Motor oil reviews?
Discussion
anonymous said:
[redacted]
The review system on Amazon is a farce.I bought a product that, to cut a very long story short, was useless, and not only fell blatantly short of the advertised specification, but was completely unfit for purpose. It then failed completely after just a few uses.
Seller was good initially and was happy for me to return it for a full refund. This all went smoothly, and I left a 3 star review saying that I didn't recommend the product at all, but the seller was good and I'd have no worries using them again.
The seller then started messaging me daily asking me if I would "kindly withdraw the review, or amend for more positive reflection", even offering me free stuff in exchange for this suggested dishonesty. I ignored it for a while, then I decided I would amend the review. I added that "after submitting this review, I have been subjected to repeated messages from the seller asking me to edit or remove the review. I can provide a full comms trail if anyone doubts this or is interested." It went quiet then.
Reported the seller to Amazon, but heard absolutely nothing back. Last time I checked they were still on there.
One place you may find useful reviews is on the Bob is the Oil Guy forums: https://bobistheoilguy.com/forums/
It's mainly US based, but many posters have a used oil analysis carried ou on their engine oil to see how it's performing.
It's mainly US based, but many posters have a used oil analysis carried ou on their engine oil to see how it's performing.
Don't get me started on Amazon reviews, the questions and answers are bad enough.
ie windscreen frost cover, question ''will this fit a VW Toerag?'' answer ''its fits my Yaris''
i mean are these people all there or in need of a care in the communtiy order, i hasetn to add not the person asking if it fits the VW, perfectly fair question.
Oh yes and lest i forget.
Car reviews, i read a diatribe once on how awful this bods Citroen C5 had been, endless list of faults and useless workshops...and the new one is no better.
Could you imagine one of those reviewing oil.
ie windscreen frost cover, question ''will this fit a VW Toerag?'' answer ''its fits my Yaris''
i mean are these people all there or in need of a care in the communtiy order, i hasetn to add not the person asking if it fits the VW, perfectly fair question.
Oh yes and lest i forget.
Car reviews, i read a diatribe once on how awful this bods Citroen C5 had been, endless list of faults and useless workshops...and the new one is no better.
Could you imagine one of those reviewing oil.
Edited by Smint on Tuesday 1st February 16:37
Edited by Smint on Tuesday 1st February 16:37
Edited by Smint on Tuesday 1st February 16:38
Baldchap said:
My favourite is the questions on Amazon...
Q: Does this product work in a car?
A: I don't know, I don't think own this product.
Q: Does this product work in a car?
A: I don't know, I don't think own this product.

Those reviews puzzled me until one day I received an email from Amazon saying "remember that thing you bought? Someone has a question... Help a Bezos out and answer the man". Until then I thought people were going on Amazon, seeing a question and answering "I don't know".
Presumably it's someone who thinks they are being asked directly and that it would be impolite to ignore it.
I saw a review on an online retailer which was "I really like this product, I wanted to give it 5 stars but I like to click each star individually and their stupid website thought I was giving it 1 star and took me straight to the comments page"... One to consider for anyone who does user interface design; some people like to turn each star on.
Worth a few minutes reading Amazon reviews for Veet hair remover.
Particularly those chaps who have tried it on the meat and two veg.
here's a classic https://www.thepoke.co.uk/2019/07/19/this-poor-guy...
Particularly those chaps who have tried it on the meat and two veg.
here's a classic https://www.thepoke.co.uk/2019/07/19/this-poor-guy...
Edited by Smint on Tuesday 1st February 17:02
I've had a few deliveries from Amazon with a card inside saying to fill in a 5 star review and they will send you a free gift, you basically have to just send them a screenshot, I purchased a plug charger for about £12 and was offered an LED floodlight worth £23 for a positive review.
Very strange
Very strange
Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


