RE: Brace of BMW M3 CSLs up for grabs
RE: Brace of BMW M3 CSLs up for grabs
Tuesday 1st March 2022

Brace of BMW M3 CSLs up for grabs

Can't decide between grey or black for the ultimate E46? Have both!



There are well-founded rumours that the special BMW M4 coming later this year will be a CSL. Not a mere CS, nor a GTS (which has been the flagship for the past two generations) but a real Coupe Sport Lightweight. The return of BMW M's most famous badge would be fitting in the firm's 50th anniversary year, though it would need a very, very special car to do it justice. After all, there have only been two BMW CSLs in half a century...

There was a 30-year gap between first and second; should this year's special M4 be a CSL, there will have been a 20-year wait from the second for the third. Well, almost - it was the 2003 Geneva show that BMW first debuted the M3 CSL, having offered prototype drives the year before and been met with overwhelmingly positive feedback.

You probably know the M3 CSL story already, because it's something of an icon round these parts, but it's worth repeating. It's hard to believe in a modern context, where track focused cars can sell out before they're announced, but the CSL didn't fly out of the showrooms. It was a lot more money for just 17 more horsepower, there wasn't a manual option, and the standard M3 was already wonderfully good.



Early Michelin Cup tyres that didn't like moisture further hampered its cause - because what was the point of an M3 - the definitive everyday performance car - that couldn't be safely used for much of the time? Of course, that all rather missed the point of the CSL. It was more about drastically reducing weight (110kg less than a standard car) than just ramping up the power, a fact that was overlooked by some at the time.

Things are rather different now. The CSL is not just a highly coveted modern classic, it's also likely to be a frontrunner in our recently launched best M car ever poll (vote now!) and is seen as a real high point for BMW in the 21st century. Values have been climbing for a while; the switch to turbo M cars will have helped, because nothing since the CSL has sounded quite so good as the 360hp S54 through a carbon airbox. Probably the current BMW design direction has played a part, too, because nothing since the CSL has looked so good as an E46 M3 with a carbon roof, those wheels and an upswept bootlid.

However, this isn't a story about another M3 CSL that costs more than a new M4 - it's about two. M specialists Munich Legends has a pair of CSLs for sale, one in the commonly seen Silver Grey and another in the much rarer Sapphire Black. They're both fabulous (because every CSL is) but even by that exalted standard these look like special examples. The black car has 35,000 miles recorded and, while there isn't any more detail just yet, the condition looks near enough flawless. The AP Racing calipers behind the wheels are a popular mod for a notoriously underbraked BMW.



The silver one is, if anything, even better, yet to clock over 16,000 miles and also with the AP upgrade. It looks like both have the air con and radio that were no-cost options when new. Either would make a fine addition to any collection - or both would be great ahead of the new car...

It won't come cheap, of course. £200k might be insufficient to secure both, what with the grey CSL for sale at £115k and the black one up for £98,000. Who'd have thought that initial £60k investment would have turned out so well? And while they're now rather different prospects at six figure asking prices, we wouldn't expect either CSL to hang around long, for all the reasons listed above. Imagine the excitement for these cars, too, if that most hallowed of BMW nameplates makes a return...








Author
Discussion

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

45,305 posts

211 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
These are such good looking cars to my eyes, and they've been great investments for their owners as well. Such a very cool car I reckon.

hufggfg

658 posts

224 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
The Article said:
Who'd have thought that initial £60k investment would have turned out so well?
I know this isn't the point of the article, but it always kind of winds me up when people say this on the basis of a notional price increase.

£60k in 2004, growing to £98k in 2022 is a 2.8% annual rate of growth. That is a relatively poor investment (just below inflation). £115k makes that rate of growth 3.7%, still not exactly great.

Sure, making money on any car is better than the average, but that doesn't mean that things like this are good "investments".

wpa1975

14,870 posts

145 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
Great looking car, black would be my choice.

rb26

808 posts

217 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
hufggfg said:
I know this isn't the point of the article, but it always kind of winds me up when people say this on the basis of a notional price increase.

£60k in 2004, growing to £98k in 2022 is a 2.8% annual rate of growth. That is a relatively poor investment (just below inflation). £115k makes that rate of growth 3.7%, still not exactly great.

Sure, making money on any car is better than the average, but that doesn't mean that things like this are good "investments".
That doesn't even include costs of;
Insurance
Tax
Upkeep
Petrol
Consumables

Unless we're talking about the F40s and 288 GTOs of the world (circa 2007 they were 200k and 180k respectively), then cars are generally a really REALLY bad investment

Dombilano

1,481 posts

86 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
I'd love a go in one of these on a track like Croft, shame they'll probably end up in an underground carpark in London with a custom dustsheet

AKA PABS

316 posts

153 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
I’d only ever plumb for a CS with a manual box.

3795mpower

509 posts

161 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
rb26 said:
hufggfg said:
I know this isn't the point of the article, but it always kind of winds me up when people say this on the basis of a notional price increase.

£60k in 2004, growing to £98k in 2022 is a 2.8% annual rate of growth. That is a relatively poor investment (just below inflation). £115k makes that rate of growth 3.7%, still not exactly great.

Sure, making money on any car is better than the average, but that doesn't mean that things like this are good "investments".
That doesn't even include costs of;
Insurance
Tax
Upkeep
Petrol
Consumables

Unless we're talking about the F40s and 288 GTOs of the world (circa 2007 they were 200k and 180k respectively), then cars are generally a really REALLY bad investment
And for some additional insight a friend of mine sold his in 2008 for £33k,
he was quite pleased at the time as it was more than he paid for it !

benzinbob

750 posts

87 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
rb26 said:
hufggfg said:
I know this isn't the point of the article, but it always kind of winds me up when people say this on the basis of a notional price increase.

£60k in 2004, growing to £98k in 2022 is a 2.8% annual rate of growth. That is a relatively poor investment (just below inflation). £115k makes that rate of growth 3.7%, still not exactly great.

Sure, making money on any car is better than the average, but that doesn't mean that things like this are good "investments".
That doesn't even include costs of;
Insurance
Tax
Upkeep
Petrol
Consumables

Unless we're talking about the F40s and 288 GTOs of the world (circa 2007 they were 200k and 180k respectively), then cars are generally a really REALLY bad investment
Yeah, but look at it this way- you’d have had a really nice car to enjoy for 17 years and not lost money. That’s rare. The smiles would be worth something no?

daveco

4,418 posts

238 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
3795mpower said:
rb26 said:
hufggfg said:
I know this isn't the point of the article, but it always kind of winds me up when people say this on the basis of a notional price increase.

£60k in 2004, growing to £98k in 2022 is a 2.8% annual rate of growth. That is a relatively poor investment (just below inflation). £115k makes that rate of growth 3.7%, still not exactly great.

Sure, making money on any car is better than the average, but that doesn't mean that things like this are good "investments".
That doesn't even include costs of;
Insurance
Tax
Upkeep
Petrol
Consumables

Unless we're talking about the F40s and 288 GTOs of the world (circa 2007 they were 200k and 180k respectively), then cars are generally a really REALLY bad investment
And for some additional insight a friend of mine sold his in 2008 for £33k,
he was quite pleased at the time as it was more than he paid for it !
I remember at one point there were about ten CSLs for sale on this very website at the height of the recession.

Leggy E46 M3s were going for £8k or thereabouts.

Tired/rusty examples of E36 328s and E46 330s could be had for as little as £1-2k, and were being used predominantly as track and drift cars.

It's amazing how BMW's inability to design a nice car these days has impacted the value of their older cars hehe


hufggfg

658 posts

224 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
benzinbob said:
Yeah, but look at it this way- you’d have had a really nice car to enjoy for 17 years and not lost money. That’s rare. The smiles would be worth something no?
Oh totally. It makes it a much more attractive prospect to run as a car if you're going to enjoy it as well, but that doesn't make these cars a good investment from new! That said, the silver grey car has done an average of less than 900 miles per year, so it hasn't exactly been much fun for whoever owned it.

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
How much is a CSL that's done some track days, and has done say 100k miles?

hufggfg

658 posts

224 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
rb26 said:
Unless we're talking about the F40s and 288 GTO
Since you mention it, if I understand correctly, the 288 GTO new was around $85,000, and is now worth around $3m. That's approx 10% growth per year. Certainly an ok investment, but certainly not particularly amazing.

Similarly, the F40 was $400k new in 1987, worth around $2m today, so 4.7% return.

Really, even at the top end cars are not very good investments.

DaveyBoyWonder

3,992 posts

205 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
£100k for a 20 year old BMW. A lottery win would definitely, definitely see one of these in my garage... absolute no brainer for me vs a new M car... (although I could be tempted to do the manual conversion).

TEKNOPUG

20,502 posts

236 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
hufggfg said:
The Article said:
Who'd have thought that initial £60k investment would have turned out so well?
I know this isn't the point of the article, but it always kind of winds me up when people say this on the basis of a notional price increase.

£60k in 2004, growing to £98k in 2022 is a 2.8% annual rate of growth. That is a relatively poor investment (just below inflation). £115k makes that rate of growth 3.7%, still not exactly great.

Sure, making money on any car is better than the average, but that doesn't mean that things like this are good "investments".
Inflation is 2.2% per year since 2004. So it's more like 0.6% annual rate of growth ~ £6k in 18 years. Less VED, Insurance, Servicing...

benzinbob

750 posts

87 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
hufggfg said:
benzinbob said:
Yeah, but look at it this way- you’d have had a really nice car to enjoy for 17 years and not lost money. That’s rare. The smiles would be worth something no?
Oh totally. It makes it a much more attractive prospect to run as a car if you're going to enjoy it as well, but that doesn't make these cars a good investment from new! That said, the silver grey car has done an average of less than 900 miles per year, so it hasn't exactly been much fun for whoever owned it.
Not much fun you’re right..it’s not one of those cars you could park up and look at either, like a Countache or a Pagani. It’d sit around until a seal of some sort dries up and you’d need to spend £1k fixing it.

And then park it up again.


borat52

585 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
hufggfg said:
Since you mention it, if I understand correctly, the 288 GTO new was around $85,000, and is now worth around $3m. That's approx 10% growth per year. Certainly an ok investment, but certainly not particularly amazing.

Similarly, the F40 was $400k new in 1987, worth around $2m today, so 4.7% return.

Really, even at the top end cars are not very good investments.
If you take the snapshot of the market since rates went to near zero (2008 ->) then things look much better.

It's near zero interest rates that have boomed "collectable" cars, and it'll be a return to interest rates which brings them back down again. who would hold investment money in a car if a savings account or bond paid 2,3,4,5%?

Andyt25

1,190 posts

279 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
The best car au have ever owned and I should never have sold it….Even more so as mine sold for 27k back in 2010…Gutted.

BigChiefmuffinAgain

1,794 posts

129 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
hufggfg said:
rb26 said:
Unless we're talking about the F40s and 288 GTO
Since you mention it, if I understand correctly, the 288 GTO new was around $85,000, and is now worth around $3m. That's approx 10% growth per year. Certainly an ok investment, but certainly not particularly amazing.

Similarly, the F40 was $400k new in 1987, worth around $2m today, so 4.7% return.

Really, even at the top end cars are not very good investments.
+1. And if you owned an F40 for 30+ years, you would have had to replace the tanks at least 3 times, which is probably $75K plus depending on where it is done, plus the other associated costs over that time, say $5k a year if you are very luck, so $225K over the period. And that assumes nothing major goes wrong... And this has been probably the best market ever for these cars...

darreni

4,551 posts

301 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
blade7 said:
How much is a CSL that's done some track days, and has done say 100k miles?
70k ish I reckon, if it’s up together.

Murph7355

42,073 posts

287 months

Tuesday 1st March 2022
quotequote all
Looking at older cars is always difficult, and I know tastes vary. But...

An F355 or one of these? Or, I'm sure, any number of other cars at that price level (Aston Vanquish? F550? Honda NSX? Air cooled pork?).