Car and insurance for a youth.
Car and insurance for a youth.
Author
Discussion

Louis Balfour

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
We've a youth approaching 17 and he needs a car.

He will need to drive himself and siblings to school as soon as he passes his test, so we don't want him running a £500 shed from Ebay. He also works for our business, so we want something half presentable for when he is seen by customers.

Now, I am torn about all of this. He is a sensible lad, but he is nevertheless a seventeen year old. So do we...

1. Let him pay for the whole show himself.

2. Chip in half.

3. Buy him a car, he insures it.

4. He buys a car, we insure it.

5. Buy another pool car and put him on the company policy. Pray nightly.

6. None of the above.

?


Jamescrs

6,561 posts

96 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
I would say he should have something invested in it to make him think about being responsible for his actions personally, either split total costs with him or let him buy the car and you help out with insurance if you are wanting to assist in some way.

Personally I think if you do it all for him he doesn't have the same appreciation of the cost should be have a lapse of judgement and things go wrong.

All that being said I don't know your lad.

Saleen836

12,530 posts

240 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Louis Balfour said:
3. Buy him a car, he insures it.

4. He buys a car, we insure it.
If you do either of these be prepared for insurance to possibly work out more expensive than the cost of the car, but having insurance in his name will mean he accrues NCB which wil be a big benefit for him

Louis Balfour

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Saleen836 said:
Louis Balfour said:
3. Buy him a car, he insures it.

4. He buys a car, we insure it.
If you do either of these be prepared for insurance to possibly work out more expensive than the cost of the car, but having insurance in his name will mean he accrues NCB which wil be a big benefit for him
Our insurance broker said this.

But I have never, ever known a situation where an insurer won't mirror or gift NCB if pushed. They always start off with "you've got no NCB" but they have ALWAYS done something if you can prove you've driven without issue for X period. So, if we insure and he later wants his own cover, in my experience it's no problem.

James_33

683 posts

97 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Option 1 for me, as nice as it is that you have the option to purchase a car for him, i think people appreciate things more when they've had to work for it themselves.

Certainly worked for me in life, come from a working class background so things were never handed to me anyway, but because i know things are not so easily gained i think it's made me appreciate it more when i do get whatever it is.

Louis Balfour

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
James_33 said:
Option 1 for me, as nice as it is that you have the option to purchase a car for him, i think people appreciate things more when they've had to work for it themselves.

Certainly worked for me in life, come from a working class background so things were never handed to me anyway, but because i know things are not so easily gained i think it's made me appreciate it more when i do get whatever it is.
I was in the same situation. My first car cost £175 and it wasn't THAT long ago.

But I am not persuaded that struggling as a young person bestows any benefit. I knew plenty of lads whose parents helped them, who were thoroughly decent and responsible people.


Spare tyre

12,752 posts

161 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Simple picanto and insurance

If he doesn’t bend it, it should be roughly what you paid for it, review after a year

fatjon

2,299 posts

244 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
If the insurance is for business use the business should pay it and it’s a tax deductable cost. It would be barking to pay it out of taxed personal income.

I put my lad in a Ranger, leased to the company, insured by company. Benefit in kind is minimal as it counts as a van and it’s not a peanut sized death trap. Even with company paying for fuel the BIK is next to nothing.


Emily's dad

277 posts

167 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
My daughter has just passed her test, I bought and insured her first car for her.

£3500 Hyundai i10 which costs £950 to insure.

She’s studying hard for A levels and has a part time job so she can put some money away for uni later in the year, so I was prepared to get her on the road.

She appreciates what it has cost, as I involved her in the scouring Autotrader looking for suitable cars and getting on line to get insurance quotes.
She’s over the moon with her little car, and the freedom it gives her.

I was happy to pick up the tab, she and all teenagers have had a terrible couple of years of home schooling, missing social events, just at the point in life when they are starting to grown into young adults.
Her passing her test and the life event it represents to her was worth my outlay.

Only trouble is youngest is 17 later this year, it’s going to cost me another 5 grand.


Louis Balfour

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
fatjon said:
If the insurance is for business use the business should pay it and it’s a tax deductable cost. It would be barking to pay it out of taxed personal income.

I put my lad in a Ranger, leased to the company, insured by company. Benefit in kind is minimal as it counts as a van and it’s not a peanut sized death trap. Even with company paying for fuel the BIK is next to nothing.
How much does it cost, out of interest?

Haltamer

2,679 posts

111 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
If you're wanting him to run siblings etc. as well as company work, It seems right to me that you'd buy it for him - Otherwise you're forcing him to spend more than he may desire.

Of those options, Number 5 sounds most amicable for all involved and would give you reasonable agency to choose something modern and safe.

James_33

683 posts

97 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Louis Balfour said:
James_33 said:
Option 1 for me, as nice as it is that you have the option to purchase a car for him, i think people appreciate things more when they've had to work for it themselves.

Certainly worked for me in life, come from a working class background so things were never handed to me anyway, but because i know things are not so easily gained i think it's made me appreciate it more when i do get whatever it is.
I was in the same situation. My first car cost £175 and it wasn't THAT long ago.

But I am not persuaded that struggling as a young person bestows any benefit. I knew plenty of lads whose parents helped them, who were thoroughly decent and responsible people.
Oh on the contrary, I never struggled (as such) I think i just took that bit more pride in the fact that i had bought my first car myself, through the paltry wages i was on at the time as a then 17 year old (20 years ago) ok it was only a Citroen AX that cost me £700 with the insurance being 3x that, but it was a bit more of an eye opener to how much other things cost, and something i have kind of placed into my own children's heads that to have things nice in life you've got to work hard for them.

I think if i had to say another option other than option 1 then i would say maybe help him with the insurance, rather than buying the car??

fatjon

2,299 posts

244 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
The lease is about 400/month. Y1 insurance was 2.5k but he’s now in year 3 with no claims or tickets and it’s about 1.2k

It’s dear for the company but if I paid it out of my pocket it’s money I already got taxed on so in round numbers it’s plus 40% and no VAT reclaim so even dearer again. The big plus is he’s in a safe and presentable motor which were my two main considerations. If he’s a sensible lad and business can stand it then it’s a possible solution with some financial advantages.


Louis Balfour

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
fatjon said:
The lease is about 400/month. Y1 insurance was 2.5k but he’s now in year 3 with no claims or tickets and it’s about 1.2k

It’s dear for the company but if I paid it out of my pocket it’s money I already got taxed on so in round numbers it’s plus 40% and no VAT reclaim so even dearer again. The big plus is he’s in a safe and presentable motor which were my two main considerations. If he’s a sensible lad and business can stand it then it’s a possible solution with some financial advantages.
We could do this. But £5kpa in more than I would ideally like to spend.

I could insist that he has it sign written so that advertising would offset the cost. He doesn't know yet about the new chemical toilet emptying business we are opening. wink



TwigtheWonderkid

49,308 posts

181 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
Louis Balfour said:
He also works for our business, so we want something half presentable for when he is seen by customers.
No one cares anymore. Plenty of millionaires drive Smart cars and plenty of skint people lease Mercedes. We live in an age where your car says less about you than it's ever done.

Louis Balfour

Original Poster:

28,176 posts

253 months

Sunday 6th February 2022
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
Louis Balfour said:
He also works for our business, so we want something half presentable for when he is seen by customers.
No one cares anymore. Plenty of millionaires drive Smart cars and plenty of skint people lease Mercedes. We live in an age where your car says less about you than it's ever done.
A £500 Mini with Carlos Fandangos and fat exhaust is not the image we seek to project.



daqinggregg

5,335 posts

160 months

Monday 7th February 2022
quotequote all
When it comes to choosing a car have a look at some a bit left field, not the normal teenage fodder. There was a PH member, who got his son a Volvo C30 as the insurance was favorable when compared to the usual candidates.

Jayho

2,442 posts

201 months

Monday 7th February 2022
quotequote all
Haltamer said:
If you're wanting him to run siblings etc. as well as company work, It seems right to me that you'd buy it for him - Otherwise you're forcing him to spend more than he may desire.
This. As soon as you've put an obligation to him for his car its no longer fully his car.

If he's already agreed that he'll help chauffeur the siblings and already helping out at your business, maybe he's already got a suitable level of maturity and care for things?

How close are his siblings to driving age? Maybe buy something like a polo or golf through the business and it can be everyone's first car? With some sort of caveat that he should buy his own once the next sibling turns 17?