Auto hypochondria?
Discussion
I've been in and around cars as a hobby and as an essential tool for getting around. Also as a mechanic for a while as well.
I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
ingenieur said:
I've been in and around cars as a hobby and as an essential tool for getting around. Also as a mechanic for a while as well.
I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
You may have got some of that the wrong way round .I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
Mechanic tells you there is something wrong you knew nothing about and proceeds to strip down the car to charge £££ onto the bill .
I don't have this as such but I do have auto perfectionism. I'd legitimately spend far too much to make a snotter drive and look better, much to the bank account's dismay.
What I can't stand is people who go the total other way and drive around in cars with a disco dashboard, a steering wheel that's upside down, steering wobbles over 40 and brakes that sound like a train has slammed on. Really irks me that other people would choose not to resolve obvious faults, let alone phantom ones.
Thinking more as I typed this, my former mechanic knew of a fella that had a 2018 Astra. He had done a fair amount of work to it, new stainless exhaust, painted calipers, grooved brake disks, "stuff" pads of one colour or other, suspension work, spoiler, some trim wrapped and a few other bits and pieces. I only saw the car once and while it wasn't to my taste, it looked like the workmanship was high quality. He insisted it had a problem with the brakes. Every time he braked, there was a clunk. Kept taking it back to Vauxhall who kept telling him they couldn't find the problem, nor identify any brake clunk. I heard he took it back countless times under warranty until they changed the caliper brackets but it was still there according to him. I think he ended up with about 5 sets of caliper brackets on before it was found that there was actually some sort of manufacturing problem with the hub. I heard they changed that but have never heard from him since. I suppose every so often, one of those phantoms is real.
What I can't stand is people who go the total other way and drive around in cars with a disco dashboard, a steering wheel that's upside down, steering wobbles over 40 and brakes that sound like a train has slammed on. Really irks me that other people would choose not to resolve obvious faults, let alone phantom ones.
Thinking more as I typed this, my former mechanic knew of a fella that had a 2018 Astra. He had done a fair amount of work to it, new stainless exhaust, painted calipers, grooved brake disks, "stuff" pads of one colour or other, suspension work, spoiler, some trim wrapped and a few other bits and pieces. I only saw the car once and while it wasn't to my taste, it looked like the workmanship was high quality. He insisted it had a problem with the brakes. Every time he braked, there was a clunk. Kept taking it back to Vauxhall who kept telling him they couldn't find the problem, nor identify any brake clunk. I heard he took it back countless times under warranty until they changed the caliper brackets but it was still there according to him. I think he ended up with about 5 sets of caliper brackets on before it was found that there was actually some sort of manufacturing problem with the hub. I heard they changed that but have never heard from him since. I suppose every so often, one of those phantoms is real.
Toni Carbonara said:
ingenieur said:
I've been in and around cars as a hobby and as an essential tool for getting around. Also as a mechanic for a while as well.
I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
You may have got some of that the wrong way round .I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
Mechanic tells you there is something wrong you knew nothing about and proceeds to strip down the car to charge £££ onto the bill .
I may have suffered from this condition when I was a young single man with a lot of time on my hands.
I mean who ever checks the level of oil in their diff?
I’ve never given it a single thought since I was about 19.
I still have my ‘to do’ lists for my cars, but it can take years for some of the issues to be addressed, if indeed they ever do.
I mean who ever checks the level of oil in their diff?
I’ve never given it a single thought since I was about 19.
I still have my ‘to do’ lists for my cars, but it can take years for some of the issues to be addressed, if indeed they ever do.
Owners groups for all manner of cars are awash with people who hear a strange noise or rattle once and immediately decide the engine is a few rotations away from ultimate doom, then wonder why it takes the dealer months to diagnose the problem that doesn't actually exist.
I can understand if something is clear and repeatable, but a machine with thousands of moving parts may make the odd rattle here and there that is completely immaterial.
I can understand if something is clear and repeatable, but a machine with thousands of moving parts may make the odd rattle here and there that is completely immaterial.
ingenieur said:
I've been in and around cars as a hobby and as an essential tool for getting around. Also as a mechanic for a while as well.
I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
I think VW consider all their customers to suffer from this unless there is a fault code.I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
ingenieur said:
I've been in and around cars as a hobby and as an essential tool for getting around. Also as a mechanic for a while as well.
I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
My father in law was like that. I have seen on more than one occasion people dismantling a car (or getting a mechanic to do it) and spending unnecessarily on phantom faults which I would say in some of these cases didn't even slightly exist.
Is it possible to have 'auto hypochondria' - where you think there's something wrong with your car but actually it's totally fine.
His car was regularly in the garage for stuff he just had a hunch about. It wouldn't be a failure, or a warning light. It would just be a feeling that something wasn't quite right.
When he changed cars the newer one would have similar issues.
I'll be honest now my car has hit 100k miles it does give me a bit of hypochondria, I thought I heard a bad noise, booked it in and got a call to say nothing wrong with it, happily I realised then I'd found a trusted garage for if things do go wrong(which they did), I stopped worrying until Monday, when the clutch went. It getting repaired next week, but I am now thinking of trading in for a new car, for the warranty and piece of mind.
The Vauxhall story above, when my Astra (2017) was new and under warranty it had a clunk when steering, a common problem, however Vauxhall said there was no fault. after 3 or 4 visits to the main dealer I took it to an independent garage who looked underneath, identified the problem, and gave me a short letter to give to Vauxhall to tell them what to replace. The service manager at Vauxhall was in a massive sulk that I did this, but they did do the repair under warranty and the problem went.
Main dealer also tried to refuse a warranty claim because I hadn't fitted new tyres through them, I told them I thought that was complete BS(in much more polite words), and they honoured the warranty claim, trying their luck I think.
The Vauxhall story above, when my Astra (2017) was new and under warranty it had a clunk when steering, a common problem, however Vauxhall said there was no fault. after 3 or 4 visits to the main dealer I took it to an independent garage who looked underneath, identified the problem, and gave me a short letter to give to Vauxhall to tell them what to replace. The service manager at Vauxhall was in a massive sulk that I did this, but they did do the repair under warranty and the problem went.
Main dealer also tried to refuse a warranty claim because I hadn't fitted new tyres through them, I told them I thought that was complete BS(in much more polite words), and they honoured the warranty claim, trying their luck I think.
Jaguar steve said:
757 said:
Driving a shed resolves this
It does. Sheds are the perfect solution to practically every car anxiety and trauma or worry you can think of.1)Hated having to park it anywhere, it would ruin my night out worrying about it
2)Spent hours every weekend cleaning it and waxing it with crazy expensive wax from some guy on Scoobynet
3)Got upset every time I noticed it had another scratch or dent (usually while washing it)
4)Was constantly paranoid something was wrong with it or it wasn't as fast as it should be. Running it on Super Unleaded and resetting the ECU and convincing myself it felt different (it didn't)
5)Having to get it serviced at a main dealer every six months
6)Seeing that payment go from my bank account every month to pay for it.
Now I drive a shed and I don't give the car a second thought. I service it myself with eBay oil and filters, it costs me nothing each month, cleaning it takes about 15 minutes when I can be bothered, if it gets a new scratch or dent I instantly forget about it and don't care in the slightest.
It really is no f
ks given motoring, worrying about a car is something I can well do without.Toltec said:
I think this is closely related to paranoisia.
It is. If you are a typical enthusiast (within reason!) you appreciate that regular routine servicing is essential, as is basic checking of fluid levels and tyres. Also cleaning the car is not only sensible but will extend its life. Again, not obsessive, just up to adequate standard.This is the balance between a fetish and common sense.RazerSauber said:
I don't have this as such but I do have auto perfectionism. I'd legitimately spend far too much to make a snotter drive and look better, much to the bank account's dismay.
What I can't stand is people who go the total other way and drive around in cars with a disco dashboard, a steering wheel that's upside down, steering wobbles over 40 and brakes that sound like a train has slammed on. Really irks me that other people would choose not to resolve obvious faults, let alone phantom ones.
Thinking more as I typed this, my former mechanic knew of a fella that had a 2018 Astra. He had done a fair amount of work to it, new stainless exhaust, painted calipers, grooved brake disks, "stuff" pads of one colour or other, suspension work, spoiler, some trim wrapped and a few other bits and pieces. I only saw the car once and while it wasn't to my taste, it looked like the workmanship was high quality. He insisted it had a problem with the brakes. Every time he braked, there was a clunk. Kept taking it back to Vauxhall who kept telling him they couldn't find the problem, nor identify any brake clunk. I heard he took it back countless times under warranty until they changed the caliper brackets but it was still there according to him. I think he ended up with about 5 sets of caliper brackets on before it was found that there was actually some sort of manufacturing problem with the hub. I heard they changed that but have never heard from him since. I suppose every so often, one of those phantoms is real.
I drove past an Astra lst night on the motorway, and the rear left wheel was bouncing up and down like mad like the shock absorber had seized or something, and the guy had no lights on even though it was dusk. No idea why the guy thought that was safe to drive, it must have been a mission to keep it under controlWhat I can't stand is people who go the total other way and drive around in cars with a disco dashboard, a steering wheel that's upside down, steering wobbles over 40 and brakes that sound like a train has slammed on. Really irks me that other people would choose not to resolve obvious faults, let alone phantom ones.
Thinking more as I typed this, my former mechanic knew of a fella that had a 2018 Astra. He had done a fair amount of work to it, new stainless exhaust, painted calipers, grooved brake disks, "stuff" pads of one colour or other, suspension work, spoiler, some trim wrapped and a few other bits and pieces. I only saw the car once and while it wasn't to my taste, it looked like the workmanship was high quality. He insisted it had a problem with the brakes. Every time he braked, there was a clunk. Kept taking it back to Vauxhall who kept telling him they couldn't find the problem, nor identify any brake clunk. I heard he took it back countless times under warranty until they changed the caliper brackets but it was still there according to him. I think he ended up with about 5 sets of caliper brackets on before it was found that there was actually some sort of manufacturing problem with the hub. I heard they changed that but have never heard from him since. I suppose every so often, one of those phantoms is real.
Joey Deacon said:
...worrying about a car is something I can well do without.
Me too. Been there and done that and know from long experience how ruinously toxic that is.The surprising thing is that despite owning sheds and more needy and precious cars simultaneously for decades is how long it's taken me to realise it.
Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


