LED headlights --- HOW much?
LED headlights --- HOW much?
Author
Discussion

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
You used to get a halogen bulb for £15 or an HID for £30.

Now your Merc LED dip beam gives up the struggle and you need a complete headlight unit to fix...

£860 or, if you're lucky, a control unit for about £100, and the bumper has to come off first, and it might need coding by, guess who?

Is this supposed to be bloody progress?

Pardon my swearing, but.... bloody Norah....irked

Jaguar steve

9,232 posts

241 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
It is very much progress for the business concerned.

A £800 + labour + VAT headlight is just one more symptom of the direction in which capitalism is heading and how the Moneymen behind it are squeezing everybody's balls harder and harder and jump on every opportunity to fk anybody over the moment they get their wallet out.

The solution of course is refusing to put yourself in the situation of needing a £800 + labour + VAT headlight in the first place.

Pica-Pica

16,738 posts

115 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
My E36 need a new headlamp unit (non-LED). BMW wanted about £300 several years ago. I got a Europarts one for £75 pounds, bloody crap it was.

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
Jaguar steve said:
The solution of course is refusing to put yourself in the situation of needing a £800 + labour + VAT headlight in the first place.
Well, yes, of course but, the way things are going, you will have no choice if you need a new or newish car. I would have chosen HID, but there was no option.

To make matters worse, I can't see any benefit in LED over HID.

KillerHERTZ

1,129 posts

229 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Well, yes, of course but, the way things are going, you will have no choice if you need a new or newish car. I would have chosen HID, but there was no option.

To make matters worse, I can't see any benefit in LED over HID.
In theory they last longer + work instantly.

Whats up with it? take it to any decent electrical engineering workshop, they can re-solder it etc for peanuts.

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
KillerHERTZ said:
mybrainhurts said:
Well, yes, of course but, the way things are going, you will have no choice if you need a new or newish car. I would have chosen HID, but there was no option.

To make matters worse, I can't see any benefit in LED over HID.
In theory they last longer + work instantly.

Whats up with it? take it to any decent electrical engineering workshop, they can re-solder it etc for peanuts.
HIDs come on instantly, I have them on my BMW.
Downside is that the driver unit/ballast unit can be pricey at a dealer.

Largechris

2,019 posts

122 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Jaguar steve said:
The solution of course is refusing to put yourself in the situation of needing a £800 + labour + VAT headlight in the first place.
Well, yes, of course but, the way things are going, you will have no choice if you need a new or newish car. I would have chosen HID, but there was no option.

To make matters worse, I can't see any benefit in LED over HID.
Depends on which model we are talking about.

Matrix units are, frankly, brilliant and massively better than previous tech. I used to work as an automotive lighting supplier.

On the new E class Mercedes spent 35 million Euros just on the headlamp development and tooling, and the control of the matrix beams required 15 million lines of code.

Audi figures were similar.

For OE use, these units will be entirely obsolete with the mid life facelift after 3 years of production, none of that R+D will be reused.

£800 for a spare after that is a bargain.

Incidentally the above figures I've given you explain why Mclaren and Aston Martin don't fit matrix headlights. No cash to develop them.

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
KillerHERTZ said:
mybrainhurts said:
Well, yes, of course but, the way things are going, you will have no choice if you need a new or newish car. I would have chosen HID, but there was no option.

To make matters worse, I can't see any benefit in LED over HID.
In theory they last longer
Yes, 4000 hours claimed. I've done 4000 hours (OBD revealed) but I wouldn't have spent £860 over the same period replacing HIDs.

KillerHERTZ said:
Whats up with it? take it to any decent electrical engineering workshop, they can re-solder it etc for peanuts.
No they can't, I don't think you understand how these things work. If I'm wrong, I would welcome your guidance.

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
Largechris said:
control of the matrix beams required 15 million lines of code.
Some would say that's a bad idea.
I would, and that's what I'm qualified in.

valiant

14,370 posts

191 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
Just bought a car that has LED lights and they do work very well and the manual does state that they should last the life of the car (but being a Peugeot that means about 5 years hehe )

My last car was a Volvo that had active bending xenons and one headlight unit was around £1200 to replace! Eek!

Jaguar steve

9,232 posts

241 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Jaguar steve said:
The solution of course is refusing to put yourself in the situation of needing a £800 + labour + VAT headlight in the first place.
Well, yes, of course but, the way things are going, you will have no choice if you need a new or newish car. I would have chosen HID, but there was no option.

To make matters worse, I can't see any benefit in LED over HID.
I know it's stating the 'bleedin obvious but that's how it is.

I'm very much of the mind situations like this exist because of the proliferation of leasing rather than purchasing. Lessors don't have to care about reliability or parts prices as it's all covered under warranty so manufactures don't have to care either. This leaves them free to deliberately engineer parts to have a limited life without affecting new registrations knowing they and their dealers can absolutely clean up in a few years time.

It's a great investment in future business security for them for them but a shocking one for the second or third owner who has to cough up

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
Largechris said:
Matrix units are, frankly, brilliant and massively better than previous tech. I used to work as an automotive lighting supplier.
There was nothing wrong with HIDs I have experienced in the past, I don't need anything better.

Largechris said:
On the new E class Mercedes spent 35 million Euros just on the headlamp development and tooling, and the control of the matrix beams required 15 million lines of code.
Holy crap, so they didn't do it just to prise more £ out of owners, then. They aren't going to recover those costs out of replacements. What's it all about, then, smartarse syndrome of "we're doing it because we can"?

Largechris said:
£800 for a spare after that is a bargain.
HID £30 is even more of a bargain...tongue out


KillerHERTZ

1,129 posts

229 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
No they can't, I don't think you understand how these things work. If I'm wrong, I would welcome your guidance.
I do have a fair understanding of how these work.

What is the actual issue? 9/10 with LED headlights its a dry solder or a Diode has failed which can be repaired if the headlight is dismantled. Not somthing you can get done at a dealership.

I had the LED indicator part of my CLS55 rear cluster give up the ghost and it was fixed by an electrical engineer in less than an hour. Dry solder issue.

Bennet

2,133 posts

162 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Largechris said:
control of the matrix beams required 15 million lines of code.
Some would say that's a bad idea.
I would, and that's what I'm qualified in.
Is that even realisitically plausible.....?
15 million lines to interpret an image on camera and illuminate certain parts of the led matrix in response...?


carlove

7,918 posts

198 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
I had to change my bulb on my Astra recently, cost £2.99. loser

A girl I know has a 2009 3 Series with halogens (I think that makes it an E90, not really sure) her sidelight blew and she was quoted £130 for a new one, it had the angel eye or whatever they’re called lights.


mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
KillerHERTZ said:
mybrainhurts said:
No they can't, I don't think you understand how these things work. If I'm wrong, I would welcome your guidance.
I do have a fair understanding of how these work.

What is the actual issue? 9/10 with LED headlights its a dry solder or a Diode has failed which can be repaired if the headlight is dismantled. Not somthing you can get done at a dealership.

I had the LED indicator part of my CLS55 rear cluster give up the ghost and it was fixed by an electrical engineer in less than an hour. Dry solder issue.
My apologies, I thought you were being flippant. Did the engineer have to split open the unit or did someone else do that?

I've searched everywhere for repairers, but got nowhere. Who was the engineer who helped you?

stevemcs

10,413 posts

124 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
It will need coding and the bumper does need to come off. If its the LED sidelight thats failed you need to work out if it the LED iteslf (cheap on ebay) or the control unit under the headlight - not so cheap from merc but they do offer remanufactured ones or if its the headlight. Start by swaping bits over from the other side.

Yes it does need coding, it can be done outside of a main dealer.

The next big money spinner is calibration of ADAS.

Jaguar steve

9,232 posts

241 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
Bennet said:
CraigyMc said:
Largechris said:
control of the matrix beams required 15 million lines of code.
Some would say that's a bad idea.
I would, and that's what I'm qualified in.
Is that even realisitically plausible.....?
15 million lines to interpret an image on camera and illuminate certain parts of the led matrix in response...?
And even if it is plausible what's the bloody point?

Just because you can does not mean to say you should.

mybrainhurts

Original Poster:

90,809 posts

286 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
stevemcs said:
It will need coding and the bumper does need to come off. If its the LED sidelight thats failed you need to work out if it the LED iteslf (cheap on ebay) or the control unit under the headlight - not so cheap from merc but they do offer remanufactured ones or if its the headlight. Start by swaping bits over from the other side.

Yes it does need coding, it can be done outside of a main dealer.
Thanks. It's the dip beam, the DLRs are also built into the headlight, so they would also be a problem

kambites

71,748 posts

252 months

Friday 24th September 2021
quotequote all
I think I'll stick with my halogens which cost about £5 a bulb (although the units themselves are eye-wateringly expensive if you damage them). smile