Modern cars and long gearing…
Modern cars and long gearing…
Author
Discussion

irish boy

Original Poster:

3,925 posts

267 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Having just updated the daily driver from an older diesel to a fresher one (Avensis) I’m struggling to get on with the gearing.

The old one was a well judged 5 speed, 3rd gear for 30’s, 5th for anything above 50. The 5th gear in the old one is between 3rd and 4th on the newer one. On a typical A road/55-60 cruise it’s almost a struggle for 5th as its well below 2k rpm/out of the turbo zone, 6th requires at least 80. Shift light indicator constantly telling me to change up.

The worst of it is the economy is 5mpg worse despite basically the same engine size and horse power.

Is it down to lab testing for economy? It just doesn’t seem to work in the real world/U.K.

CABC

6,320 posts

132 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
diesel Avensis is a small issue. emissions regs dictate the same for petrol sports cars, and that really hurts. it's not always rose tints that have some lamenting the new order. last century, manufacturers did their best to make a car for you, the consumer. Now the dominant force for drivetrain decisions is legislation. in other words, technology has progressed but we're not getting the best cars possible.

vikingaero

13,591 posts

200 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
All about economy and emissions. The family VW Bussat has a 7 speed DSG and if it's it 7, it can kickdown 2-3 gears to get a shift on.

Truckosaurus

13,313 posts

315 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
The shift lights are a waste of time, they come on just above idle in order to allow earlier manual gearchanges during the emissions tests - no use in real life.

Modern auto gearboxes are no better, having so many ratios and changing up and down the box constantly to be at very low revs when off the throttle and up near the redline once you press the loud pedal, might as well be a CVT.

hedges88

690 posts

176 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Sometimes the gear ratios are just for getting good emissions and economy figures that then don't translate to good driving on the road. I went from a 2010 Mercedes A160 Blue efficiency to a 2009 A150 (same engine) and on the motorway I kept going for 5th gear and realising I was already in it because it's a much shorter gearbox. It makes the non- efficiency one so much nicer to drive even if the on paper performance is the same. It doesn't have much power so a shorter gearbox helps a lot with the driving experience and it's much more competent on the motorway because you're in the power band better. Tad noisier and a few MPG down but very much better to drive.

I imagine many many cars are like that now. Longer spacing between the gears is much less pleasurable in terms of achieving precise and slick gear changes in my humble opinion. The turbocharged torque offered by a lot of modern engines does make longer gearing more feasible though.....

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
irish boy said:
Having just updated the daily driver from an older diesel to a fresher one (Avensis) I’m struggling to get on with the gearing.

The old one was a well judged 5 speed, 3rd gear for 30’s, 5th for anything above 50. The 5th gear in the old one is between 3rd and 4th on the newer one. On a typical A road/55-60 cruise it’s almost a struggle for 5th as its well below 2k rpm/out of the turbo zone, 6th requires at least 80. Shift light indicator constantly telling me to change up.

The worst of it is the economy is 5mpg worse despite basically the same engine size and horse power.

Is it down to lab testing for economy? It just doesn’t seem to work in the real world/U.K.
er, have you considered following the shift lights suggestion?

Any modern car should be able to sit at 1,200 rpm in top all day long. Yes, you'll have to change down to overtake or accelerate hard, but the pay off is you burn less fuel, which is kinda the point!


irish boy

Original Poster:

3,925 posts

267 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
er, have you considered following the shift lights suggestion?

Any modern car should be able to sit at 1,200 rpm in top all day long. Yes, you'll have to change down to overtake or accelerate hard, but the pay off is you burn less fuel, which is kinda the point!
1200 in top equates to about 55. On a flat road/cruise on the instant economy meter reads around 8 mpg less than shifting to 4th/1800 rpm where the whole engine and drive train just feels more comfortable.


Edited by irish boy on Thursday 30th December 12:51

RumbleOfThunder

3,728 posts

234 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
I have never in my life found a "normal" car with gearing that's too long. Quite an odd gripe really. Use the gear below or change your expectation about what the sweet spot in the rev range is, OP.

trevalvole

2,095 posts

64 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
I think some of these high-geared manual cars are quite different to drive than the older ones where top in a typical petrol-engined car was not much more than 20mph/1000rpm. In the older cars, in mixed driving, you could drive in top gear at speeds above 30 to 40 mph and unless you came across a hill, you could keep it in top gear. The driving experience wasn't that much different to driving an automatic once you were up to speed. Now with cars with higher gears and turbo engines that often won't pull below 2000rpm, you are continuously having to change gears and more traffic and lower speed limits are making this worse. I wonder if these changes have accelerated the move to automatic gearboxes for those who could accept lower-geared manual cars, but not the newer higher-geared ones?

Chubbyross

5,017 posts

116 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
irish boy said:
Having just updated the daily driver from an older diesel to a fresher one (Avensis) I’m struggling to get on with the gearing.

The old one was a well judged 5 speed, 3rd gear for 30’s, 5th for anything above 50. The 5th gear in the old one is between 3rd and 4th on the newer one. On a typical A road/55-60 cruise it’s almost a struggle for 5th as its well below 2k rpm/out of the turbo zone, 6th requires at least 80. Shift light indicator constantly telling me to change up.

The worst of it is the economy is 5mpg worse despite basically the same engine size and horse power.

Is it down to lab testing for economy? It just doesn’t seem to work in the real world/U.K.
er, have you considered following the shift lights suggestion?

Any modern car should be able to sit at 1,200 rpm in top all day long. Yes, you'll have to change down to overtake or accelerate hard, but the pay off is you burn less fuel, which is kinda the point!
Yes, but you do then feel like you’re in a station taxi.

Muddle238

4,421 posts

144 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Surely you just change gear when you need to, regardless of what speed you're doing.

I've had cars with both short gearing and others with longer gearing, I always prefer the longer gearing as it's less buggering about changing gear around town.

Pistonheader101

2,206 posts

138 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
ZF8 gearboxes are the way to go

DodgyGeezer

49,419 posts

221 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Pistonheader101 said:
ZF8 gearboxes are the way to go
can't disagree with you there - mine is amazing

GroundEffect

13,864 posts

187 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Depends on the OEM but when I was designing manual transmissions we selected our ratios (gearset and final drive) based on a few key metrics:

- what modelled with the best CO2/mpg on cycle test
- diesel or petrol (diesel generally can have much wider ratio steps)
- wheel and tyre sizes proposed to be sold
- sufficient performance feel and,
- adequate gradability in top gear so that customers didn't needlessly downshift to maintain speed on a motorway

There was more to it but that's what I remember from 5 years ago.

Also, it's TALL gearing. Not long.


irish boy

Original Poster:

3,925 posts

267 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
GroundEffect said:
Depends on the OEM but when I was designing manual transmissions we selected our ratios (gearset and final drive) based on a few key metrics:

- what modelled with the best CO2/mpg on cycle test
- diesel or petrol (diesel generally can have much wider ratio steps)
- wheel and tyre sizes proposed to be sold
- sufficient performance feel and,
- adequate gradability in top gear so that customers didn't needlessly downshift to maintain speed on a motorway

There was more to it but that's what I remember from 5 years ago.

Also, it's TALL gearing. Not long.
Good post, especially the last line. Didn’t know that.

Lester H

4,474 posts

136 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
I suspect this is all about unintended consequences. For a tiny theoretical fuel saving, cars are higher geared. The frequent result is that many drivers and lots of enthusiasts simply change down earlier and this burns extra fuel . It has a parallel in the reduction in the size of chocolate bars in the interest of health, which of course increases profit per bar but causes many consumers to buy two. Reverting to cars, the awful start stop systems add considerably to resource greedy battrery manufacture add an infinitesimal fuel saving...in theory.

Edited by Lester H on Thursday 30th December 17:29

Panamax

10,127 posts

65 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Muddle238 said:
Surely you just change gear when you need to, regardless of what speed you're doing.
Yes, it's as simple as that. I have no time for "gearing's too long". When you've got 6 gears and can go from standstill to 90 mph in third there isn't a problem. More flexible engines, more gears to choose from, job done.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
Panamax said:
. When you've got 6 gears and can go from standstill to 90 mph in third there isn't a problem
In my opinion that IS part of the problem. If you can easily do over 90mph in 3rd gear then aside from track days you'd never need more than 2 gears to be blitzing the speed limits.

There is a joy to low closely packed gear ratios which allow you to use a lot more of 3rd, 4th and 5th.

The other annoyance of tall gears is people who only use up to 2000rpm or 1/3rd of the available rev range accelerate like snails.


Panamax

10,127 posts

65 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
aka_kerrly said:
In my opinion that IS part of the problem. If you can easily do over 90mph in 3rd gear then aside from track days you'd never need more than 2 gears to be blitzing the speed limits.
Most humans are capable of engaging first and second gears to help!

The other aspect is there's no point having 6 gears if they're so close together they actually make the car slower due to the time wasted changing gear.

I always manage to find a gear that's suitable. There are plenty to choose from.

p4cks

7,551 posts

230 months

Thursday 30th December 2021
quotequote all
My Merc CLA has the shortest 1-3 gears gearing imaginable. More so than a Fiat/Abarth 500. The speed in which it wants you to get to third gear is ridiculous... pulling away, you now need second. Then by the time you've released the clutch it wants you in third. I'm debating making the clutch return a little stiffer which allows me to build up the muscles in my puny left leg