Any one else learn from playing in the snow?
Any one else learn from playing in the snow?
Author
Discussion

markswebpages

Original Poster:

174 posts

199 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
When I first got my licence (4 years ago) the first time it snowed I very carefully went out early in the morning and found a empty car park and had a play.

Not only did it give me some amusement, but I learned allot about what happens when you do certain things in the snow and also just how unpredictable it can be making me very aware you shouldn't take anything for granted whilst driving in the snow.

When I was talking to some of my less car minded colleagues at work about the impending cold weather and the possibility of snow I mentioned it and they couldn't understand why I'd done it and what I could possibly of learned from doing it. All of my friends who are car minded have done the same as me so I was wondering if it's just something that most people who have an interested in cars and driving do?

PS

I'm not suggesting that it would be a good thing if on the first snowy morning of the year everyone went out and tried to do the same as (a) this would lead to allot of accidents in car parks which wouldn't help anyone and (b) there's no shame in making a tit of yourself by getting it wrong in an empty car park (as long as you don't damage anyone else's property). But I do feel it helped to keep me safe when driving in the snow.

Mastodon2

14,143 posts

187 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
I have done this before, good fun and helpful too. I think the most important thing I learned obvious but A) the brake pedal will do nothing if you press it too hard, and B) quick steering inputs will unsettle the car and pretty soon it will be sliding in it's direction of travel and the steering wheel will not do much of anything for a few seconds until the car straightens out.

Both are common sense (I'd hope) but deliberately inducing them showed me how easy it is to go wrong. Driving a car in this conditions is a fine balance, and your limited control of the vehicle can very quickly slip away from you without correct and measured inputs.

Just this morning when turning my car over to keep it healthy (saw a few cars having difficulty starting when I was walking the dog) I drove it around the car park where it was parked just to get a quick practise in. I did lol at a friend of mine who tried to get his stuck car off his drive by "flooring it in 1st gear", he didn't get far!

Pothole

34,367 posts

304 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
was just posting same somewhere else...the fun I had out at lakeside in my Dad's old Maestro in the 90s has stood me in good stead for living up this country lane, although I did nearly hit the wall at the end of the drive just now!

IforB

9,840 posts

251 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
"Playing" in snowy car parks does help your driving skills and understanding of how a car reacts in adverse conditions. The fact that it's as fun as anything is of course completely secondary...

cptsideways

13,811 posts

274 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
Ask anyone who has crashed accidently in the snow, if they go out playing in it Answer = NO

Ask anyone who has'nt crashed accidently in the snow, if they go out playing in it Answer = YES

Generally speaking of course






Small Print: Mishaps caused by humorous & exuberent behaviour in motor vehicles in such treachereous conditions are exempt from this survey

CraigyMc

18,079 posts

258 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
I did that about 10 years ago. It was actually quite helpful (get car moving, put it in a slide, then try to get control back).

Being cocky and getting into a 400m downhill skid starting at 70mph (on 2" of virgin snow!) on the way home taught me something else: don't be so cocky.

Car and driver were both physically unharmed, driver drove the rest of the way at under 30mph.

C

EDLT

15,421 posts

228 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
The problem with going for a play in the snow is that you learn things that are at odds the PH "knowledge", such as the effects of ABS and traction control.

Balmoral Green

42,554 posts

270 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
Some people don't learn though.

I'm sat in the spare room looking down our hill. Some come up the hill quite well, low revs, high gear, keeping going at a steady rate and maintaining traction, and can even get going again if they have to stop for the idiots getting nowhere in 1st gear with a gazillion revs. It is funny when those who have a clue have to stop for gazillion revs, then wait for gazillion revs to stop, then they pull off and drive around gazillion revs, uphill, then gazillion revs tries again and gets nowhere. You'd think they might learn when vehicles coming up behind have stopped and waited, then pulled off cleanly and driven around them several times. And they resume once again with a gazillion revs.

I ought to put a sign up "2nd gear, no more than tickover or 1000 rpm max, be gentle, don't stall, and you'll be alright, you'll actually move!".

It's not all bad though, as looking down our hill and watching folks, it only looks like 1 in 4 who haven't a clue.

The worst is having to stop on the way up, because some bloody pedestrian is walking in the road, and they don't make much effort to get back on the pavement, and you can feel the pain and anguish of those trying to stay steady and not have to lift or stop as they come up the hill. I think I'd be on the horn and screaming out of the window at them.

markswebpages

Original Poster:

174 posts

199 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
I did that about 10 years ago. It was actually quite helpful (get car moving, put it in a slide, then try to get control back).

Being cocky and getting into a 400m downhill skid starting at 70mph (on 2" of virgin snow!) on the way home taught me something else: don't be so cocky.

Car and driver were both physically unharmed, driver drove the rest of the way at under 30mph.

C
Yeah been there although not at 70. I decided that I could cope with driving anywhere so to test this out I went for a drive down some country roads and discovered that steep downward drops and zero grip is a bad thing.

Apart from being able to figure out what works and what doesn't it also made me allot less on edge (but not complacent) therefore my actions where much smoother and better thought out when the car did something I wasn't expecting. Last year I ended up ferrying 3 other people into work all through the snow because they couldn't get there cars out of the places they lived in, funnily enough I could with my trusty old cavalier LOL.

The best thing I learned by far was to try and be smooth, as sudden changes of any sort will land you in a whole world of trouble.

CraigyMc

18,079 posts

258 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
Balmoral Green said:
Some people don't learn though...gazillion revs....
Last year I was coming home from Guildford to Romsey on the A31, and was caught in the ice-rain problem that had many people stuck in their cars overnight. During my (very delayed, tortuitous) route home on country roads, I was stuck for a few minutes behind a lady driving a honda civic type-R exactly in the mannerr you suggest, up a hill.

It got boring enough for me to stop, get out of my car, walk up to her (frantically wheelspinning) car, tap on the window (she stopped wheelspinning at that point and put her foot on the brakes).

Me: "Try as few revs as possible without stalling, luv"

Her: "eh... okay"

She did as I asked, and drove straight up the hill.

If it's really that simple, shouldn't it be something that's common knowledge?

C

IforB

9,840 posts

251 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Balmoral Green said:
Some people don't learn though...gazillion revs....
If it's really that simple, shouldn't it be something that's common knowledge?

C
Yep. It should. It's amazing how little clue some people really do have when it comes to driving in low grip conditions. Actually, it's not amazing, it's really quite scary.

ooo000ooo

2,631 posts

216 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
I discovered , in a moment of panic on an icey main road a few years ago, that if you have 4 wheel steering and the front wheels locked up that the rear wheels are still turning and can be used to steer the car around the queue of traffic you are heading for.
Remembering to turn the opposite direction to where you want to go is the hard bit.

Biker's Nemesis

40,974 posts

230 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
I've been driving on the road for nearly 30 years and never miss the opportunity for a bit of fun.

I'd say it does help.

littlebasher

3,915 posts

193 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
Gives new purpose to a piss poor handbrake....had some 360 fun earlier myself

Edited by littlebasher on Saturday 27th November 17:14

masermartin

1,649 posts

199 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
Yes, I do this on occasion in the winter, and it helped me keep my car on the black stuff about 8 years ago when I hit a random patch of black ice. Next morning there was a queue of Porsches, BMW's etc being craned out of the ditch.

Edit:

ooo000ooo said:
I discovered , in a moment of panic on an icey main road a few years ago, that if you have 4 wheel steering and the front wheels locked up that the rear wheels are still turning and can be used to steer the car around the queue of traffic you are heading for.
Remembering to turn the opposite direction to where you want to go is the hard bit.
ROFL biggrin

Edited by masermartin on Saturday 27th November 17:23

i remember

3,296 posts

208 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
I went into a car park last year ( feb this year? ) and decided id try and learn a bit of control with a few self inflicted turn ins, did help "feel" how everything goes.

That said i do drive very carefully in bad road conditions and wouldnt put others at risk trying to have a bit of "fun".

It does help smile

LC2

254 posts

195 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
cptsideways said:
Ask anyone who has crashed accidently in the snow, if they go out playing in it Answer = NO

Ask anyone who has'nt crashed accidently in the snow, if they go out playing in it Answer = YES

Generally speaking of course

Small Print: Mishaps caused by humorous & exuberent behaviour in motor vehicles in such treachereous conditions are exempt from this survey
I must be the exception then.
I fell off the road while driving along the snow covered tracks up to Hamsterley, back in the 90s, when it snowed heavily during the RAC. Took a bit of shoving to get out of the ditch smile (1)

Doesn't stop me playing in the snow.

(1) Slow speed, no damage. Avoiding someone who decided to open their door as I was approaching - If you've driven the tracks around the Hamsterley stage, you'll know how tight it is.

Prof Prolapse

16,163 posts

212 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
I learned that winter tyres, four wheel drive and years of experience are worth fk all when the car in front doesn't have any of them.


IanMorewood

4,309 posts

270 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
Trouble nowadays is that most supermarket carparks have ANPC/CCTV cameras and your likely to get a visit a few days down the line from the BiB to discuss your dangerous driving.

Cock Womble 7

29,908 posts

252 months

Saturday 27th November 2010
quotequote all
IanMorewood said:
Trouble nowadays is that most supermarket carparks have ANPC/CCTV cameras and your likely to get a visit a few days down the line from the BiB to discuss your dangerous driving.
On private land?