would you work for someone like this?
Discussion
this is a genuine letter written to a postdoc in chemistry...
http://boingboing.net/2010/06/25/i-have-noticed-th...

http://boingboing.net/2010/06/25/i-have-noticed-th...

that kind of attitude is still very much prevalent in chemistry departments nowadays. More so in the US from what I understand. It is particularly the organic chemistry what do it because the work they do is just trained-monkey bench work that benefits from more time being put in. In any job that involves sustained intellectual input or creativity its not worth working much more than 40 or 50 hours a week - anything above this and productivity plummets.
Hahaha, my boss last summer could have written something similar. I even fell asleep in the tractor and he didnt get the hint. Didnt understand the idea of time off, and didnt think that it was needed for about 3 months. I did 6 weeks without a day off - averaged about 85 hours a week.
Mike
Goes with the supervisor, mostly in physics it is pretty relaxed - however in US it can be almost like the letter. Sink or swim, the good groups get so many people wanting to join, often paying their way that if they don't do 12+ hrs a day 6-7 days a week they'll get the shove for someone who will.
As you said it also depends on the topic / project if its just sitting at a bench/computer iterating then of course people can be pressured into spending excessive hours, in my area the cash burn could be horrendous so it needs some regulation. Also safety plays a part as well.
I've seen some groups/people use/abuse foreign students by giving each composition to work on incrementing by 1% values and then get them to work a standard set of measurements/characterisations - is that PhD or post doc work? probably not.
Also the old 10,000 hours comes into play for a good PhD - 12 hrs a day will get you the work done in 3 years.
Goes with the supervisor, mostly in physics it is pretty relaxed - however in US it can be almost like the letter. Sink or swim, the good groups get so many people wanting to join, often paying their way that if they don't do 12+ hrs a day 6-7 days a week they'll get the shove for someone who will.
As you said it also depends on the topic / project if its just sitting at a bench/computer iterating then of course people can be pressured into spending excessive hours, in my area the cash burn could be horrendous so it needs some regulation. Also safety plays a part as well.
I've seen some groups/people use/abuse foreign students by giving each composition to work on incrementing by 1% values and then get them to work a standard set of measurements/characterisations - is that PhD or post doc work? probably not.
Also the old 10,000 hours comes into play for a good PhD - 12 hrs a day will get you the work done in 3 years.
Perfectly normal in science research, certainly within universities. My missus did this pretty much throughout her Ph.D and her post docs. Perhaps the difference is that it would not be put into so formerly in writing and a lot of it is down to personal commitment and dedication.
Some people can be very demanding and the rules for lab research are most definitely not he same as in the commercial sector.
Some people can be very demanding and the rules for lab research are most definitely not he same as in the commercial sector.
Edited by drivin_me_nuts on Thursday 8th July 22:15
Condi said:
Hahaha, my boss last summer could have written something similar. I even fell asleep in the tractor and he didnt get the hint. Didnt understand the idea of time off, and didnt think that it was needed for about 3 months. I did 6 weeks without a day off - averaged about 85 hours a week.
But that's only half a season! What was the 12 and 13 wk average? And less of the 'about 85'. Do the sums. I could've sworn I did 120 hours for months on end when I were a lad. Turns out I never did as much as I felt like I'd done.And if you get sleepy just go to sleep. If the boss whinges, remind him that there is no opt out of statutory breaks and see if he does anything about it.
Ironically this will become an open letter to the employer as eventually, when he or anyone else Google's his name they'll find this thread at the top of Google, make their own mind up about the dear DR. I suppose if it's a big company thinking about employing him and his team to develop compound X (or whatever his science is about), they might be impressed by the work ethic. Personally I'd employ a moderately hard working decent guy over a harder working a-hole every time but that's just me. I wouldn't judge this guy on the strength of this letter one though, however OTT it seems.
Forum | The Lounge | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff







