Getting a car insurance quote from NFU mutual.
Getting a car insurance quote from NFU mutual.
Author
Discussion

GasEngineer

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

93 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
In the (surprising) absence of a PH Insurance section I'm posting here. Admin please move if its not the appropriate section.

After seeing their TV ads I thought 'd get a quote from NFU. Their website, like all their competitors, has a "Get A Quote" button.

Clicking this opens up four Yes/No boxes:
Are you an existing customer?
Are you over 80?
Do you want the insurance to start within the next 30 days?
Another question?

Whatever combination of Yes/No you answer to the four questions it just take you to a page telling you to ring them. Which you can't on a Sunday.

If it is only by phone call, I'm sure they will lose business as I can't be the only person who can't be arsed to call them when they are open and verbally go through all the questions with them.

Anyone else had experience with NFU?

this is my username

444 posts

91 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
GasEngineer said:
Anyone else had experience with NFU?
Yes - they are great. They are helpful, you deal with a skilled person in a local office instead of someone in a call centre. Have always been good on the couple of occasions we have made a claim.

Not the cheapest but I have no intention of moving anywhere else.

vintagecat99

35 posts

163 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
this is my username said:
Yes - they are great. They are helpful, you deal with a skilled person in a local office instead of someone in a call centre. Have always been good on the couple of occasions we have made a claim.

Not the cheapest but I have no intention of moving anywhere else.
Agreed I have been with NFU for over 20 years. Always been very helpful and claims (two) have been efficiently handled. Again not the cheapest but have never felt any desire to move

Ziplobb

1,623 posts

315 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
this is my username said:
you deal with a skilled person in a local office instead of someone in a call centre.
this
and these sorts of people tend to have their weekends off and enjoy them - its one of the reasons why they are a bit more expensive - good to deal with though - old fashioned decent service

FA57REN

1,279 posts

86 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
this is my username said:
Yes - they are great. They are helpful, you deal with a skilled person in a local office instead of someone in a call centre. Have always been good on the couple of occasions we have made a claim.

Not the cheapest but I have no intention of moving anywhere else.
But that skilled person could be much more productive if they weren't handling calls from people who just want a quote.

Their website should be able to take enough data to give a ballpark figure so as to funnel the number of phone calls to those who are seriously considering buying a policy.

Plymo

1,280 posts

120 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
FA57REN said:
this is my username said:
Yes - they are great. They are helpful, you deal with a skilled person in a local office instead of someone in a call centre. Have always been good on the couple of occasions we have made a claim.

Not the cheapest but I have no intention of moving anywhere else.
But that skilled person could be much more productive if they weren't handling calls from people who just want a quote.

Their website should be able to take enough data to give a ballpark figure so as to funnel the number of phone calls to those who are seriously considering buying a policy.
Yep, even better would be if the online form took the usual details like address, car details, date of passing test, NCB, previous claims etc that can be a pain describing on the phone, for the company to then call back either with a price or a few follow up questions...
Can't remember what company it was but I've used one like that before and it worked reasonably well.

GasEngineer

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

93 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies.

NFU is about £100 a year more expensive than my Aviva renewal quote.

Is the better service worth it?


sgtbash

766 posts

167 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
GasEngineer said:
Thanks for the replies.

NFU is about £100 a year more expensive than my Aviva renewal quote.

Is the better service worth it?
Aviva were brilliant for me when I had to claim. They won't touch me now though laugh

r.g.

608 posts

243 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
They do this as the Underwriting performance of their motor book will be much better than if they accepted business over the net.

People (not all) find it easier to lie about various things online than over the phone, and an experienced call handler will be able to read between the lines and ask more probing questions if needed. This means they are then able to price the risk as it actually is rather than price it based on what someone thinks they want to hear. This results in a far better client base.


Pica-Pica

16,727 posts

115 months

Tuesday 8th March 2022
quotequote all
We were with NFU Mutual for about seven years. My 335d always had a ‘sports’ premium and excess on it, but it was still cheapest. We arranged the policy face to face in a local office, and no admin cost when changing cars. This year we changed to LV= as they had a very competitive price and didn’t class mine as a ‘sports’ car. We also wanted to take separate policies for strategic reason, to ensure we both get a NCD. Another reason was that GoCompare have given us a £250 free excess cover on both policies, we have the policy details of that separately.

Additionally we took out recovery with START Rescue, which is a low annual cost and £30 a call-out. As we have not called out for years, these seems good value too.

As a side note, we have just had our house policy renewal quote, with LV= which has gone DOWN in price).