Discussion
I'm not talking about impressive 0-60 times, more the usual cut and thrust of getting where you're going on today's busy roads where one requires an ability to emerge from a junction a pubic hair in front of a car and disappear into the distance before he's lifted off the throttle and uttered "cheeky bugger".
New cars, no matter how powerful or how impressive their on-paper acceleration figures are seem incapable of the task.
It's all soft limiters and flat spots. My new Golf has a very similar power to weight ratio to a Passat Mk5 110TDI I ran 25 years ago yet feels a lot slower and a lot less responsive.
What's gone wrong and what cars buck this trend leaving them able shoot off from stationary like stabbed rats?
New cars, no matter how powerful or how impressive their on-paper acceleration figures are seem incapable of the task.
It's all soft limiters and flat spots. My new Golf has a very similar power to weight ratio to a Passat Mk5 110TDI I ran 25 years ago yet feels a lot slower and a lot less responsive.
What's gone wrong and what cars buck this trend leaving them able shoot off from stationary like stabbed rats?
I've criticised the Saab 9-5 Aero HOT a lot on here as the cheap interior was horrible and a number of other things which I won't go into again...
However, once sport mode was turned on to make the automatic gearbox start in 1st gear I don't believe it had any of that softness or torque limiting functionality so if you wanted to leave the line fast enough to crack the gearbox it would just do it.
However, it would be 14 year old car if I had it today so maybe it doesn't pass the test because that model is just so old now.
However, once sport mode was turned on to make the automatic gearbox start in 1st gear I don't believe it had any of that softness or torque limiting functionality so if you wanted to leave the line fast enough to crack the gearbox it would just do it.
However, it would be 14 year old car if I had it today so maybe it doesn't pass the test because that model is just so old now.
CoreyDog said:
Easy solution. Get a motorbike.
Barely any cars on the road that can keep up with me off the mark and I've forgotten what sat in traffic is like with having the ability to filter. My commute dropped from 20 minutes to 11 by just using the bike.
Plus ten minutes faffing for each journey Barely any cars on the road that can keep up with me off the mark and I've forgotten what sat in traffic is like with having the ability to filter. My commute dropped from 20 minutes to 11 by just using the bike.

Krikkit said:
CoreyDog said:
Easy solution. Get a motorbike.
Barely any cars on the road that can keep up with me off the mark and I've forgotten what sat in traffic is like with having the ability to filter. My commute dropped from 20 minutes to 11 by just using the bike.
Plus ten minutes faffing for each journey Barely any cars on the road that can keep up with me off the mark and I've forgotten what sat in traffic is like with having the ability to filter. My commute dropped from 20 minutes to 11 by just using the bike.


The spinner of plates said:
Most EVs are able to shoot off from stationary like stabbed rats.
Most modern ICE cars are heavily bogged down by emissions controls...
I thought the limitations were in place to stop you blowing up the gearbox and asking for a warranty replacement after 3 months? That and to aid comfort. Most modern ICE cars are heavily bogged down by emissions controls...
Modern cars are expressely set up and calibrated to be smooth and quiet. I suspect this makes one think they are "slower" than old cars.
However, they are not. A typical modern passenger car may well have a mass that is 30% to 50% higher than an old one (mk2 golf gti ~1,000 kg, m8k golf gti, ~1,400 kg) but they also typically have torque outputs twice as high, ie 200% of the original, and that torque is available at a much lower engine speed (mk2 gti with 168nm @ 4250 rpm vs Mk8 with 370Nm above 1600rpm). And of course a modern car has a gearbox that not only has more gears, is likely to be automated meaning you are really always in the right gear
The difference is that modern cars are more refined, and when you are not driving aggressively, actively reduced engine aggression in order to maximise fuel economy. Back in the day, the engine had one set of maps and setting and that was that, today you have manyh modes, settings and maps.
And finally, modern suspension geometry, traction optimisation and even the chassis control electronics, combined with modern tyres mean a modern car can put down to the road far far more tractive effort than an old one.
All those make a modern car faster everywhere.
Perhaps what the OP should have questioned is why modern cars are not setup and calibrated like old cars, to make them "feel" fast ???
However, they are not. A typical modern passenger car may well have a mass that is 30% to 50% higher than an old one (mk2 golf gti ~1,000 kg, m8k golf gti, ~1,400 kg) but they also typically have torque outputs twice as high, ie 200% of the original, and that torque is available at a much lower engine speed (mk2 gti with 168nm @ 4250 rpm vs Mk8 with 370Nm above 1600rpm). And of course a modern car has a gearbox that not only has more gears, is likely to be automated meaning you are really always in the right gear
The difference is that modern cars are more refined, and when you are not driving aggressively, actively reduced engine aggression in order to maximise fuel economy. Back in the day, the engine had one set of maps and setting and that was that, today you have manyh modes, settings and maps.
And finally, modern suspension geometry, traction optimisation and even the chassis control electronics, combined with modern tyres mean a modern car can put down to the road far far more tractive effort than an old one.
All those make a modern car faster everywhere.
Perhaps what the OP should have questioned is why modern cars are not setup and calibrated like old cars, to make them "feel" fast ???
What engine is in your new Golf? The old 1.9 had nice low down torque, maybe you bought into the 1.6 tdi? The 2.0 tdi cr is nice and punchy, obviously nothing compared to a real performance car, it certainly punches away when needed. Engines especially diesel became emission strangled, VW even updated the maps after their scandel and smoothed the performance. Car's became heavier and chased economy over performance, so gearing for economy over performance, your Golf might even have some faults.
It was a crap car, but my old V6 Omega with an old torque converter slush box was great for nipping out into small gaps.
Not so much power that it had to be limited in 1st, a old TC auto box so it sat there in 1st gear ready to go. And RWD so had good off the line traction.
The only down side was if it was wet the traction control was so intrusive it killed the power and could land you in the s
t.
Not so much power that it had to be limited in 1st, a old TC auto box so it sat there in 1st gear ready to go. And RWD so had good off the line traction.
The only down side was if it was wet the traction control was so intrusive it killed the power and could land you in the s
t. Tannedbaldhead said:
I'm not talking about impressive 0-60 times, more the usual cut and thrust of getting where you're going on today's busy roads where one requires an ability to emerge from a junction a pubic hair in front of a car and disappear into the distance before he's lifted off the throttle and uttered "cheeky bugger".
New cars, no matter how powerful or how impressive their on-paper acceleration figures are seem incapable of the task.
It's all soft limiters and flat spots. My new Golf has a very similar power to weight ratio to a Passat Mk5 110TDI I ran 25 years ago yet feels a lot slower and a lot less responsive.
What's gone wrong and what cars buck this trend leaving them able shoot off from stationary like stabbed rats?
The b5/b5.5 passats also have very peaky power delivery; they’re reasonably capable when fully in to their stride but fairly flat either side of the dollop of power they have in the middle of the Rev range.New cars, no matter how powerful or how impressive their on-paper acceleration figures are seem incapable of the task.
It's all soft limiters and flat spots. My new Golf has a very similar power to weight ratio to a Passat Mk5 110TDI I ran 25 years ago yet feels a lot slower and a lot less responsive.
What's gone wrong and what cars buck this trend leaving them able shoot off from stationary like stabbed rats?
I imagine a modern Passat would trounce a b5.5 away from the line at idling revs.
Anything mundane driven my a special breed of muppet that can do a 60ft time to shame the drag racing greats to get out in front of you, then immediately slow to 10 mph under the posted limit, small MPV's, Honda Jazz's, Micra's etc.
One that impressed me in terms of off the line pace was a Bentley Continental Supersports, you expect it to be fast but was kind of expecting a sort of jet aeroplane experience of gathering acceleration following a stately start. Nope, 650 ish bhp, wads of torque, 4wd and two and a bit tonnes pressin four big tyres down and driving through traditional (very strong) automatic gearbox meant it was second only to a Tesla Model S. You kind of start off and appear 20 meters down the road like you teleported there.
One that impressed me in terms of off the line pace was a Bentley Continental Supersports, you expect it to be fast but was kind of expecting a sort of jet aeroplane experience of gathering acceleration following a stately start. Nope, 650 ish bhp, wads of torque, 4wd and two and a bit tonnes pressin four big tyres down and driving through traditional (very strong) automatic gearbox meant it was second only to a Tesla Model S. You kind of start off and appear 20 meters down the road like you teleported there.
Demelitia said:
Tannedbaldhead said:
I'm not talking about impressive 0-60 times, more the usual cut and thrust of getting where you're going on today's busy roads where one requires an ability to emerge from a junction a pubic hair in front of a car and disappear into the distance before he's lifted off the throttle and uttered "cheeky bugger".
New cars, no matter how powerful or how impressive their on-paper acceleration figures are seem incapable of the task.
It's all soft limiters and flat spots. My new Golf has a very similar power to weight ratio to a Passat Mk5 110TDI I ran 25 years ago yet feels a lot slower and a lot less responsive.
What's gone wrong and what cars buck this trend leaving them able shoot off from stationary like stabbed rats?
The b5/b5.5 passats also have very peaky power delivery; they’re reasonably capable when fully in to their stride but fairly flat either side of the dollop of power they have in the middle of the Rev range.New cars, no matter how powerful or how impressive their on-paper acceleration figures are seem incapable of the task.
It's all soft limiters and flat spots. My new Golf has a very similar power to weight ratio to a Passat Mk5 110TDI I ran 25 years ago yet feels a lot slower and a lot less responsive.
What's gone wrong and what cars buck this trend leaving them able shoot off from stationary like stabbed rats?
I imagine a modern Passat would trounce a b5.5 away from the line at idling revs.
I know exactly what you mean
We Currently run:
- S63 cabrio 650hp twin turbo (lethargic)
- Vanquish S 600hp n/a (less lethargic)
- AMG GTR 720hp twin turbo (the most responsive turbo ive driven)
- iPace 400hp (stupidly responsive)
On any given day in a normal driving > instant response needed situation, then the ev is just there, ready and waiting ALL the time, so much so i run it in snow mode evry time i get in it as it’s annoyingly responsive, brakes also as it happens.
If the GTR is left at 2k and in track mode for faster throttle response then its there with the iPace and teslas ive been in, bit it was designed with inboard turbos for this response (apparently)
I tested an Aventador SVJ recently which is n/a andmthat wasnt as responsive as the gtr, about the same as the Aston actually.
EV all day for this task though, you just dont have to prepare or wait for anything, they just go! and then settle down again as quickly, as a B road passing machine they’re unbeatable, even in 4-500hp guises.
We Currently run:
- S63 cabrio 650hp twin turbo (lethargic)
- Vanquish S 600hp n/a (less lethargic)
- AMG GTR 720hp twin turbo (the most responsive turbo ive driven)
- iPace 400hp (stupidly responsive)
On any given day in a normal driving > instant response needed situation, then the ev is just there, ready and waiting ALL the time, so much so i run it in snow mode evry time i get in it as it’s annoyingly responsive, brakes also as it happens.
If the GTR is left at 2k and in track mode for faster throttle response then its there with the iPace and teslas ive been in, bit it was designed with inboard turbos for this response (apparently)
I tested an Aventador SVJ recently which is n/a andmthat wasnt as responsive as the gtr, about the same as the Aston actually.
EV all day for this task though, you just dont have to prepare or wait for anything, they just go! and then settle down again as quickly, as a B road passing machine they’re unbeatable, even in 4-500hp guises.
Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



Well that is also true! 