VW parts - warranty issue. VAT registered mechanic only?
VW parts - warranty issue. VAT registered mechanic only?
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
Hi all,

Just a quick question. Purchased a ton of parts from local VW including water pump kit in June 2020.

Car has a horrendous squeal/pulley noise from the engine bay and I had to call out the breakdown. They confirmed it's the water pump.

Rang VW who asked for a copy of the original invoice (which I have) and a copy of the invoice from mechanic who must be VAT registered.

Thing is, my local mechanic who fitted it isn't VAT registered. It's been 18+ months (parts come with 24 month warranty), and VW never said it has to be fitted by a VAT registered garage at the time of purchase?

To make it more confusing, the VW branch at the time was Smith Knight Fay, and now it's Swansway.

Are they correct or is this something that's a load of crap? Does the mechanic have to VAT registered to prove his competency? What's the best way to resolve this? Fight or accept it and look to get it replaced at full cost to myself?

Inchcape VW were much more helpful. ( I rang them in error as Swansway said the branch used to be Inchcape). They said if you purchased a part from us, and it failed. We would fit and replace free of charge. No mechanic invoices needed.

What to do?

ConnectionError

2,389 posts

100 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
Standard for all warranty's I have ever had.

Must be VAT registered..

Suck it up and move on with a lesson learnt unfortnuatly


Having read this again, I thought it was for a car warranty claim, not for the parts.

So the above thoughts based on a different situation I think?

Edited by ConnectionError on Thursday 27th January 13:32

waynecyclist

14,884 posts

145 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
ConnectionError said:
Standard for all warranty's I have ever had.

Must be VAT registered..

Suck it up and move on with a lesson learnt unfortnuatly


Having read this again, I thought it was for a car warranty claim, not for the parts.

So the above thoughts based on a different situation I think?

Edited by ConnectionError on Thursday 27th January 13:32
It will be the same for parts warranty, parts have to be fitted by a registered business.

You have to provide a copy of the invoice when submitting the claim.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
Yeah it's just the parts.

I have the original invoice from VW which includes VAT.

I have an invoice from a local garage who fitted the part, but isn't VAT registered.

the cueball

1,930 posts

86 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
I think a lot of the time the VAT registered thing is just a catch all for them actually meaning "professionally fitted"...

You can of course be a professional mechanic without being VAT registered... just as anyone can be VAT registered without being a mechanic..

I would clarify with them what they actually mean.


anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
the cueball said:
I think a lot of the time the VAT registered thing is just a catch all for them actually meaning "professionally fitted"...

You can of course be a professional mechanic without being VAT registered... just as anyone can be VAT registered without being a mechanic..

I would clarify with them what they actually mean.
I did raise this, saying the mechanic has loads of city and guild type certificates, has an online presence and a registered business address (a proper garage with 4 lifts). He is on Google etc. But just not VAT registered.



paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
If his annual turnover is below the threshold to be required to be VAT registered then whilst he COULD choose to be registered (voluntary registraation) he doesn't have to be.
Common with a lot of small businesses - me included. Sometimes it can be an advantage but you then have to charge VAT so it puts 20% on your customers bills.
But if the T&C's of the place you bought the parts from state that the person/business fitting your parts has to be VAT registered I'm not sure if - or how - you could get round it.

Had the garage supplied & fitted the part then the onus would be on them to make a warranty claim with their suppliers & your issue would be with the garage.
It's an unfortunate consequence of supplying the parts yourself.

98elise

32,902 posts

192 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
paintman said:
If his annual turnover is below the threshold to be required to be VAT registered then whilst he COULD choose to be registered (voluntary registraation) he doesn't have to be.
Common with a lot of small businesses - me included. Sometimes it can be an advantage but you then have to charge VAT so it puts 20% on your customers bills.
But if the T&C's of the place you bought the parts from state that the person/business fitting your parts has to be VAT registered I'm not sure if - or how - you could get round it.

Had the garage supplied & fitted the part then the onus would be on them to make a warranty claim with their suppliers & your issue would be with the garage.
It's an unfortunate consequence of supplying the parts yourself.
I'd be amazed if a local garage didn't hit the turnover threshold for VAT. £350 a day would hit that assuming it's only open 5 days week.

The OP says they have 4 lifts, so it's not a one man band operation.



paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
Something I'm wondering too!

Canon_Fodder

1,775 posts

94 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
This sounds like a load of rubbish to me OP

What on earth have the mechanic's tax arrangements got to do with the failed component?

Competency is the key in this case and he seems to past that test to any reasonable external observer.

That said, does the warranty paperwork mention this VAT reg issue?

waynecyclist

14,884 posts

145 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
MuddyK said:
I did raise this, saying the mechanic has loads of city and guild type certificates, has an online presence and a registered business address (a proper garage with 4 lifts). He is on Google etc. But just not VAT registered.
How can he be running a garage with 4 lifts and not be vat registered scratchchin

Dynion Araf Uchaf

5,203 posts

254 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
Canon_Fodder said:
This sounds like a load of rubbish to me OP

What on earth have the mechanic's tax arrangements got to do with the failed component?

Competency is the key in this case and he seems to past that test to any reasonable external observer.

That said, does the warranty paperwork mention this VAT reg issue?
the VAT element is to prove that the parts were fitted with a documented invoice trail to back it up. In terms of this issue, IIRC, the warranty is for the parts, however these normally require fitting, and it's not unknown for customers to claim failed part and claim back the labour for work they did themselves.

Now depending upon what the OP wants, he might be able to get the parts cost returned under warranty / or new parts, but won't be able to claim the cost of removal/refitting.

I suggest he explains this to the dealer. The fact that the dealer has changed hands is irrelevant for many reasons.

ant427

166 posts

170 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
Cash only

Canon_Fodder

1,775 posts

94 months

Thursday 27th January 2022
quotequote all
Dynion Araf Uchaf said:
Now depending upon what the OP wants, he might be able to get the parts cost returned under warranty / or new parts, but won't be able to claim the cost of removal/refitting.
.
Yes, I'd presumed that the OP only wants the part replacing - perhaps he could clarify in due course?



98elise

32,902 posts

192 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
waynecyclist said:
MuddyK said:
I did raise this, saying the mechanic has loads of city and guild type certificates, has an online presence and a registered business address (a proper garage with 4 lifts). He is on Google etc. But just not VAT registered.
How can he be running a garage with 4 lifts and not be vat registered scratchchin
You would struggle to do that operating out of a van let alone a 4 lift garage.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
Canon_Fodder said:
Yes, I'd presumed that the OP only wants the part replacing - perhaps he could clarify in due course?
Very much so. I don't expect free fitting as I never had it fitted by VW.

Made some progress with the local main dealer who seems to have eased off the vat invoice demand.

Has now asked for the original parts invoice, as the invoice I have says " y deposit" _ £553.xx + VAT = £664.xx

So I said this is what I was given at the time of purchase. I have 4 printouts from ETKA with my VIN number on it which show the different parts I purchased at the time in a drawing/sketch with a pen circling the parts I ordered, a receipt from the chip and pin device, an this letterhead invoice from VW but it doesn't say the actual parts I purchased. Just " y deposit"

So now they've asked me to ring Inchcape, provide what I have to them, and ask Inchcape VW to provide me with a copy of the invoice detailing the parts on a listed invoice, and then submit that invoice to Swansway VW (because they cannot access the system/records from the previous branch they took over from)

Another headache. Luckily Inchcape have been very helpful over the phone and have confirmed no need for invoices from mechanic etc. If part failed, part failed we would have replaced it for you. Sent the invoices via email today to the super helpful guy who works in the parts department at Inchcape Stockport, who will now look into it from his system and will hopefully be able to dig out an actual invoice of parts as opposed to the one that was given to me that says "y deposit" and details the total amount.

Little Pete

1,926 posts

125 months

Friday 28th January 2022
quotequote all
In my experience of dealing with VAG over warranty claims, they just take the car in and replace any failed items. However, they do usually say that if the part has failed due to incorrect fitting, the warranty is void and you will be invoiced for parts and labour.