RE: Triumph Stag | The Brave Pill
RE: Triumph Stag | The Brave Pill
Saturday 27th February 2021

Triumph Stag | The Brave Pill

The true origin of "sixty per cent of the time, it works every time?"



After last week’s excursion into the future with a Tesla Model S - a choice which set a new record for number of comments - Pill is heading back to the reassuring familiarity of a V8 engine and questionable reliability. Plus, as you’ll notice, legitimate use of silver on black numberplates.

The Tesla came from Pill’s future, but this 1972 Triumph Stag is definitely the Spirit of Pill Past. It’s our oldest offering since the V8 engined E-Type that ran last July, and – like the Frankenjag – one that puts ticks next to the boxes for classicality, value and, most importantly, mechanical risk.

It seems unlikely that the story of British Leyland will ever be turned into a television drama, but the saga has the ingredients to support multiple seasons. Like ‘The Crown’ there are numerous dramatic hooks that individual episodes could be built around – the strange decision to hold the dealer launch for the all-important Austin Metro with a cruise to the Isle of Man over a storm-wracked Irish Sea could make a memorable one. But the overall narrative arc would undoubtedly be of things going steadily downhill, and of defeats being snatched from the jaws of victory.


One of the greatest of these near misses is the story of the Triumph Stag. This stylish open-topped four-seater should have had the world at its feet when it launched in 1970 – a handsome, affordable, V8-powered GT. Yet it died just seven years later having acquired a reputation for mechanical maladies that stood out even by the low standards of the era, and being widely adjudged to be an abject failure. A true case of tragedy over Triumph.

Like many interesting cars, the Stag began as an unofficial project. Italian designer Giovanni Michelotti had been styling Triumphs since the 1950s, between working for his homeland’s poshest coachbuilders. In 1964 he asked Triumph if they would give him an example of the freshly launched 2000 saloon he could turn into a one-off motorshow concept to demonstrate his talents. Triumph boss Harry Webster agreed, but demanded first refusal on whatever Michelotti came up with.

His vision turned out to be a stylish convertible sitting on a shorter wheelbase and with a new front end that sat quad headlamps within an extended radiator grille. It looked great, and as affordable four-seat drop-tops were rare at the time Triumph immediately exercised its right to take it on, thereby denying its designer the chance to show it publicly, with development work starting in 1966.


The leisurely pace at which the motor industry worked in those days meant it took another four years to bring it to market, and some fairly major changes. The most obvious of these was the fitment of an integral T-bar that connected the B-pillars and the windscreen rail. This was both to meet what was held to be ultra-tough rollover protection requirements in the ‘States, but also because without it the decapitated bodyshell had all the structural rigidity of a Boris Johnson promise.

The question of motive power was also a tricky one. Triumph was known for advanced engines at the time, and the original idea was to launch the Stag with the company’s well-proven straight six before substituting this for an all-new V8. Work on this fresh engine had already started when Leyland absorbed Rover in 1967, throwing up an immediate cost-saving opportunity to switch to the 3.5-litre ‘Buick’ V8 that Rover was already making.

Yet that was too obvious, especially given the politics and rivalry at the top of the newly formed group. Triumph engineers were keen to back their home team, and successfully argued development on their more advanced V8 was too far advanced to be stopped. The plan to make a six-cylinder Stag was also dropped at around the same time, meaning the new car would launch with an all-new engine.


If the finished V8 had proved to be a mechanical masterpiece this confidence would have been justified. But it’s wasn’t. The overhead cam engine was impressively light and sounded great. But although its output of 145hp was entirely respectable, and a higher per-litre output than the Rover V8, it wasn’t enough to make the Stag truly rapid. Even in 1970 a 10.7-second 0-60mph time was more cruiser than bruiser, and early press reaction was lukewarm.

But performance wasn’t the big issue – rather reliability was. Early Stag owners were soon encountering engine problems that were unusual even by BL’s less than stellar standards, with timing chain and head gasket failures, warping cylinder heads and catastrophic water pump check outs. Many issues were due to the engine’s still novel combination of an iron block and alloy cylinder heads, requiring antifreeze with a corrosion inhibitor. Owners and even some Triumph garages were unaware of this, leading to gunked up coolant passages and overheating problems. But there were also unarguable design faults – including the need to replace the delicate timing chains every 30,000 miles.

As the Stag aged into classicdom so these problems acquired the ball-and-chain status of ‘when’ rather than ‘if’. By the early nineties it wasn’t uncommon to find Stags receiving powerplant transplants – often, ironically, with Rover V8s – with these re-engined versions even being sold for a premium compared to original cars. Tougher parts and more understanding owners have solved many of the infamous issues, but there is still an undeniable frisson of risk to a Stag. Well inside the 21st century I arranged to borrow one from a dealer for a classic mag feature only to be called the day before the photoshoot: “you’re not going to be believe this, but the head gasket has just gone.”


Our Pill is an attractive 1972 ‘mk1’ being sold for what looks like a very fair price compared to the wider market given the imminent arrival of warmer weather. In place of the very slushy three-speed auto that many buyers selected it has a four speed manual gearbox with the neat option of switchable overdrive through a toggle on top of the gearstick. It also comes with what would have been very generous spec by the standards of the early seventies, including electric windows, power steering and what looks on this example to be a period appropriate radio-cassette. The dashboard also contains near equal volumes of walnut wood and instrument dials. It’s as seventies as the Bee Gees breaking into the Watergate hotel on space hoppers.

Although our Pill has covered 132,800 miles from new it is smart enough to belie the fact the five-figure odometer is on its second trip around. Recent use has been very sparing. According to the MOT history the car has done just 50 miles since April 2016, and under 6,000 since 2006. There was a big fail back in 2011 for excessive corrosion and the more perplexing issue of “offside front vehicle structure has a modification which adversely affects braking or steering.” Rust is hardly unknown to BL products of the era, but it seems to have been properly sorted; the only red on the record since then is for an ineffective handbrake in 2015. Our Pill is old enough to be exempt from vehicle tax, future MOTs and even London ULEZ payments.

The Stag sold poorly in period, fewer than 26,000 being built for all markets in seven years. Yet survival rates are remarkably high, certainly in the UK. Nearly 8,000 are still on the roads, making it one of the most popular seventies classics, with a thriving owners’ scene and comprehensive aftermarket support. Meaning that it is undoubtedly less risky to own one now than it would have been when the car was new. This is certainly a remarkably tasteful way to experience the decade that taste allegedly forgot.


Click here for the original ad



Author
Discussion

Gareth9702

Original Poster:

401 posts

163 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
A thorough inspection should reveal any bodyworks faults. No doubt there are plenty of patches of filler under the shiny paint. And the MOT record points to a need to inspect the front of the chassis very catefully. Given that all faults can be fixed at known costs, the Stag is only brave if paying top dollar without questionning ever inch of the car.

stavr0ss

273 posts

159 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
I only recently became aware of how notorious these are. A thread on another forum was discussed bmw reliability and one commenter said ‘my bmw has been the most unreliable car I’ve ever owned, and I drive a triumph fking Stag!’

Sandpit Steve

15,626 posts

105 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
stavr0ss said:
I only recently became aware of how notorious these are. A thread on another forum was discussed bmw reliability and one commenter said ‘my bmw has been the most unreliable car I’ve ever owned, and I drive a triumph fking Stag!’
Oh crap, are they *that* bad?
There was me thinking a classic couldn’t possibly be a brave pill, they’re mechanically simple and just need some spannering and the occasional welding up...

Roger Irrelevant

3,402 posts

144 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
Be sure to check that it's never been owned by Tom Donaldson.

plasticpig

12,932 posts

256 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
Sandpit Steve said:
Oh crap, are they *that* bad?
There was me thinking a classic couldn’t possibly be a brave pill, they’re mechanically simple and just need some spannering and the occasional welding up...
Nope. The engine issues are well known and probably solved on a lot of the surviving ones. They don’t rust any more than most other British 70’s cars.

FlukePlay

1,202 posts

176 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
I never imagined the performance was so poor, a 3.5 V8 pumping out just 145 bhp and getting to 60 'some time later'.

ducnick

2,295 posts

274 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
I would only entertain the idea of an engine swapped stag, or one suitably discounted to allow a rover V8 transplant. Should be plenty of later generation 4 litre lumps about now with more power and less weight.

PSB1967

514 posts

187 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
One of the many cars shows on TV I watched investigated the infamous cooling issue these had and found the design to be sound. They concluded the problem lay in the build quality on the 'line' and lack of quality control. This doesn't excuse BL metal turning to dust at a rate only beaten by Alfa Romeo in the 70's and 80's. IMO the real 'Brave' element of this and any BL product of this era isn't mechanical borkage but driving a structure that no longer has any strength due to hidden corrosion, just as an impact looms. Good luck with that!

Sandpit Steve

15,626 posts

105 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
plasticpig said:
Sandpit Steve said:
Oh crap, are they *that* bad?
There was me thinking a classic couldn’t possibly be a brave pill, they’re mechanically simple and just need some spannering and the occasional welding up...
Nope. The engine issues are well known and probably solved on a lot of the surviving ones. They don’t rust any more than most other British 70’s cars.
Good to hear, so not particularly brave then.

Am I the only one expecting something of a renaissance in classics, as the ULEZ and other initiatives become more widespread? Sounds like a car with grandfather rights is just the ticket, for journeys the politicians don’t want you to make.

Miserablegit

4,449 posts

140 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
FlukePlay said:
I never imagined the performance was so poor, a 3.5 V8 pumping out just 145 bhp and getting to 60 'some time later'.
The Stag is a 3.0 v8
The performance is fine for the car- it’s a period GT and can beat a MK1 Golf Gti from the peage on a Le Mans trip (which is all that matters !)
The engine sounds wonderful - especially through stainless headers.

Many of the faults, as stated above, were as a result of some workers doing their best to put themselves out of a job. Some engine blocks didn’t have the casting sand washed out and so the waterways clogged leading to overheating - I’d get this one checked out for structural issues etc but with a decent mileage on it I would anticipate the engine is ok.

A design fault meant the water pump was at the top of the engine - hence any fluid loss meant the water pump wasn’t doing anything. Many owners have fitted header tanks to the system to ensure the water level stays above the pump.

The beauty of a classic is the lack of electronic black boxes that can die and either be unobtainable or hugely expensive to replace. Virtually every part of the stag is available. I had mine completely rebuilt a few years ago.



Quadcamboy

122 posts

238 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
Mate had one. Evenings and weekends we spent a month getting the heads off!

Didn't have head bolts but steel studs threaded into block, at an oblique angle. We had the engine on a sling bolted to each cyl head, one by one and had to hammer the studs down through the head to get a gap between head and block. We could then get a recip saw in to cut them free. FFS

Borrowed it when finished for a weekend away with the girlfriend and it bent a rod!


anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all

Every time I see a modern "classic" on the road it's usually followed my a noxious cloud of smoke that reminds me of the 70's, but not in a good way.
Can the owners club arrange a post covid run around Westminster.
Imagine the irony of the gathered Stags (that make it that far) belching out smoke so close to the seat of power....cough, cough.

rossub

6,074 posts

221 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
8,000 of them left?!

Where the hell are they all!

RussBennett

3 posts

115 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
I have had mine for 5 years so yes I am biased. As with any classic pay as much as you can without being "silly" to minimise the work. Parts are cheaper than modern cars - new alternator for £57 for example and you can get most bits new or refurbished - except many significant body panels so there is the risk!
https://www.stag.org.uk/

LotusOmega375D

9,431 posts

184 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
There’s going to be a big Stag 50th birthday circuit parade at the Silverstone Classic this summer.

I wonder how many of them will make it all the way round?

RussBennett

3 posts

115 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
rossub said:
8,000 of them left?!

Where the hell are they all!
Go to Silverstone Classic this year - its the Stags 50th party so a good portion will be there (actually its last year but ....)

kambites

71,747 posts

252 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
I'd love a stag, but I think with this sort of car you have to enjoy working on it as much as driving it or it will just end up being frustrating.

dunnoreally

1,356 posts

139 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
Love these. There's just something about old Triumphs for me. They just have a knack for getting under my skin, no matter how rubbish they might actually be.

Miserablegit

4,449 posts

140 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
It’s just the appeal of old cars - they are “rubbish” by modern standards- don’t go, handle or stop as well as a modern shopping trolley but...

That is their appeal

They were designed in a period where there was much more freedom in design

They make a distinctive noise and have to be driven - drive like a @@@@ and you’ll end up in a hedge as there are no electronics to help you out.

I can’t think of many soft tops I don’t like - except, perhaps, a diesel.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 27th February 2021
quotequote all
FlukePlay said:
I never imagined the performance was so poor, a 3.5 V8 pumping out just 145 bhp and getting to 60 'some time later'.
Stag is a 3.0, and of its time. The triumph engine makes a glorious noise when running right