Help Requested
Author
Discussion

rewster

Original Poster:

48 posts

292 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
I get my new car (Porsche Boxster)in 4 weeks, and am currently have the following problem.

We currently have 2 cars, a Vectra V6 (T reg) and a BMW 318TDS (P reg). They are both worth about the same, give or take £500. My girlfrind is currently refusing to let me part ex the BMW against the Porsche.

I want to keep the Vectra because:-

1) Its newer, and a hell of a lot quicker and better to drive.
2) The BMW now has over 100k miles, and things are going to start to go wrong very soon, I suspect.
3) Vectra is still under factory warranty
4) Interor of Vectra is in better condition
5) Vectra is the more practical car, being a hatchback
6) The stereo in the Vectra is by far superior to the one in the BMW and has a hands free telephone kit for a mobile telephone fitted.
7) The Vectra has a private plate, which will be lost, because DVLC can't guarantee that I'll get the new V5 through within the 4 weeks required.
8) Servicing the Vectra is about 50% cheaper than the BMW

Girlfriend wants to keep the BMW because "She Loves it!!!"

I know that I am probably going to get slated, because I own a Vectra, but it makes far more sense both financially and practically to keep the Vectra and part ex the BMW.

Can you please provide me with your comments, so I can show them to my girlfriend, in the hope that she will actually listen to reason

Podie

46,649 posts

303 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
Economic sense points towards the Vauxhaul...

pdavison

1,639 posts

305 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
Easy - keep the BMW but she pays if it goes wrong !
...
Or - keep the Vectra and you pay if it goes wrong !

Bodo

12,558 posts

294 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all


Girlfriend wants to keep the BMW because "She Loves it!!!"



If she's allowed to drive the Boxster, she'll probably love it more than the BMW?

Podie

46,649 posts

303 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
Sabotage the Beemer... .. so that it won't start or something... then it HAS to go!

loaf

850 posts

289 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
The fact that you had the good sense to get the only Vauxhall lump worth a light may save you from most of the flaming

Tell her if she wants to maintain the Bavarian Muck Wagon herself, pay all the servicing bills, put fuel in it, pay for the upgrade to the stereo, then by all means she can keep it. If not, then STFU and get on with driving the Vauxhall...

alunr

1,676 posts

292 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
sorry to be a pain in the arse here but surely you're buying the Porsche because you "Love it"...

Its only fair if it goes both ways.

dubaiguy

356 posts

285 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
Part exchange Vectra AND BMW against the Boxster. Trade in girlfriend for newer model . Sorted .......

rewster

Original Poster:

48 posts

292 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all

alunr said: sorry to be a pain in the arse here but surely you're buying the Porsche because you "Love it"...

Its only fair if it goes both ways.


True, but when its time to sell, I will not have a problem removing it from my life, "just because I love it"

Natty

1 posts

282 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
IT'S THE GIRLFRIEND HERE! THERE IS NO WAY IN THIS WORLD THAT BEAMER AND I ARE PARTING! IF IT DISAPPEARS FROM OUR DRIVE, IT WON'T BE THE ONLY THING LEAVING!!

Marcos maniac

3,148 posts

289 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all



7) The Vectra has a private plate, which will be lost, because DVLC can't guarantee that I'll get the new V5 through within the 4 weeks required.



Easy one to sort = put the plate on retention as long as it is taxed & MOT fill out the paperwork at DVLA local Office and PX car, tell the garage that you have retained the plate so will notify them of new reg as soon as it comes through

note; vectra should go back to its original reg (if it had one prior to private plate)

Podie

46,649 posts

303 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all

Natty said: IT'S THE GIRLFRIEND HERE! THERE IS NO WAY IN THIS WORLD THAT BEAMER AND I ARE PARTING! IF IT DISAPPEARS FROM OUR DRIVE, IT WON'T BE THE ONLY THING LEAVING!!


you are in soooo much shit right now... - you've been rumbled mate!

So, you'll be keeping the Beemer then...

M@H

11,298 posts

300 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
Its a 318... surely you'd prefer a new 5 series...


Matt

Podie

46,649 posts

303 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all

M@H said: Its a 318... surely you'd prefer a new 5 series...


Matt


Big wooden spoon you got there M@H!

rewster

Original Poster:

48 posts

292 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all

Marcos maniac said:



7) The Vectra has a private plate, which will be lost, because DVLC can't guarantee that I'll get the new V5 through within the 4 weeks required.



Easy one to sort = put the plate on retention as long as it is taxed & MOT fill out the paperwork at DVLA local Office and PX car, tell the garage that you have retained the plate so will notify them of new reg as soon as it comes through

note; vectra should go back to its original reg (if it had one prior to private plate)


I won't be able to sell the car without the V5 though, Will I?

pbrettle

3,280 posts

311 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
318TDS - They dont call them TeDiouS for nothing. Not a nice car and probably the worst in the range bar the underpowered 316i. Could it be that it is a BMW and the other is a Poxyhall?

Personally keep the Vectra and trade the BMW. Once you start getting beyond 100,000 the UK car buying public takes a dim view (for no major reason). Get rid while you can to save as much money as poss.

Cheers,

Paul

Marcos maniac

3,148 posts

289 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all

rewster said:

Marcos maniac said:



7) The Vectra has a private plate, which will be lost, because DVLC can't guarantee that I'll get the new V5 through within the 4 weeks required.



Easy one to sort = put the plate on retention as long as it is taxed & MOT fill out the paperwork at DVLA local Office and PX car, tell the garage that you have retained the plate so will notify them of new reg as soon as it comes through

note; vectra should go back to its original reg (if it had one prior to private plate)


I won't be able to sell the car without the V5 though, Will I?




shouldnt be a problem.

pop into the dealer and tell them that you want to retain the plate and that you are going to apply now and that as soon as you get the reg details back you will inform them, basically the vectra goes to the dealer with the private plate still on it, along with the tax and they can do what they want with the vehicle ubtil you get a new V5.

A couple of months ago I retained a private Plate of Mrs M's car the day before I Px'd it, dealer was fine about it and V5 came through within about 2 weeks.

If you have got a local DVLA Office you can go in and get the ball rolling quite quickly, you need: V5, Tax disc, MOT and Insurance certificate and your chequebook (transfer/retention for available at the counter)

mel

10,168 posts

303 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all
keep them both and px the girlfriend

Podie

46,649 posts

303 months

Friday 14th February 2003
quotequote all

mel said: keep them both and px the girlfriend


Like a newer model with bigger airbags..?