Favourite LPs but not their most popular

[M138]

Something like this
I much prefer Never For Ever by Kate Bush over Hounds Of Love
I much prefer Making Movies by Dire Straits over Brothers In Arms
I much prefer In Through The Out Door by Led Zeppelin over Led Zeppelin 4

[Super Sonic]

I was going to say I preferred Simple Minds' Sons & Fascination to their most popular album, so I googled SM most popular albums to see what was at the top thinking it would be something recent, and it was a 'best of' so I scrolled down to see where S&F was and saw 'show 47 others'! Admittedly some were live, compilation etc but I remember when they had only done five albums and that's counting S&F and SFC as two. Shocker.
S&F was no5 in the chart, so I'm pleased to say it's one of there more popular ones. I'm on my fourth copy (two vinyl, two CD)

[cherryowen]

I preferred "Bleach" to "Nevermind"

[InductionRoar]

I prefer Tommy to Quadrophenia

[TwigtheWonderkid]

I prefer Give 'Em Enough Rope to London Calling.

[anonymous-user]

I prefer Momentary Lapse of Reason to Dark Side of The Moon.

[oddball1313]

slopes said:

I prefer Momentary Lapse of Reason to Dark Side of The Moon.

I prefer Animals to Dark side of the Moon

[jimothyc]

oddball1313 said:

I prefer Animals to Dark side of the Moon

Was just about to post the same, but you beat me to it.

[Hub]

I prefer the Division Bell

[oddball1313]

Hub said:

I prefer the Division Bell

A great album - let’s be honest, they’re all bloody brilliant

[jimothyc]

oddball1313 said:

Hub said:

I prefer the Division Bell

A great album - let’s be honest, they’re all bloody brilliant

The final cut?

[Macneil]

M138 said:

Something like this

I much prefer Making Movies by Dire Straits over Brothers In Arms

I much prefer Communique by Dire Straits to everything else they did
I much prefer Natty Dread by the Wailers to Kaya

[Turn7]

jimothyc said:

oddball1313 said:

I prefer Animals to Dark side of the Moon

Was just about to post the same, but you beat me to it.

Yep
Adore Animals

[Mastodon2]

The Black Dahlia Murder's most well-liked album is probably Nocturnal, although people seem to think Ritual is is a masterpiece too. Personally, I think Miasma is their best; it's raw and super honest, has the catchment tracks and the heaviest riffs, it's a banger from start to finish.

[Johnspex]

InductionRoar said:

I prefer Tommy to Quadrophenia

Isn’t Tommy “more popular than Quadrophenia”?
I never listen to Tommy but in my opinion Quadrophenia is the best album ever made anywhere in the world!

[NDA]

Street Legal to Slow Train.

[generationx]

jimothyc said:

oddball1313 said:

Hub said:

I prefer the Division Bell

A great album - let’s be honest, they’re all bloody brilliant

The final cut?

I think The Final Cut is excellent.

[dundarach]

I prefer Atom Heart Mother to Dark Side of the Moon

[Stick Legs]

dundarach said:

I prefer Atom Heart Mother to Dark Side of the Moon

100%

[Stick Legs]

Def Leppard High & Dry > Def Leppard Hysteria

Iron Maiden Seventh Son of a Seventh Son > Iron Maiden Powerslave