Autoglass vs National Windscreens vs Other?
Discussion
Had a couple of chips on my windscreen for years, didn't think much to it, until one of the chips developed into a largeish spider pattern. Still holds up fine, although probably time to get it replaced.
I'm with Hastings and their preferred windscreen supplier is National Windscreens. For £75 excess, they will come out and replace. Or for £125, I can run around getting quotes, doing pictures and they will then consider letting me use somebody I choose.
I have never claimed for anything, this is my first time. So I quickly looked at National Windscreens and the reviews seem horrendous:
https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/nationalwindscree...
AutoGlass looks better:
https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.autoglass.co....
Just wondering if anyone has any experience?
Or is it essentially pot luck and the quality of the fitter and the job is down to whomever I get on the day?
They both seem to be the KwikFit of the glass world is I am not mistaken.
I'm with Hastings and their preferred windscreen supplier is National Windscreens. For £75 excess, they will come out and replace. Or for £125, I can run around getting quotes, doing pictures and they will then consider letting me use somebody I choose.
I have never claimed for anything, this is my first time. So I quickly looked at National Windscreens and the reviews seem horrendous:
https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/nationalwindscree...
AutoGlass looks better:
https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.autoglass.co....
Just wondering if anyone has any experience?
Or is it essentially pot luck and the quality of the fitter and the job is down to whomever I get on the day?
They both seem to be the KwikFit of the glass world is I am not mistaken.
Otispunkmeyer said:
out of interest...can someone like autoglass solve a leaky windscreen? Mines not got a chip in it or anything but the seal seems to have gone funny and it leaks on the A-pillar when it rains. I have to put a towel on the dashboard to stop it dripping into the HVAC system.
They can certainly do things to help, like taking the glass out and refitting with new seals. They will ask you to sign to say that you accept the risk that they may break the perfectly good screen when they remove it - the screens they normally remove are for scrap, remember - so be prepared for that.MikeyC said:
As suggested by others, probably pot luck
If you have automatic rain sensor for the wipers, make sure it works after they replace the screen ....
I had a new windscreen in my E class which has got all sorts of sensors and cameras mounted behind the mirror. Autoglass fitted it at their own place as it all needed calibrating afterwards. If you have automatic rain sensor for the wipers, make sure it works after they replace the screen ....
Incidentally - this always makes me chuckle as it's typical of these forums - there are always those that come on here whinging that they want their windscreen fitted by the main dealer, not some "cowboy" like [insert big name here]. Riiiiiiight, so you'd like your windscreen fitted by some bloke that does about three (if indeed any) a year, instead of by someone who does hundreds a year?

Dog Star said:
there are always those that come on here whinging that they want their windscreen fitted by the main dealer, not some "cowboy" like [insert big name here]. Riiiiiiight, so you'd like your windscreen fitted by some bloke that does about three (if indeed any) a year, instead of by someone who does hundreds a year? 
My understanding is that dealers do not employ windscreen fitters themselves, rather they will sub contract the work to whomever is local or cost effective. 
They're franchises as far as I'm aware, so I guess it is pot luck as to how they're managed.
I refer my clients to National Windscreens and have never had an issue. Mine end up mostly being dealt with by the branch round the corner from me, but I know one of my Motor Trade clients on the other side of Somerset uses a different branch and that seems to go well.
I refer my clients to National Windscreens and have never had an issue. Mine end up mostly being dealt with by the branch round the corner from me, but I know one of my Motor Trade clients on the other side of Somerset uses a different branch and that seems to go well.
PistonBroker said:
Mine end up mostly being dealt with by the branch round the corner from me
My nearest branch is Watford by the looks of it. I called them direct and they said if I was to do it off insurance, it would £165 fitted for a new front screen, although they did specifically say it was not OE. Should I insist they get an OE one in?
Autoglass took 4 attempts to do mine
1) Called to ask what features it had, I told them specifically it had the extra solar coating or whatever BMW call it, they then asked me about 10 other features which i said it didn't have. Was told it needed to be order, no problem I said..
2) Fitter arrives, takes out new screen, looks at old screen.. erm that's not got the special coating on, the only thing I said it had to have!
3) New screen ordered... Fitter arrives, correct screen but nobody ordered the seals...
4) booked into the centre as I'd given up, arrive to find they'd booked the car in but not allotted any time for the job so they were too busy!
Can't imagine short of setting the car on fire somehow that it could get much worse! Did get the full excess back at the first moment I asked!
1) Called to ask what features it had, I told them specifically it had the extra solar coating or whatever BMW call it, they then asked me about 10 other features which i said it didn't have. Was told it needed to be order, no problem I said..
2) Fitter arrives, takes out new screen, looks at old screen.. erm that's not got the special coating on, the only thing I said it had to have!
3) New screen ordered... Fitter arrives, correct screen but nobody ordered the seals...
4) booked into the centre as I'd given up, arrive to find they'd booked the car in but not allotted any time for the job so they were too busy!
Can't imagine short of setting the car on fire somehow that it could get much worse! Did get the full excess back at the first moment I asked!
To redress the balance slightly..
A few years back needed a new screen on an Omega. National Windcsreens were my insurers contractor so arranged for them to come out. He removed the old screen and put the new screen in only to discover he’d packed a fitting kit (all the plastic gubbins around the edge) for a vectra. He bodged it with some gaffa tape and said the office would call me to arrange someone to come out and finish the job. 48 hours later nothing. Several chats with a call centre later, nothing. Ended up moaning on Twitter and it eventually got fixed 8 days after they did the initial job.
Last week needed a new screen on my X Trail. I’ve changed my insurers so this was put out to Autoglass. It has all the cameras and sensors etc in the screen so had to drop it at their centre.
The car was done in a few hours and as I work about 2 miles from the fitting centre they offered to run it back to me! Flawless job and great customer service.
Just my two penneth.
A few years back needed a new screen on an Omega. National Windcsreens were my insurers contractor so arranged for them to come out. He removed the old screen and put the new screen in only to discover he’d packed a fitting kit (all the plastic gubbins around the edge) for a vectra. He bodged it with some gaffa tape and said the office would call me to arrange someone to come out and finish the job. 48 hours later nothing. Several chats with a call centre later, nothing. Ended up moaning on Twitter and it eventually got fixed 8 days after they did the initial job.
Last week needed a new screen on my X Trail. I’ve changed my insurers so this was put out to Autoglass. It has all the cameras and sensors etc in the screen so had to drop it at their centre.
The car was done in a few hours and as I work about 2 miles from the fitting centre they offered to run it back to me! Flawless job and great customer service.
Just my two penneth.
Wooda80 said:
Otispunkmeyer said:
out of interest...can someone like autoglass solve a leaky windscreen? Mines not got a chip in it or anything but the seal seems to have gone funny and it leaks on the A-pillar when it rains. I have to put a towel on the dashboard to stop it dripping into the HVAC system.
They can certainly do things to help, like taking the glass out and refitting with new seals. They will ask you to sign to say that you accept the risk that they may break the perfectly good screen when they remove it - the screens they normally remove are for scrap, remember - so be prepared for that.PistonBroker said:
They're franchises as far as I'm aware, so I guess it is pot luck as to how they're managed.
Autoglass, parent company Belron, is not franchised. On the other hand...PistonBroker said:
[I refer my clients to National Windscreens.../
...all owned and operated by independent firms under one banner, similar to a franchised network. I had the screen replaced on my Panamera by Autoglass, again with all of the sensors that needed recalibrating so it went to one of their workshops.
Guy was friendly, they did the job in just over an hour (which was excellent news because it meant I only had to spend an hour in the centre of Northampton), everything still worked, it was visibly imperceptible that he'd done the job (i.e. he didn't break or scratch anything), and it didn't leak.
If I was being fussy I'd say their call centres were a bit tedious but nothing compared to the hilarity of dealing with Sky/BT/etc
Guy was friendly, they did the job in just over an hour (which was excellent news because it meant I only had to spend an hour in the centre of Northampton), everything still worked, it was visibly imperceptible that he'd done the job (i.e. he didn't break or scratch anything), and it didn't leak.
If I was being fussy I'd say their call centres were a bit tedious but nothing compared to the hilarity of dealing with Sky/BT/etc
Glassman said:
k33f3y said:
Glassman said:
Windscreens don't break on removal; careless/inexperienced fitters do.
Crazy comment , multiple factors come into play while removing automotive glass, to spout utter rubbish like this isn’t helping anyone ??Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




