Car sharing - what are the bad bits?
Discussion
Hi,
I'm having to make my wife carless for at least the next six months. It will take me that time to get our business back on track and save up a few quid for one.
I don't really want to take out finance as the last couple of years has shown me how vunerable we are when money stops coming in when you are self employed.
She only needs a car a few times a week if that if I'm not there and I see car sharing allows you to rent by the hour. I've looked at three firms:
karshare.com,
turo.com
hiyacar.co.uk
All check out ok in Trustpilot and I thought about doing it myself in the future until I saw on hiyacar.co,uk, where you get a breakdown that 75% of the cost was insurance.
Most of the prices are very high, but they do have a few Kia's that you can't really charge that much for.
Anyone used these car shares and found them good or had any problems?
Thanks,
Dave
I'm having to make my wife carless for at least the next six months. It will take me that time to get our business back on track and save up a few quid for one.
I don't really want to take out finance as the last couple of years has shown me how vunerable we are when money stops coming in when you are self employed.
She only needs a car a few times a week if that if I'm not there and I see car sharing allows you to rent by the hour. I've looked at three firms:
karshare.com,
turo.com
hiyacar.co.uk
All check out ok in Trustpilot and I thought about doing it myself in the future until I saw on hiyacar.co,uk, where you get a breakdown that 75% of the cost was insurance.
Most of the prices are very high, but they do have a few Kia's that you can't really charge that much for.
Anyone used these car shares and found them good or had any problems?
Thanks,
Dave
Dave121 said:
Just outside London in Sutton so most things doable by buses, trains, cabs.
Most of those car hire sites are London centric. Have you looked to see if there are any car share clubs with cars near you? Enterprise and Zipcar are 2 that come to mind, but there are 1 or 2 more.Have you looked a local independent car hire firms? We have one near us that we use - c.£25 for a C1/107/Aygo, £70ish for a van, backed up by car hire excess insurance. The good thing about them is that they don't use fluid pricing. I've looked at Turo and found some prices to be wacktard - for instance the £25 C1 from the hire place becomes a £30-£45 car on Turo and that will be an 8 year old car (albeit possibly in good nick).
Dave121 said:
Everytime I consider car hire I get paranoid about excesses.
Have been looking at something like an Aygo/Ka for now which I wouldn't lose too much on.
You can get special insurance to cover hire car excess. I can't recall the website offhand, but I'm sure a bit of Googling will throw something up.Have been looking at something like an Aygo/Ka for now which I wouldn't lose too much on.
C70R said:
Dave121 said:
Everytime I consider car hire I get paranoid about excesses.
Have been looking at something like an Aygo/Ka for now which I wouldn't lose too much on.
You can get special insurance to cover hire car excess. I can't recall the website offhand, but I'm sure a bit of Googling will throw something up.Have been looking at something like an Aygo/Ka for now which I wouldn't lose too much on.
C70R said:
Does Zipcar reach out as far as Sutton?
If so, surely that's the best solution. Book ahead by the hour, pick the type of car you want, even collect and drop off in different locations.
I did look at Zipcar, but then checked them on Trustpilot - https://www.trustpilot.com/review/zipcar.com. Zipcar.co.uk equally bad,If so, surely that's the best solution. Book ahead by the hour, pick the type of car you want, even collect and drop off in different locations.
Dave121 said:
C70R said:
Does Zipcar reach out as far as Sutton?
If so, surely that's the best solution. Book ahead by the hour, pick the type of car you want, even collect and drop off in different locations.
I did look at Zipcar, but then checked them on Trustpilot - https://www.trustpilot.com/review/zipcar.com. Zipcar.co.uk equally bad,If so, surely that's the best solution. Book ahead by the hour, pick the type of car you want, even collect and drop off in different locations.
It's the most simple and flexible solution available to you, assuming there are any available near where you live. It seems like a no-brainer if you only need a car occasionally. You just reserve the car on the app, walk up to the car and unlock it on the app. That's it.
(Also, you're looking at the US Zipcar reviews there - the UK looks marginally better)
C70R said:
Zipcar is fine. I've been using them for over a decade and never had a single issue. Honestly, if you spend your time comparing everything on Trustpilot, all you're going to see is people who've been aggrieved or had a problem. People, like me, who've never had any issues tend not to bother writing long-winded reviews (for better or worse...).
It's the most simple and flexible solution available to you, assuming there are any available near where you live. It seems like a no-brainer if you only need a car occasionally. You just reserve the car on the app, walk up to the car and unlock it on the app. That's it.
(Also, you're looking at the US Zipcar reviews there - the UK looks marginally better)
It's tricky to get any info/prices without joining? They are available within a two minute walk.It's the most simple and flexible solution available to you, assuming there are any available near where you live. It seems like a no-brainer if you only need a car occasionally. You just reserve the car on the app, walk up to the car and unlock it on the app. That's it.
(Also, you're looking at the US Zipcar reviews there - the UK looks marginally better)
1. What best membership for occasional 4 hours use and cost?
2. What's cost for mini size car? Didn't they use Smart cars?
3. How much deposit?
Thanks
Dave121 said:
C70R said:
Zipcar is fine. I've been using them for over a decade and never had a single issue. Honestly, if you spend your time comparing everything on Trustpilot, all you're going to see is people who've been aggrieved or had a problem. People, like me, who've never had any issues tend not to bother writing long-winded reviews (for better or worse...).
It's the most simple and flexible solution available to you, assuming there are any available near where you live. It seems like a no-brainer if you only need a car occasionally. You just reserve the car on the app, walk up to the car and unlock it on the app. That's it.
(Also, you're looking at the US Zipcar reviews there - the UK looks marginally better)
It's tricky to get any info/prices without joining? They are available within a two minute walk.It's the most simple and flexible solution available to you, assuming there are any available near where you live. It seems like a no-brainer if you only need a car occasionally. You just reserve the car on the app, walk up to the car and unlock it on the app. That's it.
(Also, you're looking at the US Zipcar reviews there - the UK looks marginally better)
1. What best membership for occasional 4 hours use and cost?
2. What's cost for mini size car? Didn't they use Smart cars?
3. How much deposit?
Thanks

Everything you need is on their website.
Dave121 said:
vikingaero said:
Around £40-60 for an annual policy - just Google car hire excess insurance
That's great! I've never heard of that - will google it and check out, even for other policies.C70R said:
Do I look like Zipcar? 
Everything you need is on their website.
Sorry, my laptop's cache is screwed and certain webpage links don't work. as with Zipcars. Just tried another pc and works perfectly.
Everything you need is on their website.
Smart London membership looks good at £6pm, as do the cheapest cars at £6.50 per hour. Zipcar USA 97% rubbish, whereas Zipcar UK only 51% crap - there's a tun up. Still a bit concerning
Great that you've always had good experiences, I always seem to fall into the other camp.
May give them a try and use a card with as little as possible on it.
I’ve just done this very exercise with a family member.
When you factor in fixed costs of depreciation, insurance, tax, MOT, servicing - then tot up variable costs of petrol, parking, tolls, repairs... then consider where this 10 square metres of metal will be parked when you’re not using it...
All of a sudden the cab / train fairs can look good value and highly convenient.
Cars work well if you’re carting multiple people / stuff around.
And obvs for a lot of us they’re a hobby we indulge / throw money at.
But if you’re an able bodied single adult traveller who just needs to get from A to B, the spreadsheet confirms that they’re often a bit of a false economy (unless you live out rural in the boonies).
When you factor in fixed costs of depreciation, insurance, tax, MOT, servicing - then tot up variable costs of petrol, parking, tolls, repairs... then consider where this 10 square metres of metal will be parked when you’re not using it...
All of a sudden the cab / train fairs can look good value and highly convenient.
Cars work well if you’re carting multiple people / stuff around.
And obvs for a lot of us they’re a hobby we indulge / throw money at.
But if you’re an able bodied single adult traveller who just needs to get from A to B, the spreadsheet confirms that they’re often a bit of a false economy (unless you live out rural in the boonies).
Edited by The spinner of plates on Saturday 5th March 16:47
Dave121 said:
I did look at Zipcar, but then checked them on Trustpilot - https://www.trustpilot.com/review/zipcar.com. Zipcar.co.uk equally bad,
I confirm Zipcar suck very badly. Tried using them for a couple of years. Found the below very common:Dirty cars.
Cars with the fuel light on.
Cars with budget tyres.
Everyone wants the car at the same time.
In addition:
You sometimes feel serious time pressure because you book by the hour and life happens but there is someone booked behind you.
You always need to inspect the car yourself and report damage because you become liable if there is something untoward with the car that you didn’t report.
As they are parked on the street, stuff happens to them after your booking. TBF, I only got called three times in 2 years about damage I wasn’t responsible for, and it wasn’t taken further, but they were still stressful calls.
Was generally a miserable experience.
On the plus side, I got to drive such a variety of cars and came to understand professional car reviews (blasting round the best roads and tracks in the UK) aren’t very relevant to most people (going to Tesco, stuck in rush hour traffic on the way to work). There often wasn’t much difference between badly reviewed cars and well reviewed cars in these circumstances.
I did the same calculations as spinnerofplates because I hardly needed a car living and working in Central London. But Zipcar was so miserable I decided just to pay up and buy my own car again. Sometimes it just sat there for a month without being used, but it was well worth the cost as it meant not having to sit in someone else's filth, worrying the fuel might run out on the way to petrol station, washing wide and clenching your sphincter on a greasy roundabout because of the budget tyres.
They do save money if you don’t drive often and about half the time, it was pleasant. ie. clean car, over half a tank of fuel, still new enough to be on OE tyres, no one booked behind you, but each journey was definitely a gamble.
I suppose if you are in a financial pinch, they will work as well. I’d probably check one of intermediary apps though that let you hire direct from car owners. I think you need an intermediary between hirer’s to check things are in order and sort things out if they aren’t. One of the main problems with the Zipcar system was this burden was mainly placed on the hirers and most of them didn’t give two s
ts.Edited by anonymous-user on Sunday 6th March 04:29
Forums | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


