heat off, cover with a lid and set to one side to soak, stirring regularly.

After about 30 minutes check the temperature, anything warmer than room temp is too warm and leave it another 10 minutes. Once cooled, turn out into a large mixing bowl and preheat an oven to 140c

Whisk eggs and stir through a bit at a time

Add the flour through a sieve about 1/4 at a time and fold in using a wooden spoon. Once fully combined turn into cake tin and cook in the middle of the oven for 3-4 hours until a skewer comes out clean.

Allow to cool, poke many holes in it with a skewer and spoon over some brandy. Wrap in grease proof paper and then cling film. Feed every other week alternating between the top and the bottom (fnarr fnarr).

Leave it two weeks after its last feed before decorating, personally prefer marzipan and royal icing (stick the marzipan on with some apricot jam or marmalade warmed up a little to make a sticky glaze for the marzipan to hold) however last year we had someone with a nut allergy in over Christmas so I skipped the marzipan and cant say I missed it

TheHeadhunter

11,635 posts

151 months

Monday 5th October
quotequote all
I use a generational family recipe, passed down my mother's (Methodist) maternal line.

We make the cake at least 9 months ahead of time, seal it, and don't open it until Christmas Eve.

I'll dig out the recipe, but the secret to the taste and moisture is that you soak the dried fruit in 'some alcohol' for 3-4 days before making the cake. My cake's fruit usually consumes 3/4 of a bottle our bourbon before baking. The moist fruit then keeps the cake beautifully moist.

The Gauge

Original Poster:

7,725 posts

44 months

Saturday 10th October
quotequote all
Bought a Waitrose Christmas Cake kit today after reading great reviews on it.
Just need to add your own butter, orange and apricot jam..



PhilAsia

7,895 posts

106 months

Sunday 11th October
quotequote all
The mum of my ex was from Grenada and made an incredibly memorable Xmas cake. The fruit sat in alcohol for at least 6 months. I never made it and was pronpted by this thread to ask ChatGPT what it was. This looks about right:

Traditional Caribbean Black Cake:
I think the cake you're remembering is very likely Grenadian black cake, also known as Caribbean black cake, West Indian black cake or traditional Caribbean Christmas cake.

In Grenada and across much of the English-speaking Caribbean, this cake is a Christmas tradition. It's dark, rich, moist, intensely fruity and fragrant with warm spices, rum and wine.

Unlike a typical British Christmas cake, Caribbean black cake often has fruit that has been soaking in alcohol for months. The soaked fruit is blended or finely processed into a thick mixture, which gives the finished cake its distinctive dark colour and dense texture.

After baking, some families add more rum or wine to the cake and allow it to mature before Christmas.

The detail you remember fruit soaking in alcohol for six months before Christmas is a particularly strong clue.

The recipe includes:

Raisins

Currants

Prunes

Dried cherries

Rum

Cherry brandy

Cherry or plum wine

Burnt-sugar browning

Butter, sugar, eggs and flour

Spices and vanilla

The recipe allows the fruit to soak for anything from a few days to a year. Some Caribbean families begin preparing their Christmas cake approximately six months ahead.

This is remarkably close to the tradition you described.

However, recipes differ between households, so this is a strong starting point rather than a confirmed copy of your ex's mother's recipe.

What makes traditional black cake distinctive?
The fruit is prepared months ahead
Raisins, currants, prunes, cherries and sometimes mixed citrus peel are chopped or minced and submerged in rum and wine.

Over time, the fruit softens, darkens and absorbs the alcohol. Some families blend the fruit before soaking it; others blend it just before baking.

Burnt sugar gives it the black colour
Caribbean cooks call this browning.

Sugar is heated until it becomes a very dark caramel, then carefully combined with water to make a concentrated syrup. It contributes the cake's signature colour, along with a deep caramel flavour and a slightly bitter edge.

The dark colour doesn't come from chocolate.

The fruit is almost a paste
The soaked fruit is often processed into a thick, dark mixture. This creates a cake that is dense, moist and rich, with fruit distributed throughout rather than large, separate pieces.

The cake is often fed after baking
Additional rum or wine may be brushed or spooned over the cake while it is warm and then added sparingly as it matures.

This develops the aroma and flavour. The amount of alcohol remaining in a baked cake varies, so it shouldn't be assumed that baking removes all the alcohol.

The alcohol: what might she have used?
Dark or aged rum
Rum is often the backbone of the flavour. It contributes notes of molasses, caramel, dried fruit and oak.

Grenada has its own rum-making tradition, so locally made rum would be a natural choice for some households. We can't determine which brand her mother used from the soaking tradition alone.

Cherry brandy
Cherry brandy is a common ingredient in Caribbean black cake. It adds a sweet, dark-cherry flavour and makes the fruit taste almost like a concentrated preserve.

It also appears in the Grenada-associated recipe mentioned above.

Port, sherry or other fortified wine
Different families use different wines. Some versions include cherry or plum wine, while others use port, sherry or a combination of wine and spirits.

The wine adds sweetness and depth and softens the sharpness of the rum.

My recommended starting combination is dark rum and cherry brandy, with a little fortified wine if you remember a softer, wine-rich flavour.

I wouldn't insist on one exact combination without knowing more about her cake.

The fruit mixture: a traditional-style recipe
This quantity makes enough soaked fruit for approximately two medium cakes.

Ingredients
450 g raisins

225 g dried currants

225 g pitted prunes

225 g dried or glacé cherries

100 g mixed citrus peel, optional

350 ml dark rum

250 ml cherry brandy

150 ml port or sweet red wine, optional

You may need additional liquid to keep the fruit covered, depending on how tightly you pack the container and how absorbent the fruit is.

How to prepare the fruit
Inspect and finely chop the fruit. If you wash it, dry it thoroughly before adding the alcohol.

Place the fruit in a clean, dry glass jar or another suitable food-safe container, leaving enough room to stir.

Pour in the rum, cherry brandy and optional wine.

Mix thoroughly and make sure the fruit is covered by liquid.

Seal the container and store it according to a reliable food-preservation method. Refrigeration is the more cautious option for a homemade mixture without a validated long-term storage process.

Check the mixture periodically, using clean utensils, and top up the liquid if necessary.

When ready to bake, process the fruit into a thick, coarse paste, adding some of its soaking liquid as needed.

Food safety note: A six-month soak is a traditional flavour-development practice, not a guarantee of safety. Alcohol strength, moisture, temperature and handling all matter. Discard the mixture if you see mould, bubbling or other signs of spoilage. Do not taste it to check.

The actual Grenadian-style black cake recipe
This version uses soaked fruit, burnt-sugar browning and a rich butter-and-egg batter.

The quantities below are a practical starting point for two medium round cakes, approximately 20 cm or 8 inches each. They are not claimed to be the exact historical recipe from the Grenada cookbook.

Ingredients
Prepared soaked fruit: approximately 1.5 1.7 kg, including some liquid

Unsalted butter: 450 g

Brown or white sugar: 450 g

Eggs: 8 10 large

Plain flour: 450 g

Baking powder: 2 teaspoons

Ground cinnamon: 1 teaspoon

Freshly grated nutmeg: 1 teaspoon

Vanilla essence: 2 teaspoons

Finely grated lime zest: 1 2 limes

Browning: 2 4 tablespoons, to taste

Extra rum or wine for feeding the cakes, optional

Some recipes use self-raising flour, less fruit, more browning or a different balance of eggs and butter. These differences are normal across Caribbean family recipes.

Method
Step 1: Prepare the fruit

Process the soaked fruit into a thick, coarse paste. Include enough soaking liquid to make it moist but not watery. Set aside.

Step 2: Cream the butter and sugar

Beat the butter and sugar until well combined and fluffy.

Add the eggs one at a time, mixing thoroughly after each addition. Add the vanilla and lime zest.

Step 3: Add the fruit and spices

Mix in the fruit paste.

Sift together the flour, baking powder, cinnamon and nutmeg. Fold these into the mixture.

Stir in the browning gradually until you achieve a deep mahogany colour. Too much browning can make the cake bitter.

Step 4: Bake slowly

Divide the mixture between two lined cake tins.

Bake at 150°C or 300°F for approximately 1½ 2½ hours. The actual time depends on the depth of the batter and the tins.

Cover the tops if they darken too quickly. Check that the centre is fully baked before removing the cakes from the oven.

Step 5: Feed and mature

If desired, brush the warm cakes lightly with rum or your chosen alcohol blend.

Allow them to cool completely, then wrap securely and store appropriately. Additional alcohol can be applied sparingly as the cake matures, following a reliable storage method for a rich, moist fruit cake.

The secret is the browning
If you want the nearly black colour associated with traditional Caribbean black cake, don't rely on brown sugar alone.

Browning is made by heating granulated sugar in a heavy saucepan until it becomes very dark caramel, then carefully adding hot water to form a syrup.

It can spit violently, and hot caramel can cause severe burns. Use a long-handled utensil, protect your hands and add the water cautiously. Allow the browning to cool before incorporating it into the cake.

The goal is dark and bittersweet, not acrid or burnt beyond use.

The characteristic colour comes from the combination of caramelised sugar and the dark soaked fruit.

It's traditionally served in small slices because the flavour is so concentrated.

The Grenadian-associated recipe described earlier features currants, raisins, cherries, prunes and citrus peel steeping in rum and wine. Spices can include cinnamon and nutmeg, alongside other aromatic ingredients.

There was definitely Carib rum and IIRC a lesser amount of cherry brandy, but not sure about the wine.

I won't be making it but if anyone is interested. It really is ideal for winter in UK.



Edited by PhilAsia on Sunday 11th October 10:59