Accident, liability query.
Accident, liability query.
Author
Discussion

Blanchimont

Original Poster:

4,089 posts

153 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
A friend of mine had an accident a while back.

Car A moved from lane 1 taking the 1st exit, into lane 2 taking the 2nd exit (slip road to motorway). Car A indicated initially, then switched off, then moved.
Car B (friend) Moved from lane 3, into lane 2, to take the slip road.

Car B was just established in lane 2, when Car A moves into lane 2, and collides with the front & rear door of car B.

Dashcam footage from car B.



Car A is claiming that car B turned into car A on the slip road itself, not the roundabout before.
Car B has provided footage, and account backs up the footage.

Car B was repaired, and paid for by car A insurance (without prejudice?)
Car B driver has side impact whiplash, backed up with drs records (seemed genuine at the time)

Car A insurance are now pushing for a 50/50 liability.

Does car B driver (friend) take it, or is it worth fighting, as they believe they're not at fault, especially not on a 50/50 basis.

r129sl

9,518 posts

234 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
It was obvious from the off that car A had got himself into the wrong lane and was struggling to get from lane 1 to lane 2. I am not sure why car B (and the other cars for that matter) did not give way to him. Car B in particular seems to have made an aggressive dive from lane 3 into lane 2, almost as if its driver was hoping to cut off Car B.

At the end of the day, however, Car A was in lane 1, Car B was in lane 3, they both went for lane 2 and the collision resulted. Classic 50:50.

Bill

58,931 posts

286 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
r129sl said:
At the end of the day, however, Car A was in lane 1, Car B was in lane 3, they both went for lane 2 and the collision resulted. Classic 50:50.
yes Why didn't car B follow the Skoda in L3?

Blanchimont

Original Poster:

4,089 posts

153 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Bill said:
r129sl said:
At the end of the day, however, Car A was in lane 1, Car B was in lane 3, they both went for lane 2 and the collision resulted. Classic 50:50.
yes Why didn't car B follow the Skoda in L3?
Friend said that was a police car coming, and moved over to allow to police car to continue on the roundabout

JQ

6,892 posts

210 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Did that impact really cause whiplash, crikey?

Carlososos

976 posts

127 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Blanchimont said:
A friend of mine had an accident a while back.

Car A moved from lane 1 taking the 1st exit, into lane 2 taking the 2nd exit (slip road to motorway). Car A indicated initially, then switched off, then moved.
Car B (friend) Moved from lane 3, into lane 2, to take the slip road.

Car B was just established in lane 2, when Car A moves into lane 2, and collides with the front & rear door of car B.

Dashcam footage from car B.



Car A is claiming that car B turned into car A on the slip road itself, not the roundabout before.
Car B has provided footage, and account backs up the footage.

Car B was repaired, and paid for by car A insurance (without prejudice?)
Car B driver has side impact whiplash, backed up with drs records (seemed genuine at the time)

Car A insurance are now pushing for a 50/50 liability.

Does car B driver (friend) take it, or is it worth fighting, as they believe they're not at fault, especially not on a 50/50 basis.
Both at fault but for me slightly more car b (dash cam car) as it was not established in the lane of collision and the red car in lane 1 was indicating and trying to move lanes which was visible and obvious to to car b.

HustleRussell

26,714 posts

191 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
JQ said:
Did that impact really cause whiplash, crikey?
No.

Carlososos

976 posts

127 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Bill said:
r129sl said:
At the end of the day, however, Car A was in lane 1, Car B was in lane 3, they both went for lane 2 and the collision resulted. Classic 50:50.
yes Why didn't car B follow the Skoda in L3?
Looks like dash cam car was getting frustrated at Skoda drivers dithering.

HustleRussell

26,714 posts

191 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Blanchimont said:
Car B was just established in lane 2, when...
I think not.

Both drivers simultaneously moving from their respective lanes into lane 2.

Blanchimont

Original Poster:

4,089 posts

153 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
JQ said:
Did that impact really cause whiplash, crikey?
Side impact. They were pretty bad a couple of days later tbf

KTF

10,735 posts

181 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Blanchimont said:
Friend said that was a police car coming, and moved over to allow to police car to continue on the roundabout
At 11s in you can see the red car coming over so your friend should have seen it coming as well. Had your friend come off in lane 2 like the Fabia then the Police car would have continued round the roundabout anyway.

50:50 all day for me.

r129sl

9,518 posts

234 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Blanchimont said:
Bill said:
r129sl said:
At the end of the day, however, Car A was in lane 1, Car B was in lane 3, they both went for lane 2 and the collision resulted. Classic 50:50.
yes Why didn't car B follow the Skoda in L3?
Friend said that was a police car coming, and moved over to allow to police car to continue on the roundabout
Even if that wasn't total bks (a bit like the whiplash), getting out of the way of a police car does not make it OK to drive into a third party. If anything, that tall tale makes it worse for the driver Car B.

The more I watch the video, the more I think the driver of Car B was being deliberately ttful and cutting off Car A. I'd advise your friend to leap upon the offer of 50:50 and regard it as a lucky escape, quite frankly.

Edited by r129sl on Wednesday 23 February 11:32

super7

2,277 posts

239 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Car A should have bailed out and stayed in lane..... he was obviously getting flustered as his options to get on the slip road narrowed.... at this point all his observations would have gone out the window and hes winging it and hoping that everyone else is getting out of his way. Obviously not!!

Don't understand car B's move to lane 2. Should have followed the Skoda.

Whilst Car B is being dick and just confusing everyone around, Car A should have realised that the slip road was impossible and bailed. More Car A than B.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Blanchimont said:
JQ said:
Did that impact really cause whiplash, crikey?
Side impact. They were pretty bad a couple of days later tbf
Did you see the footage? It was a slight impact to side. If someone gets whiplash from that, I assume they get whiplash getting out of bed each day.

Anyway, driver B was moving into lane 2 AS driver B was also moving into lane 2. As driver B was behind (and in blind spot, when driver A looked there may not have been a car in lane 2 behind with car), they would have seen (if paying attention) that driver A was moving into lane 2. When impact was
happening, neither car was "fully" in lane 2.

As white car passed, lane 2 was clear hence red car moving over. At same time driver B didn't anticipate this.

Both at fault imo. driver B has little anticipation of events, it appears clear what red car was wanting to do. Ease off, let them go and everyone's happy.....

As for police car behind, they will navigate around you, it's not an excuse to bump into someone.

Edited by Dracoro on Wednesday 23 February 11:39

t.boydy

270 posts

93 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Car B is at more fault in my opinion, not reading the road and other users....

Find it hard to believe that little bump caused any whiplash...!

Any pictures of the damage to the vehicles?

Triumph Man

9,655 posts

199 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
t.boydy said:
Find it hard to believe that little bump caused any whiplash...!
Of course it didn't...

However it's easy for us to sit here and judge. From my lofty position of someone watching the footage, you can see that Audi is unsure, and that would set off alarm bells. If it's the roundabout I think it is, it's bloody horrible anyway. If it was me, I would have sat tight behind the Skoda - once on the Motorway you can tank on past them anyway. The jerky swing implies impatience, not an ideal manoevure to do that to the nearside anyway.

/lofty footage watching opinion.

MitchT

17,166 posts

240 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Car A should have given way. Car B should have spotted that Car A was indicating and running out of time to change lanes and eased off. The whole sorry mess could have been avoided with a bit of kindness on the part of Car B and is down to the aggressiveness, impatience and intolerance that seems to be exhibited by the majority of road users towards each other these days.

I was in as similar position once. Driving in an unfamiliar city. Needed to change lanes. Indicated. Car in next lane actually accelerated into the gap to stop me. Ended up lost in a one way system for half an hour when the place I was trying to get to would have been another 30 seconds down the road if I'd been able to change lanes. Don't indicate anymore as a result, so no doubt people are cursing me for that instead now, but at least I get to change lanes without assholes blocking me.

Dracoro

9,038 posts

276 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
MitchT said:
Car A should have given way.
To whom? At the point they indicated and started moving, lane 2 was clear so no-one to give way to at that point. Car B was in blind spot and further drove that blind spot in lane 2. Had car B simply been driving in lane 2 from the start (like the white car was) then it'd be a different discussion.

DanL

6,591 posts

296 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
I’d have thought car B was looking at the blue car going left, rather than the red car coming across from the left. He could have stayed in his lane, I suppose. Red car surely should have seen car B, but…

Dark85

714 posts

179 months

Wednesday 23rd February 2022
quotequote all
Blanchimont said:
A friend of mine had an accident a while back.

Car A moved from lane 1 taking the 1st exit, into lane 2 taking the 2nd exit (slip road to motorway). Car A indicated initially, then switched off, then moved.
Car B (friend) Moved from lane 3, into lane 2, to take the slip road.

Car B was just established in lane 2, when Car A moves into lane 2, and collides with the front & rear door of car B.

Dashcam footage from car B.



Car A is claiming that car B turned into car A on the slip road itself, not the roundabout before.
Car B has provided footage, and account backs up the footage.

Car B was repaired, and paid for by car A insurance (without prejudice?)
Car B driver has side impact whiplash, backed up with drs records (seemed genuine at the time)

Car A insurance are now pushing for a 50/50 liability.

Does car B driver (friend) take it, or is it worth fighting, as they believe they're not at fault, especially not on a 50/50 basis.
Leave it up to their insurance company to decide on 50/50 liability or not.

However, if your friend, and indeed you, can't see how they contributed to the accident when they changed lanes mid roundabout, whilst in the blind spot of a car that was already trying to get into that lane then they need to improve their driving skills.