So how old is your 'new' pre-reg car?
So how old is your 'new' pre-reg car?
Author
Discussion

alsio

Original Poster:

29 posts

111 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Seeking the expert opinion of my fellow PHers on a car I purchased a year ago in 2019.

Due to an unforeseen health issue, I decided the time was right to blow some money on a ‘fun’ car.

I had been looking for an approved Porsche 718 Boxster S across the OPC network for a few months and was considering a number of cars. A new contender popped up from an Autotrader alert which was a good fit for the spec I was looking for so contacted the OPC dealer the same day. I was told it was a pre-registered car that had been registered just 2 weeks earlier in mid August 2019 (apparently for emission reasons). The car had delivery miles on it (30 miles only) and came with a 3 year warranty. In the photos/sales video I was sent it looked good - it didn’t even have number plates on it. So to all intents and purposes this car presented as brand new. A deal was done early September and I am very happy with the car.
 
Fast forward one year to now, and I was prompted by the the car to arrange a service for it. I was concerned by this as I knew that the maintenance schedule was every 2 years/20,000 miles (whichever comes first) - I had driven 4,000 miles. I presumed that this was just a set-up glitch so contacted the salesman to discuss it further. I was told that this was ‘usual and it just needed an oil service and to book it in’. I then contacted my local OPC to arrange this and during the discussion with the service advisor it became apparent that the service was due because, in fact, 2 years had passed from when the car first went through their PDI process (in Oct 2018). 
 
So the car is a 2018 model, not a 2019 as thought and had been sitting somewhere within their dealer network for over 10 months before I purchased my ’new’ car (probably outdoors, not ideal for a convertible). This has a causes a couple of ramifications, primarily the retained value of the car is negatively impacted and secondly, the maintenance schedule is all out of sync.

If I had been furnished with this information at the time of purchase I would certainly have negotiated harder and a deal may, or may not, have been done.

Now I accept, as the buyer, I should have clearly asked this question but I was excited about finding the right car and it didn’t even occur to me that it was not as new as I had presumed (I was thinking a couple of months max).
 
As such, I believe that the car was mis-sold to me and the OPC certainly did not act in good faith either at the point of sale or the subsequent enquiry as to why the car suddenly need a service one year early.

I contacted Porsche UK who ‘recognised my concerns with the true value of the car’ but advised that the problem had to resolved with the OPC. Following a number of conversations with their Sales Manager, they agreed to pay for the first service, but they did not believe that they had done anything untoward or not acted in good faith at any point.

So the service issue is resolved, which leaves the retained value of the car. Given that it was a year older than I thought it was when I purchased it, I think that the car was overpriced by £3k to £4k.

If you’ve made it this far - thanks! Do I have any redress, is it worth pursuing or should I just suck it up, buttercup?

Has anybody else had a similar experience or advice?

Many thanks

Chicken Chaser

9,131 posts

255 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Is it a 19 plate? If so, I can't see when the PDI inspection would matter. What was the cost of the service?

jjr1

3,042 posts

291 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Suck it up buttercup.

The car is not worth less as it goes on date of registration, so don't worry about it

The servicing thing is a kick in the bks though. I had to do a 4 year service on my BMW i8 last year at 3 years old for exactly the same reason. Kick up a stink and see if you can get anything to compensate for that.

As for you and me, we are now wiser and won't fall for that trick again.....

Scrump

23,948 posts

189 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
You got a discount because it was pre reg. Many new cars sit around in fields for a long time before first reg and the buyers of these don’t get a pre reg discount.

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Yeah I wouldn't say that was unreasonable at all. I think you've done very well to get them to cover the cost of the service.

Muddle238

4,421 posts

144 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
I think it’s a case of sucking it up. I believe cars can sit up to three years unregistered, before getting whatever current reg plate is being circulated by DVLA. For example, a 2018 car could be sat in a dealership for two years, before being registered, given a 20 plate and everything thinks it’s a 2020 model.

My 04 plate car was actually physically built in August 2003, it’s more common than you think. However as far as the general public and DVLA are concerned, the vehicle is as old as the registration plate says it is. If it’s a 19 plate, then as far as everyone is concerned it’s the same value as a car built and registered in 2019, even if it was physically made in 2018.

andygo

7,422 posts

286 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
I bought a pre reg Golf 7.5R in August 2017.

V5 said reg April 2017 so was 6 months old with just a few miles on it. It cant have been standing round for that long before registration as they had only been released shortly before that.

I saved about £6k from normal price and paid just under £28k.

I sold it in October this year with 34k miles on,the car was 31/2 years old. I got £22k for it. Very little depreciation (£6k in 3 years) and the fact it was a pre reg made little difference.

My advice to the OP is when it comes to sell the car, maybe don't make a big deal of the fact it was built some time before being registered, nobody will care, least of all the garage you sell it to!

kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
As far as I know, cars can sit for an indefinite amount of time before being registered. It's not unheard of for classics to be discovered unregistered then put on a new plate 40+ years after they were built.

Ari

19,837 posts

246 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
alsio said:
has a causes a couple of ramifications, primarily the retained value of the car is negatively impacted and secondly, the maintenance schedule is all out of sync.
I can't see that it's negatively valued, when you see the year of a car on Autotrader or whatever, it's always the year of registration, and that hasn't changed.

Maintenance schedule is now 'in sync', and in fact you've gained a year because the first service you have to pay for is 3 years after purchase.

Happy days.

MuscleSedan

1,614 posts

206 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
The build date is easily accessed via the VIN should it have been a concern at the time of purchase.

Besides the dealer saying the car was registered 2 weeks prior to you making an enquiry, did they make any representations as to when it was built ?

Agree the service coming up so soon is a bit off but if they have offered to help with that then fair enough.

Red 4

10,744 posts

218 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Any changes to the spec of a 2018 car compared to a 2019 car ? Anything at all ? Can you tell them apart ?

If not, then I don't see how the value is affected based on a build date as opposed to date of first registration.

Sheepshanks

41,378 posts

150 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
alsio said:
So the car is a 2018 model, not a 2019 as thought
Do you mean year based on date of manufacture, or model year?

If model year, is there any difference between 2018 and 19 cars?


The service thing was discussed here recently for another marque. It seems a bit random as some dealers reset the car at PDI and some manufacturers systems don't start counting down until the car has done a certain mileage. But certainly some people in the trade who post on her thought there was nothing unusual in the car demanding an early service.

alsio

Original Poster:

29 posts

111 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies so far - kind of what I was expecting. The car is on a 19 plate & I think the service would have probably been c£700 if I had to pay for it.

I obviously accept that I got a discounted price, but there were other cars I was considering for a similar price that were genuine 2019 cars, not one manufactured in 2018 as mine is.

I would have negotiated harder...had I been wiser and asked the $64,000 question rolleyes. Live and learn...


kambites

71,713 posts

252 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
alsio said:
I obviously accept that I got a discounted price, but there were other cars I was considering for a similar price that were genuine 2019 cars, not one manufactured in 2018 as mine is.
Out of interest, how do you know that? A great many cars first registered in 2019 will have been manufactured in 2018, irrespective of whether they were pre-reg or not. In fact I wouldn't be surprised if the majority of cars first registered in 2019 were actually manufactured in 2018, if not it will certainly be a very significant minority?

Certainly my car is the 04 model year and was registered (no pre-reg) in 2004 but was built in 2003.

832ark

1,247 posts

187 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
My wife bought one of the last pre-lci MINI Countryman JCWs (way more fun than it has any right to be!) that were lying around. Brand new on a 70 plate but I believe it was built around January. Whether this means its first service will come early I’m not sure.

Fastdruid

9,415 posts

183 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
kambites said:
Certainly my car is the 04 model year and was registered (no pre-reg) in 2004 but was built in 2003.
Equally you can have it the other way round, we used to have an 06 MY...which was both built and registered in 05.

Any difference in spec or "fixes" that were made to newer model years would be the main thing that would concern me. Particularly with Porsches less than steller reputation for reliability, I would want the very latest version!

Trevor555

5,565 posts

115 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
I look at the date stamp on the tyres.

It's a four digit number.

ie 2616

That would mean week 26 in 2016

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
Personally I would sue them. Accept no less than 50% of the purchase value in Porsche branded aftershave for all the hurt and suffering they have caused. And no doubt lots of mental anguish which has taken its toll on you, your family and your cat.

alsio

Original Poster:

29 posts

111 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
So perhaps the broader question here is there not a trading standard/sales act/acting in good faith obligation for the salesperson to disclose how long your new car had been sitting in said field (should you be foolish enough not to ask)?

The main thing that wound me up about this is that the salesman straight faced lied when asked why my car seemingly needed a service a year earlier than expected. I'm pretty sure that they know the maintenance schedules for their products...

Thanks Trevor555 for the tip about the tyre date stamp - they are 2718.

Mikebentley

8,715 posts

171 months

Thursday 29th October 2020
quotequote all
I got a 2002 “02”pre reg MINI new that suffered loads of issues with external trim constantly falling off. At about a a year old I took it in for a service and when they put the key it into the reader on the service desk the guy pulled an odd face. It told him the car was nearly 3 years old.
It turned out it was a factory car used for training assembly staff putting trim on the cars during production.

To be fair MINI prices were so good then they gave me what I paid for it 18 months after I purchased it.