Good Pies
Author
Discussion

SchillingTwo

Original Poster:

968 posts

5 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
Can anyone recommend any very good quality pies?

I used to load up at Kitsons in Northallerton and freeze them but never get up there nowadays.

What I’m looking for is shortcrust pastry, filled with plenty of meat, sold uncooked to be cooked at home, and a decent selection of fillings.

I’ve found nothing decent in London, or online. The well-regarded M&S ones don’t work for me; puff pastry, a big gap above the filling, and just not enough meat for the amount of pastry.

FlyVintage

531 posts

22 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
No help I’m afraid, but definitely interested in the answers you get here. I gave up a while ago and now make my own based on the recipes from John Kirkwood on YouTube.

SchillingTwo

Original Poster:

968 posts

5 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
I’ll have a look at that, thanks.

996Type

1,197 posts

183 months

Sunday 25th October
quotequote all
You mention Northallerton,
Just down towards the coast:

https://glavesbutchers.co.uk/about-us/

Lovely pies from here…

tomsugden

2,483 posts

259 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
https://www.turnerspies.co.uk/

Featured on the apprentice a few years back. Pies are delivered to your door and are exceptional.

droopsnoot

14,803 posts

273 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
I've had a few pies from Brockleby's in Melton Mowbray and really enjoyed them - I buy when they're at a local food festival but they do mail order as well. I've got a couple of "Moo and Blue" in the freezer at the moment.

https://www.brocklebys.co.uk/

tog

4,981 posts

259 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
Lochinver Larder

https://www.piesbypost.co.uk


I've not been there for years, and truth be told have never ordered online either, but they live long in the memory. Minimum order is a dozen which has always put me off, but I see why it makes sense from their end.

SchillingTwo

Original Poster:

968 posts

5 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
Thanks for the suggestions, I’ll have a look.

I’m not sure whey no-one sells them as uncooked, that was one of the big positives with the ones I used to get; freshly cooked at home is nicer than pre-cooked and reheated.

blueg33

47,013 posts

255 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
I have concluded one thing with pies:

They are way way better if you make them yourself!. Also much better value. A decent pie for 1 is over £5. I can do it for less than half that price with better quality ingredients.

Favourites are a chicken pie with a filling based on Chicken Dijon with added ham and a beef pie with a filling based on beef bourgignone

TheDrownedApe

1,854 posts

87 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
As a Lancashire lad i still cry over the demise of a good pie. My childhood was filled with meat & potato pies. At home, at the football, at Preston or Chorley Flat Iron.

As blue points out; make your own. I prefer hot water crust pastry

SchillingTwo

Original Poster:

968 posts

5 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
It’s the texture of the pastry that I miss as much as anything.

Mince pies from the chip shop when I was growing up (meat mince, not sweet mince) had a crunch. You could hold them by one end due to the structural integrity of the thick, firm pastry.

craig1912

4,702 posts

143 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
https://donaldrussell.com/collections/chefs-prepar...

Good quality and sold uncooked and frozen

Sway

35,766 posts

225 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
tomsugden said:
https://www.turnerspies.co.uk/

Featured on the apprentice a few years back. Pies are delivered to your door and are exceptional.
Turner's are close to me, and often pick one up when I'm in Chichester for an easy weekday meal. They're great.

But, I'd agree with the idea of making your own. Find that pie making is a really easy form of batch cooking, and highly rewarding!

Tickle

6,545 posts

235 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
Baldys are fantastic, really good! From an area know for pies, these are the best I've ever had

SchillingTwo

Original Poster:

968 posts

5 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
craig1912 said:
https://donaldrussell.com/collections/chefs-prepar...

Good quality and sold uncooked and frozen
Perfect, thanks.

ozzuk

1,465 posts

158 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
I've had stuff from Donalds, good quality, though prices have gone up it was 4.50 a pie when I last ordered!

I recently had a chunk of meat including pies from The Village Butcher (online, based in Essex) and everything was great quality.

Also...a real surprise, stumbled across Tom Kitchin Steak and Ale pies in home bargains...and they are really good!

Like the Holy Grail, I've searched for a pie that can rival the Desperate Dan marrow pie used to be sold in the Mall Tavern in London, never tasted anything that meaty in my life, and can't find anything close to it frown

blueg33

47,013 posts

255 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
tomsugden said:
https://www.turnerspies.co.uk/

Featured on the apprentice a few years back. Pies are delivered to your door and are exceptional.
My home made ones don't have this processed crap in them that Turners use. Just proper ingredients

Hydrolysed Vegetable Protein
Sodium Ferrocyanide,
Concentrated Mushroom Juice,
Maltodextrin
Truffle Flavouring
Mono and Diglycerides of Fatty Acids
Citric Acid,
Carotenes
Ammonia Caramel


None of the other suggestions on this thread contain all that crap


Edited by blueg33 on Monday 26th October 12:18

dickymint

29,243 posts

289 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
Made my own steak and kidney pudding last week...................





blueg33

47,013 posts

255 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
dickymint said:
Made my own steak and kidney pudding last week...................




Nice

normalbloke

9,007 posts

250 months

Monday 26th October
quotequote all
SchillingTwo said:
It s the texture of the pastry that I miss as much as anything.

Mince pies from the chip shop when I was growing up (meat mince, not sweet mince) had a crunch. You could hold them by one end due to the structural integrity of the thick, firm pastry.
That’s because it’s festered for 3 days under the heat lamps…