This registration number cannot be retained online
This registration number cannot be retained online
Author
Discussion

TheBinarySheep

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

76 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
So, I've found a new car that I'm interested in, but first I need to sell my car to the likes of WBAC. I've just tried to take the private plate off my car so I can put the original plate on and get a new V5 document, and the DVLA websites says 'This registration number cannot be retained online'.

Apparently I have to fill in a V317 document, which can take 2 to 5 weeks!

I've never had this issue in the past but now it looks like through no fault of my own I have to miss out on this car, and simply wait around for the DVLA to do their thing before I can even think about selling the current car.

Has anyone else had this problem, how long did the process take?

MustangGT

13,700 posts

305 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
Expect it to take 3-6 weeks. It is an annoyance that they allow you to transfer the number onto the car without warning you that there will be a problem to remove it. We have lost 3 registrations to this. Nowadays I start the process to remove the existing plate before applying my plate as a test. Then I know whether I need to remove it 6 weeks ahead of time.

TheBinarySheep

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

76 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
MustangGT said:
Expect it to take 3-6 weeks. It is an annoyance that they allow you to transfer the number onto the car without warning you that there will be a problem to remove it. We have lost 3 registrations to this. Nowadays I start the process to remove the existing plate before applying my plate as a test. Then I know whether I need to remove it 6 weeks ahead of time.
Yeh it's an absolute joke. Had no issues putting the plate on the car 3 year ago. I was in the process of taking the plate off the car and putting a deposit down on a new one, but this has thrown a massive spanner in works.

All I want to do it retain my private plate so I can put the original back on the car. Whether there's a gap in the tax history or not shouldn't make any difference at all. I'm going to assume any gap is from when the garage owned the car before me, so absolutely nothing to do with me.

Edited by TheBinarySheep on Saturday 11th April 14:36

Hagus

105 posts

81 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
Yep got this at the moment and had it before. What on earth has a previous owners or traders tax habits got to do with me years later?

sixor8

8,116 posts

293 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
I've taken plates off cars several times online with no issues. Last time was September 2025. Has it been untaxed recently or something? There's usually a reason.

The only time I had a delay was in 1994 in the days when there were DVL local offices and before the internet. They wanted to inspect my Morris Minor, probably to check it existed, and wasn't a box of bits. rolleyes

They probably do random checks in case someone only has the V5c and no actual car. They do have strict rules about tax status, but the one I did last year was a car that had been in the trade and untaxed only a few months earlier.

Sir Bagalot

6,911 posts

206 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
Has had a tax break sometime in the past 5 years

TheBinarySheep

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

76 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
sixor8 said:
I've taken plates off cars several times online with no issues. Last time was September 2025. Has it been untaxed recently or something? There's usually a reason.
i bought the car from Motorpoint three years ago, i am assuming any gaps were before my ownership.

RedLightGreenLight

197 posts

49 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
Sounds like DVLA might potentially have a marker on this registration number in their systems… could be a number of reasons like some other folks have pointed out, such as previous tax issues. Could maybe have been associated with a written off car, fraudulent cloning etc?

It might be an idea to call / webchat DVLA to get some clarification about this?

TheBinarySheep

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

76 months

Saturday 11th April
quotequote all
RedLightGreenLight said:
Sounds like DVLA might potentially have a marker on this registration number in their systems could be a number of reasons like some other folks have pointed out, such as previous tax issues. Could maybe have been associated with a written off car, fraudulent cloning etc?

It might be an idea to call / webchat DVLA to get some clarification about this?
Must be something simple or surely it would have been highlighted when i put the plate on the car of when i've taxed it every year.

alscar

8,454 posts

238 months

Sunday 12th April
quotequote all
TheBinarySheep said:
RedLightGreenLight said:
Sounds like DVLA might potentially have a marker on this registration number in their systems could be a number of reasons like some other folks have pointed out, such as previous tax issues. Could maybe have been associated with a written off car, fraudulent cloning etc?

It might be an idea to call / webchat DVLA to get some clarification about this?
Must be something simple or surely it would have been highlighted when i put the plate on the car of when i've taxed it every year.
If the car has been Sorn’d and / or not taxed at any point in the past 5 years then irrespective of which owner did that DVLA won’t allow online retention.
As such unfortunately you have to do this the old fashioned way by post.
You might get lucky and it only take the minimum time of a couple of weeks.
Afaik there is no way round this.

TheBinarySheep

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

76 months

Sunday 12th April
quotequote all
thankfully we're going to go ahead with the new car purchase anyway, so this won't hold things up. It just means we'll have to borrow extra money from ourselves and sell the old car once we get the V5 back.

UK_Scat_Pack

642 posts

181 months

Sunday 12th April
quotequote all
I ve had this every single time I’ve tried to put a cherished reg on retention. And every time it s taken about 6 weeks to get the new V5 back. I ve lost numerous private sales because of it!

Edited by UK_Scat_Pack on Monday 13th April 22:37

THE 80Y

110 posts

51 months

Monday 13th April
quotequote all
I think the taxation history should be reset everytime there is a new registered keeper.

If you buy a used car you have no idea if the car wasn't taxed a few years ago (why would you). It has nothing to do with the current keeper.

Is there a way to find out if a reg number can be retained online without going through the complete transaction? I guess if you get to the payment screen does that mean it would work?

RS Grant

1,789 posts

258 months

Monday 13th April
quotequote all
The car has had a lapse in RFL at some point in the last few years... and no matter how much you complain to the DVLA and they can see that you've always had the car taxed/SORN'd will allow them to force their archaic system to remove this flag. It's a real frustration.

Doing it via snail mail was a grim delay when you want you car sold/traded in, but when I did it towards the end of last year, it was turned around quicker than expected.

sixor8

8,116 posts

293 months

Monday 13th April
quotequote all
alscar said:
If the car has been Sorn d and / or not taxed at any point in the past 5 years then irrespective of which owner did that DVLA won t allow online retention.
As such unfortunately you have to do this the old fashioned way by post.
You might get lucky and it only take the minimum time of a couple of weeks.
Afaik there is no way round this.
That's not correct. You can take a plate off a car that is SORN, as long as it is less than 5 years since last taxed. The plate I removed from a CLK in 2025, I had only had 2 months. It had previously been 'untaxed' but this is because it was 'in trade.' I was pleasantly surprised it was allowed online. smile

https://www.gov.uk/personalised-vehicle-registrati...

TheBinarySheep

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

76 months

Monday 27th April
quotequote all
In the end it took 1 day short of two weeks for the new V5 to come back. So not too bad.

RedLightGreenLight

197 posts

49 months

Monday 27th April
quotequote all
TheBinarySheep said:
In the end it took 1 day short of two weeks for the new V5 to come back. So not too bad.
Glad it was sorted in the end, any further idea or clarification of what the issue was from DVLA side?

TheBinarySheep

Original Poster:

1,632 posts

76 months

Tuesday 28th April
quotequote all
RedLightGreenLight said:
Glad it was sorted in the end, any further idea or clarification of what the issue was from DVLA side?
Nothing, just a new v5 and a retention document arrived in the post.