Offering assistance at a breakdown
Offering assistance at a breakdown
Author
Discussion

colin79666

Original Poster:

2,228 posts

144 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
I’ve offered and had gratefully received assistance at breakdowns in the past. Usually just helping push a stranded vehicle off the road and once changing a wheel over for a lady in the office car park.

Today I was walking along a local road and saw a broken down small 4x4 at the exit of a roundabout. There was barely enough room to pass in a car due to the island and as this is a bus route I walked up to the passenger door and enquired of the driver would like help to push the car a bit further on and into the side. I wasn’t really expecting the response “are you f’ing stupid”. I responded with I’m not the one blocking the road and swearing at someone offering to help when walked on before it went further. Sure enough I looked back a minute later to see the bus stuck behind it.

Was this a one off or am I naive to think that offering help is a wise thing? I’d understand a lone woman politely declining or perhaps someone saying no thanks I’ve already got help arranged, just wasn’t really prepared for what I encountered today. Do you offer to help?

Alex@POD

6,454 posts

246 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
The guy was probably in a rubbish mood and embarrassed to be blocking the road, so lashed out without thinking... Or I'd like to think he was anyway!

I would expect help to be accepted at least, I've also offered help when necessary, one time to a guy I saw trying to change a wheel on a busy street, on the "road" side (not pavement side), with a tiny wind up jack and wheel brace. Since I had the trolley jack in the boot I figured spending 2 minutes with one of us standing in the way was better than him crouching next to the car for 15...

James_33

683 posts

97 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
Society 2022, I'm a bus driver and on occasion we have passengers who try boarding with wheelchairs, on occasion i have seen them struggle to get the wheelchair on by themselves (we are told not to assist) mainly because of false claims that have happened in the past but sometimes you feel you have to because you can genuinely see them struggling.

The amount of times i have tried helping in the past to be met by abuse just for been nice is off the chart, and not just in instances like above.

I must admit though i can take things to heart sometimes, I could see 1000 people in a day, but just takes that one ungrateful so and so to spoil it.

Miserablegit

4,449 posts

140 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
I stopped to offer assistance to the driver of a BMW that had slid into a ditch on Sunday. He had already called recovery but was grateful for the offer.
I’d always offer to help even if it risked abuse from the other person.

Worst time was many years ago offering to change the wheel of a Renault 5 (if I recall) for a pregnant lady with a toddler in the car. Crazy design of the car meant the Jack and brace were on the underside of the bonnet and were thus hotter than hell- I grabbed them without thinking and suffered burns for my troubles…


anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
I think no good deed goes unpunished covers this, more so as courtesy costs nothing.

Smint

3,670 posts

66 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
OP i'm sorry you found yet another bod who at one time would have been in a place of safety but is now a customer of care in the community.

Unfortunately the events of the last 2 years have allowed these people to show the real selves they once might have previously kept hidden, the girls on the tills at Morrisons have mentioned this a few times to me, how horrible some people hiding behind masks have been to them.

Nice retort from you though, maybe the weirdo will reflect on his behaviour at some point.

Just remembered think the last person i stopped to help on the road, really early one frosty morning chap had broke down in his old car, helped him push the thing up onto a wide verge, it was buggered and no fixing it but can't recall what the problem was now.
He was on the way to the south coast to see his daughter in some sort of recital, i dropped him at his work on the way to my work where he could borrow a van to use so the day wouldn't be a total disaster, he couldn't thank me enough, i was just pleased i helped him get to see his daughter.

Can't recall anyone ever stopping to help me but i'm usually fairly well prepared for most issues, and running oldee Toyota 4x4's breakdowns and puncturs are, (that's torn it) thankfully rare.

Edited by Smint on Monday 24th January 18:24

Red9zero

11,405 posts

88 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
I posted in another thread that I changed a lady's wheel once and didn't get a word of thanks. My Father tried to help a young girl who had broken down a while back and she just screamed at him to get away from her as he was approaching her. Conversely when I broke down on my motorbike just by Heston services on one of their bike nights, not one biker stopped to help. Now I don't help anyone and expect nothing in return.

colin79666

Original Poster:

2,228 posts

144 months

Monday 24th January 2022
quotequote all
Thanks for sharing your tales. Restores some of my faith in humanity, I tend to take things quite personally. Hats off to anyone in a public facing job these days.

Dog Star

17,650 posts

199 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Red9zero said:
My Father tried to help a young girl who had broken down a while back and she just screamed at him to get away from her as he was approaching her.
This happened to one of my best mates - woman locked herself into her car going hysterical. Personally I wouldn’t even consider stopping to help a lone female. Anyone else, no problem.

I did once see at some lights in the lane next to me a chap and his wife, kid in child seat in the back, scrap heap of a Focus. Back wheel held on with one bolt. Beeped, got his attention and pointed this out. “What the fk has it got to do with you?” rolleyes

off_again

13,917 posts

265 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I've offered and been asked for help - I carry a can of tire sealant, jump cables and I did have a tow rope until I broke it....

Never had an issue with it and I have changed peoples tires, jumped their cars and dragged a car out of a ditch before. Conversely, when I was waiting 3 hours with my sons car to be picked up when it broke down, had a few people come up and offer help, which was nice.

Second Best

6,536 posts

212 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I've stopped and offered assistance quite a few times - if I'm not in a rush, doesn't take long just to stop and ask "everything okay?" Most of the time I get told thanks but it's all in hand, no problems there.

Sometimes I've pushed a car out of a live carriageway or stopped to offer assistance/advice, nothing amazing but again, a smile and a thank you, sometimes a handshake, everybody goes away happy.

Never had a negative reaction when I've offered help but I remember offering help to someone trying to change their wipers in a Halfords car park (in the pissing rain) and making a mess of it. I said I'd happily do it for them, the lady said ok here you go and got in her car. Once I was done, I gave her the thumbs up and turned around to put her old wipers in the bin... and she just drove off. Not a word of thanks! That annoyed me.

I remember another time I saw a car parked on the side of a motorway in an unusual place, guy stood beside it looking as if he was thinking of something. I stopped to help and as I got nearer, he looked over very confused. He was having a piss.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I've helped a few people over the years and all but one have been very grateful & polite people.

There was one woman whose car wouldn't start in a supermarket car park. I offered to help & she said she'd just picked the car up from a garage plus it had been to a different garage previously as it wouldn't start. It took two seconds to spot that the (obviously new) battery wasn't well secured and the live terminal had at least 3 additional leads stacked on top with some additional ring connectors hanging off the side. With barely a few millimetres of movement the live could touch the inner wing/slam panel!

After a quick rewire with cleaned terminals I had a random allen key bolt that was the correct size for the battery retainer. I checked the state of the wiring to the starter and the trigger wire was barely attached by a few strands of wire. It took barely a minute to crimp a new terminal on.

Turned the key - INSTANT start up, it was a summers day, I was rewarded with ice cream & Capri Sunssmile

Another woman missed out on me changing her wheel because she was rude. I was walking home for lunch and spotted her at the side of the road with the "widow maker" on a slanted surface nor on the correct section of sill. She was knelt down trying to figure out how the jack goes up, from the other side of the road I asked if she needed any help. Her head span around so quick, like a freaked out owl & she snarled "my husband is on his way."

She'd stopped right outside my house & there was a trolley jack in the boot of my car, she could have been on the move in 5 minutes. Instead she was waiting quite a while, long enough for me to have a sandwich, walk the dog & wash the carbiglaugh

RealityGap

15 posts

190 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
As a lone female, who is often out in the car alone please, please don't stop offering to help. I do get the women over reacting to offers of help from men, it can be a touch intimidating when it happens, but there are lots of us that would be hugely grateful. I like to think of myself as fairly independent and can change a tyre, and jump start the car but the offer of help even if it is just someone friendly to discourage other blokes who may not be so harmless from approaching would be really appreciated!

Chief Rocka

19 posts

60 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
Lady exiting Cheshire Oaks was politely beeped pointed and waved at to stop but she started mouthing something and gesturing so got left on her way.
Chances are when she got home then looked for her handbag and couldn’t find it she would put 2+2 together it was on the roof of her car

randomeddy

1,633 posts

168 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I am a 'helper' but my wife is the opposite. Oh just leave it, they will be OK sort of attitude.

I do what I think is the right thing, I am not looking for thanks or praise I am just happy that I did what I did.

We were driving down a country road and saw an older guy walking the other way, he stood out because there was no pavement and he looked out of sorts. Half a mile further on there was a car up on its jack, straight away I knew he had been unable to remove the wheel bolts as it was a similar car to ours and they seem to tighten themselves in. I have a telescopic wheel brace thingy.

I spun round and picked him up much to my wife's protests, five minutes later he was on his way.
I had a warm fuzzy feeling all day knowing I had done the right thing.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

217 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
In the first lockdown, I was driving to my dad's with some shopping and came across an MX5 parked in the road in a narrow lane, just before a passing place. I could see the occupants apparently crouched in front of the car.

Thinking they were in difficulties, and also because there was very little room to pass, I slowdown and asked if everything was OK.

The reply from the man was "why don't you just fk off?", just as I realised he and his female passenger had stopped to have a picnic on folding chairs in the passing place.

I may have fked off in a way that sprayed them with gravel.

slipknotted

258 posts

68 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I used to stop and help stranded motorists quite often when I carried a full toolbox in the back of my car (kind of necessary when you drive a 25yr old stbox). I've helped a few people change wheels, put strangers' windscreen wipers on in Halfords carparks more than once, bodged repairs on my mates cars after they've damaged them driving like d*cks and and jumped my dad's car a few times. Nowadays with my reliable little Skoda I don't carry around the toolbox (to my shame I don't even have a jack) so there's f*ck all I could do to help most people so I spare them the hassle of me stopping. One guy did come and ask me if I could jump his car last month so that made me feel like a pillar of the community lmao.

When I ditched my Suzuki Swift as an 18yr old a taxi driver stopped to make sure we were ok and a local drove past and came back with a flask of tea and some mugs, which made the 4hr wait for recovery much nicer, what a fine chap. Apart from that I've been lucky enough to avoid being stranded so far.

Baldchap

9,639 posts

123 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I stop to help bikers, but not cars.

Rightly or wrongly I tend to assume most car breakdowns are the result of lazy maintenance or a lack of mechanical sympathy and just assume the drivers are idiots. One day it'll be me and I'll realise that st happens. laugh

SidewaysSi

10,742 posts

265 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
If you look a bit weird or may come across as someone up to no good then please don't try to "help" someone...

The reactions from other motorists may be understandable... smile

r1ch

2,956 posts

227 months

Tuesday 25th January 2022
quotequote all
I've changed tyres for people in the past and they've been very grateful for the help. Breaking down can be stressful, hope the ones who are rude feel bad about it later on.