Classic car insurance: losing no claims discount
Classic car insurance: losing no claims discount
Author
Discussion

andyvvc

Original Poster:

267 posts

174 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Both the cars i own have been under classic / high net worth policies with Zurich and Dual (alternating) since 2017. (Modern classics)

I've been advised that NCD doesn't accrue on these policies. Apparently this is the norm for classic style insurance.

Has anyone had issues getting insurance on something a lot newer after they sold their classics? For example, what if I sell one of mine and replace it with a brand new M2? I have no NCD anymore. Are there insurers who don't care about seeing a NCD form and can simply check my insurance history to see i haven't made any claims? Or am I now trapped owning classics cars for ever? smile





Edited by andyvvc on Saturday 12th February 08:04

jeremyh1

1,525 posts

158 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Now this is a really strange one

I have always insured my Saab with Adrian Flux and for years they said there would be no . No claims bonus

I then wanted another additional policy for a people carrier and Adrien Flux provided a letter stating that I had the equivalent of 7 years NCB despite having no actual NCB policy for this car !

texaxile

3,822 posts

181 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
I always insure my classic alongside my daily on a separate policy , however I understand in your case it is different, but if you ask your insurer to provide evidence of no claims being made while under their insurance, that may qualify for something.

Although classic policies don’t accrue NCD per se, it might be worth asking that although you get no discount for not claiming, if you have not made a claim, if this translates into a bonus or discount on any new policy that does allow NCD acrual.

In short, “No Claim Discount” might not apply to your policy, but “No Claim” might be relevant.



Edited by texaxile on Saturday 12th February 04:39

andyvvc

Original Poster:

267 posts

174 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Cheers folks. To be totally clear both my cars are 'modern classics' rather than things from the distant past (996 and a V8 Vantage). So both would qualify for insurance with other regular policies (classic ones seemed to work best when grouping the cars under one renewal policy)

I've spoken to a rival insurer and they have reiterated
that they would also class the cars as classics, and provide no NCD.

But if a want to add anything newer i need to provide some proof of no claims for the newer vehicle. This is the bit that worries me. I'm essentially placing my trust in my insurers to provide some kind of no claim proof . . . and any other insurer to accept that.

First World problem. But one i didn't see coming in 2017 lol!

steveo3002

11,244 posts

205 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
they should hold your ncb , meaning you wont earn an extra year but it will remain at 5 years or whatever

when you leave they should /can provide a letter saying we hold 5 years ncb that you use on a modern , some do this without question , others have promised then forgot to send it over

skeeterm5

4,619 posts

219 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
I think that There is a difference between no claims bonus and not claiming. When you come to insure your new M2 ask your current insurer for confirmation of your claims history and I would have thought that would suffice as evidence of your history.

plenty

5,036 posts

217 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
steveo3002 said:
they should hold your ncb , meaning you wont earn an extra year but it will remain at 5 years or whatever

when you leave they should /can provide a letter saying we hold 5 years ncb that you use on a modern , some do this without question , others have promised then forgot to send it over
^^^as above. You don't accrue additional NCB on a classic policy, but you don't lose it either. At least that's always been the case with my classic insurer, who have readily supplied NCB proof on request.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Most 'new no NCB' policies will mirror your driving experience elsewhere.

I insured our Volvo on a new policy two years ago (using the NCB elsewhere) and they asked if I had NCB or driving experience. I explained about my classic policy (Chimaera and Trabant) plus my Range Rover and they mirrored the discount from the off.

I would speak to a broker or the Meercats and see what they offer.

55palfers

6,397 posts

195 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
How about cases where a company car driver opts opt and buys their own car.

My chum did this and a letter from our employer confirming in excess of 20 accident free driving years got him a full NCD.

Why do insurance companies sometimes make life hard work?

355spider

133 posts

58 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
So does this only apply with classic car insurance companies, or will the majority of insurers class a certain car as a classic and therefore not award no claims?

Why does it matter if it’s classic anyway, low annual mileage?

I’ve gained NCB on a 348 and for the last 3 years a 355, 5000 miles per year, which I need to ring about as I’ve gone over slightly with one month remaining on the policy.


texaxile

3,822 posts

181 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
355spider said:
So does this only apply with classic car insurance companies, or will the majority of insurers class a certain car as a classic and therefore not award no claims?

Why does it matter if it’s classic anyway, low annual mileage?

I’ve gained NCB on a 348 and for the last 3 years a 355, 5000 miles per year, which I need to ring about as I’ve gone over slightly with one month remaining on the policy.
I think (might be wrong) that unless you specify or go to an insurer and ask for a classic policy , they will class your car as under normal use and as such will be subject to the criteria within that.

For example, I can use my classic as a daily driver under a “normal” policy (if I took one out on it) and accrue NCD, as far as I know, the customer asks for the classic policy once their car meets the criteria, insurers won’t automatically classify your car as a classic once its 25 years old, or more. They may suggest a classic policy as they are often cheaper, but come with some restrictions such as limited mileage and agreed value.

Very often, despite having not claimed on a classic policy, a letter can be issued confirming “no claim” has been made by the policyholder during the time the policy was held, and as such might be enough evidence to warrant an NCD on a new policy.

(BTW Love the 348, utterly gorgeous car - I’m jealous smile )

Edited by texaxile on Saturday 12th February 11:08


Edited by texaxile on Saturday 12th February 11:10

plenty

5,036 posts

217 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
A classic policy is a different product to a 'normal' policy.

The idea is that your classic car isn't your main car so won't be exposed to as many risky situations, and owners are likely to be enthusiasts and as such more careful about their classic car than the average Joe is about their average car.

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Exactly. And a classic policy will generally have an agreed value payout in the event of a total loss. Rather than what the 'book' says.

There was a chap on here a few years ago with a written off BMW 325i which he thought would get the equivalent of agreed value because it was a sought after 'rare' car. Was a bit miffed when offered £1500 or something for a 22 year old Beemer.

andyvvc

Original Poster:

267 posts

174 months

Monday 14th February 2022
quotequote all
Update: I've called a few insurarers over the weekend/today. All respected bigger-names in the 'decent' car insurance game.

NONE OF THEM will entertain any NCD. It's been 4 years since i had a policy in my name that accrued/protected NCD. So in the eyes of other insurers i now no longer have any NCD. (Stautory 2-year gap and NCD lapse)

I'm tempted to name-and-shame the brokers on here: but thats against PH rules.

Im now at the stage where a (different) well-known insurer of classics and the like has sorted out a (potentially) decent policy for me to sort out the two 'modern classics' and bolt on our (new to us) 2013 C Class diesel. The C class is costing me £700 to insure due to zero NCD . . .

I've spoken to my original brokers who have now suggested: I stay with them for another year and they move one of the 'modern classics' from the high-net-worth policy to a mid-net-worth policy with a different underwriter. They (the brokers, because i still use them) can vouch for me having made no claims so can get me a 'decent' NCD level/equivalent with the mid-net-worth insurer. And then next year (if i move away from the broker) i will have some form of NCD again because the mid-net-worth insurer will have had me for a year and will have the broker vouching for the fact i haven't made any claims for 20+ years


Note to others: If you are offered a classic or high-net-worth policy . . . get in writing from the broker what will happen to your NCD after1, 2+ years.


I'll advise of where i manage to get too. Livid doesn't quite sum-up how I currently feel lol!


NB - at no point in the last 4 years did my broker confirm i would lose my NCD if i remained on high-net-worth policies . . .


EDIT - I've had a coffee and calmed down a bit. This is entirely a first-world problem, I'll post up how I get it sorted for the benefit of anyone else who might find themselves in the same boat.



Edited by andyvvc on Monday 14th February 10:07

plenty

5,036 posts

217 months

Monday 14th February 2022
quotequote all
That does sound odd. On my classic policies the NCD I have earned previously is maintained when attached to a car. It doesn't accue but doesn't disappear either. It must be attached to a car for this to happen.

andyvvc

Original Poster:

267 posts

174 months

Monday 14th February 2022
quotequote all
^^^ Thats entirely where i *thought* my policy was at these last 4 years. NCD doesnt accrue (i was advised that much), but also doesn't diasappear (I was never verbally or in writing informed that my NCD could lapse).

I'll go grab some popcorn smile

Chubbyross

5,019 posts

116 months

Monday 14th February 2022
quotequote all
In my experience of nearly forty years of having car insurance NCDs are a load of cobblers. Maybe once upon a time the insurance company might have rewarded loyalty, safe driving and living in a risk-free area, but now? The best way to get your premiums down each year is to shop around annually.

Edited by Chubbyross on Monday 14th February 11:41

plenty

5,036 posts

217 months

Monday 14th February 2022
quotequote all
Chubbyross said:
The best way to get your premiums down each year is to shop around every annually.
Not since 1 Jan of this year when insurers were legally probihited from offering lower prices for new policies than renewals.

andyvvc

Original Poster:

267 posts

174 months

Monday 14th February 2022
quotequote all
After a lot more quotes and chats with my broker:

The 911 and Vantage remain on the high-net-worth policy at an acceptable renewal premium.

The C Class has been moved to A N Other insurers policy (by the broker) with the broker confirming to the other insurer that I have max NCD (9 years). That's resulted in the renewal for the Merc coming in at over 50% less than I've been quoted elsewhere with 'zero' NCD.

At next years renewal my NCD will be up to 10 years and (crucially) will show up for other insurers to see (rather than the 'lapsed' NCD status i was facing).

The fact that i did have 25 years NCD is a moot point at this stage . . .


Car insurance really shuldn't be this awkward! smile


plenty

5,036 posts

217 months

Monday 14th February 2022
quotequote all
For most insurers NCD is maxed out around 6 years. There's little no difference in the discount if you have more NCD years than that.