Motorway lane discipline
Motorway lane discipline
Author
Discussion

QuattroDave

Original Poster:

1,821 posts

159 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Morning all,

With my daily commute now including c60 miles of motorway driving split fairly evenly between M3 and M27 I've noticed that lane discipline has well and truly gone out the window on the M27 since it partially opened as a 'smart' motorway (partially as they're still "testing technology, hence the constant 60mph!)

I notice it most on the way home, between 6-7pm I constantly encounter drivers merrily trudging along in lane 3 of 4 at 50-55mph without a care in the world. I kind of 'get' that you wouldn't want to hug lane 1 as the road surface is appalling where they've burnt off old markings but lane3?

Anyone else noticed the marked reduction in lane discipline? Is it motorways in general or 'smart' motorways

Janesy B

2,625 posts

217 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
It's been like this for years now. Some sections of the M25 are just 4 lanes of people doing 60. The anti-clockwise concrete surface bit between the A10 and potters bar seems the worst for it, there's an incline and everyone seems incapable of squeezing the throttle to get up it without slowing down.

QuattroDave

Original Poster:

1,821 posts

159 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Janesy B said:
It's been like this for years now. Some sections of the M25 are just 4 lanes of people doing 60. The anti-clockwise concrete surface bit between the A10 and potters bar seems the worst for it, there's an incline and everyone seems incapable of squeezing the throttle to get up it without slowing down.
See I've noticed it around M25 for years also but just assumed people in and around London can't drive tongue out

But now I've a smart motorway <1 mile from my house it seems to be as a direct result of smart and managed motorways. Old section of M27 with no cameras, gantrys etc the lane discipline is good!

CarCrazyDad

4,280 posts

66 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
It is annoying, people just never go to L1.

dontlookdown

2,569 posts

124 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Smart motorways do seem to make it worse, but at root it's down to cameras and the more rigid enforcement of speed limits on motorways, it seems to me. All lanes doing the same speed more or less, so the rationale of L1 as a 'cruising' lane with L2/3 as 'overtaking' lanes no longer works.

Even when it's quiet, a lot of people do seem to have an aversion to L1 though. Never really figured that out.

The only answer that I can see is to change the rules so that all lanes are running lanes and undertaking is the norm, A per US freeways. Might stop the stupidity of people 'queueing' in L3 while the other 2 lanes are practically empty.

Shame because the system worked well (back when a degree of speeding by the minority was accepted. Remember the days when L3 on M1/M6/M11 was always moving at 80-90mph?) and was a much more pleasant diving experience.

scs1

339 posts

214 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
It works in my favour.
I regularly use the M3 between the M25 and junction 3, and the inside lane is now "my lane"
I can cruise down lane 1, past all of the middle lane bimblers and avoiding the German car lane (lane 4), quite often doing the 7 mile stretch without having to change course.

vikingaero

13,591 posts

200 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
I edge past lots of drivers in Lane 1, even if they are in Lane 3, 4 or 5.

I've UFO'ed lots of drivers and they are so zoned out it takes a while for them to realise.

On a recent trip from Manchester to home, I went past maybe 150 vehicles in Lane 1 and the only one to take offence was someone in Lane 4 who expected me to remain behind them.

craig1912

4,702 posts

143 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
The M27 is shocking now it has opened fully (apart from the 60 limit). Lane 1 is barely used and you see people coming on to the motorway and going straight to lane 2 despite there not being anything in lane 1. Clueless

XF-Andy

433 posts

157 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
I travel M27 and M3 most days, yesterday afternoon I must have passed at least 50 vehicles sat in lanes 2 & 3 whilst I was doing an indicated 64 in lane 1 (currently 60 limit whilst the technology is tested).

You do need to keep an eye on the MLMs in case they suddenly realise that there is an empty lane to their left though.

Was amazing to see the number of vehicles that joined at various junctions and moved straight into lanes 2 or 3. I hope that when the M27 ALR is fully functional that they display ‘keep left unless overtaking’ on the variable message signs and we’ll see whether that makes a difference.

sly fox

2,437 posts

250 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
dontlookdown said:
Even when it's quiet, a lot of people do seem to have an aversion to L1 though. Never really figured that out.

.
Because many drivers have worked out that with no hard shoulder, you are at more risk in lane one than the other lanes of coming up to a stationary vehicle. Happens on the M4 stretch in Berkshire too.

On Monday there was a broken down BMW 5 series on the <smart> M4 j12/11 eastbound who had not managed to get to one of the large laybys ( about 200-300m short) and he'd nosed the car in as close to the barrier as possible. Still required a big swerve to get around him. Would have been fairly risky getting out of the car too.

Smart motorways are a terrible idea. Sorry, to be clear, lack of a hard shoulder is a terrible idea.

There has not been any education or advertising re lane discipline for years. People are at best lazy when driving, i was taught by my driving instructor to expect every other driver on the road to be an absolute idiot and anticipate accordingly.

A trip back from Bicester Heritage on Sunday saw some atrocious driving standards including ;

Cutting up a lorry joining A34 D/C because someone moved in from lane 2 to lane one exactly at the exit of the slip road so lorry had to brake hard
Indicators turning left in lane 2 for about 5 miles
T**t in an RS Focus deciding that he really needed to read the post code off of everyone's numberplates
Driver doing 20-30 mph under the speed limit in lane two with lane one empty for half a mile or so.

We really should have mandatory retests every X (insert number as appropriate) years in my view. Would catch a lot of people out.

Louis Balfour

28,176 posts

253 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
QuattroDave said:
Morning all,

With my daily commute now including c60 miles of motorway driving split fairly evenly between M3 and M27 I've noticed that lane discipline has well and truly gone out the window on the M27 since it partially opened as a 'smart' motorway (partially as they're still "testing technology, hence the constant 60mph!)

I notice it most on the way home, between 6-7pm I constantly encounter drivers merrily trudging along in lane 3 of 4 at 50-55mph without a care in the world. I kind of 'get' that you wouldn't want to hug lane 1 as the road surface is appalling where they've burnt off old markings but lane3?

Anyone else noticed the marked reduction in lane discipline? Is it motorways in general or 'smart' motorways
It's a problem everywhere. Someone brake tested me a couple of days ago on an empty A52 because they were in lane 2 (of 2) at 60mph and I flashed them to move over.

I don't think the growing sense of entitlement in this country helps. People think they can drive where and how they like.

Last time I went to Scotland the problem was less, though admittedly that was a few years ago.





QuattroDave

Original Poster:

1,821 posts

159 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
craig1912 said:
The M27 is shocking now it has opened fully (apart from the 60 limit). Lane 1 is barely used and you see people coming on to the motorway and going straight to lane 2 despite there not being anything in lane 1. Clueless
Isn't it just! Going eastbound from M3 onto M27 I move into lane 2 just before Jn5 for two reasons - 1, the slip on Jn5 is both short and fairly blind so best to leave some room for smooth traffic flow and 2, lane 1 for about 2 miles after Jn5 is enough to rattle teeth loose! Other than that I too tend to make the most of a largely empty lane 1!

MattyD803

2,467 posts

96 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Exactly the same on the M4 now that is has opened as a Smart motorway........I can 'sort of' (but not really) understand nervous & perhaps lazy drivers don't want to keep popping in and out of Lane 1 as it leaves / re-joins at each of the major junctions....but those sitting in lane 3 and lane 4 at 60/65 is really beggars belief.

Nonetheless, as mentioned above, i'm quite enjoying the use of lanes 1 and 2 as what appear to be empty VIP lanes dedicated only to me as I sit on cruise control at 70mph.....

aturnick54

1,328 posts

59 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
The M1 around Wakefield is terrible for this. They even have to put matrix signs up telling people to keep left unless overtaking, that nobody listens to.

I give up with them, end up just passing on the left side instead.

Zarco

21,181 posts

240 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Yep SMART motorways seemed to have made people even more brain dead.

greenace

27 posts

246 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
Inside lane for driving, all other lanes for overtaking. This should be on the news. Or maybe they could flash it up every now and then on those smart roadside sign things.

And also, isn't middle-lane sitting illegal? Or at least a fixed penalty/3 points?

OutInTheShed

14,955 posts

57 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
The M27 has always been horrible.
To be fair, the junctions are mostly very close together and prone to queues, so the left lane is almost best kept for those leaving at the next exit, or to let people enter. Which is actually imposed by signs on many bits of 'smart' motorway.

I prefer 'casual' motorways myself.

Or even scruffy ones, like you get in Greece, where 'lane discipline' doesn't go as far as keeping between any two white lines.

aturnick54

1,328 posts

59 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
greenace said:
Or maybe they could flash it up every now and then on those smart roadside sign things.
They do, people don't read them.

55north1west

2,657 posts

85 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2022
quotequote all
You notice the decline in drivers paying attention as soon as you enter so called “smart motorways”. Drivers seem to mentally switch off, drive way to close to the car in front and it’s way more dangerous as Traffic doesn’t naturally clear as it does on non S M’s.
I also believe we’re seeing way more serious accidents on slip roads and entry / exits because of the higher traffic density / driver inattention caused by SM’s.
As soon as you leave the camera controlled area speeds increase and the lanes become quieter as faster traffic naturally moves on.

JP__FOX

594 posts

266 months

Thursday 3rd March 2022
quotequote all
55north1west said:
You notice the decline in drivers paying attention as soon as you enter so called “smart motorways”. Drivers seem to mentally switch off, drive way to close to the car in front and it’s way more dangerous as Traffic doesn’t naturally clear as it does on non S M’s.
I also believe we’re seeing way more serious accidents on slip roads and entry / exits because of the higher traffic density / driver inattention caused by SM’s.
As soon as you leave the camera controlled area speeds increase and the lanes become quieter as faster traffic naturally moves on.
I'm not a fan of the lack of hard shoulder on Smart Motorways but they do keep traffic moving better in peak periods.

I'd suggest the reason lanes become quieter when you leave camera controlled areas is because they put them in the busy areas to help keep traffic moving.

They're annoying when trying to make good progress out of peak hours but as someone that commutes round the M4, M25 and M1, they do help traffic flow during peak hours.