RE: BMW M5 (E39) | Spotted
RE: BMW M5 (E39) | Spotted
Wednesday 10th November 2021

BMW M5 (E39) | Spotted

The best BMW 5 Series ever shows no sign of buyer fatigue



This makes me angry. Really, really angry. And no, that's not because £55,000 is a mammoth amount to pay for an E39 BMW M5; these days that doesn't seem much of a stretch for a low-mileage car like this. The reason why I am so angry, gutted, grief-stricken, bitter, or whatever the emotion is that's currently consuming me - perhaps all of them - is because this was my car. Well, not this exact one, but I had the exact same spec, and I didn't sell it for that figure. I still miss it.

I think the E39, in any spec, is one of those seminal cars. A rare example of a manufacturer spending way more on the engineering budget than it needed, to beat the opposition. Indeed, the E39 didn't only beat its rivals, it broke them. It was way ahead of everything at the time for ride, handling, refinement, interior quality and more. And 'more' included its straight-six engines being coupled to a five-speed ZF auto gearbox which together could equal Mobil's products for slickness. In some ways, the 'sixes' were so good that there really was no need to opt for the 4.4-litre V8 in the 535i and 540i, especially because some moaned that they didn't steer as well; the V8s swapped a steering rack for a steering box, because the former wouldn't fit. The M5's S62B50 V8 was a different matter, though.

To let a small detail the steering box blind you from the bigger picture would be crazy. The M5 was mega. I first drove one not long after it was launched, and it was probably the first car I'd driven that felt properly quick. As in OMG, smack-you-in-the-chops quick, and I'd driven plenty of fast stuff by then. Not least the rival Jaguar XJR-8 with 377hp from its supercharged AJ-V8 4.0-litre. But that still didn't pack the M5's 400hp punch and it couldn't match its traction, steering positivity (even though the XJR had a rack) or its body control, either. The greatest achievement of all was that, despite the colossal power and 369lb ft thundering through the back axle, it was so sublime when it broke traction.

That's why I just had to have one. I couldn't afford anything really exotic - in terms of purchase price or repair bills - and while I could've stretched to a 911 Carrera 2, the M5 delivered similar performance with all the usability I required. So I bought one, just like this. A 2002 facelift model with the larger infotainment screen, finished in Carbon Black, black nappa leather and ostrich grey inserts. I owned it for about six years, and it was a wonderful union. My brother had an E60 M5 wagon which coincided with my ownership of the E39 but, while I loved its V10, I wouldn't have traded it for the older model. The E39 was analogue. It had a six-speed manual gearbox and the only driver settings it had included the sport button, which you pressed if you felt the need to sharpen the throttle response and weight-up the steering. I rarely did. I much preferred its default setting. The only thing I did religiously was hit the 'ESP off' switch, because I loved using the M5's 'rear-wheel steering' around any roundabout and I trusted the back end completely.



I did go through a few tyres as a result. And, speaking of costs, how reliable was it? Well, I've forgotten how many miles I did in it, but it was a lot: it was my only car and I used it regularly, including trips to the south of France every year, for which it was brilliant. In that time, I replaced all the discs and pads (as much for warping, which the front discs were prone to doing, as wear). I renewed the front anti-roll bar drop links, which broke, and the blower motor thermistor. That fails and knocks out the interior fans, which is an easy and cheap job, but, annoyingly, it went in the south of France, in August. It needed a new sump at one stage, too, but only because a BMW dealer stripped the sump plug and tried to blame me, until I pointed out who did the last service - i.e. them.

There are a few other things to watch out for when buying an E39 M5. The Vanos, of course, although mine was fine. It tends to be a little noisy regardless of wear, but if the power delivery is staged or the idle is rough then watch out. Water leaks, mainly into the rear footwell, were an E39 trait and the M5's clutch was the one area where BMW, perhaps, did under-engineer the car. I drove a few that slipped after a quick shift. The instrument binnacle display also fails. The tiny solder joints on the multiplug dry out and you start losing digits. I seem to recall you can have them re-soldered, rather than replace the whole, expensive unit.

I also had mine repainted. Stupidly, I left it under an oak tree and it got covered in bird lime, which ruined near enough every panel. So it was stripped to the bare metal and rejuvenated, including its lovely chrome-effect 18-inch wheels. At which point, I decided it was so pristine that I had to sell it before it started picking up the dents and scratches from a life spent on the streets of north London. Admittedly, mine had 70k on the clock, but it was stunning in every respect with a full BMW service history. How much did I sell it for? The princely sum of £12,000. D'oh!

But if any classic car is worth today's inflated prices, surely it's this one. I drove BMW's heritage E39 M5 not so long ago, and it's still awesome. So much so that it doesn't feel like a stretch to say it would stand a chance in a modern-day group test. It'd be left behind on performance, of course, but that just proves how pointless the power race has become. You do not need more grunt. I can say with utter confidence that, if you buy an E39 M5, you won't regret it.


SPECIFICATION | BMW M5 (E39)

Engine: 4941cc, V8, naturally aspirated
Transmission: 6-speed manual, rear-wheel drive
Power (hp): 400@6,600rpm
Torque (lb ft): 369@3,800rpm
CO2: N/A
MPG: N/A
Year registered: 2000
Recorded mileage: 26,000
Price new: £52,000
Yours for: £54,990

See the original advert here.


Author
Discussion

Big Rat

Original Poster:

384 posts

77 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Yes I get the normally aspirated…..analogue feel……etc etc…I’ve been fortunate enough to have been there with V8 V10 and V12 but for this money I’d really much rather have a 2-3 year old M5 with less miles as well for the same money …..Budget probably wouldn’t stretch to a comp but that’s fine by me…..

cerb4.5lee

45,355 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
The E39 M5 will always be my favourite M5. Very nice. cool

I'd love one. driving

Turbobanana

8,586 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Funnily enough I was following an old E39 in to work this morning. Granted, it was a 530d but I was struck by two things: how small it looked, and how much black smoke was belching out the back.

Around 2001 I was tasked with delivering an M5 to a client in London and the drive remains one of my most disappointing ever. I think I needed 300km of Autobahn to appreciate the car, because down the A12 on a Friday night it just felt boring. Quick, but soulless. One day I'd love to drive another to see if it really matches the hype (I suspect it does, but as that one trip remains my only experience in one it has stayed with me as an impression ever since).

Car in the article looks good: not surprised by the price in today's market.

pb8g09

3,298 posts

100 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Turbobanana said:
Funnily enough I was following an old E39 in to work this morning. Granted, it was a 530d but I was struck by two things: how small it looked, and how much black smoke was belching out the back.

Around 2001 I was tasked with delivering an M5 to a client in London and the drive remains one of my most disappointing ever. I think I needed 300km of Autobahn to appreciate the car, because down the A12 on a Friday night it just felt boring. Quick, but soulless. One day I'd love to drive another to see if it really matches the hype (I suspect it does, but as that one trip remains my only experience in one it has stayed with me as an impression ever since).

Car in the article looks good: not surprised by the price in today's market.
Could it be though that what felt soulless in 2001 is now glorious in comparison to the soulless feel of 2021?

Nurburgsingh

5,563 posts

269 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
I've had E28 E34 and E39 M5's all of them special in their own way...

My E39 was a moon mileage example in Oxford green with green heritage leather, they can be wallet destroying and in fact often are, but my god when you get to that empty stretch of your favourite B road... its worth every penny. If ever there was a car that was equal to more than the sum of its parts... the E39M5.

It annoys me that I had to sell it to make way fro a dog wagon, it boils my piss that the most recent owner managed to have an accident in it 45mins after buying it. 'tard!

cerb4.5lee

45,355 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
My BIL had a E39 535i, but I always thought that was hampered by the auto gearbox everytime I had a go in it though(you could argue that an auto is a better fit in something like the 5 series though). So with these having a manual gearbox that holds a lot of appeal for me.

I also like that the engine in these is reasonably torquey as well, and I'd personally prefer this engine to the V10 in the E60 M5. I've never been much of a fan of BMWs really high revving NA engines(E9x M3/E6x M5), but I do think that my opinion of those engines would change if I lived in Germany rather than the UK though.

apm142001

293 posts

120 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Unless you're one of those who buys and locks away to try and play the market (and in doing so ruins it for those of us who actually want to drive cars) I suspect it makes more sense to get an example for £25-30k that's actually had some use (they can still be found https://www.pistonheads.com/buy/listing/12453967). The one in the article looks as if it's done about 1000 miles in the last 4 years (of which next to none in the last 2 years) so would likely start throwing out a few bills if put to use.

It's a lovely thing though. Wonder how fast it feels by today's standards...

waynecyclist

14,881 posts

145 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Crazy to see how much these are worth now, still my one of my favourite M5's along with the E28.

1974foggy

751 posts

175 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Ive just picked up a 528i sport from a barn where its spent the last 10 years sitting with a faulty fuel pump, id forgotten how well made these e39s are.
Its no M5, but its nice to see them appreciated. Mine has cloth trim, full service history with BMW up until it was parked up, original mud flaps and so on.
Hoping to go through everything and get it back on the road. Cost was £750, so can afford to spend a bit guilt free.

cerb4.5lee

45,355 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
apm142001 said:
Wonder how fast it feels by today's standards...
Maybe I have my rose tints on, but I'd like to think that it still feels fairly nippy even now.

Seesure

1,230 posts

270 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Been lucky enough to have been driving one of these since June 2004... granted I'm on my second, but after almost 300k miles between the two I've owned I still enjoy the way these cars lay down the power and pick up speed in a sublime way without being frenetic.

My first car is sitting in my garage like a lost soul after the timing chain guides and tensioners gave up the ghost one day after it had been MOT'd a few years back.

My current one went through the MOT last month but with a fistful of advisories pretty much all in regards to rust in one place or another....

Might look to see what level of fabrication is needed in regards to keeping it on the road in April or May next year. Engine wise it chews a fair bit of oil when on WOT but is still capable of holding its own when needed.





Edited by Seesure on Wednesday 10th November 13:00

Gad-Westy

16,666 posts

244 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Big Rat said:
Yes I get the normally aspirated…..analogue feel……etc etc…I’ve been fortunate enough to have been there with V8 V10 and V12 but for this money I’d really much rather have a 2-3 year old M5 with less miles as well for the same money …..Budget probably wouldn’t stretch to a comp but that’s fine by me…..
Cards on the table, I love the E39 M5 but I'm sort of inclined to agree with you. I think the trouble for me at least is that I don't think these are old enough yet to feel like a true classic that you might keep for very special occasions. So I'd want to use it as a 'normal' car and at that point, there might be some shortcomings. Partly to do with modern expectations but it's also reasonable to expect that you may need to be really on top of a car like this all the time maintenance wise.

But being more positive, I do see this as peak super saloon. It's the Daddy! The E60/1 being SMG only (in the UK at least) really damages the appeal of those cars and everything that has followed since seems to lack a bit of identity and much more interchangeable with the equivalent Merc/Jag/Audi etc.

Patrick Bateman

13,220 posts

205 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Definitely got on the boat at the right time back in 2013, bought a 120k mile car for £7400.

Sold in 2016 and badly missed. At least I got the chance, looks like they're forever going to be a dream car for a lot of folk with prices being ridiculous now.

NorthNorthWest

264 posts

60 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Big Rat said:
Yes I get the normally aspirated…..analogue feel……etc etc…I’ve been fortunate enough to have been there with V8 V10 and V12 but for this money I’d really much rather have a 2-3 year old M5 with less miles as well for the same money …..Budget probably wouldn’t stretch to a comp but that’s fine by me…..
Talk about missing the point.

The spinner of plates

18,084 posts

231 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
I remember when these hit the bottom of the value curve. I was sniffing around £10k examples but always knew I needed an estate, so didn’t partake.

Remember when Hexagon started buying the good ones and sticking them up for £25k?... oh how we chuckled at that price back then...

Gad-Westy

16,666 posts

244 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
The spinner of plates said:
I remember when these hit the bottom of the value curve. I was sniffing around £10k examples but always knew I needed an estate, so didn’t partake.

Remember when Hexagon started buying the good ones and sticking them up for £25k?... oh how we chuckled at that price back then...
I think there was a period (maybe 2010 ish) when a ropey high miler was down as little as £4k. Good ones around £8k and only exceptional stuff was £10k+. I was tempted too but I guess I was put off a bit by potential bills and chickened out though I also was a bit surprised that they didn't feel faster and were a bit quiet as standard. Would still love to try another.




AC43

13,727 posts

239 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Perfection. Purposeful looking but subtle. Hugely capable.

Such a shame that today's M Cars, RS's and AMG's are so shouty in visual and in audible terms.

It seem to bring out the inner Max Power in a lot of the owners round my way.

It's tragic the way they thottle on and off, on and off. Going up and down high street, over and over.

I preferred them like this; most people wouldn't know what they were and the throbbers were all driving something else "impressive".


Turbobanana

8,586 posts

232 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
pb8g09 said:
Turbobanana said:
Funnily enough I was following an old E39 in to work this morning. Granted, it was a 530d but I was struck by two things: how small it looked, and how much black smoke was belching out the back.

Around 2001 I was tasked with delivering an M5 to a client in London and the drive remains one of my most disappointing ever. I think I needed 300km of Autobahn to appreciate the car, because down the A12 on a Friday night it just felt boring. Quick, but soulless. One day I'd love to drive another to see if it really matches the hype (I suspect it does, but as that one trip remains my only experience in one it has stayed with me as an impression ever since).

Car in the article looks good: not surprised by the price in today's market.
Could it be though that what felt soulless in 2001 is now glorious in comparison to the soulless feel of 2021?
Yes, could very well be. As I said, I'd love a go in one again now.

RDMcG

20,920 posts

238 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Best BMW I ever had. Bought it new and had it for a couple of years, but then moved on to BMW 6 series...( 645ci manual, M6 V10)..but neither could hold a candle to the M5.

SteRB5138

187 posts

245 months

Wednesday 10th November 2021
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
The spinner of plates said:
I remember when these hit the bottom of the value curve. I was sniffing around £10k examples but always knew I needed an estate, so didn’t partake.

Remember when Hexagon started buying the good ones and sticking them up for £25k?... oh how we chuckled at that price back then...
I think there was a period (maybe 2010 ish) when a ropey high miler was down as little as £4k. Good ones around £8k and only exceptional stuff was £10k+. I was tempted too but I guess I was put off a bit by potential bills and chickened out though I also was a bit surprised that they didn't feel faster and were a bit quiet as standard. Would still love to try another.
Yeah its hard to believe the M5 Wheeler Dealers showed in 2012, they only sold for £6500 after working on it! Its currently SORN'd on 158k miles

https://mikebrewermotoring.com/features/wheeler-de...