Running your diesel on the cheap. Practical alternatives.
Running your diesel on the cheap. Practical alternatives.
Author
Discussion

ElvisPenhaligon

Original Poster:

91 posts

176 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
Hello folks. I am among other things a chemist. I have sadly been pushed into the world of dag-dags by the cost of fuel and recently, I seem to be chucking too much money at fuel.

It is high time for alternatives.

Cooking oil is pretty much the same price of diesel.

Waste Veg Oil is trading on ebay at up to 60p/L. This is too expensive for water filled crap which needs reactions and separations performed on it. I am not going to dissolve parts of my fuel system with residual alkali.

Red Diesel is no good. It too is right up in price, around 86p/L which is too much for the risk of getting crushed. I will also add several points. Cat Litter (fullers earth) does not remove the red trace. The dye is an Azo dye, which means it is destectable by it's very intense and discreet absorption at very low concentrations. There are no trace metals. I gather that a sample of fuel is drawn off at the roadside and a check performed by a spectrophotometer. You cannot add other fuel dyes to mask it, including "engine oil" black, or black dyes as you will see that it too is prohibited and is treated by HMRC with the same scorn as heating oil.

Kerosene doesn't have the lubricating properties and needs to be cut with about 20% lubricating or veg oil to work. If you can source this, it is cheaper than "red" but the problem is that your smell will attract the attention of the authorities. 20% lubricant may not be sufficient in high pressure engines.

These options are no good. We must therefore turn our attentions to other oils which are not for road use (I looked at the legislation around importing road fuel from the middle east and it's ridiculous).

I am interested in discussing possibilities.

1. Importing oil from abroad. (whether cooking, fuel, insulating, etc).

2. Using insulating oil (forget the PCB nonsense, it isn't relevant in the UK)

3. Using medium fuel oil cut with Kerosene (Where can you buy medium oil?)



NB:- I was a PHer in 2002 and always regard PH as a source of genuine intellectual discussion, sound argument and quality reasoning. Please, if you want to comment on the above, can you keep the insults and irrelevancies to yourself.

Cheers, Elvis.

Fatboy

8,272 posts

303 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
I would have thought that your best bet would be contacting local small takeaways etc to see about buying their used cooking oil off them - can't see any better way of getting burnable oil for less than pump prices...

BarnatosGhost

34,596 posts

284 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
PH has changed an awful lot since 2002.

"But I don't want to go amongst mad people" said Alice to the Cat. "Oh you can't help that", said the Hatter, "We're all mad here."

How much does Bio-fuel cost to make for yourself? I used to run a Mercedes on SVO at 99p/litre. That's not a bad saving, but a 300D only does c35mpg, so compared to a 55mpg modern diesel, isn't any cheaper.

It is a toughie. I'd like someone to develop an electric motor transplant that can be put into an old car. I don't want a new car, and can't afford one anyway. But If I could buy for around, say, £2k, an electric motor and battery pack for, say, a w124 E Class, I'd be very keen indeed.

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
ElvisPenhaligon said:
Please, if you want to comment on the above, can you keep the insults and irrelevancies to yourself.
Are you actually try to avoid paying duty, and is that a relevant comment?

mrdelmonti

1,420 posts

212 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
At one point I was running my Discovery on a half and half mix of used engine oil and diesel, got the oil for free from a mechanic friend, saved me a shed load of money.

Tunku

7,703 posts

259 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
ElvisPenhaligon said:
Please, if you want to comment on the above, can you keep the insults and irrelevancies to yourself.
Are you actually try to avoid paying duty, and is that a relevant comment?
I believe there is no duty payable under a certain volume of DIY fuel per annum, although this tax avenue may have been closed since I went down it.

ElvisPenhaligon

Original Poster:

91 posts

176 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
Are you actually try to avoid paying duty, and is that a relevant comment?
I'm not really worried about the duty. If pulled, I would not like to be running dyed fuel, or something smelling of kerosene.

I and my business pay an awful amount of tax. Given the way the government hose the money around, I am not particulary worried about them not getting their duty.

HMRC test for that absorption of dyed fuel, both EIRE, EU and GB red.

Red is not an option, neither is "fking about" with used oil.

I would consider importing veg oil and processing it, given it is about 20p/L, however it is a 20ft container minimum and I haven't worked through the maths yet.

I am particularly interested in insulating oil and medium fuel oil.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
I would have thought old engine oil could be a real possibility.

But with all these techniques there is a poor return at best and a LOT of effort required.

Thus all the vegetable oils require significant chemical treatment and I doubt you could get this down to a cost of less than £1.00 odd per litre in your car, which is cheaper but there are risks of damage to the engine and so on, gumming risks and therefore probable additional repair costs.

I think you could save maybe 20 to 40p/litre if you really tried hard.

Is it worth it?

Depends on mileage, but a modern diesel giving 60++ to the gallon, might achieve the same saving with a lot less work.

I would not risk these scavenged oils etc in a new Diesel the risk of damage is too high.

I am sympathetic to every motorist in the current madness of UK fuel prices including myself. I run a 45+-50 mpg petrol daily driver nowadays instead of a Freelander, because I cover less than 6000 miles a year and the premium for deisels is too high for my use. Freelander struggled to beat 27mpg. Decent saving, but not the same class of car.

I see nothing wrong with your efforts. I do not recommend Red diesel except in appropriate use.

Have you thought of a Gas conversion? That could be worthwhile although one again, there are significant initial costs and warranty and repair downsides.

What about a secondhand car with a gas conversion? A Volvo or similar could give an effective 50+ mpg and they are a pretty robust unit.

Sorry I cannot be more positive.

The UK is no longer a reasonable fuel cost country. Nor will it be IMO in the future.

twazzock

1,930 posts

200 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
Veg oil should be closer to a quid a litre if you buy it at somewhere like Costco or Makro in 20l tubs. It's only diesel price when in small supermarket bottles from what I've seen. £1/l is far more expensive than it used to be but still represents a saving of nearly 50p/l.

Assuming 50mpg average on normal diesel at 146p/l, 50 miles would cost you £6.64

Even with a very pessimistic 10% economy knock (to 45mpg) for veg, at 100p/l, 50 miles would cost just over a fiver.

Extend that to 20k miles and the difference is nearly £600. Realistically I can imagine the difference in economy between SVO and derv to be smaller so possibly up to £700.

Is it really worth going to the effort of importing oil if filtering used oil is too much 'fking about' and you can already make a big saving with simple SVO?


GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
Are you actually try to avoid paying duty, and is that a relevant comment?
What a typical PH quote. Which duty, exactly?

GuitarTech

582 posts

181 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
Veg oil is cheap in bulk, but what diesels can actually use it without incurring damage? Does it work with PD and CR diesels, or just the old ones with a cam-timed distributor pump?

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
GC8 said:
TheEnd said:
Are you actually try to avoid paying duty, and is that a relevant comment?
What a typical PH quote. Which duty, exactly?
Jury Duty?


Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
GuitarTech said:
Veg oil is cheap in bulk, but what diesels can actually use it without incurring damage? Does it work with PD and CR diesels, or just the old ones with a cam-timed distributor pump?
Not without a real risk of trouble.

Various firms offer chemical treatment to eradicate the problems in this oil. whether that really solves these inherent problems in full, is a moot point. It certainly proves treatment is essential.

All the garage men I know, avoid such fuel, warn against the use and list the problems it will cause. When none of the trade touch it I think it is safe to suspect they will not all be wrong.

I doubt it is worth the risk and effort.

I would think buying a really efficient modern diesel is a far better bet.

Or switching to a Gas conversion vehicle.

I am afraid the days of reasonable cost fuel are lone gone in the UK. Never to return.

Happy days?


SirBlade

544 posts

223 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
GC8 said:
TheEnd said:
Are you actually try to avoid paying duty, and is that a relevant comment?
What a typical PH quote. Which duty, exactly?
Jury Duty?
You heard the OP's request.

GTFO.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
GuitarTech said:
Veg oil is cheap in bulk, but what diesels can actually use it without incurring damage? Does it work with PD and CR diesels, or just the old ones with a cam-timed distributor pump?
Any conventional diesel which uses a Bosch type pump, with a metal impeller. Citroen and Peugeot XUDs and old Mercedes diesels - anything with a plastic impeller wont last for long.

pingu393

11,216 posts

236 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
I'm a courier with a 1999 Escort van. I run it on vegetable oil.

WVO = Waste vegetable oil
SVO = Unused vegetable oil (Standard Vegetable Oil)

I use SVO (£18.45 for 20 litres from Costco). There is no VAT on the purchase price, but there is VAT liable on any duty. There is no duty to pay on the first 2500 litres used per tax year. If you use 2501 litres, you owe duty (& the VAT on that duty) at approx 56p per litre on all 2501 litres.

I keep accurate records of SVO purchased and SVO put in the van, and I keep myself down to approx 2400 litres per tax year. This should avoid any problems (I hope).

The van has a twin tank arrangement with an auxilliary tank for diesel. There is a heater coil around the SVO fuel filter and a heat exchanger. Both are required as the SVO should be at 70 deg C before going through the FIP.

The van starts on diesel and it takes about 4 miles for the engine to be warm enough to run on the SVO. There is no need to go back to running on diesel unless stopping for more than 20 minutes.

I drive it like a pussy and bimble around at approx 50-60mph and I get around 45-50mpg. The cost of the diesel and SVO combined is around £1.05 per litre.

The setup cost £250 and it took me two days to fit. Some serious wiring and plumbing was involved. But it was worth every penny and every scraped knuckle.

There are two downsides. One is having to pour SVO into the van at the side of the road rather than a petrol station. The other is not being able to use SVO at temperatures below approx 5 deg C ambient as it turns to gel.

Apparently, the gel problem can be lessened by adding some unleaded - but I haven't tried it.

There are videos on youtube showing how to refine WVO. The setup costs used to be worth it, but nobody gives away their old WVO now, so that's why I've not gone down that route.

HTH

Edited by pingu393 on Friday 23 March 19:18

bakerstreet

5,054 posts

196 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
Steffan said:
I
I run a 45+-50 mpg petrol daily driver nowadays instead of a Freelander, because I cover less than 6000 miles a year and the premium for deisels is too high for my use. Freelander struggled to beat 27mpg. Decent saving, but not the same class of car.
.
What are these magical 45-50mpg petrol cars that people on PH keep talking about??

jbi

12,700 posts

235 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
TheEnd said:
ElvisPenhaligon said:
Please, if you want to comment on the above, can you keep the insults and irrelevancies to yourself.
Are you actually try to avoid paying duty, and is that a relevant comment?
You are allowed to use up to 2000 litres of Waste oil/veg oil a year before you have to start paying tax.

That's quite a few miles.

redtwin

7,518 posts

213 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
Another option is adding LPG to a diesel. It won't run on 100% LPG, but the LPG supplements the diesel and is of course cheaper. The kits go for £450 + VAT, no clue how many miles you would need to cover the initial cost as the system usage is dependent on initial set up.

If I was doing the mileage to warrant it I would look at adding LPG to a twin tanked diesel/veg oil. Not sure where to source it, but if Costco can sell new veg oil for 92p per litre, there must be scope for more savings if buying in bulk.

GC8

19,910 posts

221 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
I wouldnt entertain any sort of LPG kit in a diesel; itll end in tears (and the car in the scrap yard).