Question for a pro (or experienced) cellist
Question for a pro (or experienced) cellist
Author
Discussion

GetCarter

Original Poster:

31,339 posts

310 months

Tuesday 3rd November
quotequote all
Quick one.

I'm writing something for a solo cello (acc by pno). It's slow and sad. Would B minor or Bb minor be better (for vib and resonance etc).

Ta in advance.

thebraketester

15,849 posts

169 months

Tuesday 3rd November
quotequote all
That's an incredible niche question :-) . I would guess that avoiding open strings is a sensible idea if you are wanting vibrato. I can ask a friend tomorrow and get back to you. Of course, Dm would yield the saddest of all sounds.

GetCarter

Original Poster:

31,339 posts

310 months

Tuesday 3rd November
quotequote all
thebraketester said:
That's an incredible niche question :-) . I would guess that avoiding open strings is a sensible idea if you are wanting vibrato. I can ask a friend tomorrow and get back to you. Of course, Dm would yield the saddest of all sounds.
Fair enough, I thought there may be some cellists here... but in case not, I've sent the same question to my conductor, and he'll probably come up trumps (sorry to use that word). I've written for cello many times in the past, but only once as a solo/lead. It's a dark art.

I googled, and Db is apparently the best key for solo cello, but that puts everything else out of kilter.

First world problems.

elise2000

1,995 posts

250 months

Tuesday 3rd November
quotequote all
Pro Violinist here- generally, sharp keys always nicer for strings (to play certainly, but also for tone IMO).

gazza285

11,262 posts

239 months

Tuesday 3rd November
quotequote all
thebraketester said:
Of course, Dm would yield the saddest of all sounds.
Yes, the saddest of all keys.