VW Main Dealer service shocker
Discussion
VW Amarok, Full VW Service history. Around two years ago whilst still under warranty and engine warning light came on. My local VW dealership diagnosed the faulty O2 sensor and booked it in to be replaced.
During the day, I was informed by the service receptionist that there was a problem-the threads that the O2 sensor had to be screwed into were damaged. "so you cross threaded the new sensor then?" I asked to be answered, "err probably-it'll need a new exhaust part to fix but we'll cover that."
Fair enough.
Now a few months ago, the vehicle started feeling and sounding different. No warning lights but I knew something was up. Books it in for it's 4 year service at my indy and he texts this photo first thing in the morning;

"Don't tell me, an O2 sensor?"
Aye, and it and the receptacle for it are threaded and both damaged. The other thing is there's no fault code for what is a glaring fault so it's been coded out.
So they've blatantly dodged the job to try and fix it and rather than replacing the part under warranty, have coded out the fault to make like it doesn't exist and not done what they said they would.
Oh and the pollen filter hadn't been changed since it was new.
I add again, this vehicle had only seen my local franchised dealer since new.
I know I'm pissing in the wind but f
king hell, how shoddy is that? These cowboys have blatantly ripped me off and as it happened so long ago there's pretty much no recourse. So a minor rant on PH is my only option (being careful not to name the particular franchised dealer).

During the day, I was informed by the service receptionist that there was a problem-the threads that the O2 sensor had to be screwed into were damaged. "so you cross threaded the new sensor then?" I asked to be answered, "err probably-it'll need a new exhaust part to fix but we'll cover that."
Fair enough.
Now a few months ago, the vehicle started feeling and sounding different. No warning lights but I knew something was up. Books it in for it's 4 year service at my indy and he texts this photo first thing in the morning;
"Don't tell me, an O2 sensor?"
Aye, and it and the receptacle for it are threaded and both damaged. The other thing is there's no fault code for what is a glaring fault so it's been coded out.
So they've blatantly dodged the job to try and fix it and rather than replacing the part under warranty, have coded out the fault to make like it doesn't exist and not done what they said they would.
Oh and the pollen filter hadn't been changed since it was new.
I add again, this vehicle had only seen my local franchised dealer since new.
I know I'm pissing in the wind but f
king hell, how shoddy is that? These cowboys have blatantly ripped me off and as it happened so long ago there's pretty much no recourse. So a minor rant on PH is my only option (being careful not to name the particular franchised dealer).
Scrump said:
That is shocking. I am really glad I have trusted local indies for my cars.
Have you spoken to the VW dealer?
I haven't Scrump. Full disclosure, they're useless but while the vehicle was under warranty I figured I might as well-how bad could they get.Have you spoken to the VW dealer?
And I get thatchings go wrong and staff let your business down but this is plain... I don't know what? Fraud?
I am going to get in touch with them but I expect absolutely nothing from them but "we can't prove that that happened during our service". I'm just more amazed that any business would do something so.. wrong!
Sensibleboy said:
So the knackered sensor was just refitted but disabled?
If the threads were knackered were they still able to hold the sensor without exhaust gas escaping? Why didn't they just fit a new sensor?
My mechanic re-tapped the threads and fitted a new sensor. Going off the fact I felt the vehicle was noisier, they refitted them broken sensor cross threaded and left it to fall out, thinking I wouldn’t know as they’d coded out any fault that sensor could give.If the threads were knackered were they still able to hold the sensor without exhaust gas escaping? Why didn't they just fit a new sensor?
The only clue to me was a rushing of air from the transmission tunnel-I thought it was a fan fault!
We have an Indy we use regularly, they’ve let us down a couple of times recently, things not being right first time and costing the same or more than VW would.
Only at the weekend I said maybe at it’s next device we should take it to VW and also get the CarPlay coded in/enabled. Perhaps we’ll do that in isolation.
Only at the weekend I said maybe at it’s next device we should take it to VW and also get the CarPlay coded in/enabled. Perhaps we’ll do that in isolation.
LaurasOtherHalf said:
On the left is the pollen filter that went into my car, on the right is the one VW “installed” at my last service just under 2 years and 15k miles ago.
I don’t know the difference apart from mankyness, my mechanics opinion is it’s never been changed since being built.
wyson said:
LaurasOtherHalf said:
I’m shocked at the state of that filter. I change out my pollen filter every year and they come out a touch grey with a couple of leaves, nothing like yours! CarCrazyDad said:
Complain to dealer principal.
I'm going to, in some ways this thread is a pre-emptive strike as I figured someone might post a reason why this could have happened innocently.But myself and my mechanic can only come up with what we have found. And he's not naive, when he showed me the pollen filter he admitted he took on a main dealer mechanic once (he's a VW specialist) who he had reservations about. On his day off they looked behind his trolley and found all the discarded pollen filters.
Sacked on return.
glennjamin said:
Had my Passat in for recall on injectors,asked if while stripped down fuel filter could be replaced. I was shocked to be given a bill for £43 just to fit fuel filter.
I'd have expected more than that. Mind you, they only change it every four years but charge you for it every two!Dealer bashing, again? Is it against the law for them to earn a living?
Yes, I am only kidding.
Whenever somebody starts a thread like this, all the PH main dealer protectors come out of the woodwork with lame-ass logic as to why the dealer hasn't done anything wrong. They will, literally, try and defend the indefensible.
Yes, I am only kidding.
Whenever somebody starts a thread like this, all the PH main dealer protectors come out of the woodwork with lame-ass logic as to why the dealer hasn't done anything wrong. They will, literally, try and defend the indefensible.
evil.edna said:
Dealer bashing, again? Is it against the law for them to earn a living?
Yes, I am only kidding.
Yes, I am only kidding.
good oneevil.edna said:
Whenever somebody starts a thread like this, all the PH main dealer protectors come out of the woodwork with lame-ass logic as to why the dealer hasn't done anything wrong. They will, literally, try and defend the indefensible.
To be fair though, I don't think anyone has?Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


