Do you still love your dream car if…
Do you still love your dream car if…
Author
Discussion

whp1983

Original Poster:

1,414 posts

170 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
It doesn’t have an engine but is EV instead?

I was sat recently and an R8 and a 458 went by…. Both cars I very much like. I was thinking if I still love the aesthetics and the specialness of being sat in them and if they drove immensely well as they do now…. Would they still be a dream car without the engine? In short minus gear change (auto or otherwise) and critically the noise and crescendo of built up speed towards a redline.

Is your dream car still your dream car if it’s silent?

mmm-five

12,403 posts

315 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
What if your dream car is an EV, like an Evija or Rimac CTwo or Nio EP9?

They can always do what the big manufacturers are already doing, and add fake exhaust/engine noises to the hi-fi.

georgeyboy12345

4,671 posts

66 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
For me, no, because the engine is what makes the car so special in the first place.

My dream car is a Ferrari 512 TR from the early 90s.

Bennet

2,133 posts

162 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
I wouldn't buy an F355 if someone had converted it into a BEV, no.

bunchofkeys

1,312 posts

99 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
Nope.

The idea of dream car with out the drama, charisma and noise of a V12 or V8 would be very much remove it from the "dream car" list.
I feel it would be a soulless box from getting my from point A to B, which are not on said list.
Fake engine noises being pumped through the speakers are naff too, it sounds awful and i pulled the plug on my X5M.

It would be like having a dream girl wanting you, but you could only look at her.





Edited by bunchofkeys on Sunday 30th January 13:21

Chubbyross

5,019 posts

116 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
It’s a really interesting question. My car would be a Miura. I would happily have one just sitting in a garage forever. It wouldn’t matter if I couldn’t drive it. Just knowing I owned one would be enough. Would I feel the same if it was electric? Definitely not. I’d want the whole car in its original entirety. To me it would no longer be a perfect Miura. Its soul would somehow be missing. It would be like stuffing a beloved family pet after it dies.

boombang

551 posts

205 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
Wouldn't bother me at all.

When the tech is there, range good, charging faster, weight down etc. I am expecting some amazing things from companies like Lotus.

One of our cars is an EV though so I see both the merits and issues near enough daily. Most of the reasons a lot of people resist moving to an EV either aren't a reality or don't impact us given how we use it and our situation.

MDL111

8,941 posts

208 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
For me that is a clear no, the engine is what makes the car for me. My favorites are Carrera GT ans 250 SWB followed by the F50 and possibly Zonda

The spinner of plates

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
No, a dream fun car I buy for pleasure will always have a petrol engine up front, driven wheels at the back and manual gear change in between.

But I’ll happily do all of my ‘travelling’ miles in a practical, safe, relaxing EV. No problem with that all.


Edited by The spinner of plates on Sunday 30th January 14:03

Geffg

1,348 posts

136 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
No. I think most of us have grown up to think of supercars / performance cars to have an engine and the sound of power. To me no engine noise detracts partly from that attraction and it’s only down to pure aesthetics rather than engine etc. I’d love a mustang v8 for the noise, make it electric and I’d lose interest.

ZX10R NIN

30,663 posts

156 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
For me the engine (not faked noise pumped in adds to the specialness of my cars) things like the Rimac are no doubt very special cars but because my car has a grunty V8 that feels special when I'm doing 30mph (not all petrol cars can do this either) as well as when I'm doing many leptons.

That's the one area where EV's don't quite cut it yet for me.

NDNDNDND

2,546 posts

214 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all

MitchT

17,167 posts

240 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
georgeyboy12345 said:
For me, no, because the engine is what makes the car so special in the first place.

My dream car is a Ferrari 512 TR from the early 90s.
I was about to write exactly the same about the Testarossa.

stef1808

1,036 posts

188 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
Not at all but since were dreaming I would love something like a F355 with a small electric battery to take over to keep the v8 for when I’m out of the city etc. Not possible with today’s batteries weight but maybe one day

Chubbyross

5,019 posts

116 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
The spinner of plates said:
No, a dream fun car I buy for pleasure will always have a petrol engine up front, driven wheels at the back and manual gear change in between.

But I’ll happily do all of my ‘travelling’ miles in a practical, safe, relaxing EV. No problem with that all.


Edited by The spinner of plates on Sunday 30th January 14:03
Yep. Same here. If I needed a car to do a boring A-Z journey then I’d be more than happy with an EV but for fun driving it would always have to be petrol. I'm not getting out of bed early on a Saturday or Sunday just for roaring tyre noise and a whining motor.

LesXRN

771 posts

150 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
My Vanquish just wouldn't be the same without that glorious V12 sound.

rjfp1962

9,394 posts

104 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
No. And mine is only a 2018 MX-5 2 Litre - So no great noise... obviously, but it has a sweet 6 speed manual gearbox.... biggrin
I wouldn't mind an F-Type V8 Roadster though, if the dream was to get even nearer to reality....!

Jasandjules

72,703 posts

260 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
No, the noise of a V8 or V12 is not something to be lost.

Geffg

1,348 posts

136 months

Sunday 30th January 2022
quotequote all
MitchT said:
georgeyboy12345 said:
For me, no, because the engine is what makes the car so special in the first place.

My dream car is a Ferrari 512 TR from the early 90s.
I was about to write exactly the same about the Testarossa.
My ultimate dream car is the Testarossa too. Realistic is the v8 mustang but something about the Testarossa!! My childhood dream. I remember there used used to be a garage on the road into north wales called two mills that used to always have really good cars and one day they had one for sale. Got my dad to stop there and we went in to have a look. Made my day completely. Never even sat in one but will always be my dream.
Maybe one day when I win loads of money I’ll own one.

Fonzo

152 posts

90 months

Monday 31st January 2022
quotequote all
Absolutely not.