what in-ceiling speakers for Atmos duties only?
Discussion
Contemplating moving to Atmos in home cinema (separate speakers/amp to music setup) and going for in-ceiling speakers (vaulted ceiling across room so can angle them correctly (as long as amp can correct for different distances as will be unusually far away). A setup with angles compatible with Dolby guidelines for 5.1.4 is easily doable. A second sub may also be added later. Amp will probably be the Denon AVC-X6500H or the AVR-3600H.
So the q is, what sort of in-ceiling speakers? Don’t want to spend a fortune, and so if £100 ones will do the Atmos effects fine then I don’t need to spend much more as I don’t want to play music through them… but no reviews out there that I can find which talk about them for home theatre duties, hence my q here - anyone got experiences/advice?
So the q is, what sort of in-ceiling speakers? Don’t want to spend a fortune, and so if £100 ones will do the Atmos effects fine then I don’t need to spend much more as I don’t want to play music through them… but no reviews out there that I can find which talk about them for home theatre duties, hence my q here - anyone got experiences/advice?
xcentric said:
Contemplating moving to Atmos in home cinema (separate speakers/amp to music setup) and going for in-ceiling speakers (vaulted ceiling across room so can angle them correctly (as long as amp can correct for different distances as will be unusually far away). A setup with angles compatible with Dolby guidelines for 5.1.4 is easily doable. A second sub may also be added later. Amp will probably be the Denon AVC-X6500H or the AVR-3600H.
So the q is, what sort of in-ceiling speakers? Don’t want to spend a fortune, and so if £100 ones will do the Atmos effects fine then I don’t need to spend much more as I don’t want to play music through them… but no reviews out there that I can find which talk about them for home theatre duties, hence my q here - anyone got experiences/advice?
You have two very differently priced amps in mind, (and I presume speakers) so it’s difficult to say exactly.So the q is, what sort of in-ceiling speakers? Don’t want to spend a fortune, and so if £100 ones will do the Atmos effects fine then I don’t need to spend much more as I don’t want to play music through them… but no reviews out there that I can find which talk about them for home theatre duties, hence my q here - anyone got experiences/advice?
Which speakers do you plan to buy please?
Once you’ve chosen the speakers to suit the amp, then you can add the appropriate ceiling speakers. These should ideally be from the same range to have the same voicing.
Ceiling / Atmos speakers do not require full range, but quality counts as always.
Poor cheap £100 pairs of speakers will sound just that.
Unpleasant obvious sound, with a different characteristic to your main speakers will be grating.
Ah, not so easy to buy matching items then!
Your speakers are pretty damn good though. I’d not expect to get the best out of them with an AVR-X6500, but it will be a very good sound non the less.
I’d get a set of something like B&W CCM665 for about £270. They’re detailed, good quality and should be easily good enough.
They’ll add a big new dimension to ALL content.
Are the Ruark speakers second hand?
I remember the cheapest Ruark sub being £599.
Your speakers are pretty damn good though. I’d not expect to get the best out of them with an AVR-X6500, but it will be a very good sound non the less.
I’d get a set of something like B&W CCM665 for about £270. They’re detailed, good quality and should be easily good enough.
They’ll add a big new dimension to ALL content.
Are the Ruark speakers second hand?
I remember the cheapest Ruark sub being £599.
Edited by Red 5 on Wednesday 1st January 19:21
I've had the Ruarks from new, pretty much. Have some Crusaders for hifi though those are going ti be swapped out soon for something else. And with such decent ones it's hard to find a timbre-matching set of inp0ceilings without spending a fortune on changing them all. So I'll check out your recommendation - thanks.
xcentric said:
I've had the Ruarks from new, pretty much. Have some Crusaders for hifi though those are going ti be swapped out soon for something else. And with such decent ones it's hard to find a timbre-matching set of inp0ceilings without spending a fortune on changing them all. So I'll check out your recommendation - thanks.
Ok second hand, or otherwise makes little difference really at this age. You can’t buy timbre matched ceiling speakers for your Ruarks.
Even if you find out who made the drive units in your L/C/R speakers.
If you do find somebody making ceiling speakers using the same brand cones, they’ll still not be timbre matched, as the electronics in the crossovers dictate too much.
Ceiling speakers are also normally be open backed speakers in a plastic / metal chassis, so don’t over think it.
You were considering an AV amp nowhere near good enough to make your Ruarks sound amazing, yet are concerned with timbre matching Atmos speakers.
These are diametrically opposed trains of though
If money is not an object (within reason), then get the bested kit.
If budget is more of a consideration, then plan based around that budget first, so you don’t make any mistakes.
Forums | Home Cinema & Hi-Fi | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff