Frankenstein - Dir. Guilermo del Torro

[GM182]

Watched this at the weekend with my wife and teenage sons. On Netflix. Thought it was very good, although the first act set-up took a little bit too long.

Oscar Isaac is excellent as usual. Jacob Elordi really steals the whole film as the creature.

It is fairly close to the book but some changes are a bit of shame - like the family dynamic and an unnecessary Christoph Waltz character. I think Frankestein is more sympathetic in the book but overall 4 body parts out of 5.

NB - quite gory in places for a cert 15. My 14 and 17 year olds were a little bit shocked in places.

[P-Jay]

Also watched it at the weekend. Looks great, but seemed over-long to me and dragged on.

For me, 30 mins shorter and it would have been better.

[Smollet]

P-Jay said:

Also watched it at the weekend. Looks great, but seemed over-long to me and dragged on.

For me, 30 mins shorter and it would have been better.

20 minutes in and I’m struggling to get into it

[Wheel Turned Out]

I'm the opposite - absolutely loved it and the runtime went in a flash for me. Contrast with Nosferatu which I felt did very much drag.

[P-Jay]

Smollet said:

P-Jay said:

Also watched it at the weekend. Looks great, but seemed over-long to me and dragged on.

For me, 30 mins shorter and it would have been better.

20 minutes in and I m struggling to get into it

It's visually stunning, great performances, but everyone know's the story.

[Xcore]

Best thing out in the last few months.

[biggbn]

P-Jay said:

Smollet said:

P-Jay said:

Also watched it at the weekend. Looks great, but seemed over-long to me and dragged on.

For me, 30 mins shorter and it would have been better.

20 minutes in and I m struggling to get into it

It's visually stunning, great performances, but everyone know's the story.

Do they really know the story though? One of my favourite novels and one that is heartbreaking, or certainly the way I read it....

[hondajack85]

Bit marvel comics superpowers . Anyone stuck together from different bits would barely be able to move.
As for pitchfork wielding villagers being horrified,there was constant war on so someone covered in scars could just say he was injured in the conflict,and lap up the sympathy.
But it was still good.

[Lucas Ayde]

hondajack85 said:

Bit marvel comics superpowers . Anyone stuck together from different bits would barely be able to move.

Terrific point - now I can never enjoy a 'Frankenstein' movie.

[PinkTornado]

Really enjoyed it- definitely could have gotten going a bit sooner but the cast and design were excellent.

[hondajack85]

Lucas Ayde said:

hondajack85 said:

Bit marvel comics superpowers . Anyone stuck together from different bits would barely be able to move.

Terrific point - now I can never enjoy a 'Frankenstein' movie.

Sorry about that,but if I think about it more he was imbued with bazzillions of volts of electricity and some sort of secret sauce. So nothing as stupid as a spider bite lol.
Its a masterpiece of logic compared to the bizarre 1931 effort where victor gets away with living happy ever after, even though he desecrated graves,and was indirectly responsible for the death of his old professor and a small child at minimum.
What were they smoking in the 1930s. Its worth watching just to try and understand the mindset at the time.

[P-Jay]

Lucas Ayde said:

hondajack85 said:

Bit marvel comics superpowers . Anyone stuck together from different bits would barely be able to move.

Terrific point - now I can never enjoy a 'Frankenstein' movie.

Or the Munsters!

[nordboy]

I really enjoyed it, all the acting was very good and sets etc brilliant.

[SlimJim16v]

This popped up on my Facebook. Quality not taken into accounts.

https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/frankenstein-movi...

[Huzzah]

SlimJim16v said:

This popped up on my Facebook. Quality not taken into accounts.

https://www.denofgeek.com/movies/frankenstein-movi...

Not credible if it doesn't include the Young Frankestein, head and shoulders above the rest.

[Bright Halo]

Why was the monster constructed from different body parts rather than just regenerating a whole deceased corpse?

[Dog Biscuit]

Watched about 25 mins then fked it off. Rubbish

[PinkTornado]

Bright Halo said:

Why was the monster constructed from different body parts rather than just regenerating a whole deceased corpse?

I've often wondered that about many film versions of the story. It's been a long time since I read the book, but I THINK that in that he wants to create some kind of perfect specimen, so chooses the choicest parts, and it is only once it is complete and animated that he sees it for the horror that it really is..?

[PinkTornado]

Dog Biscuit said:

Watched about 25 mins then fked it off. Rubbish

I know, right? Fancy the big green guy with the bolts in his neck not being all sewn together and stomping around inside of half an hour! Kept me from looking at my phone and everything. Bilge!

[Lefty]

I really enjoyed it but agree it felt a wee bit long