Model Citizen or Prat?
Model Citizen or Prat?
Author
Discussion

Big_M

Original Poster:

5,602 posts

290 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
I went shopping in the sales today and bought several items at a large store. When the girlie had finished totalling everything up on her till she said "That will be £20 please." Now one of the items I bought was £20 and the other two were £10 each - but I thought I may have done my maths wrong or misread the prices. Well I checked the receipt and there was only two items on the bill. Dilemma time. The security tags had been removed from all three items so there would have been no problem with walking out of the shop. But I just could not do it. I had to point out her error and pay for the omitted item.

What would you have done in this situation. Am I a prat?

daydreamer

1,409 posts

284 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
You will get your rewards in Heaven Big M

Or if you are into Kama, maybe even sooner .

CarZee

13,382 posts

294 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Not a prat at all, Big_M.. respect is due!

bob the planner

4,695 posts

296 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
The honest thing to do. Good on you.

Bob

johnelliott

293 posts

287 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
You did the right thing, never worth it for £10 or even £1000. You've got to do what feels right at the time. Good question though

John

Big_M

Original Poster:

5,602 posts

290 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Cheers Guys - what is worrying is that I thought about it for a few seconds. Could have been scary if I was being secretly videoed for a TV programme on morals.

CarZee

13,382 posts

294 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Anyone notice that Big_M's respect rating has rocketed in the last 15 minutes.. ?

Was that a true story then, Big_M?



what the hell's next? Deltaf telling us about him rescuing kittens from a burning building?

>> Edited by CarZee (moderator) on Tuesday 31st December 18:32

Big_M

Original Poster:

5,602 posts

290 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
CZ - 10 to 12 is not 'rocketing'?

Yep it is a true story - I have the recipts to prove it - you are welcome to a copy.

:bignewyearssloppywetkissforcarzee:

CarZee

13,382 posts

294 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all

riprock10

3 posts

290 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Your a prat .im afraid i would have had to walk away with the loot.does that make me a man of "low moral fibre".....perhaps,but if it was a wallet or something that id found i would return it,so i guess im not all bad .It must be something to do with taking from a faceless organistion(errr) that makes it right .(and no that doesnt mean im a shop lifter....they tend to use that one a lot )

yours

Dash RipRock

HarryW

15,975 posts

296 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Model citizen , always do what feels right, it's never too far wrong IMHO.

Harry

jmorgan

36,010 posts

311 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Its happened to me a few times. So well done.
What does annoy me is when I point it out and the till operator grunts a thank you as if it was my fault..
Also that person who's cheque book and guarantee card I found in the same holder, the one I took to the police station, thanks for not thanking me.

Simonelite501

1,440 posts

295 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
The right thing to do, I've already given you a respect rating, but if it would let me do it again, I would. Simon.

pies

13,116 posts

283 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all

Big_M said: CZ - 10 to 12 is not 'rocketing'?

Yep it is a true story - I have the recipts to prove it - you are welcome to a copy.

:bignewyearssloppywetkissforcarzee:


No but 10 to 14 is 40% rise Respect given... and deserved

Edited to say 10 to 17 is a 70% rise now thats "rocketing"

>> Edited by pies on Tuesday 31st December 20:54

deltaf

1,384 posts

284 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Thanx for that vote of confidence Carzee.
As it 'appens i too would have pointed out the omissin too.
Id be the first one into and the last one out of a burning building if it meant rescuing kittens.

madcop

6,649 posts

290 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all

riprock10 said: Your a prat .im afraid i would have had to walk away with the loot.does that make me a man of "low moral fibre".....perhaps,but if it was a wallet or something that id found i would return it,so i guess im not all bad .It must be something to do with taking from a faceless organistion(errr) that makes it right .(and no that doesnt mean im a shop lifter....they tend to use that one a lot )




I am afraid that technically in law you would be just the same as a shoplifter if you had walked out without paying for goods you knew payment was required.

The actions that you would take are theft and possibly false accounting under the theft act.

yours



>> Edited by madcop on Tuesday 31st December 20:19

pies

13,116 posts

283 months

Tuesday 31st December 2002
quotequote all
Not that i am encouraging shoplifting.Wouldn't proof be a problem in this case as the items were in a sale and were duly presented for payment,would you know how much the bill should be for? some sales have price reduced at the till (saves time repricing)
Say the purchase was for 50 items i doubt anybody would have noticed

Marcos maniac

3,148 posts

288 months

Wednesday 1st January 2003
quotequote all


Good on ya Big m

I walked out of M & s with a trolley full of shopping last week that I had not payed for

Mobile phone rang as I was wizzing round and I couldn't hear the caller properly, walked to the front of the store pushing the trolley and the signal was dire so I walked outside without thinking

I stood outside for about 5 mins talking on the phone and suddenly realised that I hadn't paid for the shopping No one had noticed. split second decision do I walk off or go back and pay???

Yep I went back in and paid

Harrigan

410 posts

292 months

Wednesday 1st January 2003
quotequote all
Definitely did the right thing, Big M. Good on ya!

madcop

6,649 posts

290 months

Wednesday 1st January 2003
quotequote all

pies said: Not that i am encouraging shoplifting.Wouldn't proof be a problem in this case as the items were in a sale and were duly presented for payment,would you know how much the bill should be for? some sales have price reduced at the till (saves time repricing)
Say the purchase was for 50 items i doubt anybody would have noticed


Say you didn't pay for any of the items but knew you had to! It may be difficult to prove but it does not mean it is not theft.

The only way that it would not be theft is that if you had 50 items and you were unaware that some of them had not been charged for.

As soon as you become aware of that fact, you assume the rights of the owner ('the store') and if you intend to then permanently deprive the owner of those goods without going back and offering payment, the offence is complete.

Proving shoplifting is difficult in many cases as the full definition of theft has to apply and there has to be a 'mens rea'(guilty mind) element to it.

As stated before just because the case may be hard to prove, does not mean that you do not commit it and does not mean that you may not get your collar felt if someone realises (cctv)

Theft is an arrestable offence. There is no time limit restriction on when you can be arrested for this offence and sometimes when evidence is difficult to come by or the person difficult to find, then the power of arrest can be activated years later.

Story

Several years ago, I stopped a pedestrian who was walking on the motorway trying to hitch a ride to Brighton. As with all pedestrians on Motorways I ran him through the PNC to see if he was known to Police. Not only was that the case but there was a wanted marker on him for an offence of GBH committed in Brighton 4 years earlier. He got his lift to Brighton, but not in the manner that he had expected. It was via another Police station and the custody procedure.
He had been out of the country for the time since the original offence and was not even aware that he was wanted for the offence.

I was always told, 'be sure your sins will find you out' I don't know about any of you lot but where I am concerned they have a habit of catching me up eventually . the best thing to be is completely honest just as Big M has been and can no doubt sleep at night and walk without looking over her shoulder because of it