Main Dealer Failed to Rectify Warranty Issue Three Times
Discussion
Main dealer has had my [2019] vehicle in three times for an engine noise issue. They've 'done the work' yet the noise is still there. I've now escalated the issue to the UK HO but it hasn't helped. Furthermore, the retailer has messed about with the service regime of the vehicle to justify an extra/needless oil change (and also charged me two different prices for the same thing).
Issue: squeaking noise from engine on startup. A Master Tech I know says it's known as 'budgie squeak' in the trade. It is only audible on startup when the engine is cold. Once the engine reaches a warmer temperature the noise stops (usually about 5-10 minutes) but it is loud; a real 'belt' noise chirping constantly. My tech mate suggests a clutch pack for the alternator will solve the issue.
I took the van in to my chosen retailer after discussing the issue with them. They wanted the van in the night before so that they could 'replicate' the sound. It's the van I use for work everyday so I coincided this 'inspection' with an 'Oil Change Due' flagged by the van's CPU (the van's first since buying it new). This was at 12k miles. The next day I collected the van and they said the oil change had been done and cited a faulty belt to be the cause of the squeak. Belt changed under warranty. Problem solved? Nope. The next morning, the squeak was still there. I recorded the noise on my phone (video, so they could see it was the same vehicle) and sent it to the Service Advisor's mobile (which was given to me because it was so difficult to connect calls via their centralised switchboard) via WhatsApp.
A second visit was arranged, again, dropped the van off the night before and the advisor told me that they would order in "all the parts" to get this issue resolved. The following day I collected the van and was told the pre-tensioner had been replaced (under warranty). The morning after, I started the van and there it was. The noise was still there. I recorded the noise again and sent it in to the service advisor via WhatsApp. Two blue ticks confirmed the video had been viewed and I was invited to take the van in for a third time. I explained that I use the van daily for work and that each visit isn't just a few hours; it's the 'day before' and the day it's worked on. I was offered a loan van but declined on the basis that my van is racked out to carry windscreens and my toolbox is fixed into the cargo area. In any case, I just want the issue resolved. No demands for loan vehicles or cups of coffee, I just wanted the issue resolved once and for all. I had a busy period of work ahead and I said I would be in touch to book the van back in.
An 'Inspection Due' warning came up on the dash. There were a few miles left to get to this interval (approaching 20k) and I booked the van in 200 miles short of that setting (the night before again so they could hear the noise despite the service advisor having a video file of it). On the day of the inspection, I called in the afternoon for an update. They hadn't done anything but was assured my van was next. At about 4pm I was told the van is almost ready but there were two technicians on it 'waiting for the noise to be replicated'. It turned out they had had carried out an oil change and to my bemusement, taken the van on a road test before investigating the noise. FAIL!
The service advisor said the techs couldn't diagnose a fault as there was no noise audible. No surprise there, given they'd taken the van for a spin before investigating! I reluctantly went to collect the van and was presented with a bill for the 'service'. I paid it. As I entered my PIN I asked what had been done on the service and was told, "an oil change". Just an oil change. Hang about, you did that 8k miles ago and charged me ~80-quid less for the pleasure. "It's the quality of the oil," she said. "Sometimes it needs changing sooner". What, the oil YOU changed? That oil? I looked at the invoice and noticed that the next oil change was due at 40k miles, so this oil was good for 20k miles, so why was the oil they replace only good for 8k? It later transpired that the retailer altered the service regime to cover this up. In short, the oil they dumped out of the van was still good for 12k miles. Meanwhile, I had the morning to look forward to hoping the resident budgie had migrated.
It was still there.
As before, I videoed my van making the noise and sent the file in to the service advisor. The blue ticks confirmed that the video had been viewed. I followed this (a couple of hours later) with a phone-call. No answer. I tried again 30 minutes later; again, no answer. I tried four times in total (twice the next day) and my call was not answered. I put it down to them being busy and tried again after leaving it a full 24 hours. Nothing.
I took the issue to the UK head office for the van manufacturer thinking - hoping - backsides would be kicked into action. On the 27th of October, and after three lengthy conversations over the matter, the Customer Relations Manager said the 'retailer' had booked the van in for an inspection on 4th December, and would need the van for two days, which - given the 4th is a Friday, meant I would potentially be losing the van until the following Monday! This was giving me the distinct impression that the retailer was pushing me away. The Customer Relations Manager suggested I take the van to another retailer which has now left me asking what effing use has [Brand Manufacturer] UK been in this episode! I'm back to square one.
Meanwhile, the parent company of the retailer isn't responding either (I'd like to talk to them too). It seems Coronavirus has hit them very bad as their 'Contact Us people' cannot seem to function while there is a pandemic.
I'm now considering taking the issue to the CEO of the van manufacturer and start some noise of my own on social media. My aim in sharing it here is to seek advice for which I will gratefully receive and thank you in advance for.
Cue the bird puns.
Issue: squeaking noise from engine on startup. A Master Tech I know says it's known as 'budgie squeak' in the trade. It is only audible on startup when the engine is cold. Once the engine reaches a warmer temperature the noise stops (usually about 5-10 minutes) but it is loud; a real 'belt' noise chirping constantly. My tech mate suggests a clutch pack for the alternator will solve the issue.
I took the van in to my chosen retailer after discussing the issue with them. They wanted the van in the night before so that they could 'replicate' the sound. It's the van I use for work everyday so I coincided this 'inspection' with an 'Oil Change Due' flagged by the van's CPU (the van's first since buying it new). This was at 12k miles. The next day I collected the van and they said the oil change had been done and cited a faulty belt to be the cause of the squeak. Belt changed under warranty. Problem solved? Nope. The next morning, the squeak was still there. I recorded the noise on my phone (video, so they could see it was the same vehicle) and sent it to the Service Advisor's mobile (which was given to me because it was so difficult to connect calls via their centralised switchboard) via WhatsApp.
A second visit was arranged, again, dropped the van off the night before and the advisor told me that they would order in "all the parts" to get this issue resolved. The following day I collected the van and was told the pre-tensioner had been replaced (under warranty). The morning after, I started the van and there it was. The noise was still there. I recorded the noise again and sent it in to the service advisor via WhatsApp. Two blue ticks confirmed the video had been viewed and I was invited to take the van in for a third time. I explained that I use the van daily for work and that each visit isn't just a few hours; it's the 'day before' and the day it's worked on. I was offered a loan van but declined on the basis that my van is racked out to carry windscreens and my toolbox is fixed into the cargo area. In any case, I just want the issue resolved. No demands for loan vehicles or cups of coffee, I just wanted the issue resolved once and for all. I had a busy period of work ahead and I said I would be in touch to book the van back in.
An 'Inspection Due' warning came up on the dash. There were a few miles left to get to this interval (approaching 20k) and I booked the van in 200 miles short of that setting (the night before again so they could hear the noise despite the service advisor having a video file of it). On the day of the inspection, I called in the afternoon for an update. They hadn't done anything but was assured my van was next. At about 4pm I was told the van is almost ready but there were two technicians on it 'waiting for the noise to be replicated'. It turned out they had had carried out an oil change and to my bemusement, taken the van on a road test before investigating the noise. FAIL!
The service advisor said the techs couldn't diagnose a fault as there was no noise audible. No surprise there, given they'd taken the van for a spin before investigating! I reluctantly went to collect the van and was presented with a bill for the 'service'. I paid it. As I entered my PIN I asked what had been done on the service and was told, "an oil change". Just an oil change. Hang about, you did that 8k miles ago and charged me ~80-quid less for the pleasure. "It's the quality of the oil," she said. "Sometimes it needs changing sooner". What, the oil YOU changed? That oil? I looked at the invoice and noticed that the next oil change was due at 40k miles, so this oil was good for 20k miles, so why was the oil they replace only good for 8k? It later transpired that the retailer altered the service regime to cover this up. In short, the oil they dumped out of the van was still good for 12k miles. Meanwhile, I had the morning to look forward to hoping the resident budgie had migrated.
It was still there.
As before, I videoed my van making the noise and sent the file in to the service advisor. The blue ticks confirmed that the video had been viewed. I followed this (a couple of hours later) with a phone-call. No answer. I tried again 30 minutes later; again, no answer. I tried four times in total (twice the next day) and my call was not answered. I put it down to them being busy and tried again after leaving it a full 24 hours. Nothing.
I took the issue to the UK head office for the van manufacturer thinking - hoping - backsides would be kicked into action. On the 27th of October, and after three lengthy conversations over the matter, the Customer Relations Manager said the 'retailer' had booked the van in for an inspection on 4th December, and would need the van for two days, which - given the 4th is a Friday, meant I would potentially be losing the van until the following Monday! This was giving me the distinct impression that the retailer was pushing me away. The Customer Relations Manager suggested I take the van to another retailer which has now left me asking what effing use has [Brand Manufacturer] UK been in this episode! I'm back to square one.
Meanwhile, the parent company of the retailer isn't responding either (I'd like to talk to them too). It seems Coronavirus has hit them very bad as their 'Contact Us people' cannot seem to function while there is a pandemic.
I'm now considering taking the issue to the CEO of the van manufacturer and start some noise of my own on social media. My aim in sharing it here is to seek advice for which I will gratefully receive and thank you in advance for.
Cue the bird puns.
Edited by Glassman on Friday 6th November 09:12
Edited by Glassman on Friday 6th November 09:13
Belt squeak is pretty easy to diagnose and fix, there are loads of videos on YouTube.
Not suggesting you should do this yourself as it's a vehicle under warranty and you're entitled to get it fixed, but just wondering why a professional tech would struggle at this?
I've had it three times in 30yrs as a DIY-er and fixed it pretty easily myself.
Not suggesting you should do this yourself as it's a vehicle under warranty and you're entitled to get it fixed, but just wondering why a professional tech would struggle at this?
I've had it three times in 30yrs as a DIY-er and fixed it pretty easily myself.
PurpleTurtle said:
Belt squeak is pretty easy to diagnose and fix, there are loads of videos on YouTube.
Not suggesting you should do this yourself as it's a vehicle under warranty and you're entitled to get it fixed, but just wondering why a professional tech would struggle at this?
I've had it three times in 30yrs as a DIY-er and fixed it pretty easily myself.
They have to follow a procedure. I've since done more research and have acquired a TPI for the same issue on a car engine. All the characteristics match. There's even a sound file which sounds exactly like the problem I have. Not suggesting you should do this yourself as it's a vehicle under warranty and you're entitled to get it fixed, but just wondering why a professional tech would struggle at this?
I've had it three times in 30yrs as a DIY-er and fixed it pretty easily myself.
My point is, I'm now at that stage where I need the problem sorted without the messing about. The UK HO people need to put someone on this and given how I've lost the van for over four days (and all the cab fares to make it happen) and own the problem. I'm not happy they're telling me to just try another retailer (who might be just as useless as the other) because the one that tried three times is palming me off now.
Pupbelly said:
Try a different dealer - the difference in approach to situations is staggering I have found.
Yes, I saw that when buying too. Three dealers local to me didn't seem too interested in selling me a van when I contacted them. In the end I went with a recommendation for a (franchised) van centre in Birmingham who were excellent. The van (this van) was delivered to my house. Couldn't fault the service. Glassman said:
Pupbelly said:
Try a different dealer - the difference in approach to situations is staggering I have found.
Yes, I saw that when buying too. Three dealers local to me didn't seem too interested in selling me a van when I contacted them. In the end I went with a recommendation for a (franchised) van centre in Birmingham who were excellent. The van (this van) was delivered to my house. Couldn't fault the service. Pupbelly said:
Certainly worth a call to a couple of local dealers and see if you get a sensible response, the downside is potentially the additional travelling but one of them may offer a courtesy vehicle. Found this with a local Toyota dealer, nearest one is utterly useless and is not interested unless they are selling or upselling something. Drive 10 miles to another and it was night and day between the two, the other dealer was informative, sensible and did what they were meant to without any issues, needless to say they were then used for future service work etc.
Thanks. I've now got a response from the UK arm of the business on Twitter. I feel the onus is on them now to restore my love for the brand and rebuild the relationship. Due to work commitments and nobody local prepared to tackle the issue, I couldn't do anything for a while; was stuck with the problem. I finally got put in touch with Marshall VW Van Centre in Reading who were excellent. They dealt with the problem diligently and efficiently.
After careful consideration, I decided that wiping my mouth and moving on would be ignoring the fact that it cost me considerably to get this issue resolved, so I got back in touch with VW UK and escalated the matter.
They've basically told me that because I didn't take the van back to the original dealer (you know, the one that failed to fix the problem on three occasions and gratuitously changed the oil without authority) I don't have a leg to stand on and therefore it's an open and shut case.
The lack of care from VW Commercials UK is astonishing. They simply don't give a flying proverbial.
After careful consideration, I decided that wiping my mouth and moving on would be ignoring the fact that it cost me considerably to get this issue resolved, so I got back in touch with VW UK and escalated the matter.
They've basically told me that because I didn't take the van back to the original dealer (you know, the one that failed to fix the problem on three occasions and gratuitously changed the oil without authority) I don't have a leg to stand on and therefore it's an open and shut case.
The lack of care from VW Commercials UK is astonishing. They simply don't give a flying proverbial.
Glassman said:
The Customer Relations Manager suggested I take the van to another retailer which has now left me asking what effing use has [Brand Manufacturer] UK been in this episode! I'm back to square one.
As above post, it's now been proved the original dealer was incompetent????And this manager suggested you try another dealership?
Have you suffered any losses?
If so, letter asking to be reimbursed, give them 14 days to pay, then money claim online.
Glassman said:
The lack of care from VW Commercials UK is astonishing. They simply don't give a flying proverbial.
If it’s the same as cars, you’re not dealing with VW UK - they (all the VAG marques) contract customer care out to a third party call centre whose entire purpose is to fob you off.VW have notoriously bad service. My VW Golf had a budgie squeal too and the main dealer kept denying the problem existed whilst the car was still under its 3 year warranty. Apparently according to the service advisor, he elevated it to VW UK and apparently Wolfsburg as well, but kept repeating the line that there wasn’t an issue there to fix. I felt that in their perspective, this was a normal part of ageing for some cars.
It only went away fully when it went in for its 5 year, 60k miles cambelt and water pump change. I understand the pulleys, tensioner are changed as part of this, and I got the accessory belt changed on top for good measure. That silenced the budgie squeal completely.
In fairness to them, if there was a fault code, they did replace and fix items without fuss. But grey areas like budgie squeals, that don’t affect the functioning of the car, and don’t produce codes, they would decline to fix.
It only went away fully when it went in for its 5 year, 60k miles cambelt and water pump change. I understand the pulleys, tensioner are changed as part of this, and I got the accessory belt changed on top for good measure. That silenced the budgie squeal completely.
In fairness to them, if there was a fault code, they did replace and fix items without fuss. But grey areas like budgie squeals, that don’t affect the functioning of the car, and don’t produce codes, they would decline to fix.
Edited by anonymous-user on Saturday 22 January 09:33
Miserablegit said:
What was VWs argument wrt the relevance of not taking it back to the idiots who couldn’t/wouldn’t fix it before?
Surely the fact it has now been fixed by a third party shows the incompetence of the original dealer?
I stated that taking it back to the original dealer was no longer an option on the basis that, Surely the fact it has now been fixed by a third party shows the incompetence of the original dealer?
a) they took three attempts to fix a squeaky belt and didn't refer to the TPI (changed auxiliary belt, tensioner when the TPI - as well as every else in the VAG - states it's the cambelt that needs attention) and I was left without my van for two/three days at a time on the three attempts they made (unsuccessfully) to fix the issue;
b) whilst in for one of those 'investigations' they took it upon themselves to change the engine oil - without my permission - despite the oil having been changed - BY THEM - 8k miles previously (and then subsequently altered the service regime in an attempt to cover up their mistake).
c) given that the ONLY thing left to do was the ORIGINAL fix as stated in the TPI so leaving the van with them for ANOTHER four days was not only even more inconvenience for me but nonsensical.
Ultimately, it was a trust issue and the original service centre had demonstrated utter incompetence in dealing with the problem.
I submitted a 12-page report highlighting each event which lasted for up to 16 months in the end when you allow for Covid restrictions and my work commitments. The costs of travel, loss of opportunity, hire vehicle, taxi fares etc wasn't just a few quid. The consequential loss I have suffered as a direct result of their authorised garage has left me massively out of pocket. If it was the one occasion and a few quid I would kick it into touch but it's much more that that and on principle, someone needs to reflect that I have been f
ked about over this (even if it was a grovelling apology). Here's the response to my complaint, which has to be said was aimed at director level because I stipulated that I no longer wanted to go via the Executive Office as they were now part of the complaint. They still channeled it via them...Executive Office Manager said:
Thank you for your contact with Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles UK.
I have now had the time to review your previous case. Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles UK repeatedly requested that the vehicle was to be diagnosed over a three day period. This was so the vehicle could be tested from a cold start as from previous visits to the Van Centre, the noise could not be heard. As you refused this proposal on more than one occasion, ultimately your case could not be resolved and was closed with the advice being given to escalate to the Motor Ombudsman.
After reviewing both sides of the story the Motor Ombudsman did not uphold your complaint with a decision being delivered in May 2021.
In addition, Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles UK do not provide compensation or loss of use.
As you have received a final decision from both the Executive Office and the Motor Ombudsman I would advise to seek independent advice regarding the matter if you wish to bring a claim to us.
As I explained previously, there is no further escalation available to you in Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles UK and this decision will be the final one in the matter.
Thank you for your contact and for allowing me the opportunity to respond.
The 'noise could not be heard' bit is utter bI have now had the time to review your previous case. Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles UK repeatedly requested that the vehicle was to be diagnosed over a three day period. This was so the vehicle could be tested from a cold start as from previous visits to the Van Centre, the noise could not be heard. As you refused this proposal on more than one occasion, ultimately your case could not be resolved and was closed with the advice being given to escalate to the Motor Ombudsman.
After reviewing both sides of the story the Motor Ombudsman did not uphold your complaint with a decision being delivered in May 2021.
In addition, Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles UK do not provide compensation or loss of use.
As you have received a final decision from both the Executive Office and the Motor Ombudsman I would advise to seek independent advice regarding the matter if you wish to bring a claim to us.
As I explained previously, there is no further escalation available to you in Volkswagen Commercial Vehicles UK and this decision will be the final one in the matter.
Thank you for your contact and for allowing me the opportunity to respond.
ks because on the final 'inspection', when they gratuitously changed the engine oil, they'd taken the van for a road test, ergo, the engine was warm. I cannot tell you how infuriating that was given that I'd dropped the van off to them (again) a day before they appointment so that they could replicate the noise on cold start.Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



Fingers crossed Sir.