The decline of the ICE - in my eyes
The decline of the ICE - in my eyes
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
I love cars. Always have and always will.

Honestly though - I'm totally fine with the phasing out of ICE propulsion and replacement with the forever improving EV movement.

ICE vehicles are generally (by comparison the EV) slower, more expensive to run and just generally 'old news'

EV propulsion is getting better all the time and we can look forward to some seriously fast, efficient and striking new cars.

I liken it to the turn to smartphones - initially there were the early tech adopters. Many though saw them as needless and didn't like the fact there were no buttons to press (parallel to engine noise complaint drawn) , the battery life was poor, they all looked the same and the internet was slow. Nobody 'needed' one and were seen as an answer to a question that many weren't asking

Blackberry clung on for a few years with their little buttons to appease the oldies but faded out. Now, as the infrastructure, the tech, the apps, the functionality and whole experience has improved then people would not and could no be without them.

Sure there will be a market for the nostalgia of old Nokia phones etc but generally speaking the world has moved on.

ICE and EV will tread exactly the same path. I see the Tesla as the very early iphone tbh.


Djtemeka

1,987 posts

223 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
I’ve never owned a performance car until last month. Whilst I appreciate electric cars, there are those of us that still want to buy noisy cars smile

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
I doubt it's ICE which is dying out but the whole culture of having pride in a motor car which will die out. The smartphone analogy is very good - all phones are utterly tedious and they all do the same thing. A car will not be a point of interest for anyone in the future - just like how you look at your watch and walk away as soon as someone tries to talk to you about a phone today.

Weekendrebuild

1,120 posts

94 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
I love cars. Always have and always will.

Honestly though - I'm totally fine with the phasing out of ICE propulsion and replacement with the forever improving EV movement.

ICE vehicles are generally (by comparison the EV) slower, more expensive to run and just generally 'old news'

EV propulsion is getting better all the time and we can look forward to some seriously fast, efficient and striking new cars.

I liken it to the turn to smartphones - initially there were the early tech adopters. Many though saw them as needless and didn't like the fact there were no buttons to press (parallel to engine noise complaint drawn) , the battery life was poor, they all looked the same and the internet was slow. Nobody 'needed' one and were seen as an answer to a question that many weren't asking

Blackberry clung on for a few years with their little buttons to appease the oldies but faded out. Now, as the infrastructure, the tech, the apps, the functionality and whole experience has improved then people would not and could no be without them.

Sure there will be a market for the nostalgia of old Nokia phones etc but generally speaking the world has moved on.

ICE and EV will tread exactly the same path. I see the Tesla as the very early iphone tbh.
Crap, I actually see more parallels between ev and minidiscs, just waiting for the iTunes to appear !!

JAMSXR

1,853 posts

78 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
No doubt, in my opinion, EVs provide a better A to B method of transportation for most people. On the large they are pretty dull and cost significantly more but I’m sure things will improve.

However, by using a mobile phone as an analogy, you obviously use/purchase your cars in a particular way. If you continuously want the latest and greatest, I totally get it, although when it comes to replacing your phone/EV every few years for the next feature, that’s pretty counterintuitive to the environmental benefits of EV use.

Personally, although new tech is nice for a daily car, it’s not what really excites me. It’s the noisy mechanical stuff that gets the juices flowing, I think that’s the case for most car/bike enthusiasts. Although I guess that is changing as you get tech enthusiasts coming over to the car industry, no so interested in the feel of the car but more the top trump stats and gadgets.

j3gme

954 posts

225 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
I

ICE and EV will tread exactly the same path. I see the Tesla as the very early iphone tbh.

I see Tesla as the CD of the music world, in between Vinyl and download/streaming, in others words pure electric is not the future, Hydrogen seams to be gathering pace Phillips66 have just released plans to build 250 Hydrogen filling stations across Europe

https://forecourttrader.co.uk/latest-news/phillips...

Bobtherallyfan

1,522 posts

109 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
There is a fundamental difference in the process of tech adoption though. Mobile phones weren’t forced on people, they were genuinely useful even early model types. EVs by contrast are being forced on people by legislation and taxation…..we have no choice.

I’ve no doubt that for many people EV’s are great, but not all of us live in cities, not all of us have drives and not all of us are on company car schemes where taxation makes the financial case impossible to ignore. There a reason the ICE replaced EV in the early days of motoring and for a large % of the worlds population, that still exists…the lack of flexibility of EV and the infrastructure required.

Equus

16,980 posts

132 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Djtemeka said:
there are those of us that still want to buy noisy cars smile
Serious question, but why?

Noise is just noise and a desire to make it unnecessarily is just antisocial and misanthropic. It was an unavoidable side effect of high performance ICE cars, but why on earth would anyone wish to make a nuisance of themselves with their fellow human beings, if there is no need to do so?

xstian

2,248 posts

177 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
I see more parallels comparing a gas boiler with a ASHP. ASHP are fine and for some people fit there needs exactly, but for the majority of people they are fking expensive to buy and aren't capable of meeting peoples needs, yet.

Do we really need another EV is better than Ice thread?

Edited by xstian on Wednesday 2nd March 07:01

Weekendrebuild

1,120 posts

94 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Equus said:
Serious question, but why?

Noise is just noise and a desire to make it unnecessarily is just antisocial and misanthropic. It was an unavoidable side effect of high performance ICE cars, but why on earth would anyone wish to make a nuisance of themselves with their fellow human beings, if there is no need to do so?


Why are you even on here ? Seriously! What parts of a screaming V10,V12 or burbling V8 doesn’t excite you…
I Will be quiet Honest I hate 99% of other people so take much enjoyment from your comment.

JAMSXR

1,853 posts

78 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
jamieduff1981 said:
I doubt it's ICE which is dying out but the whole culture of having pride in a motor car which will die out. The smartphone analogy is very good - all phones are utterly tedious and they all do the same thing. A car will not be a point of interest for anyone in the future - just like how you look at your watch and walk away as soon as someone tries to talk to you about a phone today.
Exactly this.

It’s the engine configuration and characteristics that have defined my bikes and cars. The sounds, styles of power delivery and mechanical nuances. It’s funny, the inefficiencies of an engine can help define it as much as the benefits - a high revving two stroke, lumpy v-twin or grumbling V8.

I’m sure is ICE fans will be like the chaps at miniature railways in the future, although hopefully we’ll be allowed to frequent motor circuits instead of country parks.

Chubbyross

5,017 posts

116 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Equus said:
Djtemeka said:
there are those of us that still want to buy noisy cars smile
Serious question, but why?

Noise is just noise and a desire to make it unnecessarily is just antisocial and misanthropic. It was an unavoidable side effect of high performance ICE cars, but why on earth would anyone wish to make a nuisance of themselves with their fellow human beings, if there is no need to do so?
Er, this is Pistonheads, right?

Trooned out

46 posts

57 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Road pricing/black boxes is going to change car driving and ownership as we know it , never mind ICE ?

vikingaero

13,579 posts

200 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
I love cars. Always have and always will.

Honestly though - I'm totally fine with the phasing out of ICE propulsion and replacement with the forever improving EV movement.

ICE vehicles are generally (by comparison the EV) slower, more expensive to run and just generally 'old news'

EV propulsion is getting better all the time and we can look forward to some seriously fast, efficient and striking new cars.

I liken it to the turn to smartphones - initially there were the early tech adopters. Many though saw them as needless and didn't like the fact there were no buttons to press (parallel to engine noise complaint drawn) , the battery life was poor, they all looked the same and the internet was slow. Nobody 'needed' one and were seen as an answer to a question that many weren't asking

Blackberry clung on for a few years with their little buttons to appease the oldies but faded out. Now, as the infrastructure, the tech, the apps, the functionality and whole experience has improved then people would not and could no be without them.

Sure there will be a market for the nostalgia of old Nokia phones etc but generally speaking the world has moved on.

ICE and EV will tread exactly the same path. I see the Tesla as the very early iphone tbh.
When Uncle Boris announced the ban of sales of petrol vehicles in 2030, there was the immediate kneejerk reaction on PH of what would we do? People adopted the sheeple woe mentality. We still have c.8 years to go! To be honest most people should be thinking about this in 2027/8 by which time they will probably have cycled through 2 lease deals on ICE cars.

A lot of you will be reading this thinking I'm a Luddite because I'm not embracing EVs. I love tech and I love change, but there is no need to change for now [cue won't somebody think of the children/planet].

Djtemeka

1,987 posts

223 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Weekendrebuild said:
Equus said:
Serious question, but why?

Noise is just noise and a desire to make it unnecessarily is just antisocial and misanthropic. It was an unavoidable side effect of high performance ICE cars, but why on earth would anyone wish to make a nuisance of themselves with their fellow human beings, if there is no need to do so?


Why are you even on here ? Seriously! What parts of a screaming V10,V12 or burbling V8 doesn’t excite you…
I Will be quiet Honest I hate 99% of other people so take much enjoyment from your comment.
Indeed. My vxr8 gets loads of attention and comments. I’ve not had a negative comment yet.

Having said that, I need to repair the switchable valves in the exhaust as they’re on loud only at the mo and even I like it quiet on occasion smile

Equus

16,980 posts

132 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Chubbyross said:
Er, this is Pistonheads, right?
Steam engines have pistons. Brake calipers have pistons.

Now can you actually answer the question, 'cos all I'm hearing so far is the petulant wailing of toddlers who've had their comfort blanket taken away from them?

Weekendrebuild said:
I Will be quiet Honest
That's good to know. smile

kambites

71,709 posts

252 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
jamieduff1981 said:
The smartphone analogy is very good - all phones are utterly tedious and they all do the same thing. A car will not be a point of interest for anyone in the future - just like how you look at your watch and walk away as soon as someone tries to talk to you about a phone today.
Personally I don't see that as anything to do with propulsion. 95+% of cars have been utterly dull and entirely utilitarian for the last... probably at least 60 years.

And there are plenty of people who spend hundreds if not thousands of pounds to make sure they have the latest, most flashy phone; primarily so everyone can see they have the latest, most flashy phone; which is also fairly analogous to cars! The proportion of "genuine phone enthusiasts" who are really interested in the technology and engineering behind phones is probably roughly the same as the proportion of "genuine car enthusiasts" who are interested in the same thing with cars.

JAMSXR

1,853 posts

78 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Equus said:
Chubbyross said:
Er, this is Pistonheads, right?
Steam engines have pistons. Brake calipers have pistons.

Now can you actually answer the question, 'cos all I'm hearing so far is the petulant wailing of toddlers who've had their comfort blanket taken away from them?
If you need to ask why the sound of a good engine is pleasurable for a motoring enthusiast, then to his point, you’re in the wrong place. Very odd comment.

Of course a good sounds is totally subjective, but we’re on a motoring forum, you do realise that?

JAMSXR

1,853 posts

78 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
kambites said:
Personally I don't see that as anything to do with propulsion. 95+% of cars have been utterly dull and entirely utilitarian for the last... probably at least 60 years.

And there are plenty of people who spend hundreds if not thousands of pounds to make sure they have the latest, most flashy phone; primarily so everyone can see they have the latest, most flashy phone; which is also fairly analogous to cars! The proportion of "genuine phone enthusiasts" who are really interested in the technology and engineering behind phones is probably roughly the same as the proportion of "genuine car enthusiasts" who are interested in the same thing with cars.
You sound bitter, that or you need to experience a few more cars.

Equus

16,980 posts

132 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
JAMSXR said:
If you need to ask why the sound of a good engine is pleasurable for a motoring enthusiast, then to his point, you’re in the wrong place. Very odd comment.

Of course a good sounds is totally subjective, but we’re on a motoring forum, you do realise that?
I'm very much a motoring enthusiast, but I've always been more interested in handling and actual performance than noise or looks (which is probably why I never got on with the TVR that I briefly owned).

If someone can give me a car that I can hustle down B-roads much more quickly than anything with an ICE, without the need to make a noise that winds everyone else up, then I'll jump at it.

Noise was an unavoidable and anti-social side effect that we had to tolerate if we wanted performance. Now it isn't, so why mourn its loss?