Farmer destroys stranded car with fork-lift...
Discussion
.... and then bills its driver for £250
Christ!
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/4758008/...
Christ!
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/4758008/...
philmots said:
What an arse.
Serious question- how can the police not get involved?
Criminal damage in these circumstances is tricky: Farmer says "I needed to remove this car and that was the only means I could do it by" in order to protect, say, 100 head of sheep from death ("damage") on the road.Serious question- how can the police not get involved?
Criminal damage in order to prevent "greater" damage is specifically excluded in the legislation IIRC. Like, for instance, kicking someone's door in to solve an immediate plumbing emergency.
Clearly, the farmer's a t
t, but he's not going to be prosecuted. If he wanted to remove the car "arsily" I can't see why he didn't put the forks through the windows, probably wouldn't have written it off and would have put his "message" across...carreauchompeur said:
Criminal damage in these circumstances is tricky: Farmer says "I needed to remove this car and that was the only means I could do it by" in order to protect, say, 100 head of sheep from death ("damage") on the road.
Criminal damage in order to prevent "greater" damage is specifically excluded in the legislation IIRC. Like, for instance, kicking someone's door in to solve an immediate plumbing emergency.
Lawful excuse are the words you are looking for. The farmer would need to justify his actions. I think he would struggle with that amount of damage to the car.Criminal damage in order to prevent "greater" damage is specifically excluded in the legislation IIRC. Like, for instance, kicking someone's door in to solve an immediate plumbing emergency.
There is nothing in The Criminal Damage Act in relation to preventing "greater" damage.
The Act also covers recklessness. This looks like criminal damage to me.
Edited by Red 4 on Wednesday 23 January 00:56
Because the police serve no purppose at all apart from speeding tickets .
used to have a lot of respect for the police force as i could not do there jobs but this just reminds me yet again why police cuts are a good thing because they do not want to do there job .
i am yet to recive any good support from the police and they wonder why they get a bashing from everyone ffs police are here to uphold the law and to serve the public not pick and choose what jobs they accept .
i am sure the english teachers will be here shortly to tell me i can not spell just to justify the poor service yet again crack on.
feel sorry for the lad there called accidents for a reason and i hope the insurance companys take the farmer to the cleaners and the young lad mentions his disgust and someone goes around and has freindly word with said farmer but i think after this story and ear bashing the police force has got then they may be foreced to step upto the plate and do there jobs
farmer has clearly got issues what i find even more frustrating the farmer can not see any notes but he his more than happy there is no passengers in the car before sticking said forks through it , i doubt he even checked
used to have a lot of respect for the police force as i could not do there jobs but this just reminds me yet again why police cuts are a good thing because they do not want to do there job .
i am yet to recive any good support from the police and they wonder why they get a bashing from everyone ffs police are here to uphold the law and to serve the public not pick and choose what jobs they accept .
i am sure the english teachers will be here shortly to tell me i can not spell just to justify the poor service yet again crack on.
feel sorry for the lad there called accidents for a reason and i hope the insurance companys take the farmer to the cleaners and the young lad mentions his disgust and someone goes around and has freindly word with said farmer but i think after this story and ear bashing the police force has got then they may be foreced to step upto the plate and do there jobs
farmer has clearly got issues what i find even more frustrating the farmer can not see any notes but he his more than happy there is no passengers in the car before sticking said forks through it , i doubt he even checked
Edited by wizzbilly on Wednesday 23 January 01:07
ajb85 said:
I'd seriously go and kill all his sheep. Not a prayer would I let the farmer be getting away with that.
Yep. Turn up a night with some dogs....Make it clear that any "orf moy laand" shotogun toting nonsense may result in the sniper who brought the dogs gettng antsy!Or maybe just sue him.....Yeh, sue him. :-)
As already said, the problem with trying to charge criminal damage is the 'lawful excuse'. The farmer will simply say that his actions were necessary to prevent the escape of his sheep onto the road where they could be hit by other cars. And that other than the windows he didn't intend to cause that amount of damage.
"Criminal Damage Act 1971
Section 1. Destroying or damaging property.
(1)A person who without lawful excuse destroys or damages any property belonging to another intending to destroy or damage any such property or being reckless as to whether any such property would be destroyed or damaged shall be guilty of an offence."
The lawful excuse section:
"Section 5. (2)A person charged with an offence to which this section applies, shall, whether or not he would be treated for the purposes of this Act as having a lawful excuse apart from this subsection, be treated for those purposes as having a lawful excuse—
(b)if he destroyed or damaged or threatened to destroy or damage the property in question or, in the case of a charge of an offence under section 3 above, intended to use or cause or permit the use of something to destroy or damage it, in order to protect property belonging to himself or another or a right or interest in property which was or which he believed to be vested in himself or another, and at the time of the act or acts alleged to constitute the offence he believed—
(i)that the property, right or interest was in immediate need of protection; and
(ii)that the means of protection adopted or proposed to be adopted were or would be reasonable having regard to all the circumstances.
(3)For the purposes of this section it is immaterial whether a belief is justified or not if it is honestly held."
As far as we know there are no independent witnesses to the actions or any conversation between the two so impossible to know who actually said what.
Its the 'Farmer Palmer' defence to shooting your dog.
Personally I have little doubt that there could have been other ways for him to resolve the fence damage & what he did was entirely deliberate. Either because he was fed up with cars going into his fence & lost his temper or he is just a complete arse.
Would be thrown out of court.
"Criminal Damage Act 1971
Section 1. Destroying or damaging property.
(1)A person who without lawful excuse destroys or damages any property belonging to another intending to destroy or damage any such property or being reckless as to whether any such property would be destroyed or damaged shall be guilty of an offence."
The lawful excuse section:
"Section 5. (2)A person charged with an offence to which this section applies, shall, whether or not he would be treated for the purposes of this Act as having a lawful excuse apart from this subsection, be treated for those purposes as having a lawful excuse—
(b)if he destroyed or damaged or threatened to destroy or damage the property in question or, in the case of a charge of an offence under section 3 above, intended to use or cause or permit the use of something to destroy or damage it, in order to protect property belonging to himself or another or a right or interest in property which was or which he believed to be vested in himself or another, and at the time of the act or acts alleged to constitute the offence he believed—
(i)that the property, right or interest was in immediate need of protection; and
(ii)that the means of protection adopted or proposed to be adopted were or would be reasonable having regard to all the circumstances.
(3)For the purposes of this section it is immaterial whether a belief is justified or not if it is honestly held."
As far as we know there are no independent witnesses to the actions or any conversation between the two so impossible to know who actually said what.
Its the 'Farmer Palmer' defence to shooting your dog.
Personally I have little doubt that there could have been other ways for him to resolve the fence damage & what he did was entirely deliberate. Either because he was fed up with cars going into his fence & lost his temper or he is just a complete arse.
Would be thrown out of court.
Edited by paintman on Wednesday 23 January 08:55
philmots said:
What an arse.
Serious question- how can the police not get involved?
I'm sick of hearing about the police not wanting to get involved; I wish I could pick and choose which bit of my job I didn't fancy doing. Serious question- how can the police not get involved?
How Farmer Palmer has acted in any way reasonably is beyond me - a clearly malicious bit of criminal damage. Malice is the key here IMO.
And yet if I was to utter the hypothetical statement, for example, "I don't like Islam/black people/gays/the disabled" on Twitter they'd be banging my bloody doors down.
Ideally the owner should have remained with the car & done that himself. Which would hopefully have prevented all this.
But, as I said, you're dealing with a 'Farmer Palmer'.
ETA Fleckney isn't 'an isolated Leicestershire village' 'in the middle of nowhere'. That part at least is total b
ks.
But, as I said, you're dealing with a 'Farmer Palmer'.
ETA Fleckney isn't 'an isolated Leicestershire village' 'in the middle of nowhere'. That part at least is total b
ks.Edited by paintman on Wednesday 23 January 09:05
robmlufc said:
Scuffers said:
that's laughable...
tell you what, you try phoning the police and see what response you get...
Ah so that makes it ok.. I see. Does the farmer own the ditch? Its malicious damage, what a ttell you what, you try phoning the police and see what response you get...
t. Car comes off the road into a ditch/fence line of a field containing livestock.
guy abandons said car, goes home.
Farmer then has a problem, he is legally responsible to keep his stock out of harms way (like wandering around the road), so, he had to deal with the situation.
Car is already damaged from coming off the road, it;s dark, how else would you propose he moved it?
Yes, we can all be smart after the event, yes, he probably could have moved it a little more sympathetically, however, it's below freezing out there, it's dark, your pissed off at yet again being dragged out of your home to deal with yet another muppet's car, pretty easy to see his viewpoint.
Having had to retrieve cars from ditches/hedges before, no matter how careful you try to be, the cars are usually a right-off before you touch them, and being blunt, how damaged would it be if ABC recovery had just done their usual winch-job on it?
Yes, I am sure said farmer could have improved his communications skills, however, the end result makes no difference, car would still be bent, fence still needs to be fixed, etc etc.
Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


